News
Egypt forbids 2,000 pilgrims from visiting Israel
Smadar Peri
Published: 08.03.07, 17:42
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
22 Talkbacks for this article
1. WELL, WHERE IS THE UPROAR ABOUT THIS?
Scott ,   LONDONISTAN-UK   (03.08.07)
If Israel had made such a ridiculous decision - WE'D ALL HEAR ABOUT IT (IN THE "NORMAL" MEDIA - NOT HERE!!!!!) ITS A DISGRACE - BUT TYPICAL OF THE ARAB MENTALITY.
2. Coptics
Yisraeli   (03.08.07)
Coptics are Christians yet they tow the muslim line even though they are persecuted in Egypt as a minority by the muslims. So dont come crying to us when they go after the Sunday people. Same story in Bethlehem and Nazereth. As Christians believing in the Bible they should all be fully supporting Israel, but they dont, they rather side with the palestinians and muslims in general. Betlechem has already paid the price when the Christians there shrilled "occupation, occupation" alongside their muslim brothers. Now they mostly lost their homes and businesses and have to leave in the night to Gilo checkpoint, then airport to any country that will accept them.
3. Gee, That's Some Peace We Have.
Terry ,   Eilat, Israel   (03.08.07)
We're really getting a lot out of our peace with Egypt. Such friendly relations - it was really worth giving back the Sinai, wasn't it? Just think, we could have the same warm relations with Syria if we give up the Golan. Then we can return to the 1967 armistice lines & give away Jerusalem - then we can have good neighborly relations with the Hamas gov't in Palestine. After that, we can become a binational state, let in 3 million friendly Arabs and forget about being a Jewish state. Then we can all move to California, if the Americans will let us in.
4. Israel's government should reciprocate
Yacov ,   Ashkelon   (03.08.07)
Over 300,000 Israelis traveled to Egypt last year supporting the Egyptian tourism industry while Israel's hotel rooms were empty and Israeli workers laid off. Israel needs to reciprocate and bar Israelis from traveling to Egypt.
5. #2 The Copts are simply afraid. Don't judge them too harshly
Zvi   (03.08.07)
Christians are increasingly being persecuted at a general level in Egypt and in the PA. Having been a persecuted minority for 2000 years, we can remember how hard it is to live at the sufferance of an oppressive system.
6. THESE HOTELIERS ARE CROOKS!!!
stude ham   (03.08.07)
Give them back their money! This is robbery and is so typical of the disgusting money sucking practices perpetrated by all those who bilk the unsuspecting tourists. The hoteliers are acting shamefully and should be forced to reimburse the innocent pilgrims.
7. Egypt should stop persecuting the Copts
Rami ,   Nazareth, Israel   (03.08.07)
US and any christian aid to egypt should be conditioned on the treatment of the christians in egypt.
8. to #2: we support justice
Rami ,   Nazareth, Israel   (03.08.07)
Unlike Muslims we do not blindly support a side that is wrong. When Israel kills innocent civilian we criticize Israel, when Palestinians kill innocent Israelis we criticize that out loud. You should come to our churches and listen to the message of tolerance and peace that is preached. We are the only religion that does not incite against others.
9. #6 Do you have a brain?
Chaya ,   Bat Yam, Israel   (03.08.07)
The hotels didn't cancel their resevations! It's the Egyptian govt that is keeping them from coming here! As the article said, they had to turn down other reservations in order to make room for these pilgrims. It is the govt of Egypt that should give the pilgrims back their money!!!
10. JEUS WENT TO EGYPT LEARNING MAGIC ANYWAY.WHERE DID HE WALK?
YEP HE LEARNED ,   SORCERY IN EGYPT....   (03.08.07)
11. RAMI, YOUR HISTORY PROVES DIFFERENT
..............DACON9   (03.08.07)
12. #10: Like Moses and Joseph, Butthead
(03.08.07)
13. #10 Where did you learn this??
Rick ,   Open Range, USA   (03.08.07)
Please tell me. I would like to know how you learned Jesus learned magic?
14. #6 CHAYA - STOP INSULTING OTHER PEOPLE
stude ham   (03.08.07)
AND STOP THINKING LIKE THOSE DISHONEST HOTELIERS! THEY HAVE INSURANCE TO COVER THESE ACCIDENTAL CONTINGENCIES. THE HOTELIERS MUST REIMBURSE THE INNOCENT EGYPTIANS OR BASICALLY BE CONSIDERED TO BE CROOKS.
15. #12 HERE IS YOUR TORAH LESSON
..............DACON9   (03.08.07)
MOSES NEVER SAID 'HE' WAS RESPONSIBLE' MOSES WAS PUNISHED BY 'GD', ONE TIME FOR ALLUDING TO THAT HE, MOSES HAD THE POWER. MOSES ALWAYS SAID IT WAS BY 'GDS' WORD THAT THIS WILL HAPPEN, AND 'GD' DID MAKE IT HAPPEN.A STARTLING REVELATION AT MT SINAII that you recognize .. and.. the 10 startling world of miracles, and the world flood and the very miracles of ISRAEL STILL STANDING INSPITE OF YOUR INQUISITIONS AND HITLERS AND ARABS ALL ATTACKING AT ONCE TO WIPE ISRAEL OUT to continue, JOSEPH READ DREAMS, ACCUARATLEY AND told the pharoah at his first meeting, THAT IT WAS NOT HE, JOSEPH THAT READ DREAMS, he told the pharoah, THAT 'GD'S READS THEM FOR HE JOSEPH and is revealed through JOSEPH BUTTHEAD.... AS YOU CALLED ME BUTTHEAD, JEUS WANTED TO BE CALLED THE MIRACLE MAKER THE SON THE god the healer , the wafer , the idols, the rejected son. JEUS TOOK responsiblity for all sorcery i mean miracles for himself. you pray to jeus. 'GD' SAID',, THERE IS NONE BESIDE ME THERE IS NONE LIKE ME. THERE IS NONE BUT ME HAVE NO OTHER gods BEFORE ME (commentary on that, GD knew that there will be false gods, so 'GD OF ISRAEL made it very clear) I AM HOLY I MADE YOU HOLY, ISRAEL MY SERVANT. so butthead, i mean kind sir, Abraham Noah and Moses offered you a portion of TORAH called the NOAHIDE LAWS, and if you follow them you will be called a rightous other nation(rightous GOY), BUT BUTTHEAD, I MEAN SIR, your nation refuses 'GDS' LAWS TO YOU AND PRAY TO A false god a mangod. SIGNED butthead, I MEAN signed DACON9
16. No. 4 Yaacov
NYC Girl   (03.08.07)
While I agree with the point you made, ideally it shouldn't require the government to bar Israelis from visiting Egypt. After all of the recent incidents of anti-Israel incitement, Israelis should voluntarily refuse to travel there.
17. Y net, it's 20, 000; Not 2,000
(03.08.07)
Muslims forming more than 92% of the egyptian population are longing to make their pilgrimage, as well .
18. misleading headline
chaim ,   miami beach USA   (03.08.07)
when I saw this headline I wondered since when did Israel deny entery to any person of the christian faith this is how it appears 'Christians barred from visiting Israel' after reading the article it reminded me of a method utilized by some Rabbis who are involved in certifying the Kashrut of a place when the owners do not want to pay the rabbis demands, they simply place an ad in the local jewish newspaper that this place is no longer under the supervision of this rabbi leaving out the reason of just why. first impressions are exteremly important so if the headline was delibertly made to mislead than that person has no right to have his reports printed
19. And the German Bishops and Vatican are silent.
AK   (03.08.07)
20. Thank you Egypt Mubarak signed Israel Olmlet RIGHT ???
M. Segal ,   Mpls America   (03.09.07)
I realize that whether Egyptians are Islam Muslim Christian and or descendents of Pharoahs if indeed Pharoahs are really part of Egypt not just a word in the Jewish bible reality again shows us the real nature of a police state they love to be the good guys... I MEAN THE GOOD G O O D GUYS... to such a degree... GET... REAL... EGYPT... this is March 2007 not March 1956... RIGHT ??? THANK YOU... M. segal
21. EGYPTIAN State-controlled paper PRAISED TEL AVIV BOMBING
Linda Rivera ,   New York   (03.09.07)
of Jewish innocents. Israel gave Egypt the Sinai in exchange for a worthless piece of paper - a peace agreement. The bloody "peace" that Egypt gives Israel: YNETNEWS (04.18.06, 07:51) Tel Aviv attack. 'There will be more' Egyptian paper praises Tel Aviv bombing State-controlled Al Gomhuria calls Monday's suicide bombing 'sacrificial, martyrdom attack,' warns more attacks to follow Associated Press An Egyptian state-controlled newspaper praised Monday's suicide attack in Tel Aviv, which killed nine people and wounded dozens, calling it an act of sacrifice and martyrdom. http://www.ynetnews.com/articles/0,7340,L-3241041,00.html The deployment of Egypt's military on Israel's border at the invitation of Israeli leaders is astonishing and treasonous. M.K. Steinitz stated: Egyptian military "has been training for war against Israel for the past 10 years." In 2004, U.S. Congressman Tom Lantos in the House International Relations Committee, warned Egypt was building up its military in preparation for a future war with Israel. Egypt receives $1.7 billion dollars in U.S. aid annually. STOP Inciting Children to Kill ! http://www.teachkidspeace.com/flash.php Palestinian Authority society are taught murdering Jews is the highest goal in life and attains paradise: http://www.pmw.org.il/AFD.html http://littlegreenfootballs.com/weblog/pictures/PalestinianChildAbuse
22. Egyptian ATROCITIES Against SUDANESE REFUGEES
Linda Rivera ,   New York   (03.09.07)
Egyptian Atrocities Against Sudanese Refugees Worsen Feburary 18, 2006 Damanga Coalition for Freedom and Democracy has learned that the Egyptian government has underreported the number of Sudanese refugees killed by Egyptian authorities, and that Egypt continues to perpetrate human rights abuses against Sudanese civilians. Damanga calls upon the United Nations office in Cairo, as well as the greater international community, to intervene on behalf of the embattled refugees. The atrocities committed in Egypt against Sudanese refugees have proved much greater than previously understood. Though Egypt has reported killing 27 Sudanese civilians in December, Damanga has received information from various refugee sources claiming that Egyptian authorities actually have killed more than 100 refugees. Several of these additional killings took place inside Egyptian detention facilities, with some victims of the December attacks succumbing to their wounds and dying in hospitals. Moreover, Damanga has learned that Egyptian authorities tortured detained Sudanese refugees, and several refugees are still unaccounted for. Egyptian authorities arrested or detained a number of surviving refugees, holding them in army and police camps near Cairo. Most have since been released, though dozens remain missing. Damanga's sources report that when releasing refugees, the Egyptian government has released them one by one, breaking apart families and individually transporting refugees to locations far away from their homes, leaving them without the means to return home or contact their relatives. Moreover, these refugees are often without their United Nations identification documents and passports, having lost their belongings in December when the government initially attacked them. Egyptian authorities routinely confiscated identification papers, cellular telephones, watches, and cameras after beating the captive refugees. The Egyptian government has not returned these items, nor have they permitted the refugees to legally request return of their vital documents and other stolen property. Egyptian security services have warned leaders of refugee demonstrations to refrain from mentioning the Egyptian government and its human rights violations on penalty of severe punishment. These threatened refugees are living in fear and require protection, as do all Sudanese refugees... http://www.damanga.org/egypt_atrocities.html
Back to article