News
Lebanon war was planned in March, Olmert says
Ronny Sofer
Published: 08.03.07, 10:02
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
17 Talkbacks for this article
1. WOW!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! HA'ARETZ.
DAVID ,   JUDEA   (03.08.07)
Now we are talking about ISRAEL'S finest and most reliable bolshevik selfhating media. One has to wonder how far gone they are ,in still trying to portray olmrat as a statesman with insight. I have never spent time to read ha'aretz. Reading YNET is already painfull enough . Israelis love to use the word hasbarah. With publications like YNET and ha'aretz we do not even need the bbc to incite hatred towards us,they do a real fine job with that.
2. So Why Did The War Go So Poorly?
Terry ,   Eilat, Israel   (03.08.07)
This only makes the failure even worse. First, then why was security so lax as to allow a kidnapping in the first place? Second, what happened to the ground invasion? Third, why was protection of the home front so disorganized? Fourth, why was the army so unprepared, the reserves ill-trained, & equipment missing? An incompetent P.M., an incompetent Defense Minister, an incompetent Foreign Minister, led to this mess. They should all resign.
3. Points To Incompetence Of IDF Generals More Than PM
Paqid 16, Netzarim ,   Ra'anana, Israel   (03.08.07)
I'm not an Olmert fan. Nevertheless, if the report is accurate, then Olmert's foresight in planning a response for the likely eventuality should be applauded. The PM is charged with relying on the Tzah"l for their military assessment of Israel's military capabilities and the military's expected results of applying their forces. The PM shouldn't be faulted for errors in our general's advice. I've served in the USAF (Intelligence) and in the Tzah"l. I've seen how both work from the inside. I was always critical of the American military because of bureaucracy -- until I served in the Tzah"l and discovered how a military can be built on a bureaucracy that values Hollywood-movie bravado above pragmatism. In battle however, the guy consumed with bravado who stands up and yells "Charge!" is the first one riding home in a flag-draped box, not the one who lives to become Rambo in Hollywood movies. Anyone who reads these talkbacks quickly realizes that Israelis typically don't comprehend pragmatism, only (often foolish) bravado. What I've seen of the workings in Tzah"l is consistent with this observation and my experience is that Israeli generals are typically no exception. Terry (#2) has well stated the implications.
4. YOU MEAN OLMERT KNEW THERE WOULD BE A KIDNAPPING???
stude ham   (03.08.07)
You mean that Israel planned the kidnapping all along? You mean Olmert was a khokhmah after all??? Why didn't he say so before??? And here we all thought he was a complete moron! Oh how wrong we all have been! So where are the kidnapped soldiers? and why doesn't he show up with them?
5. it finally came
HEZBOLLAH   (03.08.07)
finally the truth has been revealed, even though i was telling you this all along, for what a scoundral olmert and his government really are. isreal practically made the war, and took things to the extreme. isreal wanted a war all this time, and now they mention it? this just shows how the media lies to their people. they knew hezbollah would take those soldiers, but instead of preventing that, they planned to take over lebanon like what they done in the 1970s. if i was an isreali, i would be ashamed of this 100%. all your government wants is more land, more more more of everything. no one can talk back about this because everyone here knows this is true. it sickens me.
6. Hezbollah knew this already
John ,   London,UK   (03.08.07)
Hezbollah leader Hassan Nasrallah had said on TV that he knews that Israel has finsihed plans to bombs Lebanon in early 2006. It took 6 months for PM Olmert to confirm this. Hezbollah provoked Israel into war and than it defeated Israel in a stunning victory that surprised the west. Israeli defeat made Hezbollah stronger and more popular than ever. This is a year of disgrace for Israel. Olmert should resign for bringing shame upon Israeli military and the whole nation.
7. Liar, Liar, Liar and WAR CRIMINAL.
Chanan ,   USA   (03.08.07)
8. SO IT IS OLMERT'S CATASTROPHE, PERETZ HAS NOTHING TO DO.....
cHANAN ,   USA   (03.08.07)
WITH IT.
9. PUT OLMERT ON TRIAL NOW FOR HIS RESPONSIBILITY HE HAS JUST..
Chanan ,   USA   (03.08.07)
ADMITTED TO.
10. HEZBALLAH HOW LONG YOU'VE BEEN PLANNING JIHAD,5,2 10 YEARS?
.....PLANNED TO FAIL ,   IF REPORT IS TRUE   (03.08.07)
11. this is political spin: Olmert now wants to blame Mofaz
aaron ,   ra'anana   (03.08.07)
12. Olmert's Planned War
Mitch ,   Miami, USA   (03.08.07)
If Olmert is to be believed, and I doubt it, then he has the blood of 125 Israeli soldiers on his hands because he had no control over the situation when it erupted. His incompetency is without equal. Resign Olmert, resign.
13. Thank you John
Ali ,   Lebanon   (03.08.07)
14. Hizbullah are the winners.....
Rachel ,   New York, NY   (03.08.07)
It is the best thing that has ever happened in history is to defeat the arogant Jews and kick their butts.
15. Truth is out finally!
Tarek ,   Damascus, Syria   (03.08.07)
It is only believed when it is said by your own media, when Hassan Nassrallah said that 6 months ago, you called him a liar "of course"... this is the truth, it is time for you to know how your polititions think. why would they want to invade lebanon, AGAIN!! ... to #12 .. Olmart also has the blood of 1200 lebanese on his hands.
16. #`14.. great way to show off how Racists you are
jason ,   usa   (03.09.07)
17. #14 You call murder of innocent people winning?
Lina ,   USA   (03.09.07)
The war in Lebanon highlighted why Israel needs war plans on the drawing board at all times. This is no surprise. And while cheerleaders for terror like Rachel seize any opportunity to bash Israel, we know the war was not started by Israel. And while plans may have been in place, you don't know if Israel would have implemented them. The border was calm the day Hizbullah attacked, murdered and kidnapped Israeli soldiers monitoring the border. Hizbullah has the blood of hundreds of dead people on their hands. This senseless attack served no purpose. Innocent people on both sides suffered because of Nasrallah's careless act of aggression.
Back to article