News
Court convicts Hebron settler for stoning Palestinian homes
Efrat Weiss
Published: 14.03.07, 22:18
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
44 Talkbacks for this article
1. YNET Be Helpful - Expose an Islamic Terror Cell
Linda Rivera ,   New York   (03.14.07)
2. Good! She's a nut that poorly
Joe ,   Ohio, USA   (03.14.07)
represents Israel. Now let's see if the Pali's punish anybody for stoning a Israeli. That'll be the day!
3. Ynet: WHY DONT YOU PUT SDEROT ON THE FRONT PAGE
Ze'ev ,   Tel Aviv, Yisrael   (03.14.07)
Instead of the usual Peace Now, Tartman exposes, anti Jewish trival. You have the power to help your fellow Jew, to make Israel what it should be, a land where Jews are in brotherhood as a people. Expose Those That seek To Remove The Jewish People OFF THIS PLANET!!!!
4. Israel on course for destruction
Rick ,   Sydney   (03.14.07)
Israel's real enemies are its radical jewish left wing; led by the judiciary, government and military
5. WHERE IS THE STONED JEWISH GIRLS' VIDEO?
HaDaR ,   Hebron   (03.14.07)
YOU ARE DOING EXTREME-LEFT WING POPAGANDA!
6. Yifat Elkobi
Leo ,   Australia   (03.14.07)
If one were to wacth the video taken by the arab containing "evidence" Elkobi "harrasing" her, it is not hard to determine that it is a very heavily edited footage...and you could also see the alleged "victim" trying very hard to draw some kind of response from Elkobi. For something seemingly so trivial to make headline news accross Israel & for the Defence Minister and Prime Minister to raise this during the weekly ministerial meeting & make such a big deal over it, whilst there are probably a little more pressing issues to discuss during government meetings - i,e. threats from Iran, Hezbollah, Hamas etc - highlights the sickness of this nation.
7. Justice Israel style anti Jew pro arab
Yisraeli   (03.15.07)
8. Tank U for NOTHNG Ynet !!!!!!!
Alberto Cohen ,   rio de janeiro   (03.15.07)
9. i cant stop laughing
papa jay   (03.15.07)
why dont all the talkbackers get to gether and spring this poor settler out of jail she got off easy! nut job! talk about hate.
10. # 2
papa jay   (03.15.07)
pals dont have to punish pals for stoning. Israel does that all on it's own. settler get comunity service for stoning. pals, get beat then go to jail for stoning.
11. Free the Terrorists, Convict Elkobi
Avi ,   Haifa   (03.15.07)
Free the guys who murder people and let's jail some woman who cursed out her neighbors
12. Inappropriate BEHAVIOR?
marya ,   sacramento, USA   (03.15.07)
If that's the case for being charged then why don't you do something about the Arab MK's in the kenesset who daily bring shame to their position by openly siding with Israel's enemies. The hypocrisy is thick people. You're going to need hip waders!
13. Why is it that only Jews are punished?
Margaret   (03.15.07)
I am not saying this woman shouldn't be punished if she did what has been alleged against her, but please keep things in context, within the last week or two, a Jewish father of five young children who was praying was stabbed to death by Arab assailants, and several other Arabs were arrested for carrying knives into Jewish areas of West Bank. Also,there have been several foiled kidnapping attempts against Israelis as well as several shooting incidents against Israeli cars,in which an Israel civilian was injured, there have also been dozens of stoning and firebombing attacks against Israeli cars and buses,resulting in injuries and destroyed property. Recently,a 10 Jewish girl was kidnapped and gangraped by Arab boys in Arad,this coming just weeks after several other Jewish girls were gangraped by Arab youths who admitted they sexually assaulted the girls in revenge for Israeli army actions against their Arab brethern in Gaza. Why don't these events ever make news? Why is it that a Jew has to be killed or seriously injured for the story to even be reported in Israel newspapers? Why aren't these attempted murders and assaults against Jews reported as well? Yet when a Jewish woman loses her temper, and cuses an Arab female out ,who by the way did her own fair share of yelling as well as spitting too,or Jewish kids throw a few stones at Arabs it practically makes frontpage news in Israeli papers? Isn't there enough antisemitic and antiIsraeli sentiment in the world? Sometimes I am afraid Jews are their own worst enemies!
14. Ynet; Jews are not settlers in their homeland!
Daisy ,   USA   (03.15.07)
The Arabs are the real settlers! Why do you insist on using Plo propaganda!
15. SHAME ON YOU Y-NET !
SERGIO ,   TURIN   (03.15.07)
A HEADLINE LIKE THAT AND AN ARTICLE OF THAT SORT ARE JUST A SIGN OF SINNATH CHINNAM. WHERE WERE YOUR ARTICLES ABOUT THE TWO JEWISH LITTLE GIRLS STONED JUST A FEW DAYS AGO ON THEIR WAY BACK FROM SCHOOL BY EXACTLY THOSE POOR ARABS? WHER ARE THE ARTICLES ABOUT THE THOUSANDS OF SIMILAR CASES IN WHICH NO PUNISHMENT WAS EVER COMMITTED TO THE ARABS? WHY HAVE YOU BECOME AN INSTRUMENT OF ARAB PROPAGANDA AND EXTREME LEFTIST HATRED FOR JEWISH PIONEERS?
16. betzelem
gabriela ben ari ,   jerusalem   (03.15.07)
seems to consider only arabs to have been created in tzelem Elokim What about jews , for example in Amona, who have been far beyond this joke verbally harrased, insulted to the worst abuse one can bear, who have been striken with the brutallity only known to KGB and Germans and dismissed whithout a hint of a trial to their perpretators? and all this came from Olmert's appointed corps at the request of the same leftists who claim this arab neighbour deserves some justice ? NU? Jewish Haters , where were you defending these Jews from Amona ??? NOOOOOOOOWWWHHHEEEEEERRRRRREEEEEEEE
17. The sentence is risible
Michael Steiner   (03.15.07)
She should've been put in indefinite administrative detention with no access to anyone connected with her, the same way it's done to Palestinians rock throwers.
18. #13 Margaret
Michael ,   Haifa   (03.15.07)
Part of the answer to your brilliant question as to why "Arabs get punished less than Jews" ? is that we kill them in far greater numbers than they kill us...thus, there are less of them to be punished.
19. #16 poor gabriela...you should be locked up with her...
Elokim ,   Israel   (03.15.07)
This way Yifat Elkobi has A person who understands her....the ONLY person who can understand this type of behavior....would be you since you share the same disturbed mental reality!!! You just don't get it...jews in settlements are not "really" Israelis. Jews in Amona ...... well they fought the law and the law won!!! They got paid to live there and they got paid to leave! Enough said!!! It goes to say what #18 stated "we kill them (insert race, culture or religion) in far greater numbers than they kill us...thus, there are less of them to be punished." This should be applied to the "settlers" as well!!! Or better yet... let's just the Arabs judge them... ....hmmmmmmmmmmmmmm....
20. YNET Expose Islamic Killers who Fire Daily on Sderot !
Linda Rivera ,   New York   (03.15.07)
21. Murdering palestinians stoned an ambulance
Beth   (03.15.07)
who were on way to attend to a horrific traffic accident a couple of hours ago. Ho ho lets see what (doesn't) happen to THEM. Y'mach Sh'mam and the machsom witches who watch over them.
22. Muslims regularly throw ROCKS at Jews from the TEMPLE MOUNT
Linda Rivera ,   New York   (03.15.07)
and even molotov cocktails! Muslims get away with VIOLENT behavior because they are Muslims! YNET readers are still waiting for a follow-up article on the precious IDF soldier who lost his eye to a vicious hate-filled rock thrower at the anti-terror - anti-human bomb killer fence. IDF, PLEASE do an article on the soldier! Arab MKs are ALLOWED to commit TREASON! Israel's Jews are scandalously FORCED to pay high salaries to Arab MK TRAITORS! Arab MK Bishara has called several times for an intifada against Israel! Bishara openly seeks the violent deaths of the Jewish Israelis he is supposed to serve!
23. Etiquette
soldier in iraq ,   Cali usa   (03.15.07)
We have class they don't.We are the Righteous people they are not.That is why in the end jerusalem will always be ours !!!
24. Harsh punishment indeed
jackie kunitz ,   USA   (03.15.07)
If I, or my neighbors, were to be punished like that for similar "crimes" we would be spending half our lives in court and half in prison. Neighbors argue, over spilled trash, over kids fighting, over dogs messing up on lawns...But of course, this woman was a Jwew and her neighbors were Arab and that is why she was punished, not for any other reason.
25. Y-NET - absolutely should be ashamed, left wing crap!
Adam ,   London   (03.15.07)
26. 1 settler found guilty, 200,000 to go
Rustum ,   London, UK   (03.15.07)
The ugly racist behaviour evinced by the raving bigot of Hebron has been recognised as such in an Israeli court which has sent a message to Israelis that such behaviour is against the law. This has nothing to do with PLO propaganda (viz #14) or Jew-hating Israeli governments (viz the delucted Riviera). In fact it has nothing to do with anything political but the sentence is simply a statement that foul, disgusting, racist, supremacist behaviour is not acceptable in a civilised society. That is obviously a really difficult concept for many TBers to grasp, or perhaps they simply are made of the same mettle as the unbelievably foul-mouthed settler.
27. Enough already
Libneniyyeh ,   Lebanon   (03.15.07)
20- Have u ever seen a kassam? It is a pathetic weapon, smaller than a broomstick, with barely enough firepower to reach Israeli territory. Most kassams fall into the desert or else do little damage. Now if u want to talk about the heavy duty weaponry Israel is using be my guest. 21- "Murdering Palestinians stoned an ambulance" Hmm...did they overturn the vehicle on its way to the accident scene? Did it explode? Or maybe one of the drivers got a bump on his head or a stone scratched the paintwork of the car. Do you want to talk about murdering Israeli forces who intentionally targetted red cross ambulance cars (cross marks the spot, eh?) in the Lebanon war, killing instantaneously all the occupants who were near death? Or do want to talk about the schools that were destroyed? The dairy factories? The hospitals? I have had the honour of meeting some of the women in Maksom Watch. They are without a doubt amongst the most human, sane, and proactive of Israeli citizens and I applaud their noble efforts.
28. 22
Libneniyyeh ,   Lebanon   (03.15.07)
You wanna talk about treason, deceit, betrayal, brutality, ruthlessness? Hun, I don't know where to start. But I think the answer lies in an Israeli commander's remark: "more Jews, less Arabs" - which is the mildest of remarks. Why don't you go back to what your precious leaders really have in mind for the future of the state. Or better yet, just compare maps 1948 to this day and see how Palestinian land dwindles every day. See what nature of land is allotted to Palestinians. See the thousands of houses destroyed. See the families who are forced to live in shanties while just across from them, beyond the wall are great settler mansions. Before you spout your BS take a real good look at what is happening in the country. You and people like you need to be forced not just to look, but to have their faces rubbed into the reality. Would you like that? Would you like to see with your own eyes how settlements continue to expand even while Israel tells the world it has stopped, withdrawn? Would you like to see why Palestinian children grow up to hate the Israeli state? Their parents dont need to teach them that, you Israelis are doing a great job. Remember, this is the future generation. Things are not going to get better.
29. 23
Libneniyyeh ,   Lebanon   (03.15.07)
You have class? You are the righteous? LOL - too funny
30. STUPIDITY
DAVID ,   JUDEA   (03.15.07)
YNET IS GETTING MORE STUPID IN THEIR REPORTING ON A DAILY BASIS, IT KIND OF REFLECTS THE MASTERS THEY REPRESENT. BASICLY THEIR IS NO HOPE FOR THEM TO EVER GET IT RIGHT. THEIR REPORTING ONLY INCREASES HATRED TOWARDS US IN THE WORLD.
Next talkbacks
Back to article