News
IDF to probe ‘human shield’ charges
Hanan Greenberg
Published: 16.03.07, 02:56
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
52 Talkbacks for this article
1. (-:
AY_Lamb ,   USA   (03.16.07)
I don't believe the allegations
2. #1. I don't believe my post got rejected.
Larissa ,   Australia   (03.16.07)
but i guess we don't always want to believe reality
3. When Israel...
Talish ,   Phoenix, AZ   (03.16.07)
does something potentially vile, and disgusting the entire world is up in arms. When the Palestinians do such things, which are almost always proven to be true, the world kinda slumps back and does nothing. Such a double standard it's disgusting. I suppose hearing that radical Islamists committing such acts is a norm. Scary shit.
4. One would hope the Israelis would spend time better
AK   (03.16.07)
why not investigate ISM, B'tselem and peace Now and how they voluntarily serve as human shields for Arab terrorists.
5. use human shields; protect the soldiers
dante ,   uk   (03.16.07)
there is NO reason to expose your soldiers to the pali homicidal lunatics. too bad about what france or sweden have to say.
6. Legitimate
Reuven Brauner ,   Raanana, Israel   (03.16.07)
Under these circumstances, the use of these so-called "human shields" is perfectly legitimate. Why is it that our soldiers should be the ones who get blown up? You want to blow someone up, do it to your friends. I am sure that they will not mind.
7. Betzelem has
David ,   Jerusalem   (03.16.07)
NO credibility if they did not object to the 20, 30, 40 year old Arab terrorists -not little 7 year old boys - stoning the ambulances and police vehicles while they were evacuating the victims of yesterday's tragic accident? Hah??? Betzelem, therefore, can not be trusted and the Israeli courts may not accept their baloney stories and lies.
8. hahaha Tough IDF!
Harry ,   Kansas   (03.16.07)
Why don't they just hand the children assault rifles so they can sweep the area too? You never know maybe they were walking them to school. loll So much for Hezbollah "hiding" behind civillians! Why is israel buying all these start-of-the-art weapons? Why don't they just buy a bundle of children from foriegn countries who live in poverty and scatter them around their military bases?
9. #5: Listen, you idiot:
Michael Steiner   (03.16.07)
How would you like it if a group of thugs came to your door in the middle of the night, told you they were the police and took your wife by force to go next door to a group of men suspect of violent sexual assault? Use of human shields is ALWAYS UNJUSTIFIABLE PERIOD. Those who did this, if they did it, should have their asses thrown in jail together with the twenty thousand Palestinians we're holding indefinitely on no charges.
10. TSAHAL BETRAYS ITS OWN SOLDIERS ! SHAME ON THE LEFTISTS
DarkMind   (03.16.07)
11. We should exchange the IDF soldiers with US Soldiers
David ,   Jerusalem   (03.16.07)
who would not expose themselves to such dangerous missions as the IDF are told to. And then, finally, all the terrorists will be taken care of....
12. ...
Chico ,   MX   (03.16.07)
this is the reason why israel failed in its war - its army is too chicken to fight a real battle, always hiding behind civilians.
13. Better them than our boys!
Israeli ,   ISRAEL   (03.16.07)
It's the price they have to pay for continual aggression against us. If they wouldn't start something, there wouldnt' be something.
14. SAY AFTER ME
Futura ,   Europe   (03.16.07)
Israel is a lighthouse for other nations, and th IDF is the most moral army in the world. Israel is a lighthouse for other nations, and th IDF is the most moral army in the world. Israel is a lighthouse for other nations, and th IDF is the most moral army in the world. Israel is a lighthouse for other nations, and th IDF is the most moral army in the world. HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA!
15. Because the palis already brainwashed all the children to
#8   (03.16.07)
do it for them.
16. #9 Mahmooood Steiner: How about
David ,   Jerusalem   (03.16.07)
instead of sitting and watching from the comfort of your home, do the job what the IDF are doing for ONE DAY? And then we'll hear your criticism. And the same with you Betzelem and other Leftists big mouths - do what the IDF soldiers are doing and then complain.
17. Hey Steiner
Arthur ,   S Francisco   (03.16.07)
All the arabs of Israel do not worth the life of one Jewish soldier...
18. Could we stop blaming ourselves for all
Keren ,   SP-now in Israel   (03.16.07)
and start being at the offensive side too?At least a bit! What about start publishing how Israel's arabs enemies hide behind civilians,especially woman and children?How they knife in the back their enemies? Will we allways stay in this position of being accused(and accusing ourselves) and never accuse and probe our reasons? Why doesn't the Israeli press start showing massively how its enemies act and how they are?
19. #16 David: Have you tried to walk with Palistinian shoes?
Futura ,   Europe   (03.16.07)
Maybe for once you should drop yor one-sided wiew and let your guard down. Then you maybe could realize that most palestinians are humans, not evil, not religious fanatics, just humans who want the best for their children. You could make a diffrence. You live in Israel. You can change the situation from within.
20. @19 you mean this?
Suzanne   (03.16.07)
http://www.memritv.org/search.asp?ACT=S9&P1=1398#
21. If It Saves Lives, It's Justified.
Terry ,   Eilat, Israel   (03.16.07)
There is no other way to look at it. Urban warfare against armed thugs hiding among a hostile civilian population is no easy job. Such warfare requires different tactics than battlefield wars between armies wearing uniforms. Our soldiers lives are worth more than conforming to some theoretical discussion of of acceptable tactics. Getting killed is not theoretical. If using human shields saves lives, then it is certainly acceptable to me. Perhaps those that don't agree would come up with a better idea - would it be more moral to bomb them from the air? Maybe we should just use tank fire & blow up the entire building with everyone inside? The fact that these thugs hide among a civilian population that supports them places the responsibility squarely on them.
22. @21, I would not know a sane alternative
Suzanne   (03.16.07)
to get bastards who hide themselves among civillians, but, still, using the same immoral and illegal tactics as the opponent should not be allowed and done. If only the press and international organisations would be as hysterical reporting on the 'opponent' abusing civilians as they do on the sporadic violations of the IDF, it would provide a more realistic view of the troubles in the Middle East. Media controlled by the Jews? Perhaps by Neturei Karta then ;)
23. #s 16 & 17:
Michael Steiner   (03.16.07)
#16: My first name is Michael (Mikha'el Dani'el ben Mikha'el), not Mahmood and certainly not "Mahmooood," whatever that is. As far as what you say, #19 responded to you appositely. #17: Take your racist, crypto-natzi diatribes like that and shove 'em up your ass. There is no place for such sentiments in the 21st century civilized world. Every life is precious and worth the same, you moron.
24. #23 If it walks like a dog and barks like a dog,
David ,   Jerusalem   (03.16.07)
it must be a dog. Mahmood, if you act like an arab and bark like an arab, you must be an arab and your name Mahmood or something similar.
25. psychic
mazen ,   atlanta   (03.16.07)
let me take a wild guess, they will find no wrong doing and that the soldier did nothing inappropriate adn that the photos to the contrary are just our brain doing tricks on us. welcome to israel.
26. #23 well said
Rustum ,   London, UK   (03.16.07)
Keep on fighting the good fight - although I don't know how much longer you'll be able to face that litany of insults from the crypto-nazis.
27. YES ,#2 LARISSA AND KANGAROOS RUN DOWN YOUR MAIN STREETS
Efrat ,   Afula, Israel   (03.16.07)
Listen Larissa, what do you know about my country dear? ZERO. I was born in Israel AND LIVED IN AUSTRALIA and I TELL YOU GIRLY you KNOW NOTHING about MY COUNTRY. And most Australians dont even know who we are over here, and what you know lassie comes channelled through a media that has made our misery here a money-making machine that DRONGOS like you lap up and then to run around acting as if you "know something about Israel" So there is YOUR REALITY. I would absolutely love to have a conversation with you - blow your stupid ill-conceived notions sky high with facts - or at least give another side of the story - Which you may not have heard ...or choose to "overlook" :-) Stay in Muslim Bondi darling... and keep YOUR IGNORANCE to yourself.
28. Michael Steiner 9
Libneniyyeh ,   Lebanon   (03.16.07)
I wish there were more people like you! It is good to read honest and fair talkbacks that are often right on target.
29. Hey Arthur 17
Libneniyyeh ,   Lebanon   (03.16.07)
You and yours and everyone who thinks like you are certainly not chosen by God. Even Satan himself would reject you. And with your ugly comment you've just proven you're not worth the toe nail of any Arab.
30. Michael 23
Libneniyyeh ,   Lebanon   (03.16.07)
Chapeau bas, my friend. My respect goes to you - stand strong
Next talkbacks
Back to article