News
Border Guard policemen admit they abused Palestinian teen
Efrat Weiss
Published: 23.03.07, 12:20
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
55 Talkbacks for this article
31. he's not a ''kid'' he's a hooligan who attacked Policemen
Free Them now   (03.23.07)
32. # 19 Rustum - great talkback
Isragirl ,   Qiryat Yam, Israel   (03.23.07)
People on both sides are so blinded with pain and grief and hate, they stop seeing things for what they are. Interestingly enough - BBC News, which always announces every Palestinian casualty caused by the Israelis (without double-checking the facts) had nothing, and I mean NOTHING to say about the severe casualties of the recent Palestinian infighting, including the dead kid, which occurred after the long awaited unity gov. stepped in. Why is that?
33. # 14, ayman...
stephane ,   france   (03.23.07)
my comment is full of hatred? waow! how did you guess that?of course that my comment is "full of hatred"! "there is no smoke without fire",you know this proverb? if the arabs were not 24/7 attacking israeli soldiers with guns,stones,molotov cocktails,if the arab were not 24/7 looking for a way to blow up themselves among israeli kids,if the arab parents in jenin or elsewhere were not teaching their kids since they're 2 year old to hate the jews and to kill them,if.....if you were not so barbaric,believe me,my talkback would be "full of love"!!!so,my dear ayman,i'm very proud of what i said and i say it again:those soldiers are heroes.
34. #19 rustum,you're scenarios are so STUPID!!!
stephane ,   france   (03.23.07)
don't compare what happen to a stone thrower once he's caught by soldiers to what can happen to marcel in florida...if marcel is attacked in florida while he was just doing shopping,this would be an INJUSTICE.but this young arrogant little arab was throwing stones on the soldiers before he received some slaps!and you know what rustum? i'm sure that this was not the first time that this teen was throwing stones on the soldiers!so he can escape 1 time,he can escape 5 times,but it's impossible that he will never be caught by the soldiers.and when they catch him he must pay a little bit ,no?and rustum,if jewish teens were harrassing arab soldiers in an arab country,the arabs would beat them 10 times worse than israeli soldiers gave slaps to this little arab.and the arab soldiers would never be judged by their superiors!you understand?
35. I have only one word to say ...
marya ,   sacramento, USA   (03.23.07)
AMONA!!! What about the brutal on-tape beating of the Jews in AMONA? Where was your outcry then you sanctimonious hypocrits??
36. WELL SAID #8
KACH 613 ,   MEDENAT YEHUDA!!!   (03.23.07)
When the solders do what they have to do then the SICK left will screem,I did not see anyone from the left shout about Amona, they want the end of Israel and we will not let it happen!!
37. Blatant Double Standard
dovid ,   jerusalem   (03.23.07)
'Blatant Double Standard' "This is a blatant example of a double standard," Orit Strook, the head of the Yesha (Judea and Samaria) Civil Rights Organization, told Arutz-7 this morning. "When there is a case of violence against Arabs, there is an immediate suspension, but we have cases of police violence against Jews - in which criminal indictments have already been handed down! - and the policemen are still serving and have not been suspended." Strook, a resident of Hevron, provided some examples: "Mounted policeman Dudu Edry, who has been indicted of trampling Yehuda Etzion in Amona over a year ago, has not been suspended. Policeman Yaniv Reuveni, who was photographed choking a boy from Netzer Hazani during the Disengagement protests, has not been suspended. Police officer Yechiel Amsalem kicked and broke the jaw of a protestor, yet has not been suspended from active duty..." Strook said that 100 complaints against police violence at Amona last year have been submitted, but only three indictments have been served. The Border Guard unit patrolling the Hawara area, near Shechem, is often pelted with rocks. In this Wednesday's incident, the police stopped a crowd of youths suspected of taking part in throwing rocks that day. One youth did not stop when ordered to by the police, and it was he who was filmed being hit.
38. How come Rustum only comments on jewish violence
Caroline   (03.23.07)
and never Palestinians or Arab violence which is exponentially higher? Hmmm, do I smell double standards? Rustum, don't quit your day job (in the ISM).
39. Stone Thrower?
Rustum ,   London, UK   (03.23.07)
Strange - there is no mention in any of the reports that this young boy was doing anything other than walking home from school. Strange, then, to see so many people call him "a stone thrower" - obviously a figment of the poster's imagination. I believe that all those who have erroneously stated that he threw stones should be forced to apologise publicty and then go and read a book about property reparation payments.
40. #26 Racist
EK ,   Toronto   (03.23.07)
Jewish men beat their wives and children too unfortunately the community refuses to admit these things happen. Talk any social worker in Crown Heights, and you will get some insightful stories... And your argument is totally irrelevant to this story to begin with... Unfortunately the IDF sends kids into an area that isn't suitable for a 19-20 year old. They don't have the proper training or maturity to handle situations such as these. These are kids placed into villages and towns that are justifiably hostile to their presence. Unfortunately the resistance that they have isn't morale, and having children throwing rocks and stones is rather pathetic. But at the same time, the soldiers shouldn't be there in the first place. A solution needs to be found that stops Israeli soldiers from going into patrolling these towns. Or, perhaps the Palestinians should study and resort to resistance similar to the Hagannah, Irgun and Lehi, whose resistance movements were instrumental in removing an occupying force.
41. What if the ARAB ROCK-THROWERS had been SUCCESSFUL & KILLED
Linda Rivera ,   New York   (03.23.07)
or MAIMED the Jewish drivers and passengers of the jeeps the Arabs were throwing rocks at ??? Arabs VIOLENTLY attempting every day to maim and murder Jews with rocks is a CRIME AGAINST HUMANITY !
42. to isragirl
rami   (03.23.07)
nice to hear u "care" about dead kid from pal infighting. the fact is ppl in WB+Gaza have heroicaly beared ruthless situations set by all ur gov. Under these insane conditions it's amasing that we even have elections in parliament, or universities or syndicates when the rest of the mideast are free dicatorship. our ppl have little skirmishes that mean nothing compared to several historical examples of infighting in resistance movements. as for bbc thing, well bbc is way more objective than the freakin CNN or US media, when palastinians are shot in a massacre they are "militants" even if btselem says they're not while israelis are "settlers" with insinuations they're innocent like little house on the prarie, with no reference that they are armed to theri teeth like vigilanties. that's why we don't have peace cause israel has the US media a hostage to its policies, when there is more descent in israel about IDF, there is none in USA.
43. FREE THE SOLDIERS NOW-WE DONT CARE WHAT THE WORLD THINK.
MIRA ,   ISRAEL   (03.23.07)
44. Who said the arab teen was throwing rocks????
Andy ,   ramat hasharon   (03.23.07)
Why are so many people on here defending what this slap happy soldier did? Of course the border guard are our heros, but not if they decide to engage in extra-caricular ass kickings. Regardless of how many arab wives are beaten up by their husbands or how many horrible murders they commit against us, our forces have to be held to high standards in the human rights of a population we occupy. Trust me, I am no left winger, but this video footage is very disturbing.
45. Very Well Said Andy from Ramat Hasharon.
papa jay   (03.23.07)
extra-caricular ass kickings! nice touch.
46. LET THERE BE NO SUCH THING AS EXCESSIVE FORCE ON THE p'arab:
MOSHE ,   USA   (03.24.07)
MEN, WOMEN OR CHILDREN. MOSHE
47. What else is new?
Persian CAT   (03.24.07)
Israeli soldiers beating the crap out of teenagers and letting their dogs loose on women! I'm socked!
48. Andy from Ramat Hasharon
israeli ,   israel   (03.24.07)
and other talkbackers - no, I do not support violence against civilians. One correction, however, these are not IDF troops, these are policemen, Border Police officers. Stop maligning the IDF unnecessarily!
49. #41- i'd prefer that over a bulldozer through my house.
Larissa ,   Australia   (03.24.07)
50. to #26
(03.24.07)
no matter what happen to their wives....at least muslim don't cheat on their hunsband-wives,,,unlike jewish, who in a day would have.....more that 24 times......
51. to # 26 u better what out......
Mark ,   USA   (03.24.07)
Why do you have such a negative view about muslims. Yes their husband do beat them, but isn't that also hppening in other religoin such as chridtanity, hinduaosm, judaisn...u name it...I think it's wrong to pick on one religions, all the bad and good things haapen in every religion. I would of had clap of hand if that was the only religion hitting their wives but see they are not, My dad always beat my mom, and i'm not muslim.... SO don't say that agian it makes you look ignoratnt and stupid.
52. Western media
Raphael ,   Netanya   (03.24.07)
make a fuss of slapping a teen who should have been better educated. They did not say a word about the serial gang racist rapists arrested in Galilee this month. Not politically correct to point out criminal arab sadists.
53. we know Israel has guards, but where is the border ?
oberver   (03.24.07)
even from the non-materialistic aspect, we couldn't found a border for Israel. Are those guards from the army or army police ? as in many incidents like that, we couldn't find the ordinary policemen. We used only to see young military recruits with automatic guns and armoured vehicles.
54. Insted of feeling ashame
(03.25.07)
Insted of feeling ashame of your selfs you made those soldiers heros , this shows what kind of people you are , some gangs and killers came from allover the world , wild , vampiers and so on .... and then you ask .. why the entire world are against you .... it's because of you ... and your talkbacks here is a shameful witness against you ... but don't cry all the time as usual .... ehi ehi ... anti-simitics .... ehi ehi ... terrorists .... ehi ehi Nazism .... ehi ehi Jew haters ... your brocken disc ... it's not true it's because of you and what you do .
55. to # 54
Casey ,   Germany   (03.25.07)
Good JOB!!!!!
Previous talkbacks
Back to article