Opinion
Entire world is not against us
Martin Sherman
Published: 28.03.07, 11:31
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
49 Talkbacks for this article
31. Don't tie your boat to the Evangelical docks.
Dan ,   USA   (03.28.07)
32. Brilliant Treatise
Brod ,   USA   (03.28.07)
Martin Sherman's brilliant treatise is a Must Read by the leaders, policy makers and the people of Israel. He is right on target on the issues.
33. a story
marya ,   jerusalem   (03.28.07)
a man asked his friend who weared a jacket from a sheep wool .put the skin inside the wool outside .the friend told him it is better to let the wool from inside that you would feel wormer in this cold weather // the other replied you will not be more clever than the sheep .. and i think israil will not be more clever than america invading the iraqu for promoting its western freedom and democracy .. then it was away from its freedom and democracy and want to get away from iraqu to win the life and ecconomy .. .and israil must look for its life and ecconomy not more that
34. IL GOVT has ABSOLUTELY no idea about Hasbara.What a shame!
Alan ,   SA   (03.28.07)
35. PR
Joe ,   Israel   (03.28.07)
Finally, someone who is not afraid to tell the truth. Wake up Israel, before it is too late!
36. #7 Palestinian
Carl ,   Indiana, USA   (03.29.07)
I think you watch too much Arab TV. You must understand that it's nothing but hate propaganda. The same goes for Arab education. Consult independent sources, read contrasting points of view. TV (in any country) is not a good source for educating yourself, anyway.
37. 100% right. Anyone in their right mind would concur!
(03.29.07)
38. to carle ,indiana ,usa
palastinian not the ,   jerusalem   (03.29.07)
life educate any one not the tv ..so be a palastinian , nablus , palastin . and then sheck your education .good bye mu indiana .
39. THE WHOLE WORLD IS NOT AGAINST US
MAHIR ZARA ,   TEL AVIV, ISRAEL   (03.29.07)
I DO NOT KNOW WHETHER THE WHOLE WORLD IS AGAINST US. BUT I DO KNOW THAT ALL THE LANGUAGES CONTAIN THE WORDS " ANTI-SEMITE AND ANTI-SEMITISM ". THERE IS NOT A SINGLE LANGUAGE THAT CONTAINS THE WORDS " PRO-SEMITE OR PRO-SEMITISIM". IT SEEMS THAT NOBODY EVER THOUGHT THERE WAS ANY USE FOR THESE MISSING WORDS, BECAUSE THERE IS NO SUCH THING, HENCE, NO SUCH CONCEPT !!!!!
40. #36- i think #7's comment is, in part true.
Larissa ,   Australia   (03.29.07)
I found this on a Jewish-Zionist website...... "....Feiglin warns that the Western world will ultimately have to face the facts and fight Islam. What will happen then? "In the end," Feiglin asserts, "the real winner in the war between Islam and Christianity will be Judaism." I have read some of the things they say and alot of it is pretty scary... Apparently they need to "perfect the world in the kingdom of God" ...... which means...... "True peace will only come when the whole world recognizes its Creator, and the special role assigned to His chosen people and the Holy Land." ....so there will make war and not peace until everyone believes in the Jewish religion or is slaves to the Jewish people? I'm not 100% sure but from reading this and bits from othe zionist sites that is what it sounds like means.... and i am in complete disagreement with it. These quotes were obtained from: www.jewishisrael.org (Not from Arab media)
41. #6 Justice
Yaakov ,   USA   (03.29.07)
You say that the Jews' unforgivable crime was to displace the so called Palestinian arabs. You totally neglect the fact that in 638CE you muslim arabs invaded and conquered the area by force. What makes you any better? You want the right of all arabs and their descendants, who left Israel to be able to return, yet you refuse the right of Jews who were exiled forcibly by the Romans to return, as well as the 900,000 Jews from arab countries who were forced to leave their homes of thousands of years in some cases, in recent decades to be compensated for their lost property, murdered relatives, and the upheaval in their lives, for no fault of their own. Your case is full of holes, unlike what you present. There were over 100 million refugees in the 20th century, all but you 3/4 of a million resolved their refugee status in one way or another and moved on with their lives. You stubborn, vengeful fools remain in a state of material and emotional desperation, largely due to your arab brothers refusal to absorb and assimilate you, and blame everyone besides those responsible--yourselves and your arab brothers. You create a perverse society of death, instead of life, and elect terrorists to govern you, then blame the world for not accepting and embracing you. You live off the benevolence of the US & EU for the most part, since that is where the UN gets most of its money, behave with an aire of entitlement to this support, as you condemn us, burn our flags in disrespect, and kidnap and murder those we send to help you. Israel turn over Gaza to you. You loot and destroy the greenshouses that could have been the start of a real economy for you, and instead construct a terror fortress, instead of meeting the infrastructrural needs all states face, like building new sewage treatment plants and replacing old ones. When you consequently find yourselves up to your necks in your own filth, you blame Israel, the west and everyone besides thoe responsible--yourselves! With your death oriented terrorist society you even kill one another and create a situation where foreign contractors refuse to enter for fear of their lives. So you dont receive what others want to give to you. If ever a people were NOT qualified to be given statehood it is YOU! And you have only yourselves to blame for it.
42. Evangelicals will turn against us
Jeffery ,   New York, USA   (03.29.07)
This author is a dreamer, and is out of touch with reality. The Evangelicals who are pro Israel, most of them are left wing and support the Palestinians too. The truth is Evangelism is declining the world over, since it is only gaining converts in poor countries. The richer a Christian get's the less spirtiual he becomes. By contrast Islam is strong spiritually. We would be fools to rely on Evangelicals, when the backlash (already beginning here) comes it's gonna be big. Most American's want the Zionist Christians out. Evangelicals here are turning to the left, and Jimmy Carter (Evangelical) is only one example, there will be many more. These Christians have always expected a lot from us, and when we fail todeliver they turn against us. The Evangelicals will do the same when they realise their Jesus isn't gonna come cuz we're sinners. They want us to live up to their ideal, that is why they support us. Their support is conditional and quite frankly, we should tell them where to go. We need to mobilise support from our own, not others, that is suicide.
43. An old story - adolescent machismo wants to go it alone
Karen R ,   USA   (03.29.07)
Not to mention the fact that the Right needs the Palestinian conflict and the feeling of victimization to keep the people voting for it. The Israeli Right is using the same tactics that the US Right used after 9/11 - "they're out to get us, but we're too strong for them - if you'll just support the political party that holds them in contempt."
44. # 16 - It's not a dream
raphael   (03.29.07)
First, Israel should be very cautious regarding Evangelical cause their motives in supporting Jewish state are dubious to say the least. But, the lyrics of Bob Dylan's Neighborhood Bully are as actual today as the time they were written. Most of people who are anti-Israeli or anti-Zionist are not decent and mostly anti-Semites who couldn't care less for Palestinians but since they have trouble with Jews the black and the red give them full support. They would do the same for amazonian Indios, Eskimos or Klingons if they were fighting against Jews. You can't compare Palestinians with oppressed people of South Africa during apartheid or African Americans in the 60s or eastern Europeans under USSR during Cold War. They fight back and they do it mercilessly in a warfare that does not recognize non combatants. And no matter how supportive you may feel for Palestinian cause the recent case of suicide bomber children praising their mother's act on Hammas TV will make you aske some serious questions. And who in the world with even smallest bit of objectiveness can support the Iranian looney president whose greates ambition is to see the End of Days and arrival of Mehdi and his campaign against Israel. The same forces that are enemies of Israel are becoming more and more aggressive in the West, Europe especially and save those who are gone insane by their political correctness others see what is islamism all about. Sadly the governments and media in the West, afraid of raging moslems on the streets worldwide, afraid of sucide bombers throught Europe play the neutral or even proArab role in regard of Middle East. But that is not the fault of Israel, her fault is only the will to survive. Even in borders of 1948. Jewish state will always seem too big to this people.
45. RIGHT ON THE NOSE! BRAVO
Effi ,   Ramat Gan, Israel   (03.30.07)
46. Sherman's trivial pursuits
RedStarYeast ,   USA   (03.31.07)
Mr. Sherman mistakenly believes that Israel is taking part in some kind of international glamor contest and, rather than waste time displaying its own gracious curves, should devote its efforts to pointing out Miss Arabia's warts and pimples. I'm afraid, however, that an attempt to make the Arabs seem ugly is not going to make Israel any more beautiful in the world's eyes. Mr. Sherman's pie-in-the-sky proposals are laughably grandiose and impracticable. And, in the long run, they are simply PR, in the most negative sense of the term. Rather than attempt to manipulate perceptions, Israel could vastly improve its standing by tackling true impediments to international respect: free the occupied territories, end the despicable subjugation of the Palestinians, respect internationally-accepted standards of human rights, eradicate racism at home. Mr. Sherman seems to be fixated on cosmetic image makeovers. These might work for Miss Israel contestants, automobile brands, toothpastes and haemorrhoid medications. Israel's problems are too profound and serious: it needs radiation and chemotherapy, not facelifts and Botox.
47. Israel's Hasbara adopts its adversaries untruths
Dr Yoram Shifftan ,   Darom, Israel   (04.01.07)
Our official Hasbara adopts the untruths propagated by Israel enemies, such as that Western Palestine is Palestine, and this is in clear distinction, to Israel's official Hasbara until Oslo began, when Israel's MFA propagated the message that "Jordan is Palestine" Israeli hasbara has to revert to its objectively true pre-Oslo line and inculcates in the world some basic facts, in particular that there is already a Palestinian Arab State on four-fifths of Palestine (see in particular Julius Stone's book; chapter in pp 22-25) and that there is already an Arab state (being one nation according to their own documents means they deserve one state only). This is cardinal since the whole world thinks that Israel "occupies" "Palestinian land" and thus prevents Palestinian Arab "self-determination". If we kept hammering and focusing on these basic facts, also mentioning Jewish refugees from Arab countries, in particular whenever "Palestinian refugees' are mentioned, than we could change Israel's position dramatically.
48. the entire world is against us
IUC ,   Newport Beach, Ca.   (04.02.07)
For interesting positive stories about Israel....visit.. www.israelupclose.org
49. 43# Karen Go visit an abortion clinic.
Steven Wilson ,   Anchorage, Alaska   (04.08.07)
The Democratic Party has victimized 4 million childrens lives in the same period of time the war has taken place. Oh I forgot....the Democrats are free of innocent blood. Right? Wrong! Your party supports mass murder of children. Hypocritical to say the least, that Democrats constantly whine about the war and the war dead. Save some babies for a change Lone Ranger. Be a super hero for childen for a change.
Previous talkbacks
Back to article