News
Shoah survivors forced back to Germany due to Israel's lack of restitution laws
Ines Ehrlich
Published: 16.04.07, 11:32
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
50 Talkbacks for this article
31. WALK THE LINE
(04.16.07)
HELLO I AM ATILLA KARAGÖZOĞLU THEY NEED TO WAKE UP. THEY ARE TOO POOR TO TAKE THEIR HEADS FROM THE FEAR. THE GOD (G-D) IS THE BEST RABBIE. HEIS EXPECTING THEY GO OUT TO HELP WORLD.
32. What credibility dose israel have left.
AR ,   USA   (04.16.07)
The only thing it had going for it was a state to for the jewish survivors of the holocaust and future generations but it dosnt even support those very people whome the state was formed to protect. What do you have to say for your country? BTW #2 your military and defenses are paid for by US tax payers. Israel gets more money from the US in aid and free weapons than the entire continent of africa. Dont use bs talking points to justify the hypocracy of your nation. But i didnt expect much from the most corrupt democracy in the world.
33. SHAME!!!!!!!!
female ,   Tel Aviv   (04.16.07)
My G-d, what a shame.....I didn't see the documentary unfortunately, but my co-workers told me about it....I'm originally from the Netherlands and I know that even the Dutch children from Holocoust survivers receive money so they can see therapists or need special medicine here in Israel...not only did the parents suffer terrible during the Shoa, but also their children who were born after the war, suffered....we have for our Dutch citizen who live in Israel, a very good organisation, with qualified therapists who also speak Hebrew and Dutch....I have to say though that the money they receive from the Netherlands is maybe not a lot but at least can cover the bill for medicine...
34. survivors
joseph Schonwald ,   jerusalem israel   (04.16.07)
shameful ,disgrace , how callus ,could it be the Jewish state doing to Jewish people ? G-D help us
35. AR
SAM ,   USA   (04.16.07)
Keep on lying to youself. It seems to help you out . I always said bigotry is a severe symptom of stupidity. Is Egypt in Africa? seems to me they get a hell of a lot of US dollars, almost as much as Israel. Put the rest of the continent with them and they get a HELL of a lot more money than Israel. Not all Americans are stupid, fool. Even the "Palistinians" get 100s of millins of dollars from the US. The 3 Billion we give to Israel (the US gives Puerto Rico 33 Billion , by the way) is a drop in the bucket that has to be spent in the US anyway. In other words, it just gets reinvested in the private sector. Keep lying. Goebels said if you lie long enough, someone will believe you. But here is another American saying: You can fool some of the people all of the time. All of the people some of the time, but you can't fool all of the people all of the time. Your corrupt morals and blatant ignorance is showing By the way, Israel has a $100 billion economy NOT due to the US. They don't need our money , you idiot
36. I had a relative who lived...
Flavio ,   Sao Paulo, Brazil   (04.16.07)
...for decades in Israel. He worked for Bank Leumi and retired in the 80s. He moved to Frankfurt exactly because of the health and housing package provided by the German government, after having a stroke who physically crippled him and finding out that he no longer had the means to go on living in Israel. He did not complained about the treatment received from Israeli authorities, but you could see in his eyes that, after surviving unspeakable horrors during WWII, he thought that he deserved more. He died a few years ago, in Frankfurt. It is really a shame.
37. Why is money the issue?
JK ,   NYC   (04.16.07)
Why is the comparison of value, money or support or material lifestyle, I think the idea is the most obsurd thing ever, it would give me nightmares of guilt even to suggest such a thing.
38. Holocaust survivors
Judy ,   Lexington USA   (04.16.07)
If Israel will not care for them, who will? How can Israel turn its back on those who have suffered the most barbaric and cold blooded murder in history. Shame on Israel.
39. # 23
Birdi ,   Israel   (04.16.07)
Thank you Talula. We have to change the way things run in our tiny country. There should be one organization in charge of helping the Holocaust survivours in Israel. After reading this article I am in drop jaw SHOCK.
40. #35 AR: Engage Brain Before Running Mouth
Daniel ,   Los Angeles   (04.16.07)
Wherever the money originates, Israel is not short of a few dollars to make sure that Holocaust Survivors are taken care of. As for your specific ailment, I once read a t-shirt that said "Engage brain before running mouth." Well that applies pretty much to you. One might think that someone so strident and rude, who accuses others of lying, bigotry, corrupt morals etc. would bother to check their facts before opening their big mouth. Why don't you go ahead and check your facts before accusing others of stupidity? You only embarrass yourself.
41. To #23
M. Hartley ,   Atlanta, US   (04.16.07)
Any chance to get the article in English?
42. Daniel, LA
Ryan ,   Calgary, Canada   (04.16.07)
One might also think that one would supply facts when name calling others, and back up their accusations. It is easy for anyone to post something similar to yours, but you lack any piece of intellect or fact in your post. With such a bold post and claim, you would assume that you would state one piece of factual evidence. Your the embarrassment, and if you would practice what you preach you should be engaging your brain. Do you deny that the US provides economical aid to countries other than Israel? Do you deny the fact that Israel's economy creates jobs and prosperity as well as income for the state. Now if Israel didn't have neighbours hell bent on it's destruction, I'm sure the US aid will shrink and Israel will find itself with more funds to apply to social programs. But considering the fact that you need to protect your state before applying new endeavours. I think you should go back to reading t-shirts and keeping your big mouth closed.
43. Question why do they get our money if they dont need it?
AR ,   USA   (04.16.07)
NO NATION ON EARTH GETS MORE AID FROM US THAN ISRAEL. NO NATION. who is fooling who. can you tell me one country that gets more money than israel? In the past 6 years we have givin israel about 25 billion dollars in direct military aid. (this is not including the free weapons we give them) We also underwrite the cost of many of their own defense industries including the merkerva battle tank. Of course israel needs us without us they wouldnt be able to afford the occupation you idiot. No one here is racist except for the "jewish state" idiot. Shut up everyone who critisises israel isnt a racist come up with a better argument we here that one enought. You only need to fool a few and they will do the rest my friend. Israelis have fooled our government into believing that they are our ally which is a crock. They sell our secrets to the chinease , spy on us constantly, and attack our sailors and you consider them americas friends. Your a fool.
44. AR #43
Ryan ,   Calgary, Canada   (04.16.07)
You have some good comments there, but you forget the reason behind the high funding, that is the simple fact that no country also is under attack and scrutiny as much as Israel and without the funding Israel would be overwhelmed by her enemies. Also you are wrong, in 2004, foreign aid to Iraq was 18.44 billion, compared to 2.62 for Israel, and followed closely by egypt at 1.87 billion. In 2005 Israel was 2.58 billion and African aid equated to just over 4.05 billion. So israel does not receive more aid than all of Africa. It is obvious your thoughts and posts do not have a neutral tone as you are clearly against the state of Israel, I won't use the term antisemitic as it's thrown around too often and I don't care for it. But you can't debate an issue when your attached to it emotionally, They call that a conflict of interest. The US owes us countless money for softwood deals, continually steal our fresh water and alter our tribiturary systems by building dams and factories and flooding Canadian plains close to the border. They continually violate our arctic borders, which the UN states as an act or war. Yet are we still friends? I can also provide you more instances of US abuse to Canada, and of US aid to countries other than Israel.
45. AR, also to be noted
Ryan ,   Calgary, Canada   (04.16.07)
is the fact that the military aid to Israel while higher in number is pretty much given right back to the US in arms purchases, creating jobs in america and providing taxes to the government so it's an indirect investment in it's own economy. Where as egypt who receives high amounts of aid purchases their equipment mostly from France. Instead of asking why do we give Israel so much, a better question to state if your head was so full of anti Israel chatter would be Why are we giving so much of our money to anybody while we have economical problems on the homefront. Why also, is most of that aid military aid?
46. incredibly disgusting
(04.16.07)
Incredibly disgusting. Please do something!! Not only for the survivors but also for all poor people in Israel. Incredible!!!! for a Movie !!!!!
47. Ryan. Duh!
Daniel ,   Los Angeles   (04.17.07)
Clearly you have a problem understanding the OBVIOUS (at least to anyone with half a brain) logical implication of my posting. i.e. that I DID check my facts. Moreover, you seem to have some other logic problems given the profusion of non sequiturs in your postings. Not to mention the spelling and grammar problems. Anyway, this is all pointless. Israel can well afford to take care of Holocaust survivors if it has the desire to do so. There's no denying that.
48. not surprised
ANNIE ,   damascus syria   (04.20.07)
They treat the holocaust survivors same way as the Palestinians; forcing them out. Zionism has nothing to do with judaism.
49. Haulecaust survivors
Renate Baramy ,   Ramat Hasharon   (05.09.07)
I am ashamed ot my government at the way they handled this situatin,and feel for the survivors. I am dusgusted at the behaviour of all the members of the Knesset as well as the banks. I wish there was a way for me to do something,but unfortunately I don't know what I can do/
50. A big shame
מתתיהו ,   Warsaw   (04.30.08)
I saw this program on polish TV. I never tought that something like this can be real. How can peopele and Israel care so bad the Holocaust survivors. This program was shown in many countries, haw people in the world should learn about the history of Holocaust when the country of the Holocaust survivirs do nothing to help this people. The Holocaust survivors are hereos and it is a big shame how people who can, need and must help them they don't do that. Big, big, very big shame. We can only hope that God will redress them and punish this people witch should help them.
Previous talkbacks
Back to article