News
Beilin calls Hebron Jews ‘deluded’
Tal Rabinovsky
Published: 17.04.07, 20:43
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
87 Talkbacks for this article
31. Re #16: Are you sarcastic?
Steve ,   USA   (04.17.07)
B"H If not a sarcastic twist on the name "Sharon", could you explain why he is your hero? It sounds very supportive an all, and I want to know if you admire his physique or what exactly makes him your hero.
32. Student (04.17.07)
(04.17.07)
kol hakavod
33. Re #10: What did he expose but himself?
Steve ,   USA   (04.17.07)
B"H You must be kidding to say he exposed wackos. You were referring to him and his entourage I suppose. Somehow I think they will not be fully exposed in this political season for their full activity. Olmert is too busy prosecuting those on the top of the synnogogue for throwing a water-like substance in protest of the stealing in Gaza.
34. to Peter , no.27
mordechai ,   jerusalem   (04.17.07)
I'm sorry that you are unable to distinguish between someone with a far left point of view and someone who spends his efforts inciteing hate against his fellow jews. Be aware that although there are many who fall into both of the above catagories, there are many leftists who mean well and strive for the safety and prosperity of Israel
35. Beilin
gabriela ben ari ,   jerusalem   (04.18.07)
This piece of art will have to dig deep to take Abraham Ischak and Yaakov from the lawfully bought inheritance And will be glad to that too Some people should recive the BASTARD AWARD OF THE YEAR and he would definatelly make the most ideal candidate Puhhleezzz Iosi
36. 26 Are you proud that King David built his town after
jack ,   U.S.   (04.18.07)
destroying an Arab village?
37. Beilin,a sane and courageous man
sara ,   U.S.   (04.18.07)
the treatment of the Palestinian population by the settlers is a scandal.
38. 36 - there's an Arab village on top of the Jewish site
(04.18.07)
That's what Abraham's TB meant on #26. Arabs came after the Jews were expelled. Study the history of every Muslim sacred site in Jewish ancient territory and you'll discover that it's very likely it was built on top of a Jewish holy site.
39. REAL ESTATE IN HEBRON
kowalski ,   chicago, usa   (04.18.07)
ANY JEW WHO INVESTS IN ARAB REAL ESTATE HAS ROCKS IN HIS HEAD. WHEN HE WAS CIRCUMCISED THE MOHEL GAVE THE WRONG END BACK TO HIS MOTHER.
40. Peres' poodle
Steven ,   San Francisco   (04.18.07)
His bark is worse than his bite.
41. No 8 'student' et al
Baruch Nili ,   Jerusalem,Israel   (04.18.07)
Wait til you get to the chapters about Menachem Begin, then you can re-issue your criticism in a more balanced way. As to the rest, this morning when Beilin warned against arming PA men the right were astonished at his wisdom. He is supported by several PA supporters too. Now when he suggests one of the more obvious solutions to the shtetl called jewish Hebron where at one and the same time the state of Israel is made a fool of and its IDF protects the settlers, and where terrorists like Marzel can abuse our democracy, then the usual hysterics shout and scream. And just look at the hatred incitement,slander and definitely inapproprioate language that our democracy and free speech permits here.
42. Very sad what Mr. Beilin is doing to his own people.
Allen ,   USA   (04.18.07)
43. to Baruch, no. 41
mordechai ,   jerusalem   (04.18.07)
It is a shame that you feel obligated to lower the course of the above discussion to such a degrading level. No one has called Dr. Beilin a terrorist, although by his actions , he has cause far more innocent deaths than Marzel. A little respect for your fellow Israeli, even if you disagree with him.
44. Beilin is scum
RA   (04.18.07)
The man disgusts me, he should not be allowed in Israel. He is a traitor.
45. to #25 ossanassa-there is no legal body in israel.
susan ,   israel   (04.18.07)
its just like nigeria.
46. beilin is a stupid man. some people can never learn.
susan ,   israel   (04.18.07)
47. Beilin's One way ticket to hell
malcolm   (04.18.07)
48. #41 Baruch Nili - Shtetl?
Student   (04.18.07)
Your odd use of the word shtetl reminded me of a recent talkback by Elchonon of Jerusalem on "The Hebron Test" column on the opinion section of YNET. When I went to look for it, I was surprised to find it had been addressed to you!!! So now I'll take the liberty of copying and pasting Elchonon's comment to remind you once more who is the one that has the shtetl mindset in this case. I quote: "You make m laugh the sad ironic laugh, you refer to us as "shtetel jews" how totaly ironic and even hypocritical.. We who want to expand eretz yisrael are called "shtetel jews" while the liberated jews want to crowd into the green line. We who arm ourselves are called "shtetel jews" while you liberated jews are staunchly anti gun and choose to rely on the UN for protection. We who defend ourselfs are called "shtetel jews" while you of the liberated species choose to turn the other cheeck least we provoke the goyim. We who are proud of our religion and our inheritance, who wish to fight for freedom are nothing but a "shtetl jew" You of the liberated "jew" are not merely a ghetto jew, no no no you are way below the ghetto jew.. Because the ghetto jew has what he believes for, what he lives for and what he dies for... And even the ghetto jew will rise up and fight! and fight they did in warsaw, not because they would win but to restore jewish pride. A pride you are ashamed of and disgrace. G-d help you and your ilk! Elchonon, Jerusalem." End of quote. Something for you to think about....
49. The Arabs/enemies love Beilin! I wish he lived among them
Roger ,   USA   (04.18.07)
50. Beilin is full of venom. Dear Arabs! He is yours! Take him!
Danny ,   USA   (04.18.07)
51. Gault mentality vs the new antisemitism
Ilan ,   Ariel   (04.18.07)
Recurrent theme among the secular Zionists is that they have adopted all of the classic criticisms of the Galut. Not of the Jews of the Galut, but of the jew hatred of the galut. In there lexicon religious Jews are parasites, freeloaders and anachronistic. Even one of the numerous examples like Israel's Nobel prize winner can't sway them. After all if the worse antisemite will point out the "good jew" So Beilin is no surprise. He may even believe in his cheap grandstanding and is not just playing to his brown shirt crowd of supporters.
52. To #18
Noah ,   New York, NY   (04.18.07)
You wrote: "pull the israeli army out and see how many last unprotected. " I agree. After all, if Hashem is on the side of the settlers, then they certainly don't need us to risk the lives of our children for them. They'll be fine on their own.
53. # 18 , Papa Jay, why don't you shove
Joe ,   USA   (04.18.07)
your thumb up where the sun don't shine.... If a Jew would call for the expulsion of all Arabs from Hebron, he would be accused of inciting to riot, what if a MK calls for removal of all Jews, isn't it also an incitment to riot. Beillin, you are a publicity hunter with no B***s.
54. beilin
colin ,   israel   (04.18.07)
Once again this traitor to israel show how much of a fool and idiot he really is.Claiming a new settlement as a story to bring pressure on our pioneers living in the whole land of israel is a new low.He must learn history and will know that these men and woman have been in hebron before the state of modern israel.Beilin is one of the agitators and causing much heartache for the arabs and the jews.
55. Israel will be speaking in Arabic if they listen to Beilin.
Ken Jurist   (04.18.07)
The same Beilin that wants to free Barghouti, the murderer of Jews. Now wants to remove all Jews from Hebron. This is the same Beilin that opposed killing Yassin and Rantisi, even though hundreds of Israeli civilians were murdered by these 2 terrorists. Beilin needs to understand, the Israeli people reject his surrender policy.
56. He called Hebron a "new setlement"?!
GZ ,   USA   (04.18.07)
The ancient first capital of Israel is but a "new settlement" to this man? He should be cut off from his kin.
57. Who is funding Beilin?
Dr. Jack ,   Canada   (04.18.07)
We know who is funding Beilin, the EU, and some other enemies of Israel. Last year, during a Q&A with Ha'aretz, they asked him a question I submitted, about his financial supporters. He answered that he had "forgotten" his budget papers in his office, and does not remember where his funding is coming from??? What a cheap excuse, but typical for him. As usual, he is dishonest in every aspect of his life.
58. Yossi - Traitor to Israel
Hinda ,   Northern California   (04.18.07)
Yes he's a traitor. He has forgotten history of how the Arabs under the leadership of the Grand Mufti murdered over 28,000+ Jews and about 1,000+ nonJews in the 1920s. Hebron was a Jewish village. Always has been. Even under the Ottomans, Jews were always living there. The Arafaters, many were illegal alliens who's parents had come into the country as per the orders of the Muslim Brotherhood. So Mr. Beilin needs to be escorted to Mecca - and please let him become either an honorary member of the NK or have him take the Shahadah. We who love Israel as Israel do not want to see traitors who would sell Israel down to mass murderers in the name of PIECE (not peace - as they have no idea what that is).
59. Beilin is a bigger appeaser then me.
Neville Chamberlain   (04.18.07)
Hey, atleast I got company now.
60. How come that awful Jew is allowed to cause trouble in Isr?
Stan ,   USA   (04.18.07)
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article