Opinion
Not in my name
Chas Newkey Burden
Published: 19.04.07, 09:41
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
51 Talkbacks for this article
1. boycott
Gillian ,   Ashkelon   (04.19.07)
Dear Mr. Burden, Thank you for your article, one of course, which is not news here. We are well aware of the bias of the so called "free press". More important, has this article been published in England, where its most needed.
2. Right on the button! Thanks Chas.
BigE ,   Israel   (04.19.07)
3. Thank you, Mr. Burden, little pocket of truth
Danielle ,   centre   (04.19.07)
4. GOOD ARTICLE CHAS
Scott   (04.19.07)
5. When will you get it right
Khalid ,   The Netherlands   (04.19.07)
When will zionists get it right? it is not animosity topwards Israel otr its people, it is not animosity towards the Jewish faith (as always claimed by zionist propaganda) It is just animosity towards the acts and policies of Israel in the occupied territories, it is just animosity towards the occupation and the imprisonmennt of a whole population group simply because they are different or their faith is different. It is animosity agasinst the human rights violations and abuses at the checkpoints, at the hands of the brutal Israeli border police. By the way those violations and excesses are documented on the websites of numerous Israeli human rights organizations. I suggest that zionists stop their pathetic boring repeated terms of anti semetism and anti israelism each time israeli policy is critised and attempts are made to expose the brutality of those policies against another population group
6. Thank u for having guts and brains-such a
Ora Levi   (04.19.07)
surprising mix in a journalist-and a brit at that:):):) it takes guts to stand up for truth-but u r a better man for that and i m sure u sleep well at night.
7. Yellow Journalism
Jonathan ,   Toronto, Canada   (04.19.07)
The British ashamed of their Colonial past and attrocities, choose to project their shame and guilt they comitted against Israelis and Jews. Jews need to take them to task and remind the British of their role in the Exodus, Hebron Massacre (1929) ect. and force them to face up to their crimes.
8. It's result for your brutal long occupation
(04.19.07)
Your problem that you didn't count for such day and you thought always that the holocoast will be the shield you can hide your crimes behind and you didn't count that one day the world will say enough is enough and still you prefer to moan and cry all the time than changing your selfs ... it's now up to you ... you see the world is changing around you and your sympathie account became too much down and soon there will not be anymore .... so or you change your idology with the Arabs first and then with rest of the world or face the punishments which will come one after one one day you will be totaly isolated .
9. Yeah, British journalists are largely anti-Semitic, we know
Asi ,   T"A, Israel   (04.19.07)
As they say, what else is new
10. Shocking
Raoul Schur ,   Netanya, Israel   (04.19.07)
Thanks Mr Burden for that. From what you write, it seems a whole lot worse than I thought. I would be interested to know if the Guardian, BBC etc would publish your letter. I have my doubts.
11. NUJ vote
Avi Lehrer ,   jERUSALEM   (04.19.07)
I liked your article Mr. Burden. But if you are no longer a member of the NUJ is it still possible to be a regular journalist in the UK? And like an earlier talkback, I'd be interested to know if your article was or could be published in Britain(other than a Jewish newspaper). If so, where?
12. Jews of World,I write daily here aboutUK AntiJew&Anti Israel
Alan ,   SA   (04.19.07)
The whole UK Media (Press+TV/Radio) is virtually 100% Anti Israel. Day after day the "hymn of hate" is the same .Unfortunately ,it is hard to seperate Anti Israel from Anti Jew even if that is the intention. The public see them both in one light for no special reason after exposure to this "Der Sturmer" newspaper/TV journalism. . "If you are a Jew you must be a Zionist ,so I will overturn your late Mothers tombstone and beat your 11 year old daughter up on the upstairs of a London bus!" I believe a lot of Media people must be bribed or in some way given benefits in exchange for their fervour in Israel bashing. Why such fervour?Nothing Israel can do will make them change their impression . No withdrawal from Gaza.Nothing at all! The hate press is there day after day! Israel must just get on with life and take every measure needed for security AND dont exchange those killers for Shalit .
13. Colflict against ISrael and the media
Derek ,   NJ, USA   (04.19.07)
The anti-semitic Brits don't give a rats @$$ about the Arabs, instead they want the Arabs to hate and kill the Jews. That way the British media gets "the best of both worlds": "Dead Jews" and violent stories to publish and make headlines for them it a "Win win situation."
14. Right on! great article thank G-d for sane people like you!
Eli ,   Ramat Gan Israel   (04.19.07)
15. Nothing new - the British have always been anti Israel
David ,   Karmiel, Israel   (04.19.07)
One small but relevant correction. The NUJ boycott is on "Israeli goods". Why single out the BBC for its failure to use the "T" world. ALL the English language foreign news channels we see here in Israel, including our good friends at Fox News Channel, use the word "militants". The Wikipedia defines "militant" as follows: "The word militant has come to refer to any individual or party engaged in aggressive physical or verbal combat, normally for a cause" so the usage is correct. Regarding the TV News media's anti Israel stance, you must take into consideration that the Arabs, led by Prince Al-Waleed bin Talal of Saudi Arabia, have huge share holdings in US and other Western corporations. During the Muslim riots in Paris, Fox News Channel's headline was "Muslims riot in Paris". The headline was changed to "poverty riots in Paris" after the prince's 30 second phone call to Rupert Murdoch, the head of News Corp, the parent of Fox. At the time the prince boasted about this and a number or articles about his "power" were written. You might remember that SkyNews is also part of News Corp. Britain has a long and sordid history of anti-Semitism and her appeasing of the Arab World is nothing new. A perfect example of this was the disgusting behavior of 15 service personnel captured by the Iranians. The Blair Government allowed this episode to make Britain the laughing stock of the world. However, the bad press that Israel receives from foreign journalists can be blamed on our lack of aggressive public relations. There is no Israeli News Channel broadcasting 24 hours a day. Our TV News are slow in covering events that matter and our camera crews take a very long time to get to the scene. Thus there is no way that Israel can counter false accusations when they happen. The apathetic attitude by the governments of this country are based on that old and outdated statement attributed to Golda Meir that Israel doesn't have to apologize for anything. Other things that add fuel to the fire of hatred are the constant scandals and the corruption that are so evident here. Yes, these things do happen in other countries but other countries are not Israel, the home of the Jewish scapegoat since the beginning of time. Our media moguls, the Government and the communications industry must wake up to the facts of live of the 21st Century. News, good or bad, is now! What happened and hour ago is old news and has no interest. It is no use countering manipulated photos and reports days or weeks after they happened. Our TV News people have to open up and encourage public views by e-mail and SMS. Our Channel 2 News doesn't have an e-mail address and Seder Olami has a phone number which is busy all the time! Only a full time news channel in a number of languages can counter the actions of organizations like the National Union or Journalists and the Academic Unions in the UK and other countries. We have a choice, the "status quo" of apathy or get go on an aggressive PR campaign to counter the brilliant Arab propaganda being used so effectively against us.
16. they won't
(04.19.07)
Khalid, I'm afraid they won't get it, ever! The motion called for the end of Israeli aggression in Gaza and other occupied territories. It's against actions made by the state of israel, not against religion, but you can't complain about israeli politics without being called an anti-semite.
17. Correction to Khalid & Number 16
David ,   London, England   (04.19.07)
The article never claimed that people who criticise Israel are anti-semitic. So please stop claiming that it did.
18. Thanks
Iossef ,   J'lem, Israel   (04.19.07)
Thanks for this comforting paper. Is it the beginning of a new era ? Open minded journalists writting real balanced articles ? Well, I Hope !
19. journalist
Mitchell Gayer ,   new jersey   (04.19.07)
And what thanks do the anti-semetic British get? No one has mentioned that the righteous Palistianians have been holding a British BBC journalist captive for almost a month. And that is after standing "shoulder to shoulder" with the Palistinians for the past 3 years.
20. kalid and anonymous #8,16
israeli ,   israel   (04.19.07)
YOU don't get it. This article is not about what Israel does or does not, it is not about Zionism or Israeli-Arab relations. It is about the biased British press, and I would also add blatantly and shamelessly ignorant (possibly drunk as well?) British journalists who cannot tell Itzhak Rabin from Bibi Netanyahu and who are amazed to hear about Israeli Arabs, etc. And this is not news. Methinks the good old al-Beeb has admitted to its anti-Israeli stance: http://www.ynetnews.com/articles/0,7340,L-3318582,00.html #16 - you wirte that the NUJ adopted a motion calling for the end of Israeli aggression, etc. So what? Since when does the government of Israel have to take orders from the NUJ? Does the UK government take any motice of said NUJ? And people, it is not only the British press, look at Scandinavia, Holland, and France, among others. Alan in SA, thank you, you are right, we, should focus on getting on with life. That's exactly what we are doing, believe me!
21. British are Anti Semites
JK ,   NYC   (04.19.07)
Why don't they call it the White Paper that sealed the fate of so many Jews left stranded in Christian Europe during the Nazis reign.
22. I had thought ...
Jonno ,   Oz   (04.19.07)
that perhaps the UK journalist boycott was an idea to protect Alan Johnston nad have him returned. It seems that is not the case. Thanks for the heads up.
23. Khalid -it is" animosity"(as you put it) to Jewish faith!
Alan ,   SA   (04.19.07)
24. Let them boycott
Israel   (04.19.07)
A boycott means there won't be any lying about us - it's a good positive thing!
25. I proudly boycott the UK
Mark ,   USA   (04.19.07)
26. Do not let the BBC reporters enter
MARK ,   USA   (04.19.07)
The UK must be denied entry into Israel. They need to be classified as "enemy combatant". These journalists ignore the fact that the Palestinians hold reporters hostage! Will they blame Israel for that?
27. Thanks for the INSIDE SCOOP
malcolm   (04.19.07)
I have read the Times of London and at times have been completely appalled. The only thing Burden doesn't mention is the blatant Jew Hate underlying it all. There is simply no other explanation for it.
28. Interesting state of affairs in UK journalism
JPS ,   Efrat, Israel   (04.19.07)
From what Burden writes, it looks like the rot in the UK's journalism profession is deep and wide. It leads to a big question mark over the universities in the UK, where journalists are taught. Or does it? With a history of marxist-leninism woven throughout the labour movement and upper education in the UK, it's not surprising that the end result is a generation of pseudo-professionals. A journalist (at least the ones who taught me) is charged with striving for the truth and to present the facts to the reader - and the reader is supposed to make up their mind as to what the story means to them. Marxist-Leninists, of course, believe that their system does the thinking for everybody, and passing lies off as facts is SOP. Small wonder that a generation of Anglo journalists are now out slanting the news to reflect their revolutionary views. That's what they were taught. They actually do think that what they're doing is real journalism, rather than see themselves as the propaganda tools of their cause (which they of course are).
29. #5, Khalid, Hamas charter calls for KILLING JEWS.
David ,   Boston, USA   (04.19.07)
This is not about Israeli's but about Islamofasicists call to kill Jews. Fix your own religion. There are some serious problems with the modern day application of Islam. It is highly racist and extremely violent. Its not even about Israel. These crazy Muslims are doing it EVERYWHERE in the world. I am not condemning Islam or Muslims. I have some good friends who are Muslim from different parts of the world, but these Islamofascists are the greatest threat to the world. Fix Islam and peace will happen.
30. british disgusting pieces of crap
ytr   (04.19.07)
Next talkbacks
Back to article