News
IDF commanders indicted for soldier's suicide
Hanan Greenberg
Published: 19.04.07, 18:43
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
9 Talkbacks for this article
1. Depression ..should have taken him to the doc
ben ,   singapore   (04.19.07)
....the only sane thing to do. They should not have neglected the boy :( Do you think the mother of this boy carried him 9 months and 10 day in the womb, bringing him to this world, to have fed him, cloth him, love him, groom him to manhood and to see him commit suicide ? No this is an ommission to act in the positive.Failure on the part of the IDF Officer , failure to ensure the welfare of the soldier.I am sure this is not the first case. Probe, Dig the Files ! They should have send him to the hospital, he would have got an injection to sleep and recover. This is heart breaking news ! The company commander and his deputy give them a love letter. A Temp Suspension Letter till the court concludes !
2. Someone has to take responibillity for something, here.
Ayelet Chen ,   Israel   (04.19.07)
Let this be a start. Since when is leaving a weapon unattended NOT punishable?
3. Releasing Terrorists is State-Approved "Negligent Homicide"
Observer ,   Europe   (04.19.07)
4. Standard Operating Procedure
ben ,   singapore   (04.19.07)
In a situation where the soldiers is unwell, the first thing to do is take the weapon away or put him in a safe enviroment where there is no guns. It is no good excuse to say ".....the soldier would have committed suicide sooner or later, and that therefore no personal measures should be taken against his commanding officers. ..." Here the commander's weapon – which was left in the room was used by that depressed boy.Is this a safe enviroment to leave the boy with gun left open air in the room. What commander is that ? The neglegence is that they should have sent the boy to the hospital. It is all wasted ! Very Sad ! : (
5. NO RUACH HAMEFAQED! THESE ARE NOT OFFICERS, THEY ARE IDIOTS
HaDaR ,   Israel   (04.19.07)
NO RUACH HAMEFAQED! THESE ARE NOT OFFICERS, THEY ARE IDIOTS!!! THEY ARE THE SAME GUYS WHO INSTEAD OF GRANTING SUPPORT, THEY PROMISE YOU A TRIAL IF YOU SHOOT AT THE ENEMY AND REACT WHEN SOME MUSTACHEOED IDIOT HITS YOU OR STONES YOU! THEY HAVE TRANSFORMED OUR GLORIOUS ARMY INTO A PULCINELLA ARMY LEAD BY PINOCCHIOS!
6. Well done Lieutenant-Colonel Udi ben-Eliezer,
rh ,   Ashdod Israel   (04.19.07)
The Central Command chief prosecutor should also be prosecuted for corruption of Justice. If the article is accurate it is a clear case of negligence, and failure to follow procedure. unrequited love , very powerful emotion. Should write a poem or a song, become religious, travel the word, go mad, but please do not kill yourself
7. The boy voiced distress
ben ,   singapore   (04.19.07)
He communicated his distress...that all...the comander should have taken a positive step- the only logical and resonable thing to do is to send him to the doctors. Where is that Peretz hiding ? Note to : Hanan Greenberg thank you and please PROBE FURTHER !!! Ynet thank you for REPORTING this case. PLease PROBE !
8. A REVOLUTION IS NEEDED NOW AGAINST THE ISRAELI POWERS
(04.19.07)
9. the indictment
observer   (04.19.07)
the exterior didn't have to be indicted, it's the massada culture of death which should have been.
Back to article