News
Leftists say violently attacked by settlers
Ali Waked
Published: 27.04.07, 15:13
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
95 Talkbacks for this article
31. why does a rabbi question jews in hebron ???
Andrew ,   Miami.fl   (04.27.07)
32. Nice if true, but probably a fabrication.
sk ,   USA   (04.27.07)
Really, how many fabrications need to be debunked before we just don't believe them? I think Ali Waked was the star reporter of the Gaza Beach fabrication, correct?
33. if people disagree with you: beat them up. Israel is an
Apartheid ,   Boston USA   (04.27.07)
inspiration to the world
34. Beat uppeople who disagree with you. Show how little differ
Apartheid ,   Boston USA   (04.27.07)
difference there is between the people of the multicolored kippah and the people of the brown shirt.
35. # 1, 3, 5 traitors on odds and ends
observer   (04.27.07)
at which end of the pointer? you odds !
36. #20 They have a perfect...
Josh   (04.27.07)
cover, they claim the photos were taken. Whether its true or not they have no proof. If they pulled that stuff on an Arab they wouldn't be found until the sand dune moved on. Cuts and scrapes, sounds like they didn't get beaten. Surley they would have some broiken bones and internal injuries if they were beaten by an angry crowd. The might have been b*tched slapped.
37. boo hoo hoo
Jack Bauer ,   superpower#1   (04.27.07)
Poor little instigators got what they wanted all along. A story in the news to spout their nonsense
38. Ynet can now track responses and will get back to u racists!
(04.27.07)
it was on the radio this afternoon. So take care to cover your racist, facist, violent brown-shirted tracks!
39. Good job, YESHA Jews!
Daniel ,   Columbia, USA   (04.27.07)
As they say, "Hit 'em again, hit 'em again, harder, HARDER!" "Rabbi Asherman"?!? Hardly... No sympathy, until these ISMers and 21st-Century Kapos recognize the evil they're supporting.
40. When the Arabs blow up a bus, a school, a wedding reception
Steve ,   USA   (04.27.07)
do they care who is who in Israel. They only want to kill Jews, all Jews. The leftists in Israel should seek psychological help.
41. The letists are the Kapo Jews. They should be exported
Roger ,   USA   (04.27.07)
to Ramallah.
42. May the leftists rot in hell next to Yasser Arafat or all
Stan ,   USA   (04.27.07)
other Arab terrorists!
43. #33 if people disagree with you: behead them. Islam is an
Kyle ,   Southpark, CO, USA   (04.27.07)
inspiration to the world
44. #34 Behead people who disagree with you. Show how little
Kyle ,   Southpark, CO, USA   (04.27.07)
difference there is between the people of the kaffiyeh and the people of the tricolor banner.
45. #25
Jack ,   USA   (04.27.07)
oh and by the way You are pretty foolish if you believe that, but I would venture so far as to say the vast majority of "settlers" do NOT believe that at all. But then again your reply has the air of a sarcastic moron
46. Reliable witnesses?
Sidney ,   USA   (04.27.07)
"Both Palestinians and international activists present at the scene confirmed the incident." How many never happened massacres have been claimed by Palestinians and then proved false? By the way, how many rabbis are there in Israel? It seems that Ynet almost daily has some idiotic statement by a rabbi, both on the left and right.
47. Settlers beat Left wing Rabbi
Henry Weil ,   Jerusalem Israel   (04.27.07)
The most depressing is the tone of the majority of the talkbacks, accusing these Jews of being leftist anit zionist etcc.. Sorry the Hebron group are the most extreme and do harm to the entire settler mouvement. They are althjough not all mostly fanatical messianic, see for yourself its worth the visit.
48. Kyle, perfect response!
mw   (04.27.07)
49. Daniel #2 Why are you decidedly not Zionist?
Allen ,   USA   (04.27.07)
Daniel, I plan to immigrate to Israel soon, G-d willing and I do not reject the term "Zionist" as it applies to me. I would love to live in ancient Judea or in Samaria if the govenment would not seize my home, expel me and give my property to our enemies as Mr. Sharon, Mr. Olmert, Ms. Livini and others did August 2005. As an observant Jew, why do you reject Zionism? For me, Zionism is not a religion or nationalism but merely the return of the Jews back to our homeland and the settling of our ancient heritage as Jews in Hebron and other parts of Judea and Samaria are doing according to the word of our ancient prophets. They are fulfilling prophecy aren't they? I do not understand the reason some observant Jews do not also see this. Can you explain why? Thanks.
50. G-d bless the Yesha Jews!
Mary ,   USA   (04.27.07)
51. The leftist are supporting the enemies. Remember 1929?
Alan ,   USA   (04.27.07)
52. It is not the Arabs who can destroy Israel but the Jews
(04.27.07)
The leftist Jews who lack conscience and wisdom. They are the true enemies of Jews/Israel. Can somebody remind them how the Arabs treated the Jews? Can somebody remind them of terrorism perpetrated against the Jewish nation? Can somebody remind them of the pogroms? Can somebody remind them of the laws instituted in the Arab states against the Jews? Can somebody remind them of 1929? The leftists in Israel are afflicted with the disease and there is no cure.
53. #35 I have no Idea what your asking
Sam WEinstein ,   USA   (04.27.07)
These Left Wingers are the traitors
54. left-wing activists; only One wing, Odds Not in their favor
(04.27.07)
55. #18
michael ,   jerusalem   (04.27.07)
As an American living temporarily in Jerusalem, I agree with you. I forward articles and talkbacks such as this to American relatives and friends whose opinion of Israel has been formed by the US mainstream media and Israeli gov. spokespersons in the US. Needless to say, I get a lot of return emails along the lines of , "I'm shocked" , "I never thought......" etc.
56. #47 Henry ---Extreme Jews?
Otter ,   Canada   (04.27.07)
Even if what you said were true, wouldn't that be due to the fact that only the most determined Jews have remained there, while Israel blocks the settling of this once Jewish city to any other Jew, the regular "non extreme" kind of Jews that you seem to like, the ones that would live normal, regular lives, instead of being a tiny minority besieged in a sea of a hostile Arab majority?
57. #25 - David L - What do you do with bullies?
Glenn ,   Canada   (04.27.07)
When you were in school, did you run home to mommy or did you face up to the bully in school? These talkbackers are not asking for the leftists to be hanged. 1) We don't have evidence of a beating, only allegations. 2) What were the Leftists doing there? There's a huge Arab majority in Hebron, they don't need wimpy, treasonous Jews to protect them. 3) It's illegal to harass people. They should be charged with something. 4) What are the Jews to do if confronted with an Arab-Jewish mob that's taunting and provoking them? 5) I hope you're just as passionate about violence against Jews as you seem to be against "violence" against traitors.
58. #27 - in DC
Glenn ,   Canada   (04.27.07)
Didn't it occur to you that "settlers" are just sick of people dropping by uninvited wanting to "understand"? Those people just want to be left alone, in peace. Show some respect. You have been fed the usual leftist lies and have swallowed them whole. Read history and then you'll understand the "settlers". You'll understand why they belong there and the Arabs don't.
59. to the self-rightreous clown, "apatheid, boston"
dante ,   uk   (04.27.07)
these people are the victims who are determined to fight the hordes that wish to destroy them and the vanguard of those hordes. in your ignorance and your hate, you confuse the resolve of the victims with the unprovoked, aggressive, race-hatred of the germans. you are sick in the soul.
60. Hey Apartheid
leon ,   Grand Rapids USA   (04.27.07)
Learn the difference between "disagree" and "undermine" !
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article