News
Excerpts from the Winograd report
Ynetnews
Published: 30.04.07, 22:35
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
5 Talkbacks for this article
1. Olmert: This is a direct result of trying to
David E. ,   Jerusalem   (04.30.07)
satisy the Europeans and other anti-Semitic countries instead of doing what's correct and good for your own country and citizens. Hopefully, the next Prime Minister - which will be replacing Olmert very soon - wil learn this lesson. A Prime Minister must do what's good for the country and not be selfish and arrogant. Down with Olmert NOW!!!!!!!
2. what this really says!
713 ,   Seattle US   (05.01.07)
Is that after the fact, when every single school kid in the educated world knows why Israel failed, we are going to point it out again. When in fact, no one knew why things were failing in real time. No one, not even this "commissioner" knew why things failed. He had to interview things and then rip them apart, but you could do the same thing during those "victorious" wars. There were failing during those that could have been ripped apart just as BADLY, and I do mean BADLY this report is horrible. Also it is completely dishonest.
3. Olmert WILL START A WAR TO DEFELECT IMPEACHMENT LIKE
Robin ,   miami   (05.01.07)
SHARON / KHOMAINY / SADDAM / .... THE LIST GOES ON HE LIKE THE REST OF GOV. DONT CARE ABOUT PEOPLE, THEY CARE ABOUT POWER WEALTH AND DICTATOESHIP. ZIONIZEM FOR YOU. THE JEWS WILL WIN
4. The Winograd report
roxy ,   israel   (05.01.07)
The whole Kinesset should resign as well as the PM, they are all to blame for last summer's mishandling of the war! We need fresh faces instead of the usual old warhorse that are trotted out by both Labor and Likuid. We need a new generation of leaders here, tough with the enemy,uncorruptable,genuine concern for the little guy, and the ability to communicate effectivly in English to the world media!
5. WHAT A SILLY USELESS REPORT!
narO ,   nyc   (05.02.07)
A COMMISION WHICH SIMPLY ROASTS LEADERS WITHOUT DISCUSSING THE FACT THAT THE WAR WAS BEGUN BY HIZBULLAH, AND THAT ITS CONDUCT WAS IN MANY RESPECTS DICTATED UN WASHINGTON. IT FAIL TO MENTION THE ENORMOUS RISKS TO ISRAL OF THE LARGE IRANIAN ROCKETS IN LEBANON WHICH POSED EXISTENTIAL RISKS TO ISRAEL, AND WHICH WERE DESTROYED BY IDF, AS WERE THE DANGEROUS ENEMY POSITIONS ACROSS THE BORDER. THIS WAS A TREMENDOUS VICTORY BY ISRAEL AGAINST IRAN AND ITS PROXY IN LEBANON. THIS WAR SAVED ISRAEL FROM POTENTIAL EXTINCTION BY IRANIAN ROCKETS THAT WERE AIMED AT TEL AVIV. THE COMMISSION WAS INTENT ON HUMILIATING THE PM EVEN BEFORE IT BEGAN ITS STUDY. WHAT A DISGRACE!
Back to article