News
Gaza pullout was not the last move, says Livni
Roee Nahmias
Published: 12.05.07, 13:49
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
62 Talkbacks for this article
1. There was a time when Arabs needed armies
Tracy W   (05.12.07)
to capture Jewish territory. Now it is the Israeli government that is happy to displace Jewish residents and hand over land to the Arabs, without a fight. The government calls it "a courageous, difficult and painful decision", the Egptians call it Israel getting rid of a burden, and those who care for Israel call it treason.
2. you don't have a mandte!
oded   (05.12.07)
you and the rest of the olmertnot govt. have no mandate to negotiate anything on behalf of the jewish peopole, especially, giviing the enemy more land that don't belong to them in the first place.! livni , the sooner you resign and move your cute face out, the better we all are gonna be! and take the 2 clowns with you!
3. Livni must remain in power
David ,   UK   (05.12.07)
Livni and Olmert will hang onto power to fulfil their desire to sell dear Israel 'down the river' and appease the rest of the world (except bible believing Christians). Stand up for yourself Israel - be strong for the Lord your God is with you. No other nation would be so naive as you if similar matters affected them.
4. Pals propose -IL takes Gaza and Gazans move into IL(swap)
Abdul ,   GAZA   (05.12.07)
5. good girl
cordier   (05.12.07)
Good girl. She is very charming... "i want peace, i will do concessions, please love me, we love you..." Well more territories libérated from jewish "terrorists", more qassams, more terror attacks, more al qaeda, more soldiers killed... Poor israelis you want so much "peace" that you have forgotten to be clever... What you want is not the question what palestinians leaders want is important, see the world as it is not as you want that it is... And they want to kill, to steal your wealth and that islam rule the world not a palisrael where arabs and jews will make love together in a real harmony... the national palestinian anthem call Biladi is 'by blood we will avenge you oh my country" not the "internationale" dear meretznick. Israelis wake up !!!
6. simply the worst
(05.12.07)
May G-d deliver us from this incompetent woman before she has a chance to do any more damage than she's done already. By no stretch of anyone's imagination does she speak for the majority of Israelis. May G-d give us the leadership we need and sideline the prime minister, defense minister and foreign minister--the three muskateers--who have such an amazingly high opinion of themselves.
7. Livni
Brod ,   USA   (05.12.07)
She is assuming that Israelis support giving more of their land to the dark forces. Why would Israelis give away their Biblical and Historic homeland to the Islamist-Jihadist terrorists? The 2-state solution that was engineered by the dark forces is a disaster for Israel. It means the dark forces want to usurp a huge chunk of Israel. It is time for Israelis to be vocal on this and reject this one-way street to Hell for Israel. The dark forces already own vast expanse of land that stretches from the Indian Ocean all the way to the Atlantic Ocean. They should accommodate their people who are squatting in Israel and trying to usurp Israel from the Jews. Instead, they are pressuring the EU and America to do their dirty work on tiny Israel, that is, to usurp a huge chunk of Israel for themselves. It is time for Israelis to say NO to this crap. It is also time for America to stop being manipulated by the Wahhabist Saudi dark forces to do their craps. Instead, America should pressure Saudi Arabia to accommodate their people squatting in Israel. AMERICANS MUST NEVER FORGET THAT THE SAUDIS ATTACKED AMERICA ON 9/11!!! The fact is the Saudis are the main sponsor of Islamist-Jihadist terrorisms around the world! READ: "SECRETS OF THE KINGDOM" [2006] BY GERALD POSNER. "JIHAD INCORPORATED" [2006] BY STEVEN EMERSON. "HATRED'S KINGDOM" [2003] BY DORE GOLD. "PREACHERS OF HATE" [2004] BY KENNETH R. TIMMERMAN. "SLEEPING WITH THE DEVIL" [2003] BY ROBERT BAER. "ONWARD MUSLIM SOLDIERS" [2003] BY ROBERT SPENCER. "THEY JUST DON'T GET IT" [2005] BY COLONEL DAVID HUNT.
8. The Palestinian Authority Call for the MURDER of ALL Jews &
Linda Rivera ,   New York   (05.12.07)
the MURDER of AMERICANS. Livni and all who seek a global Islamic TERROR State in Biblical Judea/Samaria - actively work for Islamic conquest of Israel and the entire free world. Broadcast from Gaza mosque, Oct 13 2000, Dr. Ahmad Abu Halabiya, on Palestinian Authority TV (transcribed by Memri): "Have no mercy on the Jews, no matter where they are, in any country. Fight them, wherever you are. Wherever you meet them, kill them. Wherever you are, kill those Jews and those Americans who are like them..." Flash Video - What Americans need to know about jihad: http://www.terrorismawareness.org/know-about-jihad/ Jihad's Goal is "Death to America" The Goal of Jihad is WORLD DOMINATION JIHAD Demands WAR on ALL INFIDELS The ARMIES of Jihad are HERE in the West STOP inciting children to kill ! http://www.teachkidspeace.com/flash.php Flash Video-The ISLAMIC MEIN KAMPF http://www.terrorismawareness.org/islamic-mein-kampf/ In 2000, leaflets were distributed in major British cities that included slogans: "The final hour will not come until the Muslims kill the Jews."
9.  Livni DECEIVES for ISLAM. Jewish LAND in Exchange FOR WAR
Linda Rivera ,   New York   (05.12.07)
10,000 Jews suffered RELIGIOUS Jew cleansing from Gaza and northern Samaria-rendered jobless and homeless and forced into poverty - victims of the “peace process” - their high-tech greenhouses, farms, businesses and land seized for the terrorists who fired thousands of rockets into Gaza’s Jewish towns. Muslim mobs celebrated by desecrating and destroying sacred Gaza synagogues. Boasting an Al-Qaeda and Hizbullah presence, the Jew-cleansed areas of Gaza have been transformed into global terrorist training grounds and rocket firing sites into Israeli communities. Jewish Land in exchange FOR WAR.
10. #1 Israel used her Military to Seize Land for Islam
Linda Rivera ,   New York   (05.12.07)
It is a shocking betrayal of every Jew and every non-Muslim on earth. Israeli leaders gave the world a powerful message: it is acceptable to render Jews jobless and homeless and seize their land and assets for Muslim terrorists. Which country and which non-Muslims will be next to receive the same cruel and ruthless punishment - because they are not Muslim?
11. Livni asking for Arab attack
Arik ,   Hedera   (05.12.07)
Now she will come back and tell "You see even Muslem Brotherhood loves me. I am loved by everyone". She must be removed as soon as possible. What a coward individual!
12. Israel Will Not Survive Olmert, Livni
Jerry ,   NYC, USA   (05.12.07)
The choice is yours Israel, keep them and perish or remove them and live.
13. EINSTEIN DEFINED MENTAL ILLNESS
BOBBY SOLO ,   ITALIA   (05.12.07)
EINSTEIN DEFINED MENTAL ILLNESS AS: "DOING THE SAME THING OVER AND OVER EXPECTING DIFFERENT RESULTS".
14. Two-state solution?
David L.   (05.12.07)
Duh. Is there really another solution? I can't believe some people are still debating this.
15. New Elections Now No Livni Peres Peretz Olmert
Sam Weinstein ,   USA   (05.12.07)
She is no different from the gang of 4 new elections now. National Labor Strike by the people of Israel if needed to force new elections. She did not even question why no Arab has honored their part of the deal or have compromised.
16. Building trust
Colin. ,   Barcelona.   (05.12.07)
Peace can only come when the two sides trust each other. Right now that is not so. A trust building program must be implemented with a timeframe governed only by results. The program should be citizen orientated; projects of joint concern: the environment, health , food and the arts, with no meddling from politicians.
17. Livni's last move: Tel Aviv pullout
Frank ,   Canada   (05.12.07)
18. She is HORRIBLE
Mark ,   USA   (05.12.07)
How can she seriously think they are worthy of a state?? They've had two years with an independent Gaza and all it has become is giant terror base with rival gangs regularly killing each other over small disputes. LIVNI AND OLMERT MUST GO!!!
19. Dumbassed comments from the FM
Gideon Reader ,   Ft.Lauderdale,Fl.USA   (05.12.07)
Will the Kadima-crats never stop? Ms.Livni. Get a hobby. Meet some nice man. Go out to dinner. Find a "day job". Just get out of the Israel killing business. And take the other Kadimacrat incompetents with you. Gotenu! Is there not some sort of academy where one sends cabinet ministers ; a Cabinet Min 101, so the stupidest things can be avoided?
20. Same tire anti-Israel rhetoric with a new 'leader'
Reality Check ,   BaGolan   (05.12.07)
21. Livni Move to Sderot-EXPERIENCE Your PHONY PEACE Daily
Linda Rivera ,   New York   (05.12.07)
The Palestinian Authority hailed as heroes the terrorists who brutally murdered defenseless 8 months pregnant Jewish mother, Tali Hatuel, and 4 little daughters in Gush Katif in May 2004. In Sderot, Israeli victims of the “peace process” live in continual fear of constant daily rocket attacks. Their desperate pleas for help are cruelly ignored! http://sderotmedia.com/?p=256
22. There's a reason they call her "Birdbrain."
sk ,   USA   (05.12.07)
Yup, another Disengagement is what Israel needs! This time, try to expel 10x more Jews than last time! This way, you can move all those Pal killers right next door, with nice, commanding positions to fire their missiles on all of Israel's major cities! BTW, EXPECT that after Tel Aviv is hit, the Pals will go after Jerusalem as well. Remember, they don't care about that city; they just don't want the Jews to have it. Disengagement 1 brought you daily missile attacks from Gaza (soon, they will hit the power plant in Ashkelon). Disengagement 2 will bring you attacks from all directions. In the unlikely case that Israel survives, it will have produced a generation that has been expelled from their homes and that believes that the Israeli government is unscrupulous and sinful. Priceless!
23. Livni
Alia ,   France   (05.12.07)
I like her politics and her courage , I hope she'll remain in office.May people like her who are willing to find a compromise be encouraged.Only compromise can bring peace.
24. israel land mass.
Harry Lipchin ,   Kfar Sava, Israel   (05.12.07)
Does Israel / Livni have a land mass strategy.From a security and nuclear threat perspective,this is a critical issue that never seems to be considered or aired.Politicians seem only to talk about giving land "back " to the Palestinians that was not theirs in the first place.
25. Tel Aviv pullout is imminent.
Marwan ,   Amman, Jordan   (05.12.07)
26. Compromise !
ben ,   singapore   (05.12.07)
Livni, you bring home the kidnapped soldiers to their parents, you get the support. Otherwise Good Bye !
27. Same mistakes, same results
Caroline ,   Israel   (05.12.07)
A new trend in Israel is to present Tzipi Livni as a saviour of Israel. In fact her Kadima friends feeling the end of their mandate to approach, try by all means to stay at power. Tzipi Livni is their last chance of political survival. They play Tzipi's card because until now she is one of rare ones in Kadima who is not under any kind of investigation. Winograd's commission did not blame her but did not praize her neither. Not being a thief or sex offender does not make one eligible for the premiership. During the 2nd Lebanon War she was simply unexisting and this is the reason that she didn't add to the harm done to our country. Do we need to reward the inactivity? She was nil during the war when we needed true leaders. Now she wants the power and she starts showing her colors by talking again of the new withdrawals. If you do the same mistake again and again the result will still be the same, Tzipi.
28. withdrawal frim west bank
alex ,   canada   (05.12.07)
What compromises have the arabs made? Name one? Answer o! Livni, another lawyer who is not able to really negotiate and stand up for Israel, just like she told Olmert to resign but didn't have the guts to resign when he refused. Withdrawal like she proposes will get more missiles into Israel.
29. She Also Believes In Karl Marx And the Tooth Fairy
Tony   (05.12.07)
She does not believe in modern polls or the rhetoric of the average Israeli though. Her deluded left leaning value system allows her to be conceded. Of course conceit is a fault and Tipsy Livni has no faults. With a first name that translates as birdie is it any wonder she is a total air head?
30. #16
ebo   (05.12.07)
agree with you .and there should be real wish to end up all the violence from the two sides no way but peace to live and let the other survive in peace and prosprety
Next talkbacks
Back to article