News
IDF may respond harshly
Ronny Sofer
Published: 15.05.07, 20:13
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
37 Talkbacks for this article
1. Big talk, no action
Sidney ,   USA   (05.15.07)
We have been through this before. Israel needs a new government now.
2. Same song and dance
yada yada yada ,   israel   (05.15.07)
Have been hearing the same song and dance since the disengagement-- "one more qassam and we will react harshly" bla bla bla bla bla. Actions speak louder then words.
3. Let the citizens of Sderot respond
MK ,   Stamford   (05.15.07)
Since the Olmert government is to timid to rerspond, the only way the Kassams will stop is when the citizens of Sderot take care of their own defense and start firing their own rockets into the Gaza strip. Enough is enough - no more Mr. nice guy - let's give the Palestinians a taste of their own medcine!
4. No Peace w/o Victory!
Bluto ,   U.S.A.   (05.15.07)
There is plenty of time to talk AFTER crushing the savage uprising in the territories. When will Israel stop acting like the "51st state?" U.S. administrations come and go and so do EU leaders, but Israel is forever! Strart remembering and acting accordingly -- NEVER AGAIN!
5. trust the "sources" til no more israel, C''V
chani ,   israel   (05.15.07)
No it's not especially unfortunate that the attack came after olmert reached out to enemies avowed to our destruction. WHat the media won't tell you is that their very reporting and supporting and enhancing overtures to our enemies, is resulting in danger to all Jews. Let the truth be known and say NO to the media and its message. Look for the truth and it can be found and so will every single answer. Of course the negativity will persist -- until it's swallowed up forever. And every single reader has the power to make that sooner than later. Power to the people -- Am Yisroel Chai.
6. more Olmert speak loud more he does nothing
cordier   (05.15.07)
standard idf procedure : we have a discussion, we have a discussion, we minimize palestinians death, we have discussion, we say we can do nothing, we have a discussion, we made a warlike declaration, we bomb empty places, we say we have told you so "military action"serve nothing, we want a diplomatic solution... 13 billions of dollars for an army which doesnt want to fight but want good cars for his tel avivian generals and wage increases... a lot of money waste... Ah ben Gourion, in this time Israel was governed by men not larves...
7. Consent
Schvach   (05.15.07)
Common. One murdered Jew is one too many. But how does the Israeli government respond - as though it's a third party spectator to the events that determine its present and future. And what happens when Israel goes after the bad guys - immediate retribution by the Arab terrorists, and against Israeli government officials to boot. Remember the exploding cell phone that blew off the head of the Arab terrorist named 'The Engineer'? I think it was the following day that an Israeli government minister was killed on his way to work as revenge. What to do? Bite the bullet. They have to be stopped. Diplomacy is for dignitaries. Dignitaries are people who are dignified. Arab terrorists are not!
8. harsh lies from Olmert Peretz
Marcel ,   Florida   (05.15.07)
We don't believe your lies Olmert,Peretz. You are incapable of doing anything. Olmert can do nothing ,he does not have permission from his master Goerge to defend Israel . All he is permitted to to is surrender more land and evict more Jews . THAT IS ALL OLMERT CAN DO Israel no longer has anything harsh left except harsh Amona and harsh attacks on Jewsih settlers. What is meant by the empty words of the kadima criminals is more weaposn and money for the Plaestinian criminals as a reward for what thye are doing in Sderot and elsewhere.
9. Just shut up Olmert
AK   (05.15.07)
You are incapable of doing anything right. The Arabs are no longer afraid of you and of Israel -- they've got your measure after you lost the war with Hezbollah. The only threat you present is to the citizens of your own country and to Israel and the only thing you are successful at is dismantling the state of Israel at the direction of Bush and the EU. You are truly a disgrace. Please, resign, call new elections a maybe somebody more competent and with some backbone can undo at least a little bit of that Oslo gang and you have wrought.
10. The Govt. of Achora
Erik   (05.15.07)
may possibly, perhaps, maybe do something or nothing. Olmert and Peretz fiddle while Sderot burns. What a damn disgrace.
11. Where is Dresden when we need it?
New Yorker ,   New York   (05.15.07)
Is there any pride or honor left in Israel? Who are the Israeli leaders more worried about: the people of Israel or the so-called "innocent palestinians"? Shame! Idiocy!
12. This goverment is lacking balls - pathetic
Avraham ,   NYC   (05.15.07)
13. BLAM THE GAZA WITHDRAWEL FOR THE KASSAM.
TOM BENS ,   USA   (05.15.07)
14. Rolling over. The FUN part!
Gideon Reader ,   US   (05.15.07)
DUH! Ya' think? Hey I got an idea. Howzabout Israel, Israelis, and Jooooos EVERYWHERE just be quiet and become even biger targets than ever? D'ya think that would make the Islamofacists and the miserable Leftist happy? Huh, do ya' Huh?
15. Action needed
Brod ,   USA   (05.15.07)
Less talk and more action needed! The dark forces must not think that they can continue attacking Israel with impunity.
16. Winograd said not to bomb empty fields
Morgan ,   IL   (05.15.07)
Give missiles to Sderot residents. They will do a better job than these two impotents
17. WOW!!! IDF BOMBED AN EMPTY FIELD OF FLOWERS.
THAT WILL SHOW 'EM ,   ..............DACON9   (05.15.07)
18. Remember Nero
Raymond ,   South Africa   (05.15.07)
Israel burns--Olmert fiddles.
19. We need to preempt the strikes ! Hamas is laughing at us !
redkmike ,   tel aviv - Israel   (05.15.07)
This whole Olmert Peretz thing is becoming really sickening. The IDF has been ordered to respond with SOP - standard operating procedures. Wasting more money firing rockets into empty fields. Let's get these jackasses out of the government asap. Hamas is laughing at us !
20. of course IDF can scratch its skin "harshly".
observer   (05.15.07)
21. Move Olmert's office and residence to Sderot
Drumgoole ,   Newark NJ   (05.15.07)
What is so hard to understand is why Olmert continues this policy of restraint or ineffective and useless responses like firing rockets into empty fields. Is it because he knows that the IDF has not yet recovered from the horrendous showing in Lebanon and is not ready to fight? Maybe it is that Olmert is being pressured by Rice to continue restraint. What is most impossible to understand is why more mass demonstration s have not been held demanding new elections. Olmert is nothing but a slick politician who doesn't have the slightest idea of how to respond.
22. We hate you Olmert. you too Sharon. ONLY BIBI!!
(05.15.07)
23. Olmert is playing with fire
Jonathan and Mollie ,   Pennsylvania   (05.15.07)
What will it take for the Israeli govt. to finally stop the rockets from falling on Sderot? Will it be mass casualties from a direct hit on a school or hospital? Will Israel evacuate Sderot and give up? What Olmert and Peretz do not seem to understand is that showing restraint curries no favor with the US or the Europeans. The US population is supportive of Israel and the chill in relations was caused by the IDF's ineptness in Lebanon since Bush gave Israel a green light to decimate Hamas. Europe is different. The general population is antisemitic and criticizes Israel for any response including doing nothing. So, as long as the US protects Israel's interests diplomatically, the EU's critic ism is meaningless because they would only love israel if it were destroyed. The truth is that Israel needs to have a crushing victory in order to reestablish deterrence no matter what the US and Eutope want.
24. unilateral
ed ,   London UK   (05.16.07)
not only does israel make unilateral withdrawals, also unilaterla warfare, where the Hamas fire missiles, and israel does nothing
25. #23
Cato theYounger ,   USA   (05.16.07)
WELL SAID, JONATHAN AND MOLLIE.
26. OLmert and Peretz need to listen
Cato theYounger ,   USA   (05.16.07)
to the words of General William Tecumseh Sherman, American Civil War.If they do not listen to his words, this war of attrition will be lost BY ISRAEL.Israel must learn the following and ignore Eurabia.Here is what Sherman said , and it applies in the case of Israel: " EVERY ATTEMPT TO MAKE WAR EASY AND SAFE WILL RESULT IN HUMILIATION AND DISASTER." also: "WAR IS CRUELTY, AND YOU CANNOT REFINE IT;AND THOSE WHO BROUGHT WAR INTO OUR COUNTRY DESERVE ALL THE CURSES AND MALEDICTIONS A PEOPLE CAN POUR OUT. THE CRUELER IT IS, THE SOONER IT WILL BE OVER. WAR IS THE REMEDY OUR ENEMIES HAVE CHOSEN, AND I SAY GIVE THEM ALL THEY WANT.THIS WAR DIFFERS FROM OTHER WARS, IN THIS PARTICULAR.WE ARE NOT FIGHTING ARMIES BUT A HOSTILE PEOPLE, AND MUST MAKE YOUNG AND OLD, RICH AND POOR, FEEL THE HARD HAND OF WAR. MY AIM ,THEN,WAS TO WHIP [THE ENEMY], TO HUMBLE THEIR PRIDE, TO FOLLOW THEM TO THEIR INMOST RECESSES, AND MAKE THEM FEAR AND DREAD US. FEAR IS THE BEGINNING OF WISDOM. IF THE PEOPLE RAISE A GREAT HOWL AGAINST MY[ STRATEGY] I WILL ANSWER THAT WAR IS WAR, AND NOT POPULARITY SEEKING.'
27. A Criminally, Morally Derelict Regime
Adina Kutnicki ,   US   (05.16.07)
The Olmert regime is criminally negligent towards its citizens. It is therefore totally ILLEGITIMATE. Any regime which FAILS to protect its citizens is de facto stripped of its authority. This is a fact accepted by all so called democracies as it is the NUMBER ONE tenet of any democracy. The people need to arm themselves any way they can. They are not obligated to be the 'sacrifices for peace' that the left in power deems them to be. War crimes tribunals against this derelict regime must be in the offing. NONE of them should escape prosecution. None of them!
28. To #23
M. Hartley ,   Atlanta, US   (05.16.07)
You've hit the nail on the head with regard to the US population. Nobody, but nobody can understand why Israel is sitting on its hands, allowing those 2-bit Palis to fire rockets into Israel with impunity. What happened to the people, who fought the 6-Day and Yom Kippur wars and who pulled off the raid on Entebbe? The Israelis were our heros of whom we stood in total awe. Now, every day, one waits for some kind of explanation, and none is ever given. It makes one want to cry.
29. IAF helicopters fired at the open fields in northern Gaza
naro ,   nyc   (05.16.07)
Great waste of ammunition idiots!
30. Why respond at all
Y ,   N   (05.16.07)
The palis are doing an excellent job of killing each other.
Next talkbacks
Back to article