News
Secret report: Chances captive survived are slim
Ynet
Published: 17.05.07, 21:41
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
17 Talkbacks for this article
1. And Shalit? Same Fate?
emanon ,   USA   (05.17.07)
2. what else to expect from canibals?
seyyed idi amin   (05.17.07)
3. Why is this helpful to report?
(05.17.07)
This is no better than Nasrallah's torture of the families. If it is true, it is bad enough that the families have been told - it should be up to them to announce or not.
4. to # 3 re: why...
Mikle White ,   Canada   (05.18.07)
Because, hezbollah and hamas should not hold the all state of Israel hostage because of 3 solders in their hands. IDF lost over 100 solders in last war alone...
5. it was always unlikely that they would be brought back alive
Adam ,   Manchester   (05.17.07)
There was a good chance that were killed either in their capture or executed at the hands of their captures within the month of their abduction. G-d help them if they are still alive and G-d help their families who are tortured by this every day. I think that Shalit is still alive. He is a good bargaining chip and is held by animals who know what he is worth, hundreds or even thousands of their terrorist prisoners.
6. Yedioth Ahronoth
ben ,   singapore   (05.18.07)
Where is that blessed boy Corp Gilat Shalid ? The mossad shuold have the intelligence information report by now as to the where about of this boy. Tell them not to touch Gilat Shalit, or we will finish their friends in the Israeli Prison on by one. IDF/ Mossad- go rescue Shalit now . Dont let me down ; - (
7. Real secret report, apparently
RA   (05.18.07)
8. Kill Nasralah and bury him in pig skin
Super Cholo   (05.18.07)
Let him go to play poker with arafat and yassin
9. If it is true...
Daniel ,   Israel   (05.18.07)
If this is true; it is very sad. Only this was known before we could have saved those 120+ and thousands other wounded and disabled for ever children, the whole issue is very sad. After loosing so much; we left the job unfinished! We should have at list got the culprit; dead or alive!
10. to #4
(05.18.07)
And will publishing this now bring back the 100 we lost? it is the nature of our country (and theirs) that we can agonize and be held captive over the fate of 3 soldiers. the family should be told; the army and government should act accordingly; no more deals where we give 1000 for 3 dead bodies...but it doesn't have to be published. It gains nothing. Hizbollah already knows if they are dead or alive. Let the families know and let government policy reflect this. All they have to do is say something like, we won't negotiate - and if the families know, they won't protest. In the end, it will make us look stronger - that we won't negotiate, even if the reason is because we know they are most likely not alive.
11. Kadima went ,as always, achora
gabriela ben ari ,   jerusalem   (05.18.07)
and didn't bother to bring back these two (three) men twisting our needs to UN USA pressure seems to run rampart in Hiloni post zionist Israel Not even Kassams "mezizzim " these
12. i'm gonna....
joe ,   sheffield.u.k   (05.18.07)
get bergmans book n shred it n then burn it n then send him the ashes. shabat shalom le-mishpachot shel ha-chayalim.
13. OLMERT...Bring our three brave soldiers home now!
Miriam ,   Israel   (05.18.07)
14. To #13 Miriam: HOW!
David ,   Karmiel, Israel   (05.18.07)
Pray tell us Field Marshall Miriam, your plan for bringing them home. I am sure Lt. General Ashkenazi would love to hear it. What do you propose? Freeing Samir Qumtar? Freeing all the terrorists or simply giving up? Maybe we should all leave Israel and go back to Europe pre 1933? Personally, I think this is pretty irresponsible reporting. You don't "speculate" about the lives of our soldiers. You publish facts, Mr. Editor!
15. don't worry, some Iranian doctors are the best in the world
rami   (05.18.07)
however u disagree with the ideology of hizbulla, u have to admrie their bravery.....comandos jumping into burning tanks and kidnapping soldiers...that's amasing, not the IDF who uses human shields in nablus to go door to door, pathetic! p.s i like the europe option, i really do....
16. #15
(05.18.07)
there are more muslims in europe than there are jews. apparently they like it there more than jews. do you know why muslims like it there more than jews???? because we have israel and you have nothing. this is why you run and enter countries that don't want you to begin with. everywhere you run, you people create dirt, chaos and destruction. everywhere the israelis go, they create humanity, prosper, advance and give unimaginable gifts to humanity. believe me, europe and the usa would rather see millions of brilliant hard working jews enter their countries rather than charity cases like arabs who are violent, dirty and uneducated.
17. #15 Hezbollah hide behind skirts
andy ,   orlando,U.S   (06.05.07)
Hezbollah were extremely brave firing rockets from amongst civilians towards israeli civilians.They were really courageous hiding behind ladies skirts and not fighting the mighty IDF in the open.As for Israelis returning to Europe,50% were originally refugees from Arab countries where they were persecuted.How many wars have the Arabs lost with Israel?
Back to article