Culture  The Buzz
Oprah coming to Israel for solidarity visit
Itamar Eichner
Published: 22.05.07, 12:03
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
119 Talkbacks for this article
31. #30 Yeah..when the Arabs murder the Arabs then it is
Danny ,   USA   (05.23.07)
the Jews fault. Another sock Arab fantasy!
32. "Solidarity" with Who?
Alan ,   SA   (05.23.07)
33. Oprah will be getting a letter from
john ,   nz   (05.23.07)
the Palestinian Campaign for the Academic and Cultural Boycott of Israel. ..soon. Perhaps, she'll change her mind or maybe not. To her coming to Israel may not neccesarily be a sympatiser. Just another campaign to boost her popularity.
34. Rashid!
Ben ,   Pennsylvania, USA   (05.23.07)
You are a hoot! Keep it up. I bet you get a kick from all the talk backs that think you are seriouse.
35. Wants to please Jewish lobby to keep her business
ana ,   usa   (05.23.07)
She saw how they went after President Carter for saying 1% of the truth about Jewish occuption of Palestine. She doesn't want to be next, and I doubt a black, southern woman can ever support Jewish occupation and opression of Palestinians.
36. #31: Last I checked Arabs did not fly F16s in Gaza
David ,   NYC   (05.23.07)
It was your occupation army that murdered 8 members of the same family in Gaza yesterday or was it not?????
37. Stupid idea folks, she'll be bad-mouthing us the whole time
Ran ,   London   (05.23.07)
wait and see
38. #36
(05.23.07)
eight died as a result of being in a house full of terrorists and ammos, explosives, etc... usually hidden in hoispitals, schiils, mosques, civic building and personal homes of citizen in the strip. the other 40 died during the intrafighting between hamas and fatah. you may not only not know your math. you aparently can't read the news accurately.
39. #7 -Why do they make fun of Rashid
(05.23.07)
Brother, you speak the truth
40. #30
Adam ,   manchester   (05.23.07)
You have lost 48 as most of them were killed by your own people, Hamas v Fatah! The only way to stop your infighting and your struggle for domination with bloodlust is to attack your democratic neighbour who will then HAVE TO retaliate, which will unify you against a common goal. Nice and sick, the Palestinian psyche. Yes, your people are dying and when 1 civilian on either side gets killed it is a terrible thing. However, when you choose a terrorist organisation like HAMAS, who doesnt want peace but to destroy and (I know you wont like it) an established Jewish neighbour or an old terrorist like Arafat who was offered half of Jerusalem, Gaza, 97% of the West Bank and 3% of Israel proper and still said NO! you can only blame yourselves. If Abbas was offered that today his would grab it with both hands and not let go, but Arafat blew it! You will never get this offer again..... Also, the motive for Hamas attacks is to cause as much death and destruction as possible, civilians or military, it doesnt matter. Israel tries to kill militants or terrorist (whatever you want to call them). It is sad when civilians are killed as collateral damage but War is Hell and the purposes of bombing on both sides is different!
41. number five
solemnman ,   nahariya   (05.23.07)
I agree with number fives assessment. I also believe that Oprah's misplaced sympathy for shahids was born of ignorance not malice. Her life has been a great triumph of intelligence and willpower over extreme hardship and adversity.The school she established for girls in Africa is a wonderful testament to her warm and generous heart. I am confident that her views will be transformed by her visit here.
42. PALESTINE HAS NEVER EXISTED!
PALESTINIANSAREAMYTH ,   USA   (05.23.07)
43. Oprah Winfrey trip to Israel
Katherine Weathers ,   Huntsville, AL   (05.23.07)
I think it's great that Oprah Winfrey will be travellling to Israel at the invitation of Elie Wiesel. While she's there she needs also to visit Gaza and the West Bank and talk to the suffering Palestinian people. Preparatory to this trip she should read "The Lemon Tree" by Sandy Tolan. This book will give her the perpspective of both a Palestinian family and an Israeli family who are intimately connected to the establishment of the state of Israel in 1948.
44. WELL SAID ADAM FROM MANCHESTER
rosie ,   sydney   (05.23.07)
well said, but it will make no impression on the morally bankrupt latte sipping lefties who blog here- I am sure they are all sharing two neurones ( both of which are inhibitory)
45. Palestine has and will forever live
Iman ,   United States   (05.23.07)
I am looking forward to this visit, now if only we can get her to our side. She will definately realize the suffering of the Palestinians.
46. Re Oprah
marty ,   toronto canada   (05.23.07)
To compensate for perceived pro Israel bias (Oprah visit) CBS have agreed to create "Survivor Gaza" next season.
47. #1
mark ,   ca   (05.23.07)
Yes, black whomen who made it,automaticly become white.Idiot.
48. Just what we need
ilana   (05.23.07)
Another condi with an agenda. She is NOT pro-Israel!!!
49. visit to Israel
David Gordon ,   Seattle, WA USA   (05.23.07)
In your visit to Israel, please have some Palestinians show you life under the Israeli Occupations so you understand the suffering of the Palestinian families.
50. She can visit Qalkilya and have a lesson in rocketing
(05.23.07)
Do the palis do anything without killing each other and other people? Look at Lebanon, it has terror bases camouflaged as refugee camps, all full of "innocent" palis, running with AK47s. Poor oppressed people, stop killing everyone that you don't like, and start acting like human beings. Or is the way of terror better, because you get to heaven faster, you terrorist thugs? I'm sure Oprah will stab us in the bag, as she's known as an apologist for Islamic terror.
51. Oprah
Bradenton, Fl.   (05.23.07)
If she does go I hope she visits a refugee camp and talks to some Palestinians to see what their lives are really like and the lack of freedom they have - also to see the checkpoints -Maybe she should watch Occupation 101 before she goes!
52. Response to #42
Robert Lavigna ,   Madrid, Spain   (05.24.07)
A Doctor of History and Geography--and of course, a United Statesian to boot. What a coincidence! Keep gobbling down that Prozac, buddy!
53. Israel suffering?
Davy de Verteuil ,   Pari France   (05.24.07)
Are you saying that the Palestinian victims aren't a humanitarian issue. Opra visit to Israel vindicates Israel's 40 years of brute violence in it's occupation of others land and livelihood? How come such powerful state is always portrayed as the victim acting in defence even whet it's obviously on the offensive? No amount of stardom could further sanctify Israel's behaviour but blemishes those who attempt to vilify her victims by hoodwinking truth.
54. #51
PSsommers ,   Canada   (05.24.07)
Yes, the Palestinians just want a nice little peaceful state. Check out Gaza and Lebanon as I wrote this. A Palestinian man, whose house was destroyed by Hamas, said today in a BBC piece that he prays for the day that Israel takes back control so he and his family can live in peace.
55. Where is Barbara
Max Mann ,   Sherman Oaks, USA   (05.24.07)
Oprah may not be perfect. She may hang with the Mandela crowd, but if she visits Israel and expresses her sympathy, and brings positive coverage to Israel, she will have done something that very few Jewish stars have done. Would Barbara Streisand ever accept Elie Weisel's invitation?
56. Your visit to Israel
Hedy Epstein ,   St. Louis, MO, USA   (05.24.07)
While in Israel, be sure to also go to the West Bank to see & experience how Israel's occupation & apartheid policies & practices adversely affect Palestinian life. This will give you a more balanced picture.
57. #55 max. Streisand's issue is global warming
debra ,   usa   (05.24.07)
i doubt she knows she's jewish or that there is an Israel.
58. #56 Hedy Espstein's peace idea
Yardena   (05.24.07)
I remember you!! the 80 + senile who demonstrated lending her "jewishness" to our enemy the Palestinians in the disguise of a peace lover. at your age, shame on you!
59. No. 51
Renee, NYC   (05.24.07)
Actually, I have a better idea. Maybe she should watch the footage that Yasser Arafat tried to suppress of Palestinians in the West Bank and Gaza celebrating the attacks on 9/11.
60. Davy de Verteuil
Korem ,   New York, USA   (05.24.07)
40 years? Look up the occupation during the 70s and early 80s. Israel was building universities in the territories. There was no intifada nor was there a call to end occupation (except terrorist activities to destroy all of Israel), and as a result, Palestinian life in the territories was not anything like it is today. And don't forget that the occupation itself started as a result of capturing territories during a defensive war, the territories having been earlier occupied by Egypt and Jordan. Israel is not on the offensive. Every single Israeli strike or raid is a direct result of an Hamas attack.
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article