News
Hamas wants Israel back in Gaza, Gillerman says
Ynetnews
Published: 22.05.07, 20:45
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
27 Talkbacks for this article
1. Keep away from Gaza
Sammy ,   Newcastle, UK   (05.22.07)
Theres absolutely no need for Israel to fall into that trap. The result will only be the killing of innocent civilians as these careeer criminals hide amongst them. Continue bombardment from the air and fire back shell for shell, rocket for rocket until those morons stop. Its quite staggering to realise that all Haniyeh has shown he is capable of doing to run a country is to promote murder, violence, hatred. Look at HIS CONTRIBUTION to the Palestinian people. POVERTY, MURDER, KIDNAPPING, VIOLENCE, FEAR. I look at him with UTTER DISGUST at the heartache, the desolation that he has brought upon Gaza. ALLAH WILL JUDGE HIS CRIMES.
2. Israel hasn't called it "casus belli" = Israel is weak
observer   (05.22.07)
3. if u think that then...
jr ,   toronto, canada   (05.22.07)
and the Military/political officials also think it then do NOT fall into their trap! but u still need to do something to stop the missiles!
4. TAKE HAMAS INVITE> SEEK AND DESTROY
2 ENEMIES 1 ATTACK ,   ..............DACON9   (05.22.07)
5. There he goes again ....
Tracy W   (05.22.07)
cheering for the doomed Quartet "peace" initiative. He says: to "continue exerting pressure on Hamas to accept Quartet preconditions vis-a-vis Israel, namely, recognition of the State, renunciation of violence and acknowledgement of previous agreements between Israel and the Palestinian leadership". All that is history. There is no peace partner. There is no peace plan. There are no moderates in the PA. While Israel, under American influence, continues to hope for Hamas' acceptance of those conditions, the towns of Israel will continue to live under terror and be evacuated one by one. Today is Sderot that is being emptied. Tomorrow Ashkelon, then others. While the misguided Bush and Rice continue pushing their ill-conceived Saudi plan, the Palestinians have plans of their own: the terrorizing of Israeli communities until they have all been vacated. They are also softening up the target, preparing for a major attack by Hezbullah and Syria. And whoever else wishes to join, even elements within Israel itself. Perhaps it is more than a coincidence that both plans seem to complement each other. One side with inaction or barely any reaction, but lots of false hope. The other side relentlessly arming itself and pushing forward. First of all there must be a moratorium on all peace talks until the Palestinians stop their aggression against Israel and against each other. They must prove that they are a credible entity before there is any thought of giving them a country. But with no likelihood of Palestinian culture undergoing any positive change, then Israel must reverse the Disengagement. The Palestinians need to be "adopted" by more established Arab countries. As things stand now, they have zero prospects for a viable country. There can be no Palestine. The only solutions left for Israel now are the difficult and unpopular ones. Enough with peace talks already.
6. Hamas wants Israel in Gaza!
Y ,   N   (05.22.07)
Then it is one thing for Israel to do and that is to stay out. Gaza is a trap and everybody knows it. Let the palis fight each other.
7. Hamas wants to do what they do best-pray&kill
Alan ,   Sa   (05.22.07)
8. Not working though
Korem ,   New York, USA   (05.22.07)
The Government made it clear they will probably not launch a ground invasion into gaza and they will respond with airstrikes and a security zone in the north.
9. Gillerman is wasted on the UN -- he should be FM, at least.
AK   (05.22.07)
10. NO NO NO!!! HAMAS JUST WANTS ISRAEL!!!
stude ham   (05.22.07)
11. Keep on Pounding
Dave Levy ,   Burbank. CA. USA   (05.22.07)
Hamas has it's supporters worldwide., from Jimmy Carter to op-ed writers in the media. They claim it's all Israel's fault., that the fence and other defenses (retaliatory raids) are provoking the Palestinians. If Israel would only withdraw to the pre-67 lines and allow 5m Arabs to live in Israel proper, there would be peace. In Lebanon and Iraq, with no occupation, it's Arab vs Arab..Hezbollah is ready to pounce on the Christians. In Iraq, the Shias will exterminate the Sunnis, given the chance (or vica versa). So, any such Israel move...is national suicide. Yet some media people and pundits still blame Israel for the world's ills. How dare Israel defend itself they are really saying. Like Hamas, it's all about trickery...to trick Israel into indefensible borders. Then when Israel is attacked, they won't cry one tear. Not going back into Gaza was a smart move by Olmert, if not criticized by many who are not seeing what lies ahead of the IDF. Israel does not have to occupy Gaza, just pound it.
12. NO NO NO
sk ,   USA   (05.22.07)
Jeez, what hooey. Scorpions sting, and Hamas and Fatah will naturally sting each other. It's silly to read something more into it. But look at that nonsense focusing on Hamas alone. Fatah and Hamas are both Jew-hating jihadists. And notice that biz about "the Quartet," a counterproductive waste of time (for Israel) if ever there were one. And, "the Quartet" is going to "pressure" Hamas? Huh? Gillerman and the rest of the Israeli establishment evidently lack the language to express something sensible.
13. ROCKET FOR ROCKET..AND MAKE IT COUNT.
(05.23.07)
I agree, there is a big mess waiting inside Gaza. Best to treat each Qassam or incursion with another , more deadly response. They wont learn of course - WE ALL KNOW THAT. But at least it will be even harder to live there as each strike is made. I have NO sympathy for these animals whatsoever.
14. Israel is a friend to the palestinians not an enemy
papa jay   (05.23.07)
thereby blame the common enemy of the Palestinian people, which – as Palestinians are brainwashed from childhood to believe – is Israel. no brainwash needed. Palestinians just have to take a look around them to figure out who is the enemy. Gillerman needs to put down the crack pipe. to insinuated that Israel is the Palestinians friend not enemy he surly must be on crack.
15. Uh.. yeah.. I said this many times last week!
(05.23.07)
Mr. Gillerman, I am glad you read my talkbacks! It is true! Hamas is an utter failure at running a state, so they fall back on what they do best.. kill innocent, unarmed, defenseless people. Killing people into submission now is not enough to cow the Pals into following Hamas. Now they wish to bring Israel into the mix for a common enemy to unite the Pals. The Pals are so full of hate, they swallow it, hook, line, and sinker every time!
16. DAN GILLERMAN FOR PRIME MINISTER
Chaim ,   USA   (05.23.07)
Gillerman is great, and would be a superb leader for the State of Israel. Get SMOLmert out.
17. PLEASE COME TO US !!
QASSAM MASKEDMAN ,   GAZA   (05.23.07)
i want to send message to israel poolish soldiers .. come back to Gaza .. because we are very thirsty of your blood . bye
18. Papa Jay
Korem ,   New York, USA   (05.23.07)
Why no brainwash needed? What causes every single Israeli airstrike in history except attacks by brainwashed Hamas thugs? Face it, right now, the Palestinians are suffering far more under the poverty handed to them by the PA and by the Hamas-Fatah infighting, than by any Israeli airstrike or raid. And don't give me BS about Israel causing the Palestinians to be in poverty, The PA has always received a massive amount of foreign aid, and even after the int'l boycott, receives it through the office of the president. The inefficiency of the government and their inability to lead makes pointing fingers at Israel a much easier tactic than actually helping the people. And they even get a bonus- people like you, papa jay, on their side.
19. ISRAEL DOESN'T NEED TO ENTER GAZA, SIMPLY CONTAIN IT
ZALMAN ,   Central Coast, USA   (05.23.07)
WHY ENTER, IT WOULD ONLY BE A TEMPORARY SOLUTION & WOULD GIVE THE TERRORISTS SOMETHING TO TARGET & ATTACK, ITS BETTER FOR THE IDF TO CONTINUE TARGETED MISSIONS, KEEPING THE TERRORISTS ON THE RUN AND LOOKING OVER THEIR SHOULDER, NOT KNOWING WHEN OR WHERE IT'S COMING FROM, THIS WILL KEEP THE TERRORISTS PREOCCUPIED WITH SURVIVAL, GIVING THEM LESS TIME TO COORDINATE ATTACKS, A DELIBERATE BUT LIMITED CONSTANT OFFENSIVE IN THIS SITUATION IS ISRAELS BEST DEFENSE
20. Hamas, Fatah, Bloods, Crips all the same.
Roch ,   Albuquerque NM, USA   (05.23.07)
There nothing more then street gangs with cool titles to make them seem legit. The Pals will never amount to anything as they are nothing more than international street gangs, gang banging each other. Then they fire their home made missles on innocent Israeli cititzens. With all the money spent on the rockets and guns to kill each other they could feed their families. How pathetic!
21. Tracy W, great and so right message !
(05.23.07)
22. #19
(05.23.07)
very very smart. agreed!
23. Hamas wants Israel to re-capture Gaza.
john ,   nz   (05.23.07)
If not, why do they keep provoking Israel. Now send in the F16s tomorrow.
24. Israel wants it the easy way
observer   (05.23.07)
Israelis have tasted the bitterness of losing human life in its war with Hezbullah. They want to war at a safe distance, so they Make Every thought which save them from going into gaza; "The Wise Thought".
25. Israeli weapon : electricity to GAZA
moshe ,   k.motzkin Israel   (05.23.07)
Israel has a weapon that will effect all of Gaza: electricity. Given pal hostility, terror, rockets, etc Israel can respond without endangering a single soldier of the IDF or a single citizen. Why doesn't Israel even consider rationing the Israeli supplied electricity, water, and food entering GAZA ? ? ............................. Not humane? ............................ Is it more humane to uproot Israeli cities , to rocket them, to make everyday Israeli life into a Hell ? ? moshe, Israel
26. DO YOU REALLY THINK THAT PEOPLE ARE SUCH DUMBS?
thinking man   (05.23.07)
israel stole the territory of palestine,jordan,syria & during 57 years is killing palestinian women & children & after all this if hamas fired some iron tubes on sderot it is terrorism at the time when israel is killing civilians in palestine & lebanon by best technology planes & tanks & millions of cluster bombs were thrown over lebanon is normally.israel is violating UN resolutions 197 & 425 for tens of years & AFTER that is crying about 1701 resolution which was issued less than one year ago,where is the logic?
27. #25 because Gaza & Egypt would cut their gas to Israel
observer   (05.24.07)
Electricity is an Israeli weapon given (up) to Gaza on purpose. it's that simple !
Back to article