News
Israel arrests Palestinian minister of education
Ali Waked
Published: 24.05.07, 07:12
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
41 Talkbacks for this article
1. Please...Israel is a joke. The Hamastani murderers
Steve ,   USA   (05.24.07)
will be released in no time.
2. b ready for retaliation...u have 2 pay heavey price 4 that!!
(05.24.07)
3. Arrest?????
Yusuf ,   Delhi, India   (05.24.07)
Say IDF kidnapped Hamas ministers.
4. Lock them up in Sderot
(05.24.07)
5. What Arrogance
Jasmin Knowles ,   KL, Malaysia   (05.24.07)
And let's here Israel's defenders once again try to refute comparisons of their state to the worst practices of Apartheid-era South Africa. Even as a non-Arab, non-Muslim like me can see through all the brutality and hypocricy of the state of Israel. So sad.
6. Send them to Lebanon !!!
rh ,   modiin   (05.24.07)
The Lebanese know how to deal with naughty Palestinians.
7. #5 What arrogance Jasmin
Lina ,   USA   (05.24.07)
Do you also see the brutality and hypocrisy of the Palestinians? Maybe you were busy scolding Israel while dozens of kassams barraged Sderot. Every time Israel defends her residents, people like you squeal Apartheid. When Israel gets battered, you remain silent.
8. Jasmin Knwoles
mike ,   US   (05.24.07)
should spend a night in Sderot, practicing Israeli apartheid methods of avoiding falling Hamas rocket. Idiot.
9. Israel above all intl laws & treaties, can do anything
wan ,   USA   (05.24.07)
and get away with it. After all, it occupied and wiped Palestine off the map and got away with it.
10. ISREAL MUST TARGET TERRORIST LEADER IT IS THE ONLY WAY.
MIKE HAMEN ,   TX,USA   (05.24.07)
TO STOP KASSAM ATTACKS.
11. #5 - You are totally incorrect....
Maurice ,   Montreal, Canada   (05.24.07)
...in accusing the state of Israel of arrogance, apartheid and hypocrisy. South Africa 's white citizens were not attacked day after day by rockets causing terror, injuries and death. I would like to see which other country in the world would have shown so much restraint before finally deciding for some action. The real hypocrisy is in your own words which are nothing but a futile coverup for your ugly and immoral antisemitism.
12. Mike, why you don,t try to sleep in gaza?
Yusuf ,   Delhi, India   (05.24.07)
13. TAKE OUT ALL THIS MAFIA BOSSES NOW
(05.24.07)
Israel found the most painful spot - all first # 1 thru 5 responses are from Hamas supporters. Go ahead. Do it. Show them what you can do when they cross the line. on sand.
14. Jasmin Knowles , KL, Malaysia (05.24.07)
ben ,   singapore   (05.24.07)
You look at you Malaysia's case concerning the case of LINA Goh and the murder of the Mogolian Girl and the Police Brutality over your malaysians in The Malaysian Police Lock Up . First look at your Country Malaysia. I can see well for my self where you are coming from Malaysia a country that oppress the Minority Race- Indians and Chinese ! Ask Mr. Karpal Singh , he will tell you ! I can see through all the brutality and hypocricy of your Malaysia, So cut the crap and the drama !
15. Yusuf , Delhi, India (05.24.07)
ben ,   singapore   (05.24.07)
Where were you when the mosque in Hydrabad was bombed. Pressing the buttons from somewhere ?
16. Israel ARREST Haniyeh, ABBAS and Gun Khalid Marshaal
ben ,   singapore   (05.24.07)
TERRORIST SHOULD NOT BE GIVEN ANY PLACE IN ISRAEL. GET RID OF THE FAKES ! THESE ARE THE CULPRITS !
17. Arresting Hamas Terrorists
Stan ,   Sydney, Australia   (05.24.07)
#9 - Israel did not wipe any Palestine off any map -- it was never there to begin with. Israel only recaptured its homeland. Learn your history -- the unbiased truth not the Hamas slant. Israel should also hold those characters until Shalit is released.
18. Brilliant!
BJL ,   Appleland USA   (05.24.07)
Now keep them this time until the rockets stop and they give Shalit back. Hamas terror must be stopped. Quit playing around......
19. 5 Well to be honest, I would not be too terribly
freedom ,   canada   (05.24.07)
interested in living in South Africa now, with the relationship they have with Zimbabwe, you read your news do you not? Jasmin, tell us all about the burning of christian churches in the west bank. Maybe you can convince me Hamas is not part of that Apartheid description. Cheers, nice to turn the tables on you.
20. Yusuf, I cant spend the night in Gaza
Mike ,   US   (05.24.07)
since Im part Jewish, and the murders of Hamas rule Gaza now. Gaza is now Jew-free, but still filled with killing, mayhem and disorder, all due to the actions of Palestinians, who continue to murder Jews after all the withdrawals. the only solution and 'peace' that the arabs will be satisfied with is when all the jews of Israel are dead or converted. I hope IDF obliterates that hell hole, any nation would a long time ago.
21. What's a great democracy!!
Peggi   (05.24.07)
What a democracy Israel has. It is shame on this government.It won't be a long time for all the people to fully support radical positions against this terrorsit state. The day light will come whether Israel likes it or not !!
22. #11- You are the one who is totally incorrect
Khalid ,   The Netherlands   (05.24.07)
Before answering your questions, could you please tell us which ciountry in the world occupy other people's land, lock the local population in detention camps like situations, build settlements (in violation of international laws) settlements destined for a specific poulation group (from which the original inhabitants of the land are excluded), confine the original population of the land behind walls separating them from their farms and businesses thus depriving from any prospect for a decent life? First try to answer these questions, and look at the actions taken by the state of Israel (the only democracy in the Middle East, where your basic rights including citizenship rights, are determined by your religious background) , then you can see who is the totally incorrect you or cintributor #5?. In fact you are focusing on the reactions of few individuals and ignoring the actions of the state of Israel, actions leading to anger, despair, frustration providing the fertile ground for the reactions which you are solely focusing on in your talkback.
23. Hi Ben
yusuf ,   Delhi, India   (05.24.07)
Hi Ben, what you expect me to do? I dont belive in doening harm to any one. I want Justice to every oppressed people irrespetive of thier religion
24. we must eliminate hamas and all hamas supporters
(05.24.07)
25. TRADE THEM FOR SHALIT!!
Mark ,   USA   (05.24.07)
Now Israel has 33 of these terrorists. They should offer them back only in exchange for Shalit. 33 for one sounds like a good deal on their side to me?
26. # 22 Khalid: You are the one who is totally incorrect
Josef Matamoros ,   Finland   (05.24.07)
Your words "original inhabitants" tells it all: the Israelis, they were, are and will be the original inhabitants. First Arabs came as tyrants and usurpers after Muhammad, most came during early 1900's due to the Jewish initiated social and economic development. To your knowledge: your text is equivalent with Thousand and one night stories, yes just stories without any connection to reality. And last: don't spoil the Netherlands with your stay there, go back to Arabia.
27. We Have Room For Many More ....
Terry ,   Eilat, Israel   (05.24.07)
This is a step in the right direction. This policy should have been continued since Shalit was kidnapped. Along with targeted assassinations, destruction of their personal assets, & terrorist infrastructure - the entire Palestinian leadership must be made accountable. This includes Fatah. There is no reason not to target the Fatah leadership as well, including Abbas.
28. teach them a lesson
sisse ,   guinea   (05.24.07)
Isreal don,t release them until they release shalit. Haniyeh also should be arested.
29. Dei Yusuf
ben ,   singapore   (05.24.07)
We have given the PA' s numerous time and space already now it is time to smash the Gaza Terrorist out of action, their bunch of Polititians are the the head behind the many Qassams. They kidnapped my children, they send suicide bomb, they drag in woman, children as thier HUMAN SHEILD. so much so I now call them "chisheild " tell me is this what Islam is all about ? I have many muslim friends here in Singapore and all around the world, but it is very disgusting to see this international terror network goin around killing innocent people, your own Muslim Ummah. Now the same happens in Israel.TELL ME WHY SHOULDNT MY CHILREN REMAIN SILENT taking the frequent rockets , being shot into Israel by the PA Terrorist. The Polititians of the PA are the real terrorist.In fact Israel should ARREST many more especially that Haniyeh, Abbas and the Khalid Marshaal. Dei Yusuf you said that you dont believe in doing harm to anyone. but let me tell you the harm my children Yisrael.They kidnapped my child Gilat Shalit and to date been twisting our arm and the tears of the parents are flowing like river of blood. You know, this is the time for applying the SWORD on the Gaza Terrorist. If you are a TRUE MUSLIM, you will know the agony of my People, the Children of Avraham.If you know your quran well, you will know who we Isareli are.So please, now it is time we end the atrocities of the Gaza Terrorist to bring PEACE to the Civilians of Both SIDE The PA and The Israeli. We will not stop the attack against the Gasa Terrorist and their Polititians till they end their militant activity. I am sorry it is time for Breaking The BOW. Israel is there to BREAK THE BOW of EVIL. Dei Yusuf, that is all, I have to say. ben singapore
30. Education Min-He educates 2year olds to kill the Jews with
Mickey Mouse as a ,   Teaching Aid Alan SA   (05.24.07)
Next talkbacks
Back to article