News
Police permit pride parade in Jerusalem
Lilach Soval
Published: 24.05.07, 22:44
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
60 Talkbacks for this article
31. another Hizbolah war in June?!
Hanna   (05.25.07)
32. Korem, they don't read the Bible.
sk ,   USA   (05.25.07)
It couldn't be more obvious that S & G were punished because, while having such luxury, they were very cruel to outsiders and the needy. One of Lot's daughters, as I recall, was set on fire for feeding a hungry man. When we recall that such behavior is utterly contrary to such a central rule of Torah as that one should love one's neighbor as oneself, it can be seen that S & G are the very antithesis of Torah. But to the Bible-thumpers here, all of this is extraneous to the story they want to "read" into the Bible. It's a great approach to textual explication: ignore most of the text, read other text as if it meant nothing, latching onto something (likely mistranslated), and then proclaim, presto!, this is G-d's will. Talk about a lack of "strict construction." I take some small comfort that most of the nastiest TBs are from goyim, and a large percentage of these are Christian missionaries dedicated to converting Jews. Not surprising: you have to pretty pushy to be Christian and push Jews around in Jerusalem.
33. #26 LOL!!!!!!!!!!! Where do you think the word came from?!?!
(05.25.07)
LOL!!!!!!!
34. Contempt on Jewish G-d and Jewish values... a deja-vu?
Nebojsa Yitzchak M ,   Toronto   (05.25.07)
Is Israel tired of being a nation in just one generation? 2000 years to this point a 100 generations perished in golus with a dream of a nation, once the dream was realized it is turning into perverted experiment. How far it can go? Perhaps next year a parade of pedophiliac, perhaps zoophiles, or really next "phase" maaan nacrophiliacs, or necrophiliacs? What is this "open-house" about? Perhaps to bring the bonding of Israeli youth (14 years old high school students to be introduced to sodomy... as a open minded policy to educate children that sodomy is OK!) Israel is experimenting with its own existence. Every nation is established on account of some values that bond society into a nation or it will disappears on account when the disintegration of such a cohesive force draws apart society into crowd of nobodies waiting to be taken from their misery. Israel is not built on values of SODOM AND GOMORAH Israel is made into a nation because it REJECTED perversion, profanity and degenerate "EXPERIMENTS" that local nations engrossed themselves into. Sodomists were not "news" in those regions but to the Jews it is a totally new level of chutzpa to challenge the G-d to the very core of its existence. Israel was build on the ashes of the nations which practiced very life stile that those idiots are so desperate to introduce into Israel. Jews just come from the ashes of goulus and first thing to do is to build a SODOM AND GOMORAH out of Israel ... yes it is painfully obvious that Israel is become tired of EXISTING as a nation why? Perhaps no one can hate Jews and Jewish values more than ex-Jew can? Because he knows that those values are real and that he is a …freak? A fraud? as long those values are around him his very “essence” is challenged, and his perverted “experiments” are challenged by the reality. Sodomy was present throughout the history for thousands of years and all societies considered it as perversion, no one society did LEGITIMIZE such behavior, condoned perhaps to such a level i.e. Sparta, decadent Rome but never institutionalized nor legitimized for a reason of a common sense and perhaps some sense of decency and morality that did prevail at the end, at least amongst the CIVILIZATIONS that SURVIVED… because people cared enough to matter.
35. Take your parade to Mecca.....
BJL ,   Newland USA   (05.25.07)
Oh, they will kill you there..... Just be happy in TA and leave the Holy City alone.
36. G'VALT
Asher Barkin ,   Cleveland,USA   (05.25.07)
G'VALT, OY LELBONO SHEL TORAH. GVALT, YIDDEN GEVALT. THIS CANNOT HAPPEN
37. gay parade?
jack ,   usa   (05.25.07)
I remember reading just a few days ago here on ynet about how tel aviv was/is the secular city and jerusalem is/was the religious city. And it is becoming more so since seculars are moving from jerusalem to tel aviv and religious moving the other way....so explain to me why have a homoparade in the religious city where people are more likely to become offended ??? or is that the point? to rub their faces in it.... how can you keep a holy city "holy" with this type of stuff going down? tourists that come to see "holy" jerusalem do NOT want to hear or see such a thing... they tend to be appalled by such behavior, and it is definetly not good PR for jerusalems tourism industry. oh and by the way I am a secure, non bigoted, non phobic personality that doesnt want a parade in my neighborhood either...but if it meant that it wouldnt take place in jerusalem, I'd be happy to let them march by here instead!
38. Can they just do it in private? married male-female...
Hanna   (05.25.07)
couples don't show off their bodies in the streets asking everyone to acknowledge their right to have sex with each other! why do gays need to have a parade and expose themselves to children? And why so much disrespect to Jerusalem's religious community? If gays believe they should have the right to be gay, and want respect for their belief, Israel's religious Jews also want respect for their belief that there shouldn't be any gay parade in Jerusalem. I can't recall any gay in Israel's 60 year history being hanged or killed in other manner for being gay . If there is a need for a parade to ask for equal rigths it should be in Iran, Syria, Saudi Arabia or other countries where they hang gays and kill them without trial.
39. J'lem, Mecca and Vatican
Stephen Weiner ,   NYC, USA   (05.25.07)
The parade should be held only if it is simultaneously in Jerusalem, Mecca and the Vatican City. Otherwise it is just a statement that Jerusalem under Israel is not Jewish.
40. Rick, that was at least civilized (27)
sk ,   USA   (05.25.07)
How about I give you the bottom line from a few perspectives? It's been a while since I studied all this, so please forgive me if I err a bit. Traditional Orthodoxy holds that Lev. 18:22 prohibits any man-on-man action. Woman-on-woman action is prohibited by some "emanations and penumbras" that the Rambam pointed out. My impression is that these boil down to women will not be servicing men if they are servicing each other. Be fruitful, etc. However, there is no death penalty for w-o-w action. Other interpretations are quite different. Some say that the prohibition was against anal intercourse between men. Others say that the prohibition was directed against anal intercourse with male temple prostitutes, who were selling their services as a substitute for "proper" temple offerings. There was an interesting analysis of Talmudic selections in Israel National News a while back that traced out a history of this prohibition. Because anti-gay bigotry has been the norm for so long in what we call Orthodoxy, Orthodox rabbis (particularly among the Haredim) have taken the easy way out and have proclaimed the whole issue simple & settled. This from the people who endlessly complicate just about everything else. Adios for a month. sk
41. #26 & 32
Asher ,   Cleveland,USA   (05.25.07)
Vnei'daah Osam.
42. Again those haters ?
charles ,   petach tikva   (05.25.07)
As someone wrote it , all , or most of the anti parade are Americans . Go , and oppose those parades in YOUR country if you want , but shut up regarding MY country . Don't bring in god command or other religious arguments , they will only have for result that the religious will , at least , be disliked . I'm certainly not gay , but i will defend their right to parade in their , and my Capital city , and this is not yours . They certainly serve more their country in all the possible ways , IDF , working , paying taxes and so on . And don't send them to other places , Yeroushalaim is also their Capital , and it's their fullest right to demonstrate there peacefully .
43. What are they trying to prove?
izzy d   (05.25.07)
In my many discussions with gayness i have discovered a deep seated intolerance of intolerance, a major reason why they are so spiteful as to come to Jerusalem to make their point (its also a pun) after all why should they march in Tel Aviv where they will be accepted as just another normal day? but in Jerusalem where a parade stirrers up the firestorm that is evident just in the preceding TB, that is exactly what they want. And i challenge any gayness to prove me wrong . oh they say its about raising awareness and the public needs to be informed that they have less "rights" like marriage and death insurance. Who's opinion are they trying to change? the government? by causing all this trouble its doubtful that the kind face of the legislation will come out to play. all they want is to FLAUNT and if they are persecuted they are justified in their extreme anti social behavior. oh no, gayness isn't being respected by those who believe in another source then humanitarian teachings. Andrew Sullivan - the closest thing to a intellectual gayness, has written his opposition to pride parades that cause more bad then good. if we all stayed home and let them march in peace they would be more disappointed then ever. give them a few hours in the year where they can feel some pride. obviously self esteem is a serious issue for them. and im not homophobic because that is a politically sourced word invented solely to lend an aura of "victim" to the gayness, amazing how there is no word for someone genuinely bothered by the sight of them.
44. Happy people beautiful colors happy times have fun kids!
healthy heterosexual ,   Jerusalem   (05.25.07)
and no I don't mind it if my tax shekel is spent in order to insure that you are safe while you have a good time parading and partying down! :)
45. Who are the protesters and where do they march...
(05.25.07)
The protesters are from all over the world. It is their goal to march on J'lem for it would be a feather in their cap. these people are insiters and to prove it lets look at what neighborhoods they want to march through. They want to march through religious neighborhoods. They have no supporters there, so why march there...ENCITMENT. A parade that incites should not exist. If violence breaks out, it is only them to blame. And all of the security they will need, who will pay for it? Me?
46. To those whose first language is English
Vitaliy ,   Brooklyn, NY   (05.25.07)
Please, spell and punctuate properly. English language has grammar. Use it.
47. Obeying the Law is in everyones best interest
m   (05.25.07)
How true, and how sad Jerusalem police department doesn't know the Law of God. Which begs the question what man are they following , in setting up his Law in opposition to Almighty God. Is it another Nimrod?
48. Anonymous m # 47
charles ,   petach tikva   (05.25.07)
I agree with you , exept that the police departement has to obey state secular laws , not god laws .
49. It's time for Tolerance Camp
Kyle ,   Southpark, CO, USA   (05.25.07)
Round up all those nasty, bigoted, homophobes and send them on down to Tolerance Camp. Force them to fingerpaint pictures of happy diversity, people of all races, colors and sexual preferences holding hands under a rainbow! Make them fingerpaint the happy rainbow of tolerance again, and again, and again, until they learn to be tolerant! The ones who are still homophobes after re-education in Tolerance Camp, just shoot them.
50. Kyle !
charles ,   petach tikva   (05.25.07)
Just shoot them ... you wrote . Be tolerant please , maybe for some you need much more time to reeducate . otherwise you will be called intolerant , and that's probably not your prefered name ?
51. Trust me, Hashem WILL have the last laugh.
jan   (05.26.07)
There will be NO ONE who will be able to stand before him and justify this. NO ONE. And that's a promise you can take to the bank.
52. #51
Mary ,   USA   (05.26.07)
The show will be interesting, sit back and watch. You are correct!
53. Gay parade in J'salem? Why stop there???
Rick ,   Open Range, USA   (05.26.07)
Why not march up to the Temple Mount? Why not throw a Gay Pride rainbow party at the Western "Wailing" Wall??? Let's see how happy HaShem will be the day you do that!
54. Rick #53
Brod ,   USA   (05.26.07)
If they do that, I won't be surprised if lightning strikes them on the spot as what happened to Sodom and Gomorrah.
55. Jan # 51
charles ,   petach tikva   (05.26.07)
The same last laugh he had some 60+ years ago ?
56. I thought I should do follow-up with Rick (53) ...
sk ,   USA   (05.26.07)
So, Rick, you posed in #27 as a goy wanting information. I dutifully wrote #40. You did not bother to reply (although, in fairness, I did say adios), and now have moved from questioner to full-blown Christian presumption, along with Brod, a serial offender. Suddenly, your veneer cracks, and it turns out you are a typical pushy goy. We'll find out tomorrow that you're a missionary as well. I forgot to mention one thing on my political agenda: denying missionaries access to Israel. If they get through and are identified, they are to be summarily deported. Oh and please, don't start with the "HaShem" business and try to blur the distinction between Judaism and Christianity. You are to say "God," "the Son," and "the Pigeon." Thanks.
57. Let the religious people parade too
anton ,   canada   (05.27.07)
Why dont they invite the orthodox religious people to parade in the same time so they both can be happy; they parade for different reason but not be able to attack each other. So make them both happy, because they are both people of the same Creator. They dont need to break the laws; fight and kill each other.
58. Brod's (6) perversion.
sk ,   USA   (05.27.07)
--- It looks like the sublime censor doesn't mind homohating filth, and has no problem with Brod's offensive TB, but has a problem with yours truly. Well, here is another version of the TB that was deleted. All I wanted to do, BTW, was post this and get out of town, and it is annoying that I haven't been able to do so already. -- Brod, dearest, last year I wrote in response to your TBs a number of times, and I don't recall you responding even once. I guess you believe that because the Son and the Pigeon are on your side, you can ignore me. My #13 provides a link to some of what I told you last year. Because you are invincibly ignorant, I see no reason to repeat it all now. Amusingly, though, you advise gay Jews to fight the enemy, while you do your best to make gay Jews the enemy and endanger them. These same gay Jews are most likely serving in the IDF, which is something the beloved Haredim rarely do. Your question to gay Jews might more aptly be directed to said Haredim. I consider your continuing pushiness regarding Jerusalem, the JEWISH capital, offensive. Now get back to church.
59. Do Any of The Bigots Here Even Know Why This Parade Exists?!
John ,   Maaleh Adumim,Israel   (05.27.07)
The gay pride events are to mark the Stonwall riots of 1969: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stonewall_riots A lot of people who say "They can do whatever they want in their own bars and clubs, but not in public." Well, once upon a time, that is what they did, but society did not leave them in peace. The gay pride, like many symbols, is a "never again" symbol - the gay community is saying that never again will it let itself be opressed like this. Of course, I do agree that it would be wrong of them to have a parade in Jerusalem where everyone was butt-naked. Those do happen and are that's OK for where they are accepted, but in Jerusalem - as any of the bigots who protest the parade would know if they took a look - by and large, the parade is very low-key. The protest against the parade make significantly more noise than the parade itself! The parade being held in Jerusalem is not to be provocative. It is for the gay community to remind themselves and everyone else that never again will they allow themselves to be oppressed.
60. sk , regarding brod
charles ,   petach tikva   (05.27.07)
Do you expect an answer of this guy ? he is very busy reading his holy books , to find something in them to spray his hatred toward , seculars , gays and other good people he hates .
Previous talkbacks
Back to article