News
250 British academics against Israel boycott
Ynet
Published: 13.06.07, 07:21
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
52 Talkbacks for this article
1. don't you think that you deserve the boycott
rushdi hasan ,   gaza   (06.13.07)
don't you think that you deserve this boycott since you are arresting the Palestinian education minister ?
2. RUTH BARUCH
J.(ph.d) ,   UK   (06.13.07)
I told you the "boycott"=nonsense. as well as other things about which you don't have the courtesy to reply to even if you may disagree which is typically israeli which is wot the kids r taught by their parents n teachers who turn a blind eye 2 cheating which is the norm like goin 2 priv. schools n lessons n live in R- A Gimmel wachin 40" flatscreens in their mersedes parked in their penthouses just b4 they jump.
3. Reply to #1
Elchi ,   Modiin, ISRAEL   (06.13.07)
The Palestinian "education minister" who advocates the destruction of the sovereign state of Israel? In a single word: no. Any other idiotic questions?
4. Hallelujah !
dd   (06.13.07)
This time, the power of good prevailed. Who knows what's going to be next time ?!
5. J(ph d)
(06.13.07)
Are you for real or just another encoded shady character who uses digits instead of language ?
6. #1: no
oferdesade ,   israel   (06.13.07)
well, yes, actually. any country that is so willing to make it so easy for you & your ilk to murder our children on busses, in scools & in restaurants (something not even the IRA ever did) is so stupid it should be condemned by intelligent people everywhere.
7. #1
(06.13.07)
is there education in gaza???? i had no idea. seems to me you people use your academic institutions to teach false revisionist history, hate and bobm making.
8. boycott
colin ,   israel   (06.13.07)
Wonder if these boycotters realise that the computers they use to boycott israel are Israei programmed?At the same time that medicine that keeps them healthy is Israeli formula,Oh the clean water filtration must be dismantled -its Israel technology.Damn they forgot thier religion was founded by that damn Israeli jesus.Hell now history was written by the idiotic Israeli Moses How xcan they study all that modern Einstein theory its Israeli.Pity they have such problems.What the hell will life be if there was no Israel for these so called academics who have nothinng else to do but boycott Israel.
9. To Rushdi Hasan: well, what kind of 'education' does he do?
The Doc ,   Haifa, Israel   (06.13.07)
Are you referring to the same person who encourages and initiantes well-documented (on BBC for that matter), Summer Boot Camps for palestinina 4 year olds and up where they learn how to suicide bomb Jews? Is he the same one supporting the racist official educational material where Israel does not exist and Jews are depicted as pigs and monkeys? Well, if THAT yuo call "education", then YOU ought to arrest him for poisoning kids' minds and soul. If one needs boycotting, then it is the PA that deserves it based on the racist, fascist, murderous and primitive teachings in kindergardens., schools, universities offical Television (with their barbaric Mickey Mouse and "Kill the Jews" children programs). Yessir - if one deserves to be boycoted and banned from the list of civilized nations it is YOUR people!
10. Hamas bombs Schol in Sderot - where is the UK boycott?
The Doc ,   Haifa, Israel   (06.13.07)
The Hamas terrorists - officially the PA Government after murdering several hundreds of their own people - have bombed a Sderot School today (and several times in the past). Where are the UK Academics calling for a boycott of the PA "scientists" for supporting a crime against an Israeli school within thesovereign Israeli Territory? Where are the UK Unions bycotting the PA for specifically targetting civilians. No, that will not happen any time soon as it does not fit the agenda of the UK Islamo-Leftists, hungry for Jewish blood.
11. Foolish Europe (important article)
MB ,   IL   (06.13.07)
SPANISH NEWSPAPER ARTICLE KEEP IT FOREMOST IN YOUR THINKING THAT THIS WAS WRITTEN BY A SPANISH WRITER ABOUT SPAIN AND EUROPE. ALL EUROPEAN LIFE DIED IN AUSCHWITZ By Sebastian Vilar Rodrigez(*) I walked down the street in Barcelona, and suddenly discovered a terrible truth - Europe died in Auschwitz. We killed six million Jews and replaced them with 20 million Muslims. In Auschwitz we burned a culture, thought, creativity, talent. We destroyed the chosen people, truly chosen, because they produced great and wonderful people who changed the world. The contribution of this people is felt in all areas of life:science, art, international trade, and above all, as the conscience of the world. These are the people we burned. And under the pretense of tolerance, and because we wanted to prove to ourselves that we were cured of the disease of racism, we opened our gates to 20 million Muslims, who brought us stupidity and ignorance, religious extremism and lack of tolerance, crime and poverty, due to an unwillingness to work and support their families with pride. They have turned our beautiful Spanish cities into the third world, drowning in filth and crime. Shut up in the apartments they receive free from the government, they plan the murder and destruction of their naive hosts. And thus, in our misery, we have exchanged culture for fanatical hatred, creative skill for destructive skill, intelligence for backwardness and superstition. We have exchanged the pursuit of peace of the Jews of Europe and their talent for hoping for a better future for their children, their determined clinging to life because life is holy, for those who pursue death, for people consumed by the desire for death for themselves and others, for our children and theirs. What a terrible mistake was made by miserable Europe.
12. #7 - Of course there is education in Gaza!
Secret Observer ,   Londonistan   (06.13.07)
And it is very thorough! Admittance qualifications are of a very high standard with expectations of a minimum basic knowledge from compulsary home indoctrination. Entrance examinations for 3 year olds include the following questions: 1) Who stole our land? 2) What do you call the sons of pigs and monkeys occupying our land? 3) Who will you kill when you commit jihad? 4) How many virgins does a martyr get? (This question is avoided when the applicant is a female because they haven't figured out a befitting reward yet!). Not such simple questions eh? The education they receive guarantees the children a heroic future, I am sure you will agree.
13. There Has Always Been A Boycott Of Palestinians
Seth ,   Washington, DC   (06.13.07)
The "Palestinians" (Arab residents of territories of Jordan and Egypt who seized land awarded by the UN for a Palestinian state) have always been looked down upon by other Arab cultures. Nobody has any real interest in their success or failure except as pawns. Lebanon, Iraq, Saudi Arabia...none of these countries really like Palestinians as people and the fact remains that hundreds of thousands of Gazans desparately want to work again in Israel and provide for their families.
14. #10 The "UK Boycotters" consists of Muslims,
Ganit ,   Israel   (06.13.07)
self-hating Jews and anti-Semites. So you can't expect them to boycott their own terrorists.
15. #5
J.(ph.d;T.E.F.L ) ,   UK   (06.13.07)
'tis thou who R the Shady Character (i.e.anon).Thou art an UNREAL character cos thou dont know wot is bein sed so thou art ignorant as Ruth BRACHA hu ain't R.BARUCH but thou understandeth not 4 thou B digital.BTW...GTG !!GOTTCHA.
16. #4 d.d.
joe ,   sheffield.uk.   (06.13.07)
Where have you been. I've missed you.Looks like you only write posts about the U.K. Why not come over and have some pasta & basil @ my place?And we could watch football on t.v.
17. Ban the boycott!
Lina ,   USA   (06.13.07)
Those pushing this boycott should be ostracized from academia. People like Tom Hickey, David Rose and Sue Blackwell are simply waging their own personal vendetta against Israel at the expense of British universities. They claim Israel discriminates against the Palestinians then turn around and push discrimination against Israel. Let the voices of reason step forward in Britain and dump the trouble makers.
18. Boycotters' minds
Ram ,   London   (06.13.07)
How can we stop the Isreali Jews from showing us up? Answer: Let's turn Palestinians into saints suffering gross injustices under illegitimate "occupation". Facts on the ground? History? UN resolutions? Don't need that, all can be turned on its head!
19. #11 Foolish Europe
Terry ,   Eilat, Israel   (06.13.07)
Truer words were never written. These words should be re-printed in every newspaper in the world, especially in Britain. Thanks.
20. boycott
leo solomon ,   nahariya   (06.13.07)
If it weren't bad for Britain ,bad for academic freedom and bad for the Palestinians would it then be o.k.?The fact that Israel is the only nation against which this tool is being employed doesn't seem to bother these academics.The fact that it is a clear expresssion of Jew hatred doesn't seem to matter.Who will come forward and declare that this proposed boycott is unjust ,undeserved and a despicable expression of anti semitism.
21. #11
Hamburger ,   Hamburg   (06.13.07)
What strikes me as amazing, is the publisher that was not afraid to publish this article! Especially after Muhammad cartoons....
22. These british academics are right
hizki ,   germany   (06.13.07)
A statement from more than 250 distinguished British academics condemning the British boycott of Israeli universities as “bad for Britain, bad for academic freedom, bad for Palestinians and bad for peace”. Professor Robert Winston, a fertility expert, called the academic boycott proposed by the Universities and Colleges Union (UCU) Congress in protest of the continued occupation of the Palestinian territories, “utterly inappropriate”. “The academics in Israel are the very people we should be working with, rather than against if we want to promote better understanding,” Winston said. Well spoken, well said.
23. #21, the publisher was brave, but the writer is
(06.13.07)
using a pen name. European thought is now captive to the fatwas.
24. #11: Is Europe foolish?
hizki ,   germany   (06.13.07)
The author Sebastian Vilar Rodrigez who wrote "And under the pretense of tolerance, and because we wanted to prove to ourselves that we were cured of the disease of racism, we opened our gates to 20 million Muslims, who brought us stupidity and ignorance, religious extremism and lack of tolerance, crime and poverty, due to an unwillingness to work and support their families with pride. " displays the same intolerance that ultimately led to the shoah that he laments, with his broad generalizations about muslims. Muslims don't like to work, they do not contibute in the sciences or high tech, ... what a load of crock. If the author truly laments the sins of his ancestors agaiants the Jewish people then he should suggest carving out a bit of christendom as a Jewish colony, which will give additional security to the jewish state. He should try to estimate the value of damages that chtistendom owes to the Jewis people and provide it in real estate with defendable borders from christendom. He shouldn't ad sin upon sin, by using his "regret" for the sins of his ancestors to jsutify additional sins (with the same root) against another people.
25. Important: international reputation of British academics!
Zaphod ,   Pluto   (06.13.07)
"Tom Hickey, the chairman of Brighton University’s UCU branch and proposer of the motion, said that it would enhance the international reputation of British academics."
26. #1
Takan ,   Elat   (06.13.07)
Did the Israelis arrest Mickey Mouse (Farfur)?
27. If you want to boycott Israeli technology ...
Tobias ,   Germany   (06.13.07)
and any products and technologies developed or produced in Israel, then start by not using PCs with Intel Processors, MS Windows XP or Vista, Mobile phones, some Anti-Cancer drugs, ... and many other things invented in the last 30 years. Get an "Volksempfänger"-radio as your electronic entertainment device, and a computer made in CCCP , if you want to be sure to have non-israeli, non-jewish, not-developed-in-Haifa-or-Rehovot technology.
28. #19 terry
rastafarian ,   nottingham.uk   (06.13.07)
hey,man,us brits dont kno how 2 reed n rite;us brits r illlitrate;but sumtimes us reed the times n kno wot is goin on,man,like wot de spaniard rote;so f.off wiv yor patrnizashun ngo n play soccer on de RIGHT/LEFT wing.yor call now,man
29. No. 20 Leo Solomon
NYC Girl   (06.13.07)
Your comment is right on target. Nowhere was it mentioned that these boycotts are racist and single Israel out to the exclusion of every other country, most of which are far worse than Israel could ever be. It's the same as when a Palestinian will step up and say that suicide bombings are wrong. Unfortunately, they only think they're wrong because they're detrimental to "the cause." Not because the murder of innocent Israeli civilians is completely immoral.
30. #11 - Europe is still not comfortable with democracy
Glenn ,   Canada   (06.13.07)
and it's unconsciously longing for the tyranny they lost as a result of the US destruction of Nazism and Fascism. That explains why they are so anti-American today, and why they have passively embraced the presence of Islam and its progressive takeover of their societies. Also, Germany is experiencing a lot of conversions to Islam. They like the strict rules which are an alternative to the excess freedom in European society.
Next talkbacks
Back to article