News
'Israel not responsible for Gaza refugees'
Efrat Weiss
Published: 17.06.07, 10:22
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
77 Talkbacks for this article
61. To keren
Ali   (06.17.07)
vai te embora de volta para o brasil the palestinians has more right than you in staying there, go back to brazil
62. Unilateral Disengagement
Joseph Kaufman ,   Sunnyvale/Jerusalem   (06.17.07)
Apparantly collective madness competes with idiocy in the minds of those pigmies presently sitting in the Israeli parliament. We were told that we disengaged from Gaza, at such a tremendous cost, so as to wash our hands of the fate of those who hate our guts, the Palis. They voted Hamas in. Why do we not let them enjoy the fruits of their choices? What have we to gain taking on responsibility for these people. Let the arab world tend to them. The mind boggles at how Israeli's even consider helping the Gazans. Let them help themselves, or die. A pox on them. A pox on the pigmy politicians in the Knesset. Woe is Israel at this time of perfidious leadership. Israel, these problems serve you right, you've chosen these leaders, and haven't taken to the streets to remove them from power, as they bleed you.
63. Only a Fool ...
klaus ,   Jerusalem   (06.17.07)
...would help them. They were so unhappy with the low number of deaths the fatah caused that they voted in the hamas to kill even more of our innocent citizens. When the murderers started killing THEM they ran to us for help? They hired mercenaried to kill us! Let them sleep in it - lock the borders!
64. Again your stupidities KEREN
charles ,   petach tikva   (06.17.07)
First of all , do you need a map of Israel in front of you to know the situation ? Secondly , Israel does not let them in . Egypt do'nt want them , no other country neither . Do you know , certainly not ignorant little girl , that they could not enter Egypt when this country occupied Gaza from 1948 to 1967 .
65. #9 #34 Keren and Ali
Carl ,   Indianapolis, USA   (06.18.07)
Keren: you're basically right. Ali: If Gazans were to be accepted into other Arab countries, Israel would facilitate the approach and arrival of rescue ships.
66. #64 Charles - There's no need to be insulting
Carl ,   Indianapolis, USA   (06.18.07)
to make your point. Everyone here has the right to express their ideas and to disagree without resorting to using terms such as "your stupidities" or "ignorant little girl". If you wish to share your knowledge or wisdom with us, please do so. Just spare us the condescending or insulting comments towards other readers.
67. Re #40: Disengagement never worked
Steve ,   USA   (06.18.07)
B"H I said the opposite of the #40 response. Disengagment never worked. It is time to reengage the civilian population and feed the refugees in Gaza. You may need to clear and secure territory in Gaza to do so, but they are your bridge and your bread, so you must care for them in the territory that they come from.
68. #1 Ben - Underage children kill Jews
Carl ,   Indianapolis, USA   (06.18.07)
There are international organizations established with the purpose of aiding refugees. Israel is under attack from those people. What you are suggesting is very noble but not practical. It's Israel's compassion that has gotten it in the trouble it's in. What are rich Arab countries with a lot of real estate doing for these suffering people???
69. Disengagement never worked
Steve ,   USA   (06.18.07)
B"H This is Israel's problem and the "disengagement" was a myth. Once Israel conquers Hamas, it is going to have to govern again. It might have to setup some refugee camps in the northern part of the strip for the refugees to live in and take territory so long as Hamas refuses to cooperate for the purpose of having an area for these refugees to live. Israel will have to feed these disengaged also. It might as well get used to taking care of the population again.
70. They're not refugees
Steve ,   Raleigh   (06.18.07)
They're poor people leaving a bad neighborhood. They deserve no consideration of any kind. Turn them back. If Egypt wants them, maybe they'll take them in.
71. The Palestian people VOTED for Hamas, so EAT WHAT YOU COOKED
ls ,   israel   (06.18.07)
72. Send them back. Don’t let them in.
Alex   (06.18.07)
73. Palestinian refugees
leah amdur ,   Jerusalem Israel   (06.18.07)
Its all a trick for all the Palis to come into Israel. Send these refugees to Iraq, Iran, South Africa and let all the Anti semites world wide welcome them in. Condy Rice should take a few million in and so should Britain and France.
74. Gaza
Mick Downes ,   UK   (06.18.07)
How sad to see so many hate filled comments
75. Gaza Refugees with a big ?
AlbertoGA ,   Houston, USA   (06.18.07)
Are you taking a chance in Israel that you will regret soon ? I am 1000 % sure. The Fatah now need to move out of GAZA...and fast ! The same Guys are the PLO who want the TOTAL DESTRUCTION of ISRAEL The only difference with the Hamas ...is the UNIFORM... and, the time schedule of those 2 people. They want us dead or out of Israel just the same Shalom from Houston Alberto
76. YES, Israel is responsible
lorie ,   st. louis mo usa   (06.18.07)
You treat these people like animals and now you say you are not responsbile, that is horrible. This fighting is all Israel fault, you are heartless breed of people
77. #76 Lorie Get A Brain
andy ,   orlando,fl   (06.19.07)
How do you arrive at the conclusion Israel is responsible for the Gazan arabs killing each other? Where is your logic? The arabs there elected a group of terrorist thugs namely Hamas who are killing another bunch of terrorist thugs namely fatah.The arabs have reaped what they sow.Let them kill each other.
Previous talkbacks
Back to article