News
Report: Abbas asks Israel to release Barghouti
Roee Nahmias
Published: 26.06.07, 14:19
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
30 Talkbacks for this article
1. Here's Proof For Need Of The Death Penalty
Reuven Brauner ,   Raanana, Israel   (06.26.07)
This man masterminds murders of numerous Jews. He is captured, but kept alive in an Israeli prison. The Arabs want him back in return for something or another. Undoubtedly he will return to his murderous ways. More Jews will be killed. Go Israel!
2. releasing barghouti
israeli ,   israel   (06.26.07)
to restore order in Gaza is like releasing Benny Sela to prevent sex crimes and rape.
3. More Concessions = More demands (End)
Pat ,   Alabama, USA   (06.26.07)
4. IF
leon ,   Grand Rapids USA   (06.26.07)
If Ohlmert accedes to this, and releases Bergouti (or however you spell it), I will entitle my next post : " Neville Chamberlain Rides Again!"
5. Who is Abbas to be demanding anything from us?
Talula ,   Israel   (06.26.07)
And why are we worried about what goes on in Gaza? And even more to the point, why is Saeb Erekat asking that WE show concern for the wellbeing of the Gazans? What the fuck is going on here?!?!?!?! Let Hamas take care of themselves. They wanted to take control of Gaza, well now, they have it. Abbas hasn't done anything decent or note worthy for us, not ever, and here he is demanding that Marwan Bargouti be released, a man who was responsible for many Israeli deaths. It's the beginning of the end for Israel.
6. Abbas's admission
freejay ,   Israel   (06.26.07)
Here he clearly admits that he doesnt want us to hurt Hanass. How much proof does our stupid government need to realise that this whole hamass?fatah split up is a set up. Now they will get even more concesions in gazza and west bank whih will result in suicide bombings and israeli citizens being murdered. Notice how Abass is DEMANDING this and that but offers nothing in return. The funny thing is that the appeasing fool Olmert will give it to them and hurt israel more than the damage he already has done.
7. let me think about it... no.
mike ,   israel (formerly usa   (06.26.07)
brainwash him into a dutiful zionist tool first, if he is released.
8. A Mockery of Our Judicial System.
Terry ,   Eilat, Israel   (06.26.07)
Can a convicted murderer be freed as a political favour to our country's enemies? If this is the case, we will truly be living in a country with no law. #1 (mr Brauner) is correct. This is proof of the need of the death penalty for terrorism. Not as a deterrent nor as punishment, but to avoid political blackmail & the risk of a repeat offence endangering innocent lives.
9. THEY ARE NOT YOUR FRIENDS, OLMERT, YOU IDIOT!
Isabella ,   Israel   (06.26.07)
10. Barghouti and No. 5
Paul Usiskin ,   London UK   (06.26.07)
Two questions: 1.What has Olmert ever done for us? 2.What is the foul language code for Ynet Talkbacks. I've never seen anyone use the "F..." word before. Isn't enough that we have to put up with all sorts of biyuv from hysterics and paranoids without foul language being permitted too?
11. Let's all run amok!
In shock in ,   Israel   (06.26.07)
Because the judicial system in our country means NOTHING!!
12. Abbas can ask all he want, but gets no respect
JPS ,   Efrat   (06.26.07)
Bargouti is in jail for murder. It's what the Palestinians call their "legitimate right to resist the occupation." Unfortunately, it's what HRH and Amnesty both call war crimes. Oh yes, Israel too says you can't go around shooting it's citizens in the head and blowing them up in malls and restaurants - the reason why Bargouti is sitting in prison for a long, long time. For murder. If Abbas wants to start the process to get Bargouti freed, he needs to stand up in front of a microphone and say in Arabic "The Palestinian people reject violence and accept peaceful negotiations as the only means for reaching a two-state solution. The Palestinian Authority hereby forbids and outlaws any military action against Israelis and demands and immediate resumption of direct peace talks." In otherwords, sorry Mahmoud, the answer is NO.
13. What's Abbas ever done other than take and take and take
Kyle ,   Southpark, CO, USA   (06.26.07)
All Merde must go!
14. #10 Paul Usiskin - London
Terry ,   Eilat, Israel   (06.26.07)
Paul, Israelis are generally not native English speakers & that word & similar Anglo-Saxon expletives do not carry the same connotations or emotional charge. In other words, they are not "dirty" words in the sense that they are in England or America. More to the point, this is a very emotional issue - that word was actually quite appropriate under the circumstances. My reaction to the release of the criminal murder Barghouti included the same word. I just didn't write it in the talkback but I would bet you that 99% of people who read the article used the same word to themselves. To tell you the truth, I rarely hear Olmert mentioned anymore without that word; it's become part of his name.
15. one more militant leader?!
unpainted   (06.26.07)
what can he offer the people?In the end -just more death and destruction.There is more need of someone free of this extremist ideas.Abbas should care more about his people.They are first in line,not this single man.
16. ABBAS IS IN NO POSITION TO DEMAND ANYTHING!
srude ham   (06.26.07)
He's lost the war against the palistinians. As for bargoodi... let him rot in jail until picked up in sheol along with supreme idiot olmert.
17. Release Barghouti in exchange for Al Merde
Alan ,   SA   (06.26.07)
18. Trade bigbooti FOR olmert fudd
Jeff Snarkey ,   Omaha, USA   (06.26.07)
get olmert fudd off the streets
19. TO MOST OF YOU
A Bethlehemite   (06.26.07)
Abbas and his government was the one that recognized and willing to make peace with Israel....but that's what most of you here do not want. The issue here is security. Strengthening Abbass to control the militants in the WB, gather support and have one security force. Stop the violence and negotiate. Have law and order on the streets. How to accomplish all that is the question. Not what has Abbas has done for us.
20. Abbas demands release
leib ben yisrael ,   madison wisconsin   (06.26.07)
but did Olmert demand elimination of hate education in Palestinian school curriculum updated by Abbas contrary to the promises he made?
21. to #19, a bethlehemite
freejay ,   Israel   (06.26.07)
You claim Abass wants peace??? 12/1/2007 Palestinian Authority Chairman Mahmoud Abbas on Thursday called on Palestinians to refrain from internal fighting and to direct their guns only against Israeli "occupation." (Abbas, speaking during a rally marking the 42nd anniversary of the founding of his Fatah party)
22. It's not the beginning of the end; it's the middle of the en
Ken Price, Ph.D. ,   Dallas, TX USA   (06.26.07)
The beginning of the end was Oslunacy, and the treachery of Peres, Beilin, Hirschfeld, Pundak, et al who met with Arafat at the same time that his henchmen were murdering Israelis, and while the law on the books forbade Israelis from meeting with the PLO. But what is the law in Israel, since Oslo? It has become an extension of politics and a tool of the Left - used against the Rightwing and in defense of PA terrorists. Even the appt. of high IDF officers has been politicized by the PM's hoping to avoid indictments. This is not the beginning of the end for Israel. This is the middle of the end. The end of the end, sadly will be here before you know it.
23. necessary supplies
Mike ,   Jerusalem   (06.26.07)
"to ensure all the necessary supplies were transferred into the Strip." i.e guns ammo, bullet proof vests, materials to make bombs and kassams Olmert is a big enough tipesh to send them this too.
24. OLMERT DOES NOT CARE THAT BARGHOUTI KILLED PEOPLE.
MIKE HAMEN ,   USA   (06.26.07)
25. BARGHOUTI LONG TERRORIST RECORED.
FORMAN ,   USA   (06.26.07)
THE ATTACK ON THE SEA FOOD MARKET IN TEL AVIV[MARCH 5,2002]KILLED SGT-MAJ.SALIM BARCHAT 33 YEAR OLD,YOSEF HABI 52 YEAR OLD,ELI KAHAN 53 YEAR OLD. THE ATTACK ON THE GAS STATION NEAR GIVAT ZEEV,NORTH WIST OF JERUSALEM [JANUARY 15,2002]KILLED YOEL CHEN. ATTACK ON MAAL ADUMIM ROAD [JUNE 12,2001]GREEK MONK TSIVOUK TAKIS GERMANUS WAS KILLED. AND BARGHOUTI WAS ACCUSED WITH 21 MORE COUNTS OF MURDER IN 33 OTHER ATTACKS.AND IF PEOPLE LIKE OLMERT THAT DO NOT CARE ABOUT WHAT BARGHOUTI DID THEN THEY ARE NO DEFFERENT.
26. When the Gazan suffer they come to Israel. Israel dont help!
Steve ,   USA   (06.26.07)
27. Proof Abbas incapable of providing security
Steve ,   USA   (06.26.07)
B"H The Arab dream is positioned as peaceful statehood. Yet Abbas has more concern for murderers. Why? If Abbas is trying to run a state founded on murder, that is not living in peace. Does anyone contest the evidence that Barghouti is a murderer? Of course not. I say that the dream of a state living in peace with Israel is at risk with such an attitude. This with the unreasonable demands of putting the capitol in East Jerusalem also. That issue should be off the plate and should not be finalized at this time if Abbas is interested in security and peace. It is understandable that Abbas cannot afford to be seen as the "loser" on this point. But what he cannot perceive is that he cannot afford to be perceived as a "winner" on this point either, and this is why that issue needs to be delayed out. It is not resolvable, and it is unreasonable to put in place a false resolution that heats up the conflict rather than settles it down. Instead of focussing on locating the capitol city there, what needs to be focused on is getting institutions working to provide security in Ramlah to the common people. A premature move would strengthen terror rather than prevent it and this would be harmful. The discussion would move on to importing people from other countries instead of focussing on maintaining peace. That basically means a Hamas presence that would overthrow Abbas and sink the ship. In other words, Abbas's recommendations are a great way to provide for Abbas's ultimate overthrow and an ultimate extension of Hamasstan. Either Abbas has to see the light and stop making such rediculous comments now, or Israel might as well as cut to the chase and allow "free" passage of Hamas, facing the rocket launches on Tel Aviv as a consequence. Israel has to politely say no to Abbas's suicide attempts.
28. Abbas
Nemesis   (06.26.07)
Who is Abbas to "demand" anything? This poor excuse of a leader should be on is knees begging. Of course,Olmert is practically on his knees begging them to be nice. What a farce! Is the best beggar going to win? Then the Pals will get whatever they want,because they're the experts at begging.. Its time for Netanyahu.
29. #10 Paul Usiskin
Nemesis   (06.27.07)
You've never seen anyone using the "F" word before?? Must have led a sheltered life,Paul. Maybe you should stick to Readers Digest ..that shouldn't offend your dainty sensibilities.
30. shame you Olmert, you are a disgrace, Abbas is a better man
Mike ,   Jerusalem   (06.27.07)
Shame on us, we are a disgrace to ourselves. Abbas NEVER misses and opportunity to DEMANd the release of barghouti that bloody murderering terrorist, yet not a single one of our PMs with the exception of Bibi who in the ended melted like an artic in eilat to B.J. Bill Jefferson Clinton yemach shmo vzichro at Wye River EVER DEMANDED th release of Jonathan Pollard whose crime waas to provide us with info promissed to us for our saurvival by the US which they chose not to give us! Shame on us! We can learn something from Abbas! Olmert before you even think of arab terrorist murderers think of one of our own Jonathan Pollard, think of Gilad Shalit, Ehud Goldwasser Ron Arad etc.
Back to article