News
Transfer and resettlement – Tehran Style
Roee Nahmias
Published: 01.08.07, 16:12
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
39 Talkbacks for this article
1. Syria, Lebanon and Gaza to be replaced by Persians!
The Doc ,   Haifa, Israel   (08.01.07)
Yes - THAT would be the irony of the day! Now wonder Ahmedinejad has been toting the nuclear rifle - to keep attention diverted from the atrocities and genocide it has been doing on their own soil and people! And they dare to accuse uf of "genocide", "racism" and "apartheid" and go on denying "Holocaust"? Iran is nothing more than a thug waiting to be taught a lesson. Hopefuly that lesson comes before they go nuclear.
2. Where is the Arab League / Mr. Musa?
Semsem ,   New York, USA   (08.01.07)
Where are the 2 faced hypocrites at the Arab League led by Mr. Musa? Silence at Darfur and Iran/ But always ready to bash Israel. Mr. Musa also says the Temple in Jerusalem was not built where everyone knows it was located.
3. Transfer and resettlement
James ,   London, UK   (08.01.07)
It is ironic that a media supporter of Israeli government should even think about writing on this subject on any other country! No country has ever done more to destroy lives, displace people from their homes and create the largest and longest running refugee problem in the world than Israel!. The consequences of which is most of the worldwide instability in the last 40 years and current instability in the entire world! It maybe convenient to use the Iranian President’s miss-represented statements to pretend that this is a new problem caused by Iran! However, the fact is that Israel has always had these problems and always will, until the day that fairness is seen to be exercised by the Israeli government! I would love to read your article on Transfer, resettlement and creation of refugees on the state of Israel! p.s. Extreme dislike, or even hatred of the corrupt and heartless Israeli government, has nothing to do with dislike of people’s religions. The people running the government of Israel are evil because they use Evil policies to destroy people’s lives and all for MONEY! p.p.s. This is not Jewish bashing, I am one myself! But evil is evil whatever its colours and however it is dressed up!
4. No Talkbacks From Palestinian Readers?
Terry ,   Eilat, Israel   (08.01.07)
I'd love to hear their comments. But you want my politically incorrect opinion? You Arabs deserve the Turks & Persians. You manage to hate us & spread anti-Semitism all over the world, you have made us out to be the devil on Earth. You oppressed us when we lived in your countries & then you expelled us (actually, you did us a favour) & stole everything we owned. You murder black Africans by the hundred thousands in Darfur & then blame "Zionists" for the effort to stop genocide. You have poisoned the United Nations & made it a corrupt & useless organization. You spread terrorism throughout the world in the name of religion & teach children that murdering Jews & infidels will lead to paradise. You have created poverty, misery, & ignorance in all your countries & then blame us for your failure. Maybe you'd like us better if we treated you like the Persians do? It's certainly what you deserve. Please, let's have some comments, especially from Israeli Arabs.
5. james you are an idiot- and your "facts" are all wrong
jack bauer ,   usa   (08.01.07)
6. James the "Jew"
herb glatter ,   pittsburgh, pa, usa   (08.01.07)
originally i was going to use an expletive and leave it at that. then i wanted to ask you: why are Darfurians dying to enter Israel when they could simply go to their "brotherly" countries? we have had "Jews" like you in the past and will have them in the future. how about having integrity first then becoming a Jew?
7. Yes, James, you're an idiot and you 'facts' are all wrong
Tuvia Fogel ,   Milan, Italy   (08.01.07)
8. Where is the BBC?? In Israel with the Pals
Lemmings Hotline ,   sd usa   (08.01.07)
9. #3 - Racism and bashing
The Doc ,   Haifa, Israel   (08.01.07)
"James" - it is interesting that you claim to be Jewish. So bloody WHAT if you are Jewish? Is this supposed to tell anything? Your rants are racist, terror-supporting and of course taken straight from the Islamo-Leftist book of racism, deception and lies. We have a free press here in Israel if you have not noticed - and they print whatever they please - sorry they do not always voice the racist rants of idiots like you or sound in support of barbaric tyrants like Ahmedinejad. We have every bloody right to say anything we please - I am happy that this gets you mad, "Jewish James". Maybe you should also PROVE your rants with real facts and not only parrot the slogans you undoubtedly heard in a London Mosque or at a Union thugs gathering, and in your imbecilty - wanted to believe. You see, most of us here KNOW you kind well and could not care less what you say, think or do. Don't invest too much in Muslim propaganda here, in Israeli forums. You have plenty of places to display your ignorance, hatred and backwardness in thousands of equally primitive and racist Muslim forums. I am sure you'll find enough supportive growls from the hyenas over there, to keep your hatred (or self-hatred) flame consuming you from the inside.
10. James !!!!
(08.01.07)
You must be either totally brainwashed or full of gorey hatred towards yourself as a so-called Jew. Before posting anything else from now on, I advise you take a long and serious look at yourself, breathe in loads of fresh air, count to 10 and only after that start thinking about your subject matter. Not that you will arrive at the right conclusion, but at least you may give yourself a fair chance to cogitate humanely.
11. Transfer
(08.01.07)
The transfer plans of the ayatollah state do not surprise me in the least. Two things do surprise me by all means. One is the fact that Ahmadinejad promised to wipe Israel off the map and meantime, he is satisfied with "relocating" (what a convenient word ! ) entire Arab populations. The second is even more baffling, namely, the whole Arab world has joined into a huge choir of the silence of the lambs.
12. #3 james is not jewish
pinny from lawrence ,   usa   (08.01.07)
a careful read of "JAMES" shows him to be a non jew. his mispellings and his "MONEY" comment.
13. James i know what you where thinking with this post
Mike ,   Israel   (08.01.07)
Its the only way i can get attention. To be very honest with i was not going to post but after i finished laughing i realized to spare you 30 seconds. You need some major intervention in your life son, your in so deep in it you cant even begin to know, "No country has ever done more to destroy lives" Man alive your such an idiot its beyond belief. Your post has achieved nothing, no normal person can even begin to argue your mindless point its so far of into your deep deep empty skul. Can someone give this combined total of 4 cells that calls him self a human some air.
14. The persians
T.I ,   Israel   (08.01.07)
Iran underscores it's persian racism all the time, the Iranian regime of course cooperating with Arabic countries, but in the meantime discrimination of non the persian is extending. It's an appropriate message according to the Islamic empire. Iran eventually aspiring to seize the whole world. My jews or non jews brothers don't get panicked because hypocrisies, they will wake up somehow, even if they like it or not, after saturday comes sunday. James is jew-hated, don't spend on him talk back, he isn't worth your spit.
15. Talkbacks from Palestinian Readers #4
Paul ,   Seattle   (08.01.07)
So absolutely right, Terry. I couldn;' have said it better myself.
16. There is few differences among arabs,persians and other
Ahmed ,   Egypt   (08.02.07)
muslim people in the region,paksitan,afganistan.....all the differences were invented by the west,these people is the "same" people really,and all the muslim are determinated to unite.don´t remember one choose,the west create these borders,and it can change on the future.there are differences between a syrian,iranian or iraki?????there are differences between a yemenite,saudi or pakistani??? I don´t see differences,are the same people.
17. Ethnic diversity..wake up Ahmed
Zuri ,   Sydney Australia   (08.02.07)
Yes I do tend to agree with Ahmed from Egypt, how I do not have anything against anybody as I agree we( israelis) and Arabs or infact Moslems from around the world, It would be nice to exchange some Arabs with for example Swede, Dutch, Finnish, and Hungarian and Israel politacl problems, in turn the Palis will mix with Europeans and mellow down a bit and the world will be a better place..just use your Imagination.
18. #3 James from UK: Jews Cause of all Evil
Liliane ,   Brighton, UK   (08.02.07)
#3 so according to James from the UK the Jews are the cause of all Evil in the world. The usual trash Jews have been hearing for 2,000 years and a good example of increasing antisemitism in Britain. As to refugees, he avoids mentioning the 1 million Jews forced to flee from Arab countries.
19. # 16 Ahmed Egypt. Typical of Muslim Brotherhood denial !!
KMR ,   Middle East   (08.02.07)
20. #16 keep dreaming. Iran clearly sees a big difference
Zvi   (08.02.07)
And yes, a lot of Arabs see a big difference too. The west didn't create Iran/Persia. Persia was around several thousand years ago, just as Israel was. The west didn't create Persian language (or Pashtun or Coptic or Hebrew or Kurdish) and make them different from Arabic. The west didn't create north African culture and make it different from Pakistani culture, which differs from Lebanese culture, which differs from Persian culture. The west also didn't create the Shia-Sunni split that has resulted in so much bloodshed over the centuries, nor did it create Islamist oppression against Jews and Christians (or Muslim acceptance of the same in some areas at some times). To the extent that everyone - Egyptians, Israelis, Lebanese, Japanese, Iranians, Eskimos and Kenyans - are all the same, sure, middle easterners are all the same. But beyond that...? Get real.
21. #16...Persians look down on Arabs.
Greg ,   New York City   (08.02.07)
always have. they see Arabs as a lower life-form, like dogs. if you call a Persian an Arab, he will kick your ass.
22. Reality Check 101 for #16
Robert Tilden   (08.02.07)
Ahmed, do you speak Parsi? Urdu? Tajek? Turkish? You speak Arabic. Admiting that Persians who call their country Iran because they are Aryan. Arabs, like Jews are Semitic. It is a linguistic difference that is big. Palestinians on the other hand are one and the same as Syrians, Jordanians and Lebanese. As you know Ahmad, Egyptian arabic is not the same as Syrian - Palestinian Arabic. Most of the Gulf Arabs have the same dialect as well. So when you get a little more educated, you are welcome to comment again, but get a brain first.
23. To James #3. Not Functioning Properly.
Maansingh ,   The Netherlands   (08.02.07)
You write :".. (Israel is responsible for) the worldwide instability in the last 40 years ...". You mean to say that Israel is responsible for the : -- Bosnian War 1992 - 1995 ; -- Kosovo War 1996 - 1999 ; -- Cambodja War + killing fields 1972 - 1989 with 2,5 million killed, being one-quarter of Cambodja's population ; -- Iraq - Iran War 1980 - 1988 ; -- Afghanistan War 1979 - 1999 in which 1 million Afghans died and 5 million became refugees ; -- China - Vietnam War of 1979 ; -- Algeria fighting insurgents 1992 - 1998 ; -- Morocco fighting Polisario 1976 - 1991; -- East Timor War 1975 - 1999 whereby one-third of the East Timorese population got killed, namely 200,000 by Indonesia ; -- Rwanda mass slaughter of 800,000 inhabitants in just 3 months time in 1994. SO, James you put the blame for all those fightings, killings, wars in the last 40 years on Israel ??? I think your brain is not functioning properly !!
24. To Ahmed #16. Different Countries And Peoples.
Maansingh ,   The Netherlands   (08.02.07)
You write :"... all the differences were invented by the West, ...". Darius the Great of Persia lived around 500 B.Chr. He conquered many countries and peoples like Babylonia (nowadays known as Iraq), Bactria (nowadays known as Afghanistan), Gedrosia (nowadays known as Baluchistan, part of Pakistan), Syria, Armenia, Turkey, Cyprus, etc. -- each with their different religions. The Ottoman Empire around 1450 AD - 1850 AD conquered countries like Iraq, Syria, Judea, Saoedi Arabia, Egypt, Libya, Koerdistan, Armenia, Greece, Bulgaria, Roemenia, etc. Greek Orthodox, other Christians, and Jews could continue to practice their religion. So, Ahmed, different countries and peoples existed at the time of Darius the Great in 500 B.Chr. and at the time of the Ottoman rulers around 1500 AD. HOW can you say that differences were created by the West ??? I hope you are not that stupid to consider Darius the Great and the Ottoman rulers to be Westerns.
25. Ynet's main problem !
Atilla Liman ,   Karagözoğlu   (08.02.07)
it is to decide to be a serious news site or not. this is Ynet's main problem. Lets give a look at Ahmadinejad 's photos. on main page photo is deadly funny. on article one is also same. even enemies deserve respect. grow up MYYNET. I am good example for you. Look I am doing fine these days. growing up. but you are staying where I left you :) with my love with my light I am always around to watch you My brother Ynet :) Love Atilla Liman Karagözoğlu
26. Terry #4 well said,maybe we shud learn from the Persians?
Yisraeli   (08.02.07)
27. Hold a world conference about this in Israel
Gidi ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (08.02.07)
If the government had any self dignity, they would summon academics from all over the world to discuss the transfer policy of Iran. It would be great. This is what Israel should do.... if only.
28. Where is the outcry from the UN, EU and America against this
RBY ,   Zichron yaakov   (08.02.07)
ethnic cleansing. Since Israel is not involved, nobody cares.
29. #26 Yisraeli - That was my point.
Terry ,   Eilat, Israel   (08.02.07)
Did you ever hear Turks talk about Arabs? I had many Turkish & Iranian friends when I was in college & the comments about Arabs made the Ku Klux Klan sound moderate. Much as I fear the current Iranian regime & it's nasty ideology, I have a hard time condemning their treatment of Arabs; evidently, Muslims know how to handle other Muslims better than we do. Even the Arab regimes treat their own populations this way. Notice, by the way, that there were no Israeli Arab talkbacks - where are the Arab MK's who are so quick to condemn the country that pays their salaries? Except for that brainwashed fool James from the UK, not even a comment from the usual Israeli-bashing leftists.
30. #22 to your "reality check" XDDDDDD
Ahmed ,   Egypt   (08.02.07)
First of all,i don´t agree with #19,#20,#21,#22 and #24. you write that jews are semitic,like arabs. Ok,but i think that persians and arab have more in comun,that jews and arabs.If you see a persian and arab you can´t see differences,but between an arab and a jew there are a lot of differences,not only on religion,and linguistic,the arab race is different to people of israel.Semitic is only a name by the west.Arabs are arabs,not semitic,arabs come from yemen,and his descendents are in all middle east and north of africa.For example,i am an arab of egypt and i have clear that jews and arabs are different peoples,arabs palestinians and jews are not the same people,for example.Arabs are afroasiatic people,a lot of jews are form europe,there are a lot of differences at this case. I keep that said on my first message,arabs,persians,pakistanians and afgans are the same peoples wiht different borders and lenguages.
Next talkbacks
Back to article