Jewish Scene
Hitler listened to Jewish, Russian composers
Ynet
Published: 07.08.07, 12:28
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
63 Talkbacks for this article
1. Twat
Simon ,   Rishon Lezion   (08.07.07)
So, not just a mass-murdering psychopath and sexual deviant, but a hypocrite to boot.
2. so did ben-gurion,mayer, peretz and homolmert. So what
adolf kastner ,   berlin   (08.07.07)
3. So what - most anti-Jewish fanatics
Canadian Otter   (08.07.07)
also benefit daily and throughout their lives from Jewish contributions to world art, science, technology, medicine, philosophy, etc. Their very lives may be owed to some Jewish medical advancement that allowed their parents or themselves to survive. What an irony. The Nazis despised "Jewish physics", which set them back at first in their pursuit of the atomic bomb.
4. Not just The Music, HITLER LOVED JEWS !
atilla Liman ,   Karagözoğlu   (08.07.07)
Hitler loved Jews in the beginning of his life. than his love turned into sick I believe. anyway ! I have a question ! Do you like Hitler in some way ? I just smell some sickness with all these type news. Love Atilla Liman Karagözoğlu
5. Is hitler a Jew hero ?
Atilla Liman ,   Karagözoğlu   (08.07.07)
you like play, right ? lets play ! I like to listen german and Jewish songs ! But my fovarite one is german ! So, here is the question ! Am I friend of Israel ? Atilla Liman Karagözoğlu
6. Did Hitler ever fall in love with Jewish Lady ?
(08.07.07)
Ynet ! look like you know everything about Hitler ! So, can anyone responce my question, please ? Atilla Liman Karagözoğlu
7. Cant you live without Hitler ?
(08.07.07)
look like you cant. this is not an education. this is just a play ! yes, why not ! you drive me crazy. I dont get the idea of these news. I dont. Atilla Liman Karagözoğlu
8. Tchaikovsky, Borodin, Rachmaninoff not Jewish...
student ,   Israel   (08.07.07)
So, he had one performance by a Jewish violinist in his entire collection? Is this the big deal? Would it even qualify as 'Jewish music'? Tchaikovsky, for example, was well-known for his love of Christmas, using traditional religious themes in many of his works. All three composers were staunch Russians (a nationality not known for a deep love of Jews). It's not as if Hitler sat at home, listening to Mahler - a Jewish composer who used Klezmer themes in his work. That might be something. I don't understand the point of this article.
9. Mind Games !
(08.07.07)
lets brain strom ! how old were you when you were a child ? I was 6 years old. The john F. Kneedy was 3 years old ! and Hitler ! what do you think ? this is a math game ! Atilla Liman Karagözoğlu
10. Agree with Atilla
Aharon   (08.07.07)
Enough with this Hitler obsession. I don't care what music he listened to.
11. Atilla - STFU already!!!!!!!
Andy ,   ramat hasharon   (08.07.07)
12. Dear Ynet, you're allowing Attila to vandalize
(08.07.07)
our Comments page. The man is not well. Please use some discretion.
13. Hitler Also Loved Gefilte Fish + Kreplach
Seth ,   Washington, DC   (08.07.07)
14. #4
Talula ,   Israel   (08.07.07)
First of all, you are the only sick one here. Sometimes you surpass the boundaries of what is acceptable, and today, once again, you surpassed that boundary with your stupid comment. Isn't there some Turkish newspaper there that you can write to and leave us alone with your nonsense?
15. # 5,6 & 7 - not quite done yet
Talula ,   ISRAEL   (08.07.07)
Furthermore, I wonder if the Armenian population will ever forget the millions of Armenians that were massacred by the Turks. See, there are some things that the world should never foget. So shut up already you irritant!
16. Everyone loves Jews - when they are gone
David ,   Zichron Ya'acov   (08.07.07)
Why should Hitler be an exceptions to his fellow countrymen. Everyone loves dead Jews! Even now they have Klezmer festivals, Yiddish weekend courses and kosher restaurants, acribic academical Judaists and seasoned ME experts - and all that without Jews.
17. To #5
Sara ,   Tel-aviv   (08.07.07)
Atilla, who cares?
18. Rachmaninov, Tchaikosvsky, or Borodin jewish???
E.S. ,   Montreal, Canada   (08.07.07)
I thought they were catholic orthodox!! Kind of questions you're finding on the web... Q: Is it true that composer Sergei Rachmaninov refused to play his Third Piano Concerto after hearing it performed by a Jewish pianist? A: In addition to being a brilliant composer, Rachmaninov was a popular performer, and he greatly enjoyed playing his Third Piano Concerto. Then he heard Vladimir Horowitz in concert, performing the same piece. Rachmaninov reportedly felt that Horowitz was so brilliant that his version of the Third Piano Concerto could never be topped - even by the composer himself. So Rachmaninov never played the piece in public again.
19. Hitler, the musical, with fien taste..Oy Veyz meir
Petra ,   USA   (08.07.07)
20. ATTILA
Gilbert ,   Paris   (08.07.07)
Where Attila puts his feet, grass no more grows.
21. Love me tender love me do !
(08.07.07)
Love me Talula love me do :) You are a Lady Eşkiya (gang, mob ) Talula ! #12 and #17 work for you, right :) Atilla Liman Karagözoğlu
22. I am Atilla's fan.
Mr. George Bush ,   The Dark City   (08.07.07)
23. The Strauss composer family were also of Jewish origin
Jake   (08.07.07)
It was a big problem for the Nazis, because the Strauss composers were so popular among Germans, so they 'cooked the books' and created a very well crafted forgery transforming the Strauss family into 'authentic Aryans'. However, since then, the official Strauss heritage research institute in Austria has come across (in the Nazi archives) the original baptismal document of the first Strauss, the Jewish Johann Michael Strauss, when he married his Catholic Austrian wife. The institute's website shows how the Nazi forgery was done. Sick! http://www.johann-strauss.at/wissen/faelschung_e.shtml
24. The man who organized the Luftwaffe was a half-Jew
Jake   (08.07.07)
Erhard Milch. He made the Luftwaffe, and when people started to comment about his Jewish ancestry, his boneheaded boss Goering exclaimed, "I decide who is an Aryan". A forged birth certificate was created, after Milch's German mother was forced to produce a confession that he was born from an incestuous relationship with her own uncle! An even greater irony is that the 'poster-boy' of the Wehrmacht for how a true German soldier should look was the half Jew Werner Goldberg, who had initially been rejected from German public life. Check out this web page about half-Jews in the Reich German military. http://www.kansaspress.ku.edu/righitpix.html
25. Hitler's best musicians
martin Aubut ,   Canada   (08.07.07)
Hitler enjoyed Jew musicians. What a nice gentleman ! Sometimes I feel there are waves of redemption who tend to ennoble the icone of Hitler. For what ? He tried to erase jewish from Europe and tried destroy the western civilisation. At the end, I think the only person he hated was him. If he killed himself the world would probably be very different...
26. To #8
M. Hartley ,   Atlanta, US   (08.07.07)
With all due respect, but that Mahler is tough on the ears, and so difficult to hum :-)
27. To #21
M. Hartley ,   Atlanta, US   (08.07.07)
You have just committed the musical sin of the century: You mixed up Elvis with The Beatles.
28. What a twisted loony he was, eh?
Damir ,   Russia   (08.07.07)
29. Nazi Jews
avi ,   ny   (08.08.07)
Goering and Manstein-Whose real name Lewinski -had Jewish blood
30. Hitler's musical tastes
Martin Aubut ,   canada   (08.08.07)
Thanks for the paper, tonight I'm gonna listen Mahler's symphony #9. Great, I forgot that I have the cd !
Next talkbacks
Back to article