News
Peace Now to IDF: Disclose costs of outpost evacuation
Efrat Weiss
Published: 20.08.07, 11:10
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
11 Talkbacks for this article
1. evacuation costs
chaim ,   p.t. israel   (08.20.07)
if piece now thinks it is too expensive to evacuate - then maybe the answer is simply DONT EVACUATE
2. Why are the setlements illegal?
Keren ,   Israel-SP   (08.20.07)
Was illegal to re-conquer those areas in 1967? Was illegal to give blood for those areas? Why are they illegal now? Why Israel has had to lose so many lives then and now?Why? What is the value of what our brilliant former leaders and pionners fought for?It is worth nothing?It is all doomed to be lost? Are the settlements illegal because now an insane government,who endangers seriously Israel and brings insecurity to its Jews inhabitants,is saying so? Because a government that is supported by less than 10% of the population is saying so? I can say for me:I am feeling very insecure in the hands of the actual government.Very!I am relying only on G'od,and not in the minds that should lead this country to what is supposed to.I fell endangered! And History has proven that yes,this land is ours,but we have to behave properly in order to keep them .I guess,G'od wants us to be here,but through our efforts too,not only His.
3. costs
colin   (08.20.07)
And who caused all these excessive unnessesary costs if not hese same degenerated peace now idiots.
4. The cheapest way
ARyeh Chechanover ,   Netanyah, Israel   (08.20.07)
The ceapest way is not to evacuate them, but simply to remove all military protection and all state funding and leave them on thier own where they choose to be. If they are attacked by Palestinians and cry out for help, THEN the army will come and evacuate them. And if some are killed meanwhile, then we have a few crazy fantcs less in this country, good riddance!
5. Too expensive??
YOEL   (08.20.07)
So it's the best justification for not doing more. Don't evacuate! This is illegal if you consider only Pal's point of view. If you listen to them, Israel is also a catastrophy... Stop with that self-suicide, and don't forget we have to protect our jewish identity . Piss Now should move to gaza, and leave us with peace...
6. Hypocrites
Bill Epstein ,   USA   (08.20.07)
PN Settlement Watch should disclose their UK Taxpayer Cost. http://www.publications.parliament.uk/pa/cm200506/cmhansrd/cm061009/text/61009w0033.htm
7. Peace now to IDF
Adam ,   Lublin Poland   (08.20.07)
to #4 Read the HAMAS chapter: "Palestine" is all Israel. Someday they will want your city and house too and whole goyim world will talk about Jewish Israeli fanatics who stolen the land from poor opressed Palis; think about it, Shalom.
8. a question for Keren #2
laila ,   italy   (08.20.07)
and for anyone willing to answer me: when you say about the need to behave properly in order to keep the land, what do you mean? If something is built without a proper permit and/or is build on privately owned land against its owner's will, how would you call it?
9. Asking wrong question
Thomas ,   Cleveland, USA   (08.20.07)
The question that should really be asked is the disclosure of the amount of money spent on aid for the "Legal" Arab villages in Judea and Samaria as well of the amount of money spent in training Palestinian police. I'm sure the cost is much higher, but then again, those costs have already been disclosed, part of the double standard that is clearly pro-Arab and anti-semetic.
10. When we gain power, Peace Now will be banned for sedition
Feiglin Acvtivist ,   Yerusahlyim   (08.20.07)
11. To Laila #8 in Regards to Keren #2
Hinda ,   San FranFreakshow CA   (08.20.07)
Simply put: Follow the law as set forth... Ancient history can explain this greatly. Perhaps Laila you could read why the Temples were destroyed? Please explain what you meant by "If something is built without a proper permit and/or is build on privately owned land against its owner's will, how would you call it?" There are many illegal dwellings that the Arabs have been building on since "day 1" and the world is silent. Just like when the PA inhabitants (or are they squatters) murder their own children in the name of honor, why is the world so silent? When the PA and their ally Hamass (yes they are indeed allies - or pretty much the same creature) have children shows that depict how to murder innocents, why is the world silent like they were when the PA's heros (the Nazis) were murdering millions of innocents for their belief? Is Silence really so Golden?
Back to article