News
Paramedics attacked in Akko's old city
Ahiya Raved
Published: 20.08.07, 16:57
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
31 Talkbacks for this article
1. Paramedics attacked in Acre
carolyn   (08.20.07)
Sheer stupidity to attack people who are trying to save a person's life. The man probably died because of the attackers delaying the paramedics. I hope they catch those people and throw them in Jail! You don't attack someone who is trying to save a life!
2. Attacks
Ariel ,   Israel   (08.20.07)
Imagine the rage and indignation that would follow had a group of Jews attacked an Arab ambulance and an Arab died due to the attack and delay! Where are the investigations and the jail sentences ?!
3. "...afraid of being stabbed"
Avraham Rottman, M.D ,   Bet Shemesh, Israel   (08.20.07)
I agree with (and understand) what the paramedic said- "it's more difficult to resuscitate someone effectively when you're afraid of being stabbed." That makes sense to me. Who are these people- the're presumably the deceased man's friendly neighbors in the Old City of Acco.
4. Akko
Avraham ,   NYC   (08.20.07)
Arabs in Akko need to be taught a lesson to respect the law. They've grown as percentage of the city's population and with this come hostility towards the Jewish population and other problems.
5. Murder charges should be files against those who
Rivkah   (08.20.07)
obstructed the paramedics which may very well have caused the death of the man who collapsed. this should be established in a court trial. Manslaughter charges at the very least should be filed against the attackers.
6. Don't get it
(08.20.07)
Ok, let's assume they hate Jews. Let's assume that it's even justified. Let's assume they hate specifically paramedics, because paramedics don't treat arabs equally (still assuming). Even if all that was true - how will it help saving the life of one of their own (!), if they attack those evil, racist and hateful paramedics?? I don't get it.
7. This marriage cannot be saved
Robert ,   USA   (08.20.07)
Use the Bush-Olmert-Abbass agrement to determine the fate of this population. With their demographic growth there is nothing but misery and pain ahead for the Jews of Israel
8. #6 - PM Golda Meir explained this situation perfectly
Michael ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (08.20.07)
"There will be peace when Arabs love their children more than they hate the Jews."
9. WGERE DOES IT SAY THEY WERE ARABS?
naro ,   nyc   (08.20.07)
You are all jumping to conclusion, but YNet is not reporting the truth?
10. That's just it #6,
Lindsey ,   Fort Lee U.S.A.   (08.20.07)
nobody gets the arabs because they don't worry about making sense, they only know how to concentrate on violence towards Israelis, no matter what the cost to their own friends and neighbors.
11. to #9 : old Ako is 100% arab... unfortunately!
ezra   (08.20.07)
12. Be clear Ynet!
Bram ,   Netherlands   (08.20.07)
It were Arabs!
13. 1. Murder charge the attackers. 2. Ambulance personnell...
Helene ,   Israel   (08.20.07)
should call police for escort in case of need.
14. #9 interesting point for YNET
David ,   Montreal, Canada   (08.20.07)
Although #9's point is well taken, given the demographics of the old city of Acco, it seems pretty clear who made up the crowd. Nonetheless, the real question is why the word Arab doesn't appear once in the article. Clearly there's interest in this beyond the typical dog bites man story.
15. to david #14 : Just the usual leftist secular YNet Bias
ezra   (08.20.07)
16. *11 is correct.
Helene ,   Israel   (08.20.07)
17. Profiling Might Not Be Wise
Dave Levy ,   Burbank. CA USA   (08.20.07)
Okay, okay, lets get down to where the rubber meets the road. In New York City and other US cities, cabbies were often times attacked while picking up fares in some minority neighborhoods. So, what did THEY DO? They simply refused to go into these areas. Why cannot MDA and other Israeli services just stop answering calls in places like Akko, I ask? Can anyone tell me why anyone should be put in harm's way in order to treat these emergency situations. That's how you send the right message, w/o all this fanfare. As far as describing the criminals who attacked the ambulence personnel, I suppose sometimes it's not smart, other times, it's prudent. In the US, sometimes people are described as black, white or HIspanic. It's accepted. However, Israel's situation is far more volitile and sensitive. It might be better to leave well enough alone.
18. Sooo PC! Ynet can't say the dreaded "A" Word? They're ARABS!
Scott ,   USA   (08.20.07)
19. Hate-blinded mobs don't have compassion on their minds
pox upon them! ,   usa   (08.20.07)
It's hard to concentrate on compassion for a dying man when you are so filled with the rage of intolerance and bigotry. Shameful and unpardonable behavior!
20. Aren't there any arab paramedics in Acco?
Tobias   (08.20.07)
If it is dangerous for jewish paramedics to enter the old city of Acco, isn't it possible to send Arabs to there? Keep always two or more Arab ambulance teams stand-by in Acco, so that they can care about this emergencies.
21. Able to sack houses in Hebron but not defend Parametics?
Steve ,   USA   (08.20.07)
B"H Able to sack houses in Hebron but not defend Parametics? Tens of thousands of riot personell can be brought in to hoist Jews out of a home in Hebron. But here in Acco, where there is a "poor Arab" suffering, no police protection can be provided? There is a lot of force but this force has had its prioties shifted away from defense of citizenry over to destruction and expulsion. For those who criticize Mr. Feiglin for getting 25% of the Likud primary vote to oppose such craziness, rember Mr. Olmert got 20% of the general electorate's vote, and he is sitting in the PM's chair directing these matters.
22. #17 Perhaps MDA is trying to make a political point?
Healthcare worker ,   Israel   (08.20.07)
Or they are just plain Jewish, preserving life is fundamental, and to heck with the rest of the nonsense. Otherwise, it could be viewed as odd that Jews were sent on this particular call - the country is full of competent Arab healthcare providers, and matching a demographic in a political hotbed is not rocket surgery.
23. Damn Settlers!
eliyahu   (08.20.07)
How dare those evil settlers sneak into Akko and attack those paaramedics! It's so typical of them. They hate arabs so much that they stop them from getting proper medical treatment.
24. where was........
yaakov ,   Jerusalem   (08.20.07)
Rabbis for human rights, btselem, piece now? having tea served by their foreign workers! wake up Jews!
25. #20, Red Crescent carries weapons not medical supplies
Mike ,   Atlanta, USA   (08.20.07)
26. paramedics, ambulances, and the like...
jack ,   richmond, va usa   (08.20.07)
Once upon a time, In some neighborhoods in Richmond, ambulances got shot at and robbed. The police fared little better. (They can shoot back.) As a result, all emergency calls were responded to for a while with the fire department along for support. The fire department accompanyed ambulances for a time and the phenomenon vanished. Apparently one of two things occured, 1) people like firemen or at least like to watch them put out fires and so let them do their thing, and 2) perhaps the fire departments' community activity and local nature gained them more respect. The fire department sets up or attends community events in an effort to teach children not to hide from firemen in all their gear. The goal is to teach children to come to the fireman. Anyway, they set up smokey buildings, etc. Perhaps, in the future, the fire department should be sent to accompany the ambulance. Also, the fire departments are more local than other emergency responders.
27. If they don't want MDA, then stop servicing them." B"H
MDA volunteer ,   TA, Israel   (08.21.07)
28. Political correctness in Israel?
Raymond from DC ,   Washington, DC USA   (08.21.07)
In Great Britain, government spokesman were instructed not to use the phrase "Muslim terrorist", even if actions were conducted in the name of Islam. Perpetrators are often referred to as "Asians". Never mind that's a slap at law abiding Chinese or Hindu immigrants. In France, young Arab rioters are referred to as "youths". In Israel, the facts of this case are buried further. But if this is a problem whose name can't be spoken, how can it be dealt with?
29. Too many women judges
Another woman ,   Israel   (08.21.07)
It is sad that I, as another woman, should have to point out that the decline in justice in the justice system is paralleled with the increase of women prosecuters and women judges in the system. The judgements are light and meaningless and political correctness rules. The only justice they seem to want to mete out is on settlers - so obviously the courts are highly politicized.
30. It happens alot, there are many stabbings all over
(08.21.07)
and it depends on the friends of the stabbed guy, if they are drunk or just arsim they will get angry on the team for not making the stabbed ars alive and happy. By the way, ars can be an arab as well as a jew, many of the mentioned situations happen in friday evenings outside the clubs, those not allowed entrance stay outside and make alot of noise.
Next talkbacks
Back to article