Opinion
Gaza kids don't play
Roy Peled
Published: 03.10.07, 14:05
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
34 Talkbacks for this article
1. c'mon, cut the crap
israeli ,   israel   (10.03.07)
just watch Pierre Rehov's The Road to Jenin and the Trojan on youtube, young Palestinian kids speaking freely to the camera about their desire to kill Jews. In Jenin (which was second to Ramallah in income) there was no playground equipment after more than seven years of PA rule. But there were several tons of explosives. When Arafat spoke of the Palestinian womb he didn't mean demographics, he was referring to a production line of killing machines.
2. Truth hurts those Israelis who are occupation zealots
Occupaton Magazine ,   Israel   (10.03.07)
The average Palestinian mother loves her children and wants them to be safe no less and no more than the average Israeli mother. --- Occupation Magazine (Israeli site) Info and action alerts, on a daily basis
3. Usual Meretz
Israel Israeli ,   Sheinkin   (10.03.07)
What is the connection? It is simply Meretz trying to destroy Israel at the behest of its Islamist masters. Nissim Gini was a soldier despite his age. His death was not murder. Israelis did not whine that the British or Arabs who killed him murdered an innocent child. The problem is that the Arab terrorists and their supporters such as Roy Peled want to have it both ways. They indoctrinate Arab children to be racist killing machines, arm them, and send them to confront Israeli soldiers or slaughter Jewish civilians. If the Israelis succeed in stopping these children, the Roy Peled's of the world cry for the murdered innocents. The funny thing is that Roy Peled not once condemned the murderers of the Hatuel family. hypocritical. disgusting.
4. #1, correction
israeli ,   israel   (10.03.07)
I was referring to The Trojan Horse.
5. Gaza Children
gabriel ,   dallas, TX, USA   (10.03.07)
Typical pathetic Meretz b/s. It amazes me how every time a Meretz member writes an article in the press they follow always two rules: 1st, the Palestinians are never guilty. 2nd, Israelis and especially IDF are always guilty. Crawl back to your place and live us alone.
6. The writer...is an idiot
(10.03.07)
meretz or not - go join the Palestinians and be part of their propaganda machine - you are an insult to Israel. I am a mother of 5 children - my children do NOT throw stones and do not learn that death is martyrdom. You are the sorriest excuse for a human being and I'm sorry that YOU don't live in Gaza...please, please do us all a favor and go move there.
7. And this is news because?
Alon ,   Mevasseret   (10.03.07)
Look at the simple statistics - I assume you'll ignore the 10 year old with explosives in his backpack and all the teenagers that have blown themselves up - I mean, the facts might actually make your case harder, right? This article is pathetic and the only thing more pathetic is YNET for publishing it.
8. No ...
charles ,   petach tikva   (10.03.07)
I have heard once a palestinian women telling that she prefered to go to the funeral of her "shahid" son , than to his wedding . When an Israeli is killed by terrorist all the people are crying at his/her funeral . When a palestinian is killed they only shout vengeance . Israeli children are not educated to become suicide bombers , for palestinians it's a daily play . those are only some of the differences between them and us . You have'nt much samples of Israeli chidren used as combattants , maybe this only one . Palestinian children and women are often used as human shields , they do it voluntarely , so they can also be considered as being terrorists . Well you meretz member , with your and your friends writings , you will achieve one great thing , more and more so called "leftists" will distance themselve more from you .
9. Peled is a freakin idiot......
Andy ,   ramat hasharon   (10.03.07)
I am sure Palestinian mothers love their children. But they also speak freely and with dry eyes about how wonderful their martyrdom was in murderous attacks against us.
10. Hellenist!
Hertzel Rahmani ,   United States   (10.03.07)
I think the title says it all!
11. gaza civillians
danny ,   j-m Israel   (10.03.07)
the withdrawal from Gaza was explained to us, that after we are out of Gaza, we can bomb their cities if they bomb ours Meretz voted for the withdrawal. And so it would seem for bombing the cities of Gaza
12. why?
Doug ,   New Orleans, USA   (10.03.07)
Why does ynet even publish this crap? I think it's time to switch to news websites.
13. #2 While that's true, the average Israeli mom doesn't offer
her child up to be ,   used as a human bomb   (10.03.07)
14. Another Kumbaya advocate from Sheinkin.
Ivri   (10.03.07)
15. or a Usefull Idiot !!
(10.03.07)
16. Right ... so do Arabs pity palestinian children ?
Pat ,   Casablanca Morocco   (10.03.07)
Anyone tired of this retarded leftist rhetoric ? Even Arabs countries don't give a damn anymore
17. what a joke
DAVID ,   U.S.A   (10.03.07)
"The IDF of course makes sure that its officers only travel on inter-city roads and far from civilians." What a bunch bull .... Give me a break. let us compare the number of israeli kids killed to that of the palestinians. you use ur F16 on every thing. what a bunch of cowards. The IDF is nothing but a killing machine that only wants to wipe out the palestinians...
18. War is a game of death.
splungy ,   jerusalem   (10.03.07)
Kids don't protect themselves. The bigger the stakes the more fun the game. It's the job of adults in a society to protect their kids.Kids themselves don't know any better. Israel protects its kids. It's a nation that takes care of kids. We even try to take care of Palesinian kids. The Palestinians aren't a nation that takes care of it's kids. They kill their kids and would do the same to our kids if they had the chance.
19. No. 2
NYC Girl   (10.03.07)
First of all, your comment about "occupation zealots" is just a way of demonizing and discrediting those who hold a contrary opinion since there are many Israelis who are no such thing, but disagree vehemently with what you've said. Frankly, you sound as if you're either living in a parallel universe or you haven't read any of the interviews with the mothers of suicide bombers who openly express jubilation over their children becoming "shahids." Even the execrable Suha Arafat was quoted as saying that if she had a son, instead of a daughter, she'd be proud for him to become a martyr. Apparently, she'd forgotten that the Palestinian terror groups are equal opportunity employers these days.
20. #2 and #17...two parrots!
DR ,   Florida, USA   (10.03.07)
All you people do is repeat and echo what the Imams and Mullahs say and It is getting old. The truth is out there. We have all seen it, read it, listened to it.Watch youtube, google Palestinian indoctrination. These kids are born into a culture of hate and violence. and have no chance at a normal life and this is not Israel's fault. palestinians need to take responsibility for how they raise their kids and waht they teach them. People like you definitely don't help them change their evil ways.
21. Well said, Pat
Cameron ,   USA   (10.03.07)
I too have had my bloody fill of the Left.
22. it's too bad...
tom ,   toronto, canada   (10.03.07)
it's too bad that this was written by an israeli and not an arab. "there will only be peace when the arabs learn to love their children more than they hate us." - golda meir
23. Very sad...
Marc ,   Nice, France   (10.03.07)
24. Sad, indeed...
Marc ,   Nice, France   (10.03.07)
We all agree : -Kids should never ever be killed, even at war. Casualties of war are always tragic, especially tragic when kids are concerned, israeli or arabs. -That said, we are all sure of Tsahal 'purity of arms', on one side, and sheer forgery by palestinian media, with of without help of european media. (See Al-Dura controversy) -Hence, we probably all consider this Roy Peled article is very sad, has nothing to do in YnetNews, and is the perfect expression of "loony left" opinion. Put in other terms : Can't agree more with #3, #6, #9, #15 :-) And #17 is the predictable result of Mr.Peled opinion. Kol Hakavod, Roy Peled !
25. article is not well-argued and does not convince the reader
Not convinced ,   USA   (10.03.07)
Claiming that a 10-year-old Israeli kid died because he was deliberately recruited by the IDF does not convince me of anything other than the author's bias. It is an anomaly that is clearly not the usual pattern of behavior for the Israeli army. On the other hand, the so-called Palestinian "resistence fighters" have been consistent in their recruitment of children to help them with whatever the hell they think needs resisting (eg. kindergartners on their way to school in Sderot, people driving along highways, loud-mouthed settlers, etc. ) It is the overall pattern of behavior and what is deemed culturally acceptable that distinguishes the methods used by the fighters. When I read the news, I never read about Israeli kids bringing toy guns and firecrackers to army checkpoints, only Palestinian kids. How does the author justify this discrepancy?
26. Wrong Conclusion
Ed ,   USA   (10.03.07)
Peled makes a point of drawing the wrong from the Gini case: we can infer that the IDF is likely right in saying that children are part of the Palestinian war machine.
27. The truth
Alin Giurca ,   Bucharest,Romania   (10.03.07)
An IDF soldier,father of children, walks a street in patrol.He is seeing some arab children.He is thinking they are only innocent kids,innocent civilians.The next second a bullet is crushing his forehead,a bullet fired from a AK-47 weared by the "innocent" kid.As long as you will continue this stupid politics,you will expect terrorists to have adepts from little kids.Only if you will treat all of them as potential terrorists the killings will stop.The only sollution with the terrorists is what the Mongols did with Baghdad-look back in the history.Fight hard!
28. David
Leah   (10.03.07)
Well David if the Israelis want to "wipe out" the Palestinians they sure haven't done a very good job so far have they? Considering that they have one of the best armies in the world you would think after occupying so called Palestinian land for 40 years that they could have easily accomplished the goal and yet there are still over 2 million Palestinians living in the West Bank and Gaza. Not tio mention close to a million of them living in Israel proper.
29. Farfur the Homicidal Mouse
David Samson ,   Toronto, Canada   (10.03.07)
The Palestinians indoctrinate their children with Farfur the homicidal mouse. They glorify, support and vote for the murder of jews. Their schools teach them Israeli's are a people who ought to be slaughtered, and their mosques incite them to great violence and hatred. When rockets are fired at Israeli school children, the people cheer and the childrens' minds become poisoned and sick. Their is no Israeli Farfur, and if anyone ever tried to produce one it would never be tolerated or see the airwaves. The Israelis mourn death, not glorify it. They seek peace with Arabs, and have met with success in doing so. They build their society and invest in education so their children can have better lives. The fortunes that have been lavished on the Palestinians have produced nothing good, only more armaments to be fired indiscriminately at civilians. There is a world of difference between the children of these societies. It's not the fault of the Palestinian children. But it is a fact and a great tragedy. This sad truth is recognized by many Palestinians themselves though, shamefully, not the author of this article.
30. The Big Difference
David Samson ,   Toronto, Canada   (10.03.07)
Of course Israeli soldiers travel and live in the cities. This hardly makes them the same as the terrorists. The enormous difference, which the author is intellectually incapable of grasping, is that unlike the Palestinian terrorists they don't dress like and hide amongst their civilians as they wage war and fire rockets indiscriminately at civilians. The pals do this knowing full well the Israeli will have to defend herself and that pal children will die in the process. They don't care - dead Palestinian children are good propaganda. When an Israeli, like this author, attacks the IDF as child killers, the wildest propaganda dreams of the terrorists come true. And, of course, this only greatly encourages more attacks by terrorists dressed as civilians, acting from and hiding in civilian populations, and firing against civilians. Good work Roy! This type of article will only encourage more dead children on both sides.
Next talkbacks
Back to article