News
'Time for offense in Gaza'
Yaakov Lappin
Published: 05.09.07, 23:01
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
18 Talkbacks for this article
1. Looking for the Jerusalem and not the Mecca
Steve ,   USA   (09.05.07)
B"H As Mr. Feiglin stated, why fight unless there is the intention to win and settle the place permanently? What is the end-goal of the proposed move? Unless that can be defined, there cannot be success because success is not defined. It is a lack of clear directives that is keeping Hamas going at Sderot. To achieve victory, it has to be defined publically, backed politically, and executed flawlessly. Quote: The conference is a Mecca for many experts the field of counter-terrorism," Shavit said, adding that delegates would be arriving from 50 different countries.
2.  "Mecca" is an ironic metaphor!
Logic ,   Israel   (09.05.07)
"The conference is a Mecca for many experts the field of counter-terrorism." This sentence is fascinating from a linguistic point of view. Mecca, in this context, means the world's leading gathering place on the subject of counter-terrorism. The real Mecca, of course, is the home of the root cause of terror - Wahabbi ideology.
3. It's time to act!
Ram ,   London   (09.05.07)
Get rid of the weak present Israeli government. Shame on them for not doing all to protect their citizens.
4. Elect Shabtai Shavit Prime Minister
Bill Foonman ,   Jacksonville, USA   (09.05.07)
This is what is needed. He can't possibly be worse than the vacillating wimp that is currently the Prime Minister of Israel.
5. Did he really mean it?
Canadian Otter   (09.06.07)
Mr Shavit says that the WB "could never resemble the situation in Gaza, because of the IDF's presence". In other words, things are not so bad because the IDF still retains some control over the WB. Mr Shavit states this at the very moment when the American and Israeli governments are plotting to turn the WB (and eventually Gaza too) into an independent Arab state, which would be even more inaccessible to the IDF than Gaza is today. Israel is - inexplicably - surrendering control over to Iran. Does Shavit disagree with Israel's surrender under the guise of peace talks? There's nothing more explicit said on this report. It would have been interesting to have probed further. Shavit is correct in that Israel should stop its purely defensive stance (not really "defensive", since it's doing absolutely nothing), and use aggressive options. Or perhaps it would be better to simply cut off electricity to start with. Wearing down the Gazan population might be more effective than an IDF attack, which could serve to unite the population under Hamas at a moment when there's great discontent with the regime already. But if there's an IDF reaction, it should be to establish a buffer zone, which should expand each time a rocket is launched against Israel.
6. I am shocked
Alois ,   Texas   (09.06.07)
Why do you publish such a things where it may undermine the future of Olmert and his closest friends?
7. Options
ralphsrant1 ,   USA   (09.06.07)
Cut off Power, Gas make a buffer zone, seal it off three sides so that they deal only with Egypt. Finally invasion if needed.
8. Why not let this experienced gentleman take care o the whole
(09.06.07)
business?!!!!! Who could possibly be better suited? (Olmert?!) "---I can say with certainty that the IDF has a very wide selection of options to activate, enabling it to go from a state of defense to attack, where terrorists will be forced to hide," Shavit declared. Shavit has held an array of key positions during his 32 year-long career in the Mossad. Before that, he served in Israel's elite Sayeret Matkal force.
9. To Hamas. DO You Want To See The WHOLE Of Gaza.
Maansingh ,   The Netherlands   (09.06.07)
Quote :".. funding, guidance, provisions from Hezbollah ". Hamas !!!, do you want to see the same thing that happened with the Hezbollah-neighborhood of Beirut in 2006 ??? DO you want to see the WHOLE of Gaza Strip flattened by the IAF ??? IF you do -- than please continue your association with Hezbollah. IF you do NOT -- than immediately DISCONTINUE your association with Hezbollah.
10. Too Bad Olmert and Barak don't know this.
Esther ,   Ofarim, Israel   (09.06.07)
..
11. Intelligence
edmundo ,   London UK   (09.06.07)
very good, but the curent PM lacks any intelligence - he is a walkign disaster!
12. reply to # 7 & # 9
wAeL ,   Palestine & Kuwait   (09.06.07)
we are muslims & we are proud to be muslims.we are palestinians and we are proud to be so,we are living in GAZA the small and poor land and we are proud to live in it becaus its part of our country that u rapped & took from palestine in 1948 dot act stupid people Sedrot is a colony that rapped our land firing with qassam rockets at a forced colony is not terror ,the terror is what u do and the way u react and strike .dont u feel ashame? u have the most powerfull killing machines in the world and u guys are complaining like little girl from small rockets???? oh opss am sorry i forget that israel lives on petty
13. I agree with everything except:
freejay ,   Israel   (09.06.07)
He said "Fatah are in very direct and open confrontation with Hamas,". Are you serious? Fatah are paying Hamass and thats been proven! This whole split is a set up by Abass and Haniyeh! They are both terrorists and no matter what the stupid media tries tp portrays, they are in the same bed together. There are no moderate Palastinians because there has never been anything moderate about Palastine since its conception. In fact there is no Palastine and this is the stance israel needs to take! Send most of them back to Jordan and Egypt where they came from! If the rest want to be proudly called Israeli, let those ones stay. Enough of this crap!
14. Reply to #12
Mark West ,   Guernevilee, USA   (09.06.07)
Didn't kuwait round you so-called "palestinians" up and throw you the hell out of their country? we need to cut off all water and powerr to gaza - this is a must
15. Time for offensive into Gazza!!!!!!!
Vicky ,   Ashkelon, Israel   (09.06.07)
The headline should read: IT'S ABOUT TIME FOR AN OFFENSIVE INTO GAZZA. Enough is enough already. Sderot and Ashkelon would love 1 nights sleep without keeping an ear open.
16. #12 Terrorism is the organized use of fear as a weapon.Take
away the weapon & ,   the org. falls apart   (09.06.07)
17. palestian interests first Israelis second
zionist forever   (09.06.07)
OIlmert is to busy trying to please his new best friend Abbas than he is the lives of Israelis and if a Gaza operation isnt what Abbas wants then its nnot what Olmert wants and the residetns Sderot as far as he is concerned can rot in hell while he meets with his friends. The rest of the western world is trying to isolate Syria untill it ends terror and breaks ties with Iran but good old Olmert is reaching out a hand to save Assad when everybody else is putting him down. Olmerts ready to give up the Golan on Assads terms instead of saying hey Israel holds all the cards here and Syria has alot of other problems alot more important than the Golan so we play by Israelks rules which means a small portion of the Golan going to Syria as a token gesture but Israel keeps the rest and Syria formerly gives up claims to it and in exchange Israel and the US will have formal peacefull relations with Syria. Assad comes out of it with some financial help to kick start the Syrian economy, he gets a part of the Golan so he still has his victory and nobody would be causing problems for him ion the west .. the US can even get the UN to drop the Rafik Harriri investigation and of course Assad gets the standard nobel peace prize and can go down in the history books as the great man who hellped to bring peace to the Middle East.
18. To wAel #12. You Are A DISGRACE To Islam !!!
Maansingh ,   The Netherlands   (09.07.07)
You write :"we are Muslims ...". You mean you are a Muslim like Osama bin Laden is ?? WELL, Osama doesn't mind killing women and children. And because of THIS mentality -- Osama bin Laden can NOT considered to be a Muslim. And thus -- you are NOT a Muslim, while you claim to be a Muslim. You should be ASHAMED to call yourself a Muslim. People like you are a DISGRACE to the religion called Islam !!! People like you give a BAD name to the religion called Islam !!! You write :"... firing Kassam rockets at Sderot is not terror, ...". THIS reveals that you have an obnoxious, destructive mind. BTW Muslims do NOT have such a mind as yours !!! Your mind is typical of an islamofascist's mind. CONCLUSION : islamofascists SHOULD be eliminated -- wherever they are to be found !!! NO mercy should be shown to islamofascists !!! They ARE the scourge of the earth. The lesser islamofascists we have -- the more PEACEFUL the world will be.
Back to article