Opinion
The Israel liquidation sale
Zalman Shoval
Published: 12.09.07, 07:19
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
48 Talkbacks for this article
1. Zalman, you don't like it? Beat it!
Wissam ,   Occupied Palestine   (09.12.07)
Have you forgotten that Acre, Haifa, Askalan, etc. were all Arab town prior to the ethnic cleansing? What you mentioned as Palestinian "demands" are in fact the minimum traitors like Abbas are willing to swallow and market to our people.
2. 1938 Appeasement and Peace in our Time
ralphsrant1 ,   USA   (09.12.07)
Civil War will come I am sure. Based on these actions someone is getting paid by someone for this deal to sell out Israel. I have no proof but bribery is going on here somewhere. No Israeli would agree to these terms. If this happens then even I will support a Civil War and I am a non religous Jew. Quite frankly I don't even think the Army would support this deal. http://ralphsrant1.blogspot.com/
3. Pray for the people of Israel
SL ,   New York   (09.12.07)
Right-wing theorists and rabbis have warned of the utter capitulation of the secular elite, and now we see evidence that just such capitulation is underway. Driven perhaps by a self-hatred that transcends even the instinct for self-preservation, Israel's secular leaders seem to be bringing the State to the brink of disaster. We need salvation!
4. A hopeless oriental carpet-shop deal.
Isaac Haskiya ,   Kfar Glikson, Israel   (09.12.07)
5. very sad and very true...OLMERT MUST GO...ELECTIONS NOW!
aaron ,   ra'anana   (09.12.07)
6. thank you Mr. Shoval
RobertK ,   Jerusalem   (09.12.07)
for this wise commentary. The Oslo horror continues. Attacks on Israeli civilians and soldiers are treated like bad weather. Oh well, turn up your air conditioners, it's not the government's problem. The government has more important things to do, such as clearance sales to terrorists. Much was made of the "road map" and the fact that Bush put stipulations in it, like the Arabs giving up terror before Israel gives them the Temple Mount and brutally transfers tens of thousands of Jews from their homes. But the PA has remained terrorist and genocidally anti-Semitic through and through--any Israeli who strays into a PA city will be torn to pieces by a mob that will form simultaneously and include regular Palestinian civilians who are not members of terrorist organizations and include both Fatah and Hamas supporters. In this climate, Bush and Rice keep pushing for the formation of yet another Muslim-Arab terrorist-dictatorship on biblical land and Olmert, Livni, Peres, and Barak are dying to go along, to the point of--in classic Oslo fashion--yawning while Israeli civilians and soldiers get bombed. Shana tova!
7. What will Israeli Jews do now? Please tell us.
Tracy W   (09.12.07)
We understand that the Knesset represents a variety of interests, but we barely hear a whimper from the MKs in this regard. Shas is unhappy about losing the Temple Mount but nobody seems distressed enough to do something drastic, like bringing down the government and calling for new elections. Their weak murmurings lead us to think that they are rather amenable to compromise. Some small gesture to save face. I can't read Hebrew so I don't have any way to know what's the mood in Israel. I can only gauge it by the absence of any significant reaction to what Olmert is giving away. We'd appreciate Israelis telling us what they think the population will do when this agreement is officially unveiled. Will there be any reaction in terms of demonstrations? Will there be a demand for a referendum? Anything....?
8. Bait and Switch Sale
ralphsrant1 ,   USA   (09.12.07)
Civil War will come I am sure. Based on these actions someone is getting paid by someone for this deal to sell out Israel. Bribery is going on here somewhere. I have no proof, But no Israeli would agree to these terms. If this happens then even I will support a Civil War and I am a non religous Jew. Quite frankly I don't even think the Army would support this deal. That is my opinion. http://ralphsrant1.blogspot.com/
9. Olmert/Livni/Barak/Lieberman will shrink Israel to size of
RBY ,   Zichron yaakov   (09.12.07)
postage stamp. Then Arabs will declare war on us and thousands of Israelis will die for nothing. Olmert is exchanging Israel for his political ambitions. Why doesn't he go to NY and live with his daughter...he can take his wife with him too.
10. Relax, there can never be any separate Arab political entity
Uzi ,   Haifa   (09.12.07)
west of the Jordan. From time immemorial the Arabs of Western Eretz Yisrael have consistently demonstrated that they are incapable of unaided survival, especially at the national polity level. They constantly kill and steal from each other and lie to themselves, each other and the rest of the world. They never miss any opportunity to make atrocious choices and mistakes and they are incapable of sustaining and providing for themselves; they depend on others for everything. How on earth will they ever make it?
11. Olmert must go now, he is dangerous to our survival.
Avraham ,   Netivot   (09.12.07)
12. There should be an Israeli referendum
Sam ,   Canada   (09.12.07)
I haven't heard mention of holding an Israeli referendum in the event of agreement. It's i portant that Israelis of all political persuasions understand that there is a majority consensus for any deal reached and not that a deal was rammed down their throats by a few politicians.
13. SONS OF ISHMAEL- TAKE IT ALL!!!
al mann ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (09.12.07)
The sons of Abraham, Isaac and Ishmael continue their biblical competition even unto today. Esau married a daughter of Ishmael and so they battle together, Esau and Ishmael, against the sons of Isaac, the children of Jacob, Israel. This fight will go on and on until the alienating and rejecting children of Israel will realize that it exists and has a country of its own after thousands of years of persecution, is only due to the belief in the constitution given at Mount Sinai. Until they finally realize and come to their senses the persecution will continue against the children of Israel. However, they are a stiffnecked people and refuse to see the light. They are all blinded by the so-called progress of the nations. Why should soldiers risk their lives for a people who have forsaken their past and are blind to the future? They have denied their Torah. They have rejected the authority of the One who gave it to the people. YNET has rejected it, The media who violate the Sabbath have denied it. The Children of Israel must get back on track if the wrath of the nations will ever cease. Look at modern Persia (Iran), modern Assyria (Syria), modern Babylonia (Iraq), modern Rome (U.S.A.) and the other nations of Esau all waiting to rid the world of the Children of Israel. We have only one ally but refuse to acknowledge Him. The nations of the world will not give us any rest until we do. They will take Israel away from us because they realize who the authority of the world is. While the Sons of Ishmael yell "ALLAH ACHBAR" we sit back and defy and deny that Allah. So sons of Ishmael it will soon be yours.
14. "TALKING" ABOUT "PRINCIPLES"...........
AVROHOM BILGREI ,   ZION   (09.12.07)
AND THE PRINCIPAL IS A SELF APPOINTED "GRANDfather" , PREDICATED UPON A BASTARD ! THIS SAME "GRANDfather" TO A BASTARD ,JUST A FEW SHORT WEEKS AGO WAS IN A MOTORCADE THAT RAN OVER A TEN YEAR OLD GIRL THAT WAS CHARACTERIZED AS BEING INJURED "MILDLY" WITH AMNESIA,CONCOUSION, FRACTURED PELVIS, IN THE CHILDRENS WARD WITH KIDNEY TRAUMA ! HANAH SOFER'S CONDITION(THE VICTUM) REMAINS UNDER CLOAK TO THIS DAY ! TRY GOOGLING MEDICAL STATUS NORMANCLATURE , MILD OR ANY OTHER TERM ,FORGET ABOUT IT ! THE TERMS ARE ,AS ARBITRARY AND AS ABSURD, AS THE CHARACTERIZATION OF "PRINCIPALS" BY PIMP MASTER(P.M. ?) O----T ! DID I MENTION PUNDIT OF THE SHAME PHILOSOPHY FOR "DODGERS" ? O---T'S TWO SONS , FLED THEIR HOMELAND , WHERE THEIR FATHER/"GRANDfather" TO A BASTARD IS P.M. ! P R I N C I P L E S ? TALK ABOUT THE BASTARDIZATION OF LANGUAGE ! THE REAL OBSCENITY IS THE OCCUPANT OF THE P.M.'S RESIDENCE THAT KISSES ABBAS ON BOTH CHEEKS AS HIS FLAG IS HOISTED UP THE FLAG POLE ! AND THE ANXT OF PUBLISHING A LEXICON CODIFIED WORD "BASTARD" MIGHT BE THE CAUSE OF THESE COMMENT'S BEING REPRESSED ! THERES A REASON I ELECT TO DASH OUT THE NAME OF THE P.M.- IT IS AN AUTHENTIC OBSCENITY !!!
15. Shoval
Jabril Bhat ,   Cairo. Egypt   (09.12.07)
All the Jews must leave Arab Palestine because they are occupiers. There was never a Jewish presence in Palestine. The Europeans gave the Jews the land out guilt for the Holocost.
16. #15
eugene ,   israel   (09.12.07)
the ignorance of history arabs portray daily is quite amazing.. there was ALWAYS a jewish presence in "palestine" during the last ~3000 years.
17. Shoval
Petra ,   USA   (09.12.07)
Sorry old man, there was ALWAYS A Jewish presence in Israel. Lies wont support you so, live with it. Israel will always be your masters. All the promises of Israel are coming to fruition,it must gall your arab arse to witness greatness in the making. Arabs don't want to help the PLO, for good reason. Every dime they get is wasted on arms that only dig your grave deeper. Israel shall prevail, ISRAEL FOREVER!!!
18. #15
yosef ,   tel aviv   (09.12.07)
You are wrong that the Europeans gave the Jews the land out of guilt for the holocaust. The whole world supported revival of the historical Jewish homeland after World War I and gave the British a mandate to help set one up. The British immediately set up an Arab country (Jordan) on most of that land and gave the Golan to the French mandate. In what little land remained, the British encourage Arab immigration and made Jewish immigration difficult. Not one Jew had to be murdered by the Nazis if the British allowed them to go home. The British preferred to prevent Jewish immigration so that the Germans would get rid of them. During the war of Independence in 1948, the British fought alongside the Arabs in the Arab Legion. Sorry for telling you the facts
19. Tracy W. #7: Nothing has changed
Steve   (09.12.07)
It looks like the Jewish masses are once yet again willing to march like sheep into the gas chambers, in a manner of speaking. If this Olmert / Bush plan is consummated, I expect another great Arab invasion, both internal and external. Arab armies will be greatly aided by a well-armed internal Muslim-Arab population, especially in east Jerusalem where Jews will have no protection from the Arab masses. I don't see anything other than a terrible war and many dead Jews as a consequence of this insanity. One day, I expect there will be an internal reckoning amongst Jews and those who betrayed us will be judged accordingly for these terrible crimes.
20. Wait , they never missed an occasion
charles ,   petach tikva   (09.12.07)
to miss a peace . by all faregoing discussions and great Israeli propositions their answer was always NO , or a intifada . Remember only the propositions made by Barak in 2000 , their answer was murder , suicide bombers . This been said , one day we will have to make peace with them . But we can sign accords , for them those are only pieces of paper a year or a month later . Will we have the same peace with them as with Egypt or Jordan , whose populations are against it , and want still to erase Israel from the maps ? Do those people know what peace means ? they only have to go to Western Europe where the greatest enemies , France and Germany , live in peace . There you can see the meaning of this word , but those European countries are not muslim ruled , maybe the difference
21. If this is true...
The Raccoon   (09.12.07)
If this is true, these bastards from the Knesset will swing in the breeze sooner rather than later. Goddamn traitors.
22. Only Israel wins a war, then signs terms of surrender
Raymond from DC ,   Washington, DC USA   (09.12.07)
Thank you, Mr. Ambassador, for stating what is increasingly obvious. Israel acts like its very existence makes them guilty, so it offers up concession after concession to its adversary. That adversary is increasingly convinced that Israel is weak and ready to fall. Rather than obtaining peace, Israel is only inviting greater aggression. Israel's leaders have failed her.
23. To Occupied Palestine:
Mark ,   USA   (09.12.07)
What land is considered "Occupied" and what land is not "Occupied:. That is the real question that needs to be addressed. Is it 1967 borders UN partition plan 1948 borders
24. Olmert
Michael ,   Miami   (09.12.07)
Olmert is doing all that his leftist, self-hating wife, and daughter demand of him. Namely, give away Israel and destroy all pride in being Jewish and a Zionist. He should make every Israeli sick. But I geuss if 40 years of Peres did not make Israelis sick, then Olmert is just fine. Poor Israel, dying ever so slowly by it's own hand.
25. To #1
R.Alkalai ,   USA   (09.12.07)
Joel 3 & 4: 1-3) Now, in those days and at that time when I bring back the captives of Judah and Jerusalem, I will gather all the nations and bring them down to the Valley of Jehoshaphat. I will dispute with them there over My people and My inheritance ─ for scattering Israel among the nations, for dividing My land, and for casting lots over My people. They exchanged a boy for a prostitute. They sold a girl for wine, which they drank. 4-6) And what have you to do with Me, O Tyre, Sidon, and all the districts of Philistia? Are you avenging yourselves against Me? Or if you are initiating aggression against Me, I will very swiftly punish you for what you've done. You took My silver and gold, and carried off My precious treasures to your temples. You sold the children of Judah and Jerusalem to the Greeks in order to distance them from their homeland. But I will rouse them out of the place to which you sold them, and I will punish you in kind...
26. A Disaster in the making
Brod ,   USA   (09.12.07)
Despite the rising tide of global Islamist-Jihadist terrorism crusading their Jihadism, despite 9/11, and despite the atrocities of Wahhabhism and Ayatollahism, why would the West allow itself to be fooled, manipulated and pressured by the Wahhabhiists, who murdered more than 3000 Americans on 9/11, to pressure Israel to give more of its liberated Biblical and Historic homeland to the enemies of humanity? Judea and Samaria are Israel's GOD-given land from the time of their forefathers Abraham, Isaac and Jacob. Israel liberated their historic homeland from the Islamist-Jihadist occupiers in the War of 1967. Is is NONE of the business of other countries to meddle in Israel's internal affairs and pressure Israel to give away its liberated homeland. The fact is since their emergence in the Arabian Desert in the 7th century, the Islamist-Jihadists have been crusading their Jihadism to non-Islamist countries by subduing, dominating and islamizing them. Their goal is the the Islamization of the whole world. Israel is in the frontline of their Jihadism. It is time the West wakes up from their sleep. The atrocities of the Islamist-Jihadists are founded in their religion of crusading their Jihadism or Islamization to the whole world. Israel must not allow itself to be led to the slaughter place as a sacrificial lamb for the corruption, greed and sins of Antisemites and Islamist-Jihadists. Israel can and should say NO to the manipulations and pressures of external elements who want to dismember Israel, and enable the Islamist-Jihadists to usurp Israel's liberated Biblical and Historic homeland of Judea and Samaria including its eternal capital city of Jerusalem. Should Israel choose a path of cowing to these external manipulations, the end result would be disastrous to Israel. The Islamist-Jihadists will continue advancing their Jihadism on Israel until Israel will have no choice but to survive. When that occurs a major war will ignite. Israel should look at the big picture and know the latent evil agenda of the Islamist-Jihadists surrounding its tiny land. Know the GOD of your forefathers Abraham, Isaac and Jacob. He will give you wisdom and protection from the Dark Forces of the world.
27. Out with appeaser Olmert and his stooges
SID EMESS   (09.12.07)
Olmert is not mentally fit to be PM. His ministers are nothing but stooges - all willing to abandon a Jewish homeland in Eretz Yisrael for the sake of the DOLLAR and their own evil inclinations. It is time the country stood up to them - if necessary by closing the country down by a complete General Strike - demonstrations don't seem to penetrate the thick skin appeasers and their ilk -probably suppressed by the corrupt law enforcement agencies composed of goons. Will the Shofar wake them up ??? Perhaps they are too deaf to hear its clarion call or they will not attend Rosh Hashna Services (usual practice)
28. The US goal is to shrink Israel
Mark ,   USA   (09.12.07)
It should be clear that "reducing the size of Israel" was always a goal of the United States since June 1967. It would not surprise me if Bush sells or gives away free faulty military equipment (intentionally broken, missing parts) to Israel and profits from it.
29. What will be the final borders?
Mark ,   usa   (09.12.07)
A watered down Israel similar to Swwitzerland. The new Switzterland of the Mideast. Why do Arabs not demand the UN patition plan? Isn't that the ultimate goal.
30. The people of Israel speak through Olmert
Sidney ,   USA   (09.12.07)
The people of Israel have had a year to get rid of Olmert and his government of whores if they disapprove of his policies. Silence gives assent. Cry the beloved country.
Next talkbacks
Back to article