News
Beirut car bomb kills anti-Syrian lawmaker
Reuters
Published: 19.09.07, 20:40
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
35 Talkbacks for this article
1. Lebanon: the best argument against a one state solution
aaron ,   ra'anana   (09.19.07)
Lebanese Christians are an endangered species...
2. the religion of peace during ramadan...
(09.19.07)
3. #2 , how does anti-Semitism differ from Islamophobia?
HIZBULLAHI ,   SRIFA, SOUTH LEBANON   (09.19.07)
You are an Islamophobe. First, no one knows who killed the MP. Second, the bombing itself is similar to the bombing of the convoy of Elie Hobeika who had just expressed willingness to testify against "Israel" on the Sabra & Shatila massacre. While you air your Islamophobic laundry for all the world to see, we cannot but point fingers at "Israel" and USA, which are desperately trying to give Syria & Iran a bad name, to justify their upcoming war against them.
4. Syria's reply to Israel's strike
russel ,   tlv   (09.19.07)
5. Trying to give Syria and Iran bad names???
GZLives ,   US   (09.19.07)
"we cannot but point fingers at "Israel" and USA, which are desperately trying to give Syria & Iran a bad name" Please do not worry about this as here in the US we all know who and what Hezbollah, Syria and Iran are. Blood thirsty terror organizations two disguised as a State and one that executes children no less. When the planet is rid of the thuggery of Hezbollah we'll all be better off for it.
6. #3..good question!
DR ,   Florida, USA   (09.19.07)
Anti-semitism is based on steroeotypes and mis-education. Do you really think the Jews own the US gov't? Do they own all the wealth? Come on! Islamophobia is based on the fact that Muslims are responsible for 99.999% of the terror in todays world. They riot over cartoons, kill young girls in honor killings, execute people in public by stoning them, blow up markets, crowded streets, and airports with car bombs, kill each other everyday in Iraq...etc etc etc. If you cannot see this distinction, you are blind!!!
7. #2 you are pathetic
Free Lebanese ,   london   (09.19.07)
Do you think that Iran has nothing to do with this, all what has been going on in Lebanon, is to blamed on Iran syria and Hizballah thugs. You days are ending and soon we will wipe you off the map.
8. # 2 not Syria
David ,   Croatia   (09.19.07)
I also think it's not Syria. It would be stupid to think they do that. That would only lead them to catastrophe and that's the point - TO MAKE PEOPLE THINK that as number #2 says. So, my thought falls first on W. Jumblatt. Why? The most loud anti-Syrian and STILL ALIVE. Hear his interviews on al-jazeera. Or is he stupid to believe that or he has something to do that and therefore lies. My second thought falls on Israel: who would like most to have Syria an image of terrorist and assasinations -ordering regime? Divide et impera!
9. When will the Christians start hitting back?
The Doc ,   Haifa, Israel   (09.19.07)
Guerilla warfare goes both ways!
10. This is what the state of Palestine is going to look like
Jake T ,   Alaska   (09.19.07)
Same infighting, same foreign meddling, same sheltering of terror groups. And for those trying to blame Israel, check out http://www.thereligionofpeace.com/ and see for yourself.
11. #5 US Terrorism
JZ ,   USA   (09.19.07)
It is not entirely crazy to state that Western powers may be behind these attacks. The CIA has committed numerous terrorist attacks around the world to put blame on parties they disagree with. For example in 1953 the CIA committed terrorist acts and blamed them on Mossadegh. This was the CIA's attempt to gain popular support for installing a pro-American dictator. The same thing happened in Guatemala, Chile, Cuba (failed attempt), even in Europe (Operation Gladio) and who knows how many others. BTW these are all documented and you can read them on the CIA website in documents that have been declassified, so I'm not just making crap up here. Now, Syria may very well have done this, but I think we should wait for evidence instead of just pointing the finger! I mean the US does have a lot to gain from these attacks. First, it can paint Iran and Syria as aggressive meddlers in the ME. Second, it can increase support for pro-American forces within the government.
12. #9
JZ ,   USA   (09.19.07)
This isn't a Christian vs. Muslim conflict. It is a political conflict. In fact, a Muslim in this current pro-government political force (who is aligned with the member who was just assasinated today), was assasinated a little while back as well. Additionally, there are Maronite Christians aligned with the opposition, who was not alligned with this current Christian MP who was assasinated. So please, do not simplify this complex issue into a battle between Christians and Muslims, because it is not that.
13. Does not add up
(09.19.07)
Why would the US or Israel be involved in killing ANTI-Syrian politicians? Seems to me that if the candidates are against Syrian intervention in Lebanon, then it would be in Israel's interests NOT to kill them.
14. Iran speaks out
(09.19.07)
And here we have Iran saying don't mess with us
15. honest question
israeli   (09.19.07)
why is it that every country with a noticeable muslim population suffers such things on a constant basis?
16. #11 JZ from USA
HIZBULLAHI ,   SRIFA, SOUTH LEBANON   (09.19.07)
I agree with everything you said in comment #11 and #12! Thanks for pointing out the misinformation/propaganda that glosses over historical facts in an attempt to paint certain countries that oppose U.S policies in the region as 'guilty until proven innocent.'
17. #6 DR from Florida
HIZBULLAHI ,   SRIFA, SOUTH LEBANON   (09.19.07)
No I don't think that Jews own the U.S government. I do think that zionists do, and not all (nor most) Jews are zionists, nor are all zionists Jews. Also, from where did you come up with your "99.999%" figure? You say anti-Semitism is based on stereotypes and mis-education and anti-Semites reject this claim, just as you reject the claim that Islamophobia is based on stereotypes and misinformation. So bottom line is: you are an Islamophobe and you seem quite proud of it too. Quit battling semantics. The U.S has killed millions of people. America was founded on ethnic cleansing of indigenous peoples. America wants to boss everyone around, and those who oppose it are labeled as "terrorists." Is the Iraqi army in the U.S, or is the U.S army in Iraq? Is the Afghan army in the U.S, or is the U.S army in Afghanistan? If there is anyone blind here, it is you.
18. conspiracy
(09.19.07)
another Syrian raid, but in Lebanon.
19. #15 - Honest answer: it's an anger management ailment
Dr. Sigmund   (09.19.07)
caused by severe deficiency of peaceful conflict resolution notions. Life-long therapy might help. Hormonal therapy might help too. Those are the less invasive medical approaches and that's as far as I dare to go on these comments. Most societies can deal with a few of these individuals, who we call sociopaths, and turn them over to the justice system. But when you have whole communities suffering from this ailment, then you have a problem, my friend.
20. #15 not honest at all
(09.19.07)
and why it snows in Baalbek where there is a noticeable Siite population?
21. # 15 Answer
Sagi ,   Israel   (09.19.07)
Koran, Mohammad, Allah, Jihad, Fatwa, shahid. Sufficient ?
22. Man, you gotta love Arab politics.
Cameron ,   USA   (09.19.07)
23. #13
JZ ,   USA   (09.19.07)
It's called a false flag opperation and has been done before. Now I'm not saying this is necessarily the truth, but I think it should be given some thought. If the CIA carries out this attack and blames it on Syria or Iran, then they hope to increase anti-Syrian and anti-Iranian sentiment around the world, giving more justification to attacking either Iran or Syria. Also, by killing a few politicians who agree with you you increase support for the movement you support. They would look at it as taking a couple hits to reach the ultimate goal of popular support for a pro-American government in Lebanon. This same tactic has been used before! Now what does Syria have to gain from this? It only makes them look bad around the world and increases support for anti-Syrian politicians in Lebanon. Additionally, it would only serve to add to political instability in Lebanon which could spill over to Syria and ultimately be very bad for the Syrian government. No one knows who committed these acts, so to immediately blame Syria seems a bit hasty. I'm not saying in any way that I think the Syrian government is a good government, far from that it is an oppressive dictatorship, but we must wait for the evidence and stop playing political games.
24. Thank you Syria
Phillipe ,   Tyr, Lebanon   (09.19.07)
Thank you Syria for reminding us Lebanese who the real '' little devil '' is...
25. Olmert: I respect Assad
Ilan ,   Ariel   (09.19.07)
Probably because Olmert wished he had as an effective way of dealing with dissent. Ís Olmert as hateful and evil as Assad or does he only wish to be like the man he so respects?
26. This is the result of no consequences to Hariri's murder.
LEE ,   NY, USA   (09.19.07)
27. GHANEM WAS A HERO TO HIS PEOPLE
HAL TRIPP ,   LA PAZ, BOLIVIA   (09.19.07)
HAVING BEEN THREATENED MANY TIME BY HEZBULLAH AND SYRIAN THUGS MISTER GHANEM NEVER SHOWED WEAKNESS,POLITICS IN LEBANON WAS NEVER A EASY JOB,THE REPORTING OF THIS KILLING IN THE GUARDIAN NEWSPAPER IN ENGLAND WAS PATHETIC,AS SOON AS THIS BRAVE MAN DIED,THE GUARDIAN PAPER BRANDED HIM AS A ISRAELI AGENT,WITH NEWS REPORTING LIKE THIS IN ENGLAND ,THE BRITISH EMPIRE IS DOOMED BY ANTI SEMITIC, ANTI ISRAELI PAPERS LIKE THE GUARDIAN.GOD SAVE YOU
28. #17...you are wrong on so many levels!
DR ,   Florida, USA   (09.19.07)
What other religious group commits act of terro around the world? Jews don't. Christians don't, hindus don't and even if they do , it accounts for a fraction of a percent. The rest goes to Muslims To deny this is to admit that you're an idiot! I work for and with Muslims Doctors here in the US and they will agree with me 100%. Your precious "freedom fighters" of Hezballah, Hamas etc. are nothing but a bunch of brainwashed, evil people. They do not respect life like we do and this is what scares people in the West. Get it? As for the US being a bully, give it a rest. World war2 set the stage for somone to become a superpower and the US was the only country that stood up and took the role. Everyone else either surrendered or did nothing to stop Hitler....so do the math genius. The US will police the world b/c no one else can.
29. JEWS, CHRISTIANS AND MUSLIMS
maroun ,   beirut, lebanon   (09.19.07)
religion and politics kill people. there is absolutely no solution. the more you stupid Jews, Christians and Muslims hang on to your pathetic sorry excuses about religion, the more u'll have to endure this. deal with it, this is like living in the Middle Ages where religion dominates peoples every move...and no one is exempted: JEWS, CHRISTIANS AND MUSLIMS!
30. to all Hizbollah and pro Hizbollah like #8
Gavriel ,   Netherlands   (09.19.07)
Well what a coincident you’re speaking all the same as “Manar TV” and the Syrian Media. Before Syria withdrawal from Lebanon YOU used to put Israel in each and every assassination while your allied who killed Bachir El Gmayel and you all call that person a HERO... "Shartouni " and your allied the Syrian Regime assassinated all Sunnites and Christians But Shiites are out of Range!! (From 1975 till 2007) Strange this Killer always kills People who want democracy... Strange Israel is using all the effort to kill the democracy in Lebanon and SO STRANGE!!! All of them aren’t from your allies all against your ideology! Damn Israel and Al Qaeda I think they are working for Hezbollah to assassinate Politian’s? And the Strangest from this all… those assassinations no one could find who did it… I think Amin Gemayel killed his son & brother and now someone in his Parliment, and Jounblat killed his Father and Saad El Hariri Killed his dad, and Ghassan Toueiny killed his Son Gabriel… (“and you people on all those killings your areas were full of firing with happiness because Israel was assassinating for you so you can get the government) BUNCH OF IDIOTS WHO DIDNT LEARN HOW TO READ ACCEPT ONE VIEW!!
Next talkbacks
Back to article