News
Al-Dura footage to air
Yaakov Lappin
Published: 20.09.07, 18:18
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
66 Talkbacks for this article
1. u trust the french? I DONT
haim ,   mtl canada   (09.20.07)
by the time they had, i am sure they lost it all just watch it . chana tova
2. no matter what you believe about this incident...
mike ,   israel (formerly usa   (09.20.07)
having the truth come out for everyone to see is the best thing that can happen whoever is against seeing what actually happened is against the truth and has evil motives. and i doubt it will be a "blow against the jihad" since the jihad doesn't really need any fuel for it's irrational rage.
3. Footage
Shalom   (09.20.07)
This will never be shown - they will either burn/lose/destroy/edit it.
4. Who trusts Jewish occupation in Palestine? Nobody.
Tony ,   Florida   (09.20.07)
As usual Jewish occupation will blame the victim. We've seen enough of this BS. If Israel didn't occupy Palestine, mideast would've been very calm and peaceful today, and none of those crimes and problems would've occurred.
5. Ooh! Our lefties and machsom witches
Israel   (09.20.07)
won't like this one litlle bit.
6. Tony (Florida): you failed to mention who killed Jesus....
Jony ,   Here and there   (09.20.07)
7. #4 tony, arab's bootlicker...
STEPHANE ,   france   (09.20.07)
don't confuse everything my little tony... i know you love arabs very strong, and i know you're maybe an arab, but don't confuse everything. the only people who are " occupants " in israel are the arabs. they occupy hebron, nablus, sihem, jaffa, galille, all those places are known in the old and in the new testament as jewish cities a long, long, long time ago before islam was born and when arabs were farmer that were traveling all over middle -east. the only people who always remained there, in JUDEA (israel) are the jews. and tell me... the jews are not " occupying " france, india, thaïlland, darfour, so why the arabs do so much troubles their ???
8. The Arab Propaganda Machine at work again
David ,   Karmiel, Israel   (09.20.07)
Halacha demands the humane killing of animals and a kashrut certificate can only be issued if the animals or fowl are healthy. It is forbidden to cause the animal or fowl pain. A chicken that has been waived around and around is bound to have suffered even if it is psychological trauma and would not be suitable for eating under the Jewish Dietary Laws. This is blatant chicken abuse and should be banned as was the force feeding of geese!
9. Not only the French
David ,   Karmiel, Israel   (09.20.07)
The Arabs will stoop to any level to try and blame Israel for everything that plagues this world. They are actually practicing a form of Neo-Nazism. However, don't blame only the French. CNN, SkyNews, the BBC and FoxNews are just as guilty in manipulating reports to suit their Arab patrons. An example of this is that NONE of these channels aired the video of the Iranian Ambassador shaking hands with the Israel Consul in Phuket over the agreement to put their differences aside when it came to the identifying the bodies of the victims of the Phuket air crash. The matter was reported by many newspapers all over the world. Israel MUST improve its propaganda system and an Israeli Multilanguage News Channel is the answer. For some reason, the Foreign Ministry under ministers past and present doesn't seem to realize that no one wants to see or hear about old news. They want it live! Time to wake up!
10. arabs
hanna ,   israel   (09.20.07)
and when the arabs killed shalhevet pass in hebron in her baby carriage did the israelis become " suicide bombers cited the incident as their motivation to carry out a terrorist attack" ? these arabs are a sick warped people that we have no business trying to make peace with.
11. #4
db4objects: Broadens ,   Israel   (09.20.07)
You really believe that we Israelies are the cause of all Middle East problems??? How ignorant can one be! If the Palestinians, God forbid, manage to throw the Jews into the sea (their ultimate goal btw), the Plaestinians would then attack Jordan, take it over and then attack Egypt, take that one over. Then attack Siria, Iraq and make their Palestine empire. Hmmm, I wonder what kind of world that one would be? Who would you blame then #4?
12. I am sure the TV film will be altered before it is released.
ELY GREENHUT ,   Tzfat Israel   (09.20.07)
13. tony you are an idiot nothing more
ari ,   israel   (09.20.07)
14. #8 David
Steven ,   Hoboken, USA   (09.20.07)
Err, ah, David? I think this Tnet Talkback has to do with "Al-Dura footage to air", not animal cruelty. Just a point.....
15. #14 - although an oddly approprite metaphor
(09.20.07)
for how Islamic Extremists use their children...
16. #4
(09.20.07)
if the middle east would have been calm and peaceful without the occupation, then how can you explain the violence against the jewish state in 1947-48 when 7 arab armies staged war against the newly established israel in a massive attack with intention to slaughter and kill every jew in israel. there was no occupation then! if occupation creates problems and vioence in the middle east, then how do you explain the six days war of 1967 when 7 arab armies staged a cohesive attack on israel with again the intention to annihilate the jews and slaughter them....nasser screamed death to israel and we'll drive the jews into the sea. there was no occupation then since both egypt and jordan owned the gaza and west bank territories and none of the palestinians there ever asked for a state of their own and didn't call themselves palestinians then. how do you explain that violence against israel if there was no occupation in 1967? why did they start the war? if the middle east is a mess because israel occupies the territories of gaza and west bank how would you explain the many many death squadrons during the 1920's, 1930's of arabs massacring jews in masses in jerusalem, hebron....ever heard of the hebron massacre? there was no occupation then. how would you explain this violence against the jews in israel? if israel occupation is the cause of all the misery in the middle east, how would you explain shia killing sunis and violence and bombings in the middle east and killings of civilians un mass, arab vs arab, slaughter, bombs, etc.... does israel have to do with anything going on in lebanon?, syria killing 20,000 palestinians opposed to its baath rule?, hussein killing hundreds of thousands of his country men. and the 9/11 jihadi tragedy? very easy to blame the jews for everything isn't it? how would you explain the bombings in spain train station, the bombings in london, the suicide missions in various other countries, the jihadi islamic terrorism around the world claiming hundreds of thousands of innocent people. is that israel's fault too. let's face it. you are an antisemite, not a lover of humanity. the jews are the light unto the nations. they are a peaceful people in israel that are forced on a daily miserable level to deal with animals and maniacs that really do not want their own state. their main agenda is to kill the jews and eliminate israel. let's face it, even if the palestinian state was created today as we speak, it will not stop the terror against israel. and that is the truth.
17. #4
(09.20.07)
mid east peaceful without israel? you moron.... 1. iran iraq war 2. taliban 3. shia killing suni and visa versa 4. war between syria that wants to own lebanon, killing all anti syrian opposition members of government 5. sadaam hussein invading kuwait need i say more??????
18. The DREYFUS AFFAIR of the Third Millenium
Alan ,   SA   (09.20.07)
19. #4 - keep taking the medication !
redmiike ,   tel aviv and london   (09.20.07)
do you have any idea how silly your graffiti makes you look? One liners - 'occupation" and 'Palestine' If you can't do better, then spend time keeping your head down and cleaning the egg off of your face - or perhaps it's bias born of ignorance ?! How embarrassing!
20. #1- Sarkozy is good news and a new broom!
redmiike ,   tel aviv   (09.20.07)
let's give him our support! He's giving us his! Mike
21. To #14 - Ooops wrong TB - Thanks.
David ,   Karmiel, Israel   (09.20.07)
Actually, the chicken thing does fit the French though? Their Rugby symbol is a Rooster!
22. Mohammad Al-Durra
khader herzallah ,   amman-jordan   (09.20.07)
You realize what bad image Israel had as a result of cold blood killing of that innocent child in 2000 by IDF. After seven years you try to erace that by inventing lies to prove that the child was shot by Pals bullet.It took you seven years to fabricate a new story thru fabricated film.You must be ashamed of yourselves,Assume you succeed with your wrong doing,you think the world is blind?they see your killing of the Pals children every day in Gaza and the W,bank with no respect to your agreement with Abbas.Stop fooling the world,your credibility is Zero worldwide,you have to be honest with your people first then the whole world.You are not a country of Saints,you have lot of killers and blood succers.People are not dummys and not blind.Your criminal deeds talk about itsself.
23. Al-Dorra was killed ....
Sameh Ahmed ,   Khan Yunis   (09.20.07)
Al-Dorra killed during buttle between Palestinian boys and youth not armed but Israeli forces were using heavy guns and Apatche fighter.
24. ONLY IN ISRAEL WOULD THEY LET THIS NETWORK FREE ACCESS
HAL TRIPP ,   LUSAKA, ZAMBIA   (09.20.07)
ZIMBABWE HAS KICKED OUT THE BBC 3 YEARS AGO FROM THEIR COUNTRY,THE BBC REPORTER ,TIM FULLUM WAS THE MOST ANTI WESTERN, ANTI SEMITIC REPORTER ON THE BBC STAFF,MISTER MUGABE WAS NOT HAPPY WITH ONE REPORT ON THE USE OF LUXURY CARS FOR THE GOVERNMENT OFFICIALS,SO WHAT HAPPENS HE KICKS BBC OUT TO SOUTH AFRICA,IN ISRAEL THEY TREAT THIS FRENCH GARBAGE LIKE A CELEBIRTY,LETTING HIM GO FROM GAZA TO ISRAEL TO SMEAR ISRAEL OVER AND OVER,IT'S TIME FOR A CHANGE AT THE ISARELI LEADERSHIP,THEY LET THIS FRENCH REPORTER CONTINUE TO SPREAD HATE AND ANTI JEWSIH REPORTS FROM JERUSALEM WITH ISRAEL'S APPROVAL,THE WHOLE SITUATION IS SICKENING
25. Kahder & Sameh (#22, #23) don't like Pallywood exposed.
sk ,   USA   (09.20.07)
What's news here (unbelievable news) is that the French government is finally acting with some integrity on this issue. I guess we have to attributed this to Sarko. Throughout the world, Muslims brutally kill non-Muslims, and they always have when they had the power. What's new in the past 30 or so years is their expertise in manufacturing a pack of lies about their tolerance when their power was great and their victimhood now when their power is small. Islam teaches that Muslims should lie to infidels if it advances jihad. That's what 22 & 23 are doing. Just google "Pallywood" and you will find the excellent documentaries.
26. as a french jew i can testify of the pro arabic propanda
dovdevan ,   ashdod ; israel   (09.20.07)
that is often use in the french media !! everything is done to make you feel that the palestinians are the visticms of the sionism barbary ! the expression , the vocabulary the images let's take an example for the palestinian kassam rocket attack who becomes" a wave of violence between palestinian and israelis" or when israel is attacked on a dayli basis with kassam and israel retaliate the french media give the information only when israel retaliate so that it gives you the feelings that the palestinians are attacked there are many more example of the desinformation in the french media and it would take me very long time to explain it !!
27. Clear who did it
(09.21.07)
The father was beging the killer not to shoot .... sure he was not beging a Palistinian gunman ... what you are trying to hide ... is it the first time that the IDF killing children ... just yesterday a 17 years old boy have been killed by a IDF boldozer .... they teach them in the army that the Arab blood has no prise ... where is the human rights organisations around the world ... or they are made only to serve the super powers in world .
28. to no 22
fish   (09.20.07)
you miss the point - israel demands that the whole tape is shown and investigated, not the doctored parts of it, and the result is published. The fact the France is trying to avoid this smells bad, but not for you obviously... You pals have a tendency to exagerate things, to put it mildly - e.g. say that 500 people were killed in Jenin battle ) Saeb Erekat, and never apologized), Lebanese photographer who doctored his photos and added more smoke, the list can go on forever. You lie and hide, always. In Israel you can't hide much - too much free press, any politicians, president and PM are held accountable. Is your King ever critized on Jordanian TV or some tough questions are asked during interviews with him? Or with Mr Mubarak? And please don't teach us morals, you guys still live in middle ages.
29. That kid is still alive
Barron ,   Israel   (09.21.07)
Only the cameraman had a direct view of the kid & his father. No blood. Nothing! This is a hoax. The perpetrators of this awful fraud will probably find a way to destroy the film before they have to hand it over.
30. #22
Marc ,   France   (09.21.07)
...is not worth a talkback. Just search Google instead (with "khader herzallah") and you'll know how useless it is to explain anything to khader. I'm afraid the only exchange we can have with all kinds of -herzallah's #22 and -Tony's #4 is sheer violence, due to their obvious antisemitic blindness. Sad indeed.
Next talkbacks
Back to article