News
Intellectuals urge Olmert to talk to Hamas
Roee Nahmias
Published: 23.09.07, 17:08
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
39 Talkbacks for this article
31. #20: Negotiating with Cyanide!
Ariel ,   London   (09.23.07)
Negotiating with your enemy certainly has its merits. But has it occurred to you that you can not negotiate with cyanide?
32. Fateh don't want Israel to talk with Hamas
Confused ,   London, UK   (09.23.07)
This petition is a bit contradictory. On the 1 hand, it says Olmert should deal with Fateh & on other hand, it says Olmert should deal with Hamas. But Fateh & Hamas are at daggers drawn & Fateh wants no one to talk with Hamas. So, what to do? How to convince Fateh that talking to Hamas is not undermining its tenous authority?
33. inefectuals-except with their offerings of Jewish blood
Ben Temalion ,   Shiloh, MO USA   (09.23.07)
With their faith in land for a piece of paper, with messianic zeal they destroy the lives of Jews to appease their murderers. If they were humanists they would enforce the right of return of those who came to kill Jews in the the Jewish land, back to their peninsula of their own name.
34. WARNING!!!!
MATTHEW ,   UNITED STATES   (09.23.07)
MASADA2000.ORG
35. #22: Of course it worked
Ariel ,   London   (09.23.07)
All Israel had to do was kiss them and they got Southern Lebanon and Gaza for free. O.K maybe not for free but at least Israel Israel got Rocket loads of Qassam's. For them it certainly does work!
36. Intellectuals
Spencer ,   Israel   (09.23.07)
These "interllectuals" should be transferred to Gaza and the author of #20, instead if sitting on his backside in Germany, should join them. They may have an education but there understanding of the situation is non-existant
37. 29
Igor ,   Munich, Germany   (09.23.07)
How can you be so sure tha Iran is somehow involved in all of this? Don´t you think that HAMAS is funden by Saudi Arabia rather than Iran? There is no clear proof that Iran is anyhow involved in all of this. Ismayil Hanniyeh denied any involvement of Iran (according to an interview with the TV channel Euronews). It´s not Iran that somehow delays the release of the soldier, it´s your government who doesn´t want to recognize Hamas, which actually had been democratically by the Palestinian people. Israel might be unhappy with this outcome, but that´s what the Palestinians wanted and Israel has to negotiate with those who are in office, no matter who they are (terrorists, whatever). They are here and they control the territory and there is no other solution. Talk to those terrorists, recognize their organisation, negotiate with them and maybe they will even recognize Israels right to exist. It´s all a matter of negotiations and the right approach. Israel has been ignoring Hamas since it came to power and didn´t want to hold any negotiations with it. Israel should have recognized the new Palestinian government and negotiate with it instead of ignoring it and isolate it from the whole world. Fatah are the same terrorists and also want the destruction of Israel, but they "officially don´t want it." And your government deals with this terrorists and doesn´t want to deal with the others. But you have to, there is no other choice.
38. #37: You can not be serious!
Ariel ,   London   (09.24.07)
Igor Wrote:....."Talk to those terrorists, recognize their organisation, negotiate with them and maybe they will even recognize Israels right to exist. ..." You require Israel to recognise Hamas and then MAYBE? MAYBE?? MAYBE??? they might recognise Israel's right to exist?
39. They would negotiate with Hitler Also?
ralphsrant1 ,   USA   (09.24.07)
Please don't censor this. They would negotiate with Hitler Also? Hamas and Hitler are the same they want to kill us Jews. http://ralphsrant1.blogspot.com/
Previous talkbacks
Back to article