News
Goldwasser recounts confrontation with Ahmadinejad
Ynet
Published: 26.09.07, 10:53
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
43 Talkbacks for this article
1. Karnit - You are a brave & strong woman
Barron ,   Israel   (09.26.07)
You should know that the people of Israel are with you, even though many in the gov't only seek to appease the enemy and have never seized an opportunity to free all 3 kidnapped soldiers.
2. kol hakavod
(09.26.07)
3. Our prayers are with you and ur husband
eddie ,   london UK   (09.26.07)
4. Next year she will be able to visit him in Guantanamo
Lednah ,   Europe   (09.26.07)
5. well done, brave woman
gerhard ,   munich   (09.26.07)
6. #1
English guy ,   London   (09.26.07)
Now let's see lots of other brave women confronting the people behind their husbands' kidnappings, i.e. thousands of Palestinian, Lebanese and even some Syrian women confronting the Israeli PM with the same question: "where are our husbands?" Indeed, our sympathies are with Mrs Goldwasser, but we need to remember that he was a serving soldier, whereas there are thousands of Palestinians held by the Israeli state. A policy of equivalence would be good. Let's hear Mrs Goldwasser ask for the release of all the Palestinian non-combattants (unlike her combattant husband) who languish in Israeli prisons.
7. The Security Guard...
David ,   Israel   (09.26.07)
From the picture the security guard looked more interested in making sure that she wasn't mobbed than anything. I don't doubt he regretted having to escort her out as a part of his duties.
8. Give her her say!
Kev ,   London   (09.26.07)
These are the people that should have had prime audience with the monster himself. G-d bless you, Karnit.
9. Such admiration for Karnit
meg ,   israel   (09.26.07)
Ehud married a very couragous woman. I am sure that was the person that "smurf" from Iran expected to confront him. He made an ass of himself before and now show cowardice. WTG Karnit, we are with you!
10. 'English guy'
Kev ,   London   (09.26.07)
You liberals have had your day in England. Your revisionist, left wing hippy ideas are history. You and your ilk have destroyed our country, but a time is coming when no one will bother to listen to you ,anymore.
11. #6 You are mistaken
Barron ,   Israel   (09.26.07)
Any Lebanese or Syrians in Israeli jails are not civilians. They are terrorists - enemy combattants. Samir Kuntar, for instance, is a vicious mass murderer, who should never see the light of day. After the war lasy year, Israel sent back to Lebanon several detainees. Those who remained in jail belong there. Their women know exactly why their men are in jail. Bravery does not belong to them.
12. #6 It's OK to kill Jews
Liliane ,   Brighton, UK   (09.26.07)
#6 English Guy: The Palestinian prisoners are "not innocent." Killing Jews is OK. Your comments are a good example of the "new antisemitism" we Jews in Britain are experiencing.
13. A woman of courage deserves much respect.
Vicky ,   Ashkelon Israel   (09.26.07)
But will she be on an honours list at yom hatzmautz. I doubt it. To #6. Yours so called victims are actually prisoners for the murders they have commited too Israelis. Yours so brave tucked up in your little english arab quater.
14. We must take comfort from posters #4 and 6
Saul ,   Barcelona   (09.26.07)
If our enemies are down to scraping the very far depths of ignorance, distorion, half-truths, and inhumanity, we should be proud of the side we are on! A brave woman with a true voice: we are with you, Karnit! Ahmadinejad may swagger with his macho bravado to the cameras and politicians, but he crumbles before the look of your eyes. Ehud will be back!
15. #12 it's not ok to kill Jews
English guy ,   London   (09.26.07)
You wrote 2 ridiculation assertions: a) it's ok to kill Jews b) the Palestinian prisoners are "not innocent" If you could read clearly, you'd note my comparison was between combattants and non-combattants. I believe you will find that a very large percentage of the Palestinians rotting in Israeli jails are political prisoners. So what you are saying is: "it's okay to take Palestinian civilians hostage, but not okay to take Israeli soldiers hostage." Just admit your bigotry and anti-goy feelings, and we'll know where you stand.
16. #13 and English ARab Quarter
English guy ,   London   (09.26.07)
WHere exactly is this little English Arab Quarter that I'm tucked up in? What world do you live in, habibti? Is the little English Arab Quarter like the little Polish Jewish Quarter of Warsaw? i.e. would you like to see it ghettoised and then eliminated? If not, what is your problem with different ethnicities living in the UK? You have different ethnicities in Israel - it's just that we don't demolish their houses or chuck them in prison willy-nilly.
17. did something to his heart ?
Marcel ,   Florida   (09.26.07)
You asssume he is a normal soul with a heart ? Don't you realize you are dealing with evil in it's most diabolical form ? Do you really believe you can reason with ha satan and his followers will come to their senses and accpet Jews and Israel or even listen to your concerns ? I commend your boldness ,something seriously lacking among the leaders of Israel who seem to only know retreat and surrender.
18. #17 The monkey has the same stoney & hate filled heart just
like u. U both have ,   satans heart.   (09.26.07)
19. English guy
Leah   (09.26.07)
Where in the world did you get your information that most of the Palestinian and Lebanese prisoners are innocent civilians? I recently saw a show on Palestinian prisoners in Israeli jails and every single one of them bragged about committing a terrorist act, or at least trying to murder Israeli civilians. I have also read articles on Palestinian prisoners who also admitted to trying to kill Israelis. Not a single one of these people claimed to be innocent. Is that your idea of an "innocent" Palestinian civilian taken hostage? The only one who is the bigot around here is you.
20. #6 Your lynch friends in Ramallah
(09.26.07)
miss you. They know you are a true friend to them.
21. Your answer #16
vicky ,   ashkelon israel   (09.26.07)
First of all the demolishing of houses was a British idea during their empire. Secondly all ethnic's here live and work amongst each other regardless of religion and colour. thirdly, Bradford, Birmingham,Leeds,Southall. Need I go on. You live in England and demand the English live your way. not exactly whilst in Rome do as the Romans do is it. Go smoke your pipe!
22. To: English Guy
y.o west sussex.uk   (09.26.07)
The Palestinians and Lebonese are allowed to see the Red Cross but the Israeli soldiers were not permitted to.
23. #6 you seem to have an answer to everything ,so tell me why
rachel ,   usa   (09.26.07)
they won't let the red cross visit him ?unlike in israeli prisons ,criminals even get to vote and go to school.
24. #15..you just show how paranoid you are
rachel ,   usa   (09.26.07)
you think jews gang up on you because you are not jewish .hahahahahahahah.....you need a shrink .........Now that's anti-semitism!!!!!!
25. #16 wait until you have a suicide bomber near your house
rachel ,   usa   (09.26.07)
you will be singing a different tune ....What makes a conservative?......a liberal that's been mugged .....hahahahahahhahaha
26. THE COMINALITY OF AGENDAS..............
AVROHOM BILGREI ,   ZION   (09.26.07)
FINDS A HOME IN BUSH(ALL QUESTIONS ARE PRESCREENED), SO , IN NOT RESPONDING TO UNFAVORABLE QUESTIONS............. "ignored the question" IN SHARON(ABOUT 12 YRS AGO WHEN I QUESTIONED HIM IN NY) I SAID : WAS KAHNE RIGHT ? IN FRONT OF SCORES OF PEOPLE,HIS RESPONSE WAS THE SAME AS A---------d, "ignored the question". THE "STRIPE" OF THE INDIVIDUAL IS IRRELEVENT WHEN THEY: "ignored the question".
27. #21
English guy ,   London   (09.26.07)
You are dense as they come, luv. I am English so stop lecturing me about "you live in England and demand the English live your way". Do you mean I demand that they should eat mushy peas with their fish? In short, you have dug yourself into a hole of your own pathetic cruddy bigotry. As for all the "ethnics" in Ashkelon working together, you obviously live in a fool's paradise and wear blinkers - Israeli "one of the most ethnically divisive states in the world"... just try being buried in Israel if you don't have the right ethnicity, the right conversion papers, etc. But don't let a little hard reality worry you.
28. Start executing TERRORIST ONE BY ONE untill REASON PREVAILS
Nebojsa Yitzchak M ,   Toronto   (09.26.07)
Killers first, kidnapers second and failed killers afterward.. Without "advertisement" just pass the note to the freaks..
29. English guy
anne ,   israel   (09.26.07)
You didn't answer the question: what innocent prisoner? They all brag how they want to kill Israelis or that they did.
30. #27 I did live in England, I was brought up there
Vicky ,   Ashkelon   (09.26.07)
wWent to school, married, had kids, and NEVER had any trouble until the imigration from the so called Arab refugees, who did nothing but spout their hate. The demanded in one school that all the children learn the koran, protest at having to learn about english and other cultures. Here my kids were taught Arabic, met and played with children from the surrounding villages, Beduin, Druse, Christian. Not once do we demand they pray our way. My grandaughter goes to school in an international school IN ENGLAND, and only had a racial comment from a child from Iran (so called refugee). So who is racist? NOT ME
Next talkbacks
Back to article