News
Abbas: Deal must include withdrawal to '67 borders
Ynetnews
Published: 29.09.07, 17:25
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
58 Talkbacks for this article
1. THEN NO DEAL ! ABBAS THE TERRORIST CHIEF OF FATAH
David ,   Raanana   (09.29.07)
2. YNet, post my own private statement-opinion!
Yochanan ,   YESHA, Land of Jews   (09.29.07)
<<...Abbas: Deal must include withdrawal to '67 borders...>> Abbbas, go to HELL!
3. never will happen
(09.29.07)
israel will never give up east jerusalem to the palestinians. will never allow palis to move into israel except for monetary compensation (and that is after the arab countries cokmpensate the million jews whom they tortured and forc ed out of each arab counties and made into refugees before and immediately after the birth of israel in 1948....this is only just). israel will never accept going to indefensible borders. the connection between gaza and west bank will be a tunnel built under the ground to facilitate trafic movement between the two areas. once thap alis get their own state, israel closes the border. no trade, no water and electricity infrastructure from israel and no relations diplomatic or otherwise....except for a cold one as we have with egypt. then, the palis will have to start working on bulding gyheir country with the help of all the rich arab oil states instead of these states keeping the palis desperate so as to use them to destroy israel. no trade or economic connection whatsoever between israel and the pali state. all the help should come from arabs. in such a state, no military army, navy should ever be encouraged as these people have better things to sopend their money on like their economy and infrastructure. they will not be allowed to arm themselves nor smuggle armaments from syria or iran and this sohuld be watched and monitored. they do not need these things since israel will never invade or threaten this future state. so, defense isn't needed here. however, east jerusalem will never be returned. the palis will have jurisdiction on the arab neighborhoods in east jerusalem, but jews will not be removed from there as they are in the majority living there. the arabs there are in the minority. as to gaza, we left it a long time ago. it's theirs to do whatever they want with it. if the newly formed palestinian state in both parts of west bank and gaza ever attacks israel or sends suicide bombers and terrorists into jewish land, we reserve the right to attack in self defense since they are a nation now, not a terrorist civilian population and they will have to abide by clear and drawn up borders. once they cross, we hold them responsible and will act accordingly.
4. This "peace process" is the biggest sham, as in sham-poo:
Uzi ,   Haifa   (09.29.07)
The Arabs of the Land of Israel consistently demonstrate that they don't want, can't make and won't maintain real peace. They do want, however, to weaken Israel by gaining territory without 'giving' anything tangible. They ignore that "possession is nine tenths of the law" and that it's rather the Arabs who should come forward and spell out what they offer Israel in return for what they want. They also pretend not to get it that in this case "land for peace" is both immoral and unworkable. The Arabs had used the 'territories' to threaten, pester and attack Israel before we took these territories in self defence. They continue to plan, prepare and perpetrate genocide against Israel and pretend not to see that it would be suicidal for Israel to concede anything in response to their threats and aggressive action. The Arabs must realize that the only way toward peace is that rather they themselves should offer, accept and be convincingly satisfied with 'painful' territorial compromises.
5. Why there can never be any separate Arab political entity
Uzi ,   Haifa   (09.29.07)
west of the Jordan? The answer is in some hard facts: The Arabs of Western Eretz Yisrael have consistently demonstrated that they are incapable of surviving unaided or ruling themselves, especially at the national polity level. They have never exercised their inherent right of self determination and now they expect others to determine and create for them that Mickey Mouse "state" which will never be. They constantly kill and steal from each other and lie to themselves, each other and the rest of the world. They never miss any opportunity to make atrocious choices and mistakes and they are incapable of sustaining and providing for themselves; they depend on others for everything. How on earth will they ever make it?
6. The answer is so sipmle. "It's just not gonna happen"!!!!
jan ,   usa   (09.29.07)
7. Not easy to feel upbeat
Canadian Otter   (09.29.07)
Just this morning I read that the Afghanistan President is offering the Taliban seats in his government. After failing to make progress, the Afghan government is giving up. Never mind that more than 70 Canadian men have given up their lives to bring democracy to those people. Regarding Israel, these days all my hopes are for some Arab misstep that will derail this Jewish land giveaway. I don't have hopes for an Israeli uprising against the government, or for the MKs suddenly feeling shame, listening to their consciences and resigning with the purpose of having new elections that will represent the true feelings of the population. In other countries there's always the option that the army will step in to save the nation. But the IDF seems to be headed by Lefties who are more interested in keeping the religious out of the army (with Jewish expulsions in the horizon) than in preparing to face their true enemies. After all, Ashkenazi declared that in his next life he'd rather be a Druze. My hopes have sunk as low as that: just hoping for the usual Arab confusion to save the Jews of Israel. How long will Israel's luck hold? So this is the situation now: back to the 1967 borders minus land for an Arab corridor to divide Israel in two. Thousands of Jewish lives wasted over the years for nothing....
8. Israel - defeated by the peace
Marcel ,   Florida   (09.29.07)
What the Arab armies could not do in five wars they have suceeded in doing by way of a false peace led by a devious and false ally. I don't think Israel would have gone along with the Road Map if it was pushed only by the Europeans. because it has been pushed by a supposed ally ,Israel has been seduced. The terms of surrender are clearly articulated by Abbas with nothing in return for the Israeli foools,not even peace Only demands and lies and that is enought for the faithless,godless Jews to buy. It is worse than Esau giving up his brithright for one warm stew. Esau got something ,however temporary in return for selling his soul. Israel gets nothing but death and destruction for their betrayal of their God.and embracing evil
9. So all the talk is just a waste of time!
redmiike ,   tel aviv and london   (09.29.07)
Mazen's idea of bridging the gap is for Israel to give and for the Palestinians to get. The main problem is Gaza, which needs to be sealed off and made a present of to Egypt. Then Israel can probably work out something with Mazen. I always think of Mazen as being a snake and just recently considered that he's dealing with an even bigger and slimier snake - Olmert!
10. NO DEAL
Juan ,   Spain   (09.29.07)
No point in the upcoming "peace" conference either - waste of time and effort.
11. What is there to discuss?
NYC Girl   (09.29.07)
Why is it that the Palestinians always insist on going into these negotiations as if they've already arrived at the outcome? That's not the way peace negotiations are supposed to work. And, anyway, what are they willing to give up in return besides this ephemeral "peace" that never seems to come?
12. to Mr. NO "#3"
Belal ,   Atlanta USA   (09.29.07)
Mr. No, you come from abroad, occupy some one's land for free then you starting No to this and No to that. the umtlimate arrogance which will only be met with force and resistance and fighting forever and ever and ever.......start counting. who gave you the right in the first place to take peoples property MR THIEF, sorry MR NO
13. Israel says no withdrawal? another 100 yrs of negotiations
neal ,   usa   (09.29.07)
14. ENOUGH! EXPEL THEM ALL ALREADY!
Raanan ,   Ra'anana   (09.29.07)
If they insist on expulsiions as a precondition for peace, then expel THEM.
15. DECONSTRUCTING ISRAEL
DAVID ,   JUDEA   (09.29.07)
Reading the talkbacks one can see that a lot of people do not believe that all this is going to happen. We thought the same about gush katif. Our hedonists that are in the seats of power supported by Ynet and co will go to any length to deconstruct the land. For them there is no reason to be here in the first place. As long as they can pursue their hellenistic lifestyle,they will continue to bow down to lies and deceit,because that is what they bow down too also. Maybey a better solution is just to give the pallies the whole land so we can be ruled by them. Zionists tell the world that we have no claim to the land anyway ,but there are many of us who know better. Right now we are in the hands of these global pagans but they will not sucseed in the long term. Things will get a lot worse before they will get better.
16. #3
Jake T ,   Alaska   (09.29.07)
You write "Israel this and Israel that". Israel is silent. The ones making all the decisions are a small group of corrupt Israeli politicians, and they are making those decisions on behalf of a corrupt foreign power, the USA. That, dear Israeli, is the real problem. If left to the average Israelis, the situation in the country would be VERY different. But your government, including the judiciary, has been taken over by individuals who don't have the interests of the country at heart. Disloyal is the most diplomatic term I can use and still get printed.
17. This is suicidal....ELECTIONS NOW!!
freejay ,   Israel   (09.29.07)
18. NO to pullout!
Brod ,   USA   (09.29.07)
Who is Abbas to tell the Israelis as if they have a right to usurp and occupy Israel's liberated Biblical and Historic Homeland? They are talking as if they are the Super Power of the world. The fact is the Islamist-Jihadists should return to their historic homeland in Southwestern Arabia where they originated in the 7th century. Why would they steal Jewish land? Why would they usurp Israel from the Jews? Israel including its liberated historic land of Judea and Samaria belong to the Jews since 4000 years ago. Israel is the home of JEWS! If the Arab Islamist-Jihadists and all their brainwashed Islamist-Jihadists around the world don't know this, then they must be living in Mars. Abbas has NO right to demand such crap from Israel. In fact, Israel can tell him and all his terrorists to go to HELL!
19. no.
Micha   (09.29.07)
jordan lost the war. address your grievances with them. we will cede nothing. the hate from the arabs is too obvious. you screwed yourself.
20. 16
Igor ,   Munich, Germany   (09.29.07)
righ on! Yóu´re right! " The ones making all the decisions are a small group of corrupt Israeli politicians, and they are making those decisions on behalf of a corrupt foreign power, the USA. " what a pity that only a hadful of people thinks like you. :(
21. HA! HA! HA!
sam ,   jerusalem   (09.29.07)
22. borders
colin ,   israel   (09.29.07)
Abbas lives in a dream world.He demands 67 borders .Is that what he was told at the U N ?? The corrupt olmert will still try to give him his wishes as a character building effort as that olmert is the jews worst enemy.
23. Time to petition!
R.Alkalai ,   USA   (09.29.07)
It's time to de-throne Olmert and cut the power out from under him. It is time to publicly & legally state the rights every of each and Jew in a legal document-letter sent to Bush, Rice, Olmert, the Arabs. Posted this document in public, in the media, and the internet. Organize groups of people to take this legal notice, in petition form, door to door to every Jewish home, in every Jewish neighborhood. Post copies of the petition, and send it to the Israeli government. It should read: The people of Israel hereby state that they do NOT grant President Olmert, or any agent acting under his directive, permission, approval, or any mandate, what so ever, to negotiate, bargain, sell, or transfer any land asset, or landmark of Israel and the Jewish people. The citizens of Israel state herein that any such actions, what so ever, in whole or part, by Olmert, or his agents are directly and explicitly against the will of the Jewish people, and, as such, the citizens of Israel will not agree to, nor comply with any such arrangements, and regard them as legally null and void.
24. Yo "Brod", take a chill pill, have you even been to Israel??
Khalid ,   Gaza City   (09.29.07)
25. Abbas Is, And Will ALWAYS Be Arafat's Protege
Adina Kutnicki ,   US   (09.29.07)
All of Abbas's words won't change a damn thing. He and his people want to destroy Israel, nothing more, nothing less. He understands that if the Pals are to get to their real objective of obliterating Israel, they cannot do so unless they grab what they can NOW. In this regard, having Olmert, Peres, Ramon, Livni, Barak in their assigned places right now is akin to a wet dream. The urgent question is - will the Jews allow Olmert to destroy our homeland, or will they fight this post zionist regime all the way??
26. Withdraw To '67 Borders - Get Over It!
Bill Foonman ,   Jacksonville, USA   (09.29.07)
Abbas is still prattling on about withdrawal to the '67 borders. Give us all a break Mahmoud. It ain't gonna happen so get over it. and work with what you've got before you have even less to work with.
27. Pals dont want Peace so set stupid conditions
Alan ,   SA   (09.29.07)
They know Israel wont withdraw to 67 borders -so excused from peace !
28. Shocking
Ezer ,   Israel   (09.29.07)
Shocking that Olmert is conducting all these negotiations in secret. Why not come out in the open and the people of Israel will tell him where to go. We only hear of bits and pieces, more amd more concessions made by Ramon/Olmert on the part of Israel . What about Abas- no concessions whatsoever. Not even on the right of return.
29. 18
Igor ,   Munich, Germany   (09.29.07)
Right! let´s also give Germany a part of Poland and France back! and lets give Crimea back to Russia! ...and let´s give the western part of Ukraine back to Poland...and hold on, let´s attach Ukraine and Belarus to Russia since it was Russian territory a century ago. dude are you insane? do you want rearrange the territory historically? in that case many people in many countries should be expelled...those Arabs have been living ther for centuries and they didn´t occupy this land,. What about expelling all Albanians from Kosovo, it´s actually Serbian territory? and you´re talking about something 4000 years ago...how redicilous..we must concentrate on current facts and not historical bull...t, go and tell this to the UN....
30. NO SH-T SHERLOCK !
Michael Jackson ,   Yuba City, USA   (09.29.07)
no deals with Holocaust deniers / ishlamic terrorists
Next talkbacks
Back to article