News
Israel officially denies responsibility for death of al-Dura in 2000
Ronny Sofer
Published: 01.10.07, 22:16
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
87 Talkbacks for this article
1. We plan to show the film in court
harry   (10.01.07)
so why did they never show the full film before? why did they never before make a video available to whomever wanted to see it?
2. 7 years, and ilmert STILL won't go after the French ...
sk ,   USA   (10.01.07)
... and "Palestinian" liars, just issue a bland statement.
3. The film is bullshit and everyone knows it..
Evan ,   Israel   (10.01.07)
4. well, well, well....
fish   (10.01.07)
if this is true, and it was staged, israel must sue french tv for provoking war here, and causing colossal human lives loss, incl arabs for who they pretend to care so much. The created a canard, people got killed - don't let them get away with that. Israel must stop being meek.
5. Please take this matter further.Stop blood in matza stories.
Alan ,   SA   (10.01.07)
6. The film looks real, but who shot who?
DR ,   Florida, USA   (10.01.07)
Maybe the film is real and this poor boy was really shot by the Palestinians, who we know, have no regard for other people's lives???
7. Are you sure?
David Shipley ,   Riverdale, USA   (10.01.07)
Hey, I support Israel and all, but I don't think anyone, especially in the government, should jump to any conclusions. If Israel is wrong, it'll be worse than when it showed (totally false) video of UNWRA ambulances transporting Kassams. Cut the amateur hour and save accusations for AFTER the trial! That's it.
8. Not taking retaliatory measures against France 2
Carl ,   Indianapolis, USA   (10.01.07)
leaves the door open for more cases of staged reporting. Why not, if the reporters won't even lose their licenses? Sue the pants off France 2!
9. Fabricated? HA!
Zeal ,   Isramerica   (10.01.07)
"Claim everything. Deny everything. Explain nothing." - Bush Doctrine "Through deceit thou shalt do war" -motto of Mossad. "I was right to shoot 13-year-old child" Israeli soldier who shot Iman al-Hams and was acquitted. "We must use terror, assassination, intimidation, land confiscation and the cutting of all social services to rid the Galilee of its Arab population" David Ben Gurion, 1948 "The thesis that the danger of genocide was hanging over us in June 1967 and that Israel was fighting for its physical existence is only bluff, which was born and developed after the war." Israeli General Matityahu Peled, Ha'aretz, 19 March 1972.
10. Surprise!; just to imply it's the French Prime Minister
(10.01.07)
official document issued by PM? is this the way Israel manages legal issues outside the court? and insisting on not taking it to the court is the fair answer?: ((the GPO director decided that Israel should not take criminal steps against France 2's reporters or revoke the government journalist certificates that were given to them in Jerusalem.))
11. What a horrible situation for all of us
Isragirl   (10.01.07)
Children are killed. Children are killing. Grown ups are lying and betraying the trust of their children. Betraying their children. Read "Mother Courage". It's been almost 100 years since Bertold Brecht wrote that book about the ravages of war, and nothing has changed. Just the weaponry.
12. Another good quote on the subject
Isragirl   (10.01.07)
“We plan to eliminate the state of Israel and establish a purely Palestinian state. We will make life unbearable for Jews by psychological warfare and population explosion. . . . We Palestinians will take over everything, including all of Jerusalem.” Yasser Arafat quotes (Palestinian President of the Palestinian Authority from 1996. Nobel Peace Prize in 1994. 1929-2004)
13. Rahma can easily get a job on the BBC as a producer/director
Alan ,   SA   (10.02.07)
14. #9, you compiling a list of fake quotes?
Danny   (10.02.07)
15. can't decide
lildoobird ,   jerusalem   (10.01.07)
who is more full of s-it! The French or the GPO!
16. #6 - Nobody got shot & nobody died
Barron ,   Israel   (10.02.07)
The whole thing was staged. If the IDF had been shooting in that direction the cameraman would have been shot. To shoot at the kid & his father, the shooter would have had to stand behind the cameraman. Furthermore, there is no blood anywhere. The whole film is a cinematic lie - filmed straight into the "action". This "killing" is an obvious fabrication and real victims, like Daniel Pearl and many Israelis, were murdered because of it. That kid who played in the film is still around.
17. This is a nightmare
Brooke   (10.02.07)
Immoral, treasonous, stupid, ignorant leaders. These are just a few adjectives to describe Israeli leaders and their policies. Why would you not pursue any criminal channels and the revocation of journalists' licenses as a loud warning to anybody who wishes to libel Israel? Why did you allow Peres dismantling of PR ministries to defend Israel's right to defend herself on ALL issues, including the murderous oslo accords?. What is wrong with this insane, corrupt and idiotic people who have no business governing or deciding policy. They ALWAYS decide AGAINST the best interests of Israel. We are not impressed by you ALWAYS taking the other side. This is NOT honorable, wise, impressive behavior. It is traitorous, murderous disgusting policies against your country and you receive NO goodwill from the rest of the world. In fact, you teach the world that Israeli lives are worth less then your enemies. MORONS !!. All of you----GET LOST!!
18. Who can trust France 2?
Suzanne   (10.02.07)
"We plan to show the film in court" doesnt mean anything. How are we sure it is the complete film they will be showing? How will we know if they didnt mess with the images? If everything was so obvious and clear in France 2s statement from the beginning, why didnt they show us the video earlier? Something fishy here!
19. Remember the "doctored" photographs from last summer's war!
Cynic ,   USA   (10.02.07)
20. #17 Brooke - How true!
Canadian Otter   (10.02.07)
You spare no words, and still they are not harsh enough to describe Israeli "leaders".
21. What Israel really complaining about is the media coverage
A Bethlehemite   (10.02.07)
Cause they sure didnt do the same investigations or care so muchf or the 951 kids that died since Sept 2000. Most shot by the idf in the head, neck and chest http://www.rememberthesechildren.org/remember2000.html
22. #21 Bethlehemite
Zeal ,   Isramerica   (10.02.07)
You just beat me to that website! Thanks for sparing me the work!
23. #21 Hey, do you want some cheese to go with that whine???
(10.02.07)
24. Israel killed 1000s of Palestinian kids, occupied Palestine
g ,   usa   (10.02.07)
for decades. Palestinians don't need France 2 to know what Jewish occupation troops are doing to them.
25. Infuriating Israeli Timidity!
Ariel ,   London   (10.02.07)
I almost tore my hair out when I read.... "During the past seven years, Israel has preferred not to confront the most popular television station in France".... I can hardly believe this is happening. This sounds like Jews in years long gone, meekly accepting persecution as a matter of of natural course. What makes this absolutely criminally worse, is that it was a Govt decision. The French TV crew should have their passes revoked, and everyone of them, husbands, wifes Children, Cats and Dogs should be thrown out of Israel!
26. To 18
(10.02.07)
And who can trust Israel , the world trust France 2 much more than Israel .
27. #21
israeli ,   israel   (10.02.07)
951 muhamad al-dura clones, bethlemite. Now Arafat associates are admitting that the Church of Nativity Siege was also staged. In a few days from now we will learn that the beit-hanoun shelling was also "arranged", just as the Gaza beach incident. So there, Bethlemite, would you like some cheese and crackers with that whine?
28. to #20--my fellow Cdn.
Brooke ,   Toronto   (10.02.07)
From one Canadian to another---even we who are so polite and politically correct would never abide this. Read my tb on Martin Sherman's story. I say that it is impossible to consider aiiyah when it is Israeli leaders who are now responsible for the killing and terrorizing of her citizens. I feel like I am peering into an insane asylum--everybody knows it---but won't do anything about it. What do you think accounts for this madness? Thanks
29. False quotes Danny? HA HA!
Zeal ,   Isramerica   (10.02.07)
With you zionists, everything is false. Of course, that means only quotes and events that seem as totally EMBARASSING as being caught on camera killing a twelve year old in the arms of his father, then shooting the father, and killing the driver of the ambulence that came (that, of course, is definitely not the only time Israeli soldiers have fired at or prevented an ambulence from evacuating the wounded in the last seven years). Now, if I were to ask you which of the following two quotes were fake, you'd likely say the latter: "There is no such thing as a Palestinian people... It is not as if we came and threw them out and took their country. They didn't exist." -- Golda Meir, statement to The Sunday Times, 15 June, 1969. "Israel should have exploited the repression of the demonstrations in China, when world attention focused on that country, to carry out mass expulsions among the Arabs of the territories." -- Benyamin Netanyahu, then Israeli Deputy Foreign Minister, former Prime Minister of Israel, speaking to students at Bar Ilan University, from the Israeli journal Hotam, November 24, 1989. Why is this? Because the latter quote is more incriminating whereas the former is just denial that you and most Israelis have. Now if you want a real farce, check out the misquotation of Mr. Ahmadinejad and the whole "Israel wiped off the map" and "incitement of genocide" hysteria out of the quote "The zionist regime that is occupying Jerusalem must vanish from the sands of time"; in this way he was DELIBERATELY misquoted. Such does not compare with quotes such as: "One million Arabs are not worth a Jewish fingernail." Rabbi Yaacov Perrin, Feb. 27, 1994, at Baruch Goldstein's funeral. Or one common slogan: "The dead arab is the good arab"; FREE PALESTINE!
30. Crucial investigation
Fair   (10.02.07)
It is very important that the truth be established, whatever the case may be. However, the information so far provided do not indicate that any new evidence has emerged. Crucial to the investigation was the law wall by which the little boy and his father are seen sheltering, but this was was demolished by the IDF a few days later. A ballistic examination of the bullet impact on this wall would helped to establish which bullets had hit the wall around the boy and his father. Similarly, the father received some 10 bullets and he was treated in an Israeli hospital, where forenside examination of the bullets and shrapnel could have similarly helped to establish from which weapons they had been fired. Unfortunately none of this was done by the Israeli authorities and that crucial evidence was destroyed.
Next talkbacks
Back to article