News
Exclusive: Photos of navy ship hit during war revealed
Hanan Greenberg
Published: 11.10.07, 12:31
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
20 Talkbacks for this article
1. The Hanit "miracles"
Raymond from DC ,   Washington, DC USA   (10.11.07)
Shortly after the attack, a story reported thatt just moments before impact the ship hit a wave that "tilted" the ship. As a result, rather than hitting on the side, where it could have been more deadly, the missile hit topside by the helipad. Another report indicated that the missile struck just feet from ammunition, which failed to explode, and that many who might have ordinarily been topside were instead at a shipwide Shabbat dinner. Yes, it shouldn't have happened, but still it's something to think about.
2. Israel's "victory"
HEZBULLAHI ,   SRIFA, SOUTH LEBANON   (10.11.07)
It's been almost a year and a half since the war, and Israel still cannot show images of the defeat that it s terrorist armed forces suffered at the hands of the Islamic Resistance, while at the same time proudly showing off the destruction of civilian infrastructure as "proof" of its victory. Hope you're enjoying your "victory." Next time we will hit all your ships and your jets. And who knows what else we might hit.
3. Raymond was it also a miracle that it was hit &4 died
Alan ,   SA   (10.11.07)
4. #3 Srifa
Michael ,   USA   (10.11.07)
Wake up you fool. Israel decimated Beirut and can do it again in a heartbeat. Don't think for two seconds you can win a battle with an army that has a thousand times the firepower you do. Bye the way, how is Nasrallah? He doesn't seem to come out much these days...
5. 2 - too bad all you could do was CRY for the war to end
mike ,   israel (formerly usa   (10.11.07)
in last years' war you couldn't stop israel from invading lebanon, you couldn't push israel back one inch, you lost a huge fraction of your fighting force against the IDF, you couldn't stop the air force at all, your leader is still scrambling from hole to hole in fear of his life, most of lebanon hates you worse than they hate israel, all you could do was shoot crude rockets with no precision (which killed a lot of your fellow muslims), your country was crying (literally crying) for the war to stop, the UN even issued a resolution against you AGAIN in order for israel to agree to stop slaughtering your fighters and pounding your cities to dust. i pray that israel will "lose" like that many more times against you brave baloonheads.
6. Photos
Libneniyyeh ,   Canada   (10.11.07)
We saw the ship being hit on the news at exactly the same moment Nasrallah was making a speech. During his speech, he said" "you will see at this very moment the Israeli Hanit naval ship being hit by a missile and go down." And that was what happened. Of course, back in the time of war, Israeli media used to deny all of these reports (no matter that they were seen by the naked eye). The media denied any reports of casualties or defeat as well.
7. #5 Mike...why did you respond to #2 ? :-)
Scott   (10.11.07)
We all know what's coming - they dont. :-) Its almost time for some more "great victories" :-)))!!!!! LOL!!!!
8. Pretty dubious 'victory', Hezbullahi
Cameron ,   USA   (10.11.07)
My primary memory of the episode is of frightened Shiite men & their families running their Islamic fannies just as fast as they could towards Beirut. Is being able to slow the advance of Israeli ground forces what qualifies as an Arab victory these days? You Hezbollah types pulled a very stupid stunt with the Israelis and got the kind of right proper payoff you merited. Congratulations on finally being able to figure out how to use all that wicked infidel technology in order to be able to strike a ship. Yet another thing I've noticed in the time since your pounding is that you've made a real point of not really trying to anger the Israelis with actual attacks. While you may shriek & utter threats like an old woman from a safe distance, you learned yet again that in decisive, head-on match with the Jews, you wind up with the Jews slamming their fist off your Islamic nose. Looking forward to the next lesson that never is learned.
9. NEXT TIME...
mICHA   (10.11.07)
iSRAEL WON'T SHOW RESTRAINT. SEE, MANY HERE WANT MORE DEATH. LEBANESE FROM SRIFA AND CANADA. A REAL SHAME.
10. Israel's so called victory
Chris   (10.11.07)
At the beginning of the war with Hezbollah, an army made up of schoolteachers, Olmert stated that his war aim was the release of Goldwasser and the other one. So those who believe Israel was victorious please explain how Israel can say they won when Goldwasser and the other one are currently guests of Hezbollah in Iran alongside Ron Arad? Israel lost, did you see the much vaunted IDF streaming across the border with tears running down their faces towing their tanks behind them. Bombing innocent civilians into dust does not make a victory. I see Hezbollah are planting flags along the border again, they have more rockets than ever, possibly including ground to air missiles. Roumour has it they have Rapier missile systems brought from Indonesia. And most importantly Hezbollah still have Goldwasser and the other one. Oh and Israel is about to sign a comprehensive peace treaty with the Palestinian people which will see Israel withdraw from the West Bank. Yep some victory
11. Y net exclusives more important than the events themselves!
observer   (10.11.07)
On Monday, journalists toured the agricultural center at the government’s invitation to prove, Mr. Deir Ez ZOR, syria, Oct. 9 -Syria Tells Journalists Israeli Raid Did Not Occur: Mehdi said, that no nuclear weapons program or Israeli attacks occurred there. “The allegations are completely groundless, and I don’t really understand where all this W.M.D. talk came from,” Mr. Mehdi said, referring to weapons of mass destruction. http://www.nytimes.com/2007/10/11/world/middleeast/11syria.html?_r=2&hp&oref=slogin&oref=slogin Israel has been keeping the extent of damage to the warship for 14 months. it seems that Y net exclusives are stronger than the military strikes as it draws more attention than the events themselves!
12. 7 - it just rope-a-dope
mike ,   israel (formerly usa   (10.11.07)
all you have to do with these terrorist guys is to call their so-called manhood and achievements into question, which infuriates them, and they will hurl themselves pellmell into doing something even more stupid to prove you wrong. as a result, they will prove you right better than you ever could try to script it. their perverted "honor" dooms them to being the kind of enemies you could only dream of having, and they are too densely controlled by the fear of what others think, that they might be perceived as weak, to do anything about it. good fun publicly ridiculing these dopes.
13. Nasarallah celebrated too soon!
israeli ,   israel   (10.11.07)
The Hanit didn't fo down, now did it. Nasrallah went down and down he still is, hiding like a rat in a hole under the ground!
14. Mike, you are only too right
Cameron ,   USA   (10.11.07)
Man, if there ever was a culture that needed to lie down on a psychiatrist's couch and begin to start cleaning themselves up, it is surely the Muslim world. There are times viewing that part of the world when it seems like I'm watching a really bad episode of TheThree Stooges in which the boys have completely lost control of themselves.
15. Israel will think twice about using ships to shell civilians
Mr. Knowitall ,   Frostbite Falls, MN   (10.11.07)
Israel would love to prevent the Lebanese militia (Hezbollah) from rearming and upgrading its defensive weapons used to ward off the last Israeli aggression, but like the preceding war, Israel failed. Israel needs to recognize its own irrelevancy in the world and discard the proven falsehood that the IDF or IAF give Israel the ability to march around telling other nations when to jump. Modern hand held weapons in the skilled hands of a few Hezbollah soldiers decimated Israeli tanks and drove Israeli warships from Lebanon's shores, so you can imagine what even more modern weapons will do should Israel get the urge to occupy again
16. telling lies again
Joseph ,   Lebanon   (10.11.07)
french intelligence agency reported at that time that there were more casualties about 30 soldiers were killed & that the rocket hitted the sleeping quartersand reached the bottom of the ship proves this & you forgot to tell that this happened on the 3rd day of the war & after that the israel navy was practically out of the war till the end
17. Hanit was back in operation 3 weeks later
Danny   (10.11.07)
on the 6th august... So much for "serious damage" and the serious "casualties" was 4 people. What a scoop!!
18. #11, so now we DIDN'T raid Syria?
Danny   (10.11.07)
So FM Mu'allem was lying when he was describing the route a month ago. As for the damage: http://www.jpost.com/servlet/Satellite?c=JPArticle&cid=1154525814321&pagename=JPost%2FJPArticle%2FShowFull erm, some basic maths 2007/8/6 is three weeks after 2007/7/14, not 14 months but never mind... We know maths isn't your strong point, nor history nor facts....
19. #5 & OTHER BRAVE DUMBS
(10.11.07)
we have some more little surprises for you & some interesting fireworks that we prepaired for u LOL
20. wishful thinking hanan
jack bauer ,   a rewrite of history   (10.12.07)
quote - "The photos show that the fire that broke out on the Hanit naval ship, left much of it charred, including the command bridge" firstly there is NOT very much damage, at least not what can be seen from the pics. ... much of it charred? are you frigging blind hannan? I thought the command bridge is much farther forward, so how could that all be destroyed? ynet and hannan should get a reality check it was no where near being destroyed, was not near sinking, and for being blindsided by a small missile it came out rather good. The worst thing here was the loss of the sailors.
Back to article