News
6 soldiers suspected of beating Druze comrades
Hanan Greenberg
Published: 20.10.07, 23:01
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
31 Talkbacks for this article
1. Here we go AGAIN
elchonon ,   chevron   (10.20.07)
"The scuffle broke out following an argument over guard duty. Apparently, one of the Druze soldiers was late in replacing one of his comrades and hurled insults at another soldier who confronted him on the matter. " Well thats great, what kind of "insults" did he hurl... Maybe he called them "dirty jew" Maybe they beat him up because they were bored like the druze kids throwing rocks... or the druze arabs rapong jewish girls...
2. Nothing to do with him being a Druze
Golani 13   (10.20.07)
It has happened in my company too when people consistently show up late to replace people on guard duty. And these are Jews. It's annoying as hell to deal with people like that.
3. Strict investigation & discipline required.
Jewish settler ,   Shilo Israel   (10.20.07)
This incident should be carefully investigated and strict justice should be served. Additionally, the media should be careful not to aim for a sensational reporting style. It is an alarming story, more so for the dedicated work that fellow Druze soldiers contribute towards our shared country. Immediate steps should be taken by the government to both defuse actions by renegade leaders (including Druze) that seek to escalate tension, and also to quietly educate our people about the remarkable history and connection between the Jewish & Druze people.
4. if you can't behave, you will get headbutted, minimum
Ran   (10.21.07)
it matters not what race you are, ask not for whom the headbutt tolls, it tolls for thee
5. Appalled
Michael Safyan ,   Pittsburgh, PA, U.S.   (10.21.07)
As a Jewish American, I would like to express my sincerest regrets to and sympathy with the Druze community. The loyalty to Israel demonstrated by the Druze community leaves worldwide Jewry and Israel greatly in their debt. I find this behavior appalling and repugnant, both for its racist nature and because it so wrongly betrays the loyalty demonstrated by the Druze community. I hope that Israel will impose the most severe of penalties on the perpetrators to discourage such behavior in the future. Furthermore, I hope that Israel will more appropriately repay the camaraderie of the Druze community, and that this incident will become a cause for the strengthening of relationships between the Jewish and Druze communities rather than a cause for further discord.
6. disgusting, intolerable. guilty must be punished.
dante ,   uk   (10.21.07)
7. if the stuped druze people they will ever be equel
israeli ,   reality land   (10.21.07)
then they are in lala land , they are no better than the ethiopians in the eyes of jews if not worst .......
8. #1 Filthy disgusting slander
Aharon   (10.21.07)
The Druze are more loyal and important tot his country than your dear settler movement/ How shameful that you make such revolting false accusations about them.
9. Once again Israelis need a dictionary
Avi ,   nyc   (10.21.07)
Druze a semitic people. Jews a semitic people. Both of the same racial stock. Please get your terminology down or consult a quality dictionary.
10. Congrats YNET! Good as US press at playing RACE CARD!
Stewart ,   USA   (10.21.07)
11. #3 TELL THAT TO #1
David ,   Los Angeles   (10.21.07)
12. #1 YOU LEAVE NO DOUBT ABOUT YOURSELF
David ,   Los Angeles   (10.21.07)
Maybe there's a legitimate question about what sort of insults were hurled, and what sort of racism they constituted, if any. However, there's no question about you: Your comments reveal that you are a disgusting racist yourself. But then that's no surprise, given who and what you are.
13. # 1
Sagi ,   Israel   (10.21.07)
You are a very sick person. The Druze are kind and gentle people with respect for others not like you and the other black coated lunatics. You should be ashamed of yourself for what you have just said. I hope these disgusting "Jewish soldiers" go to jail for what they did and you should join them for what you said. Many Druze have laid down their lives for you and your ilk, you sad piece of humanity.
14. thanks again ynet for writing this crap
jack bauer   (10.21.07)
discipline the guys that beat him up, and discipline him for being late to guard duty both sides were wrong and ynet is wrong for trying to make jews look bad every single day by all means report wrongdoing.... but this is neither news or a reasonable title, once again
15. "Soldiers"
Michael ,   Tel Aviv   (10.21.07)
Yet another item of "mud clear" reporting!! the article says "soldiers" & "racist". Israeli soldiers yes, where is it specified JEWISH! we all know the greater percentage of the Russian immigration isn't Jewish! Perhaps some of his comrades were Druze? As much as it not the correct thing to do, bash up people for being late! However with current level of ethical and moral standards taught and achieved in our education system, what other primeval reaction would you expect from youth trained to "tough"! Please let all the half truths here be sorted out by the Army Judiscial system.! May Justice not only be done , but seen to be done! May we one day be privileged to have accurate and objestive reporting one day, SOON.
16. So he's a racist. I'm also and so is YNet. So what?
Edward   (10.21.07)
Is there a law in the Torah against racism? Am I doing anything wrong if I don't like Arabs? Are YNet and other liberal leftists doing anything wrong if they don't like Jews, especially relgiious Jews and stick up for Arabs?
17. #9 what is the difference between Jews & Druze
(10.21.07)
Jews were born Jews, that's they have the birthright. Druze were created Druze, that's they have creation-right. Jews are the pedigree copies, but Druze are the original original.
18. Where was their discipline???
Chaya ,   Bat Yam, Israel   (10.21.07)
Even if the Druze soldiers had said something insulting (which I am not excusing!), the other soldiers should have shown more discipline and simply reported the breach of rules to their commanding officer. This 'taking the law into their own hands' is unacceptable!
19. HOPEFULLY
DAVID ,   JUDEA   (10.21.07)
Ynet will in the near future cease to publish its English webpage. Ynet's biased and unprofessional reporting has been a embarrassment for a long time now, without any hope of improvement. So hopefully we can look forward to their demise soon.
20. This is disgusting!
Israel   (10.21.07)
Thank god these vile disgusting soldiers are a minority and do not represent the IDF.
21. #18 taking the law into their own feet
(10.21.07)
how could the soldiers kick a person who fell to the ground in the neck, back, stomach, hips? unless, the soldiers couldn't recognize their fore-limbs from the hind ones
22. To any Druze
Sagi ,   Israel   (10.21.07)
who reads this or hears about this, I apologize. To the Druze community in general, I also apologize. Let it be known that I have the utmost respect for the Druze who have obligated themselves to serve their country with loyalty and often do so with outstanding bravery. As much as I have respect for them, I have contempt for those who do not serve their country, especially those represented by # 1.
23. Its Only Rascists When Its Israel vs. Israel
Dale James ,   Neptune, USA   (10.21.07)
if a bloodthirsty "pal" arabian attacks a Jew its usually due to nationalistic purposes right? ynet / haaretz ???
24. What?
Eduardo ,   Croatia   (10.21.07)
Are you kidding? Druz soliders are the only ones in IDF that know how to fight and you treat them this way? Its crazy
25. We have enough enemies as it is .....
vicky ,   Ashkelon Israel   (10.21.07)
without starting on our own Druse population who have supported us throughout. We have enough problems, jail these purpetraitors, along with anyone that does the same thing to any soldier regardless of creed. Whats up with our boys today? Where is your patriatism? Where is your pride?
26. laughable sad jewish apologists..
elchonon ,   chevron   (10.21.07)
Lets see...#8.. how many settlers were caught selling weapons to terrorists to kill jews? #12 whered you get that crazy idea from? I never hurt a fly.. I merely brought up a point that everyone rushes to scream "racist" when no one knows the background... Its sad and disgusting how everyone rushes to apologize when we jews are accused... I did not say I support beating up druze.. I never said druze are unpatriotic.. though there have been cases of druze selling weapons which I oly brought up due to #8 laughable accusations. This is yet again vindication proving yet again that you folks are the racist.. as you jump up like crazy calling ME a racist no matter what I say. But the fact that I live in hebron clearly makes me some sort of wild crazy racist does it not? your assumption of such makes you a racist.
27. As a final note..
elchonon ,   chevron   (10.21.07)
I only brought up comment #1 as a showing that if Israeli's beat a druze up it must be racism.. but if druze throw rocks at passes they are merely bored... That hypocrysy is astounding.. the same way every time a jew gets beaten in new york by a black it must be a simple mugging.. how can a black be racist? Maybe hitler and the SS were just bored so they butcherd 6 million jews y'know... nothing racist there... When the arabs destroy the jewish cemetary here (once a week) you think they get charged with racism? puleeeez just more bored arab kids!
28. # 26 # 27
Sagi ,   Israel   (10.21.07)
When did Druze throw rocks and at whom ? When did Druze rape(rapong) Jewish girls."Druze Arabs'. No Sir, Druze are not Arabs and they resent being called as such. Have you ever seen a mosque in a Druze town or village ? The answer is no. You will see mosques in a mixed town or village but not in an exclusive one. The Druze religion is not an offshoot or sect of Islam.
29. Elchonon yes you are a racist
David ,   Los Angeles   (10.22.07)
1. You show your utter stupidity again and again. Who said Hitler wasn't a racist? Who said a black person can't be a racist? Buddy, if your propaganda is to be more effective than diarrhea , at least it needs to make sense. 2. Who said it was Jewish soldiers who beat up the Druze soldier and used racial epithets? You have jumped to a conclusion here, and used it to justify your own racist outbursts. 3. Your garbage about Druze raping Jewish girls sounds EXACTLY like what Jews were accused of in Medieval Poland. 4. And as I recall, it's only extreme Rightist among Israeli Jews who have murdered other Jews. And only you folks who try to injure IDF soldiers with paint thinner. Who teach your children it's OK to lie. etc etc. So don't lecture others about patriotism. 5. You've done a pretty good job of reinforcing the opinion of everyone here that living in Hebron does indeed seem to mean you're a crazy racist, yes.
30. #16
Daniel ,   New York   (10.22.07)
So I guess according to you, it's OK to be racist against Jews?
Next talkbacks
Back to article