News
Special: Video of Rabin's murder as never seen before
Ynet, Yedioth Ahronoth
Published: 24.10.07, 09:27
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
56 Talkbacks for this article
1. here comes the flood of TBs claiming 'Doctored . .
Justice   (10.24.07)
clip'! Those who would release the killer be cursed!
2. Doctored video
Shalom   (10.24.07)
new technology my foot!!! Where's the call "Blanks" that was heard? There is much hidden in this video. There are many question I would like to ask certain people in high places.
3. NOT doctored
Aharon   (10.24.07)
Amir was the murderer, but some so-called "Rightists" (the ones who visit this site) simply can't accept the fact that religious Jews can be brutal murderers too.
4. Proves Amir is Innocent
dave ,   phila pa   (10.24.07)
Rabin's spine was blown away. But he continues walking, turns around, and remains standing. After being hit with dum dums. Impossible.
5. security guards so far away
chava ,   yerushalayim   (10.24.07)
Whenever I've seen people in high positions with security guards, the security guards were closer to the person. They surrounded him. These guards weren't doing their job very well.
6. It is a bit of exaggeration to say ...
Terry ,   Eilat, Israel   (10.24.07)
That three bullets changed history. Is the implication that had Rabin lived, we would be living in the peaceful paradise promised by left-wing delusional thinkers? Does anyone seriously believe that peace was around the corner after Oslo? Arafat never wanted peace. With Rabin or without Rabin, we were headed towards an intensified conflict, as we are today. In effect, Oslo created the conditions for conflict, just as this present "peace process" is creating the seeds of a new conflict. The historical change that occured was the adoption by a large portion of our politicians of a failed policy of appeasement that is reaching it's end soon. The soon-to-fail conference at Annapolis & the resulting renewal of intensified conflict will signal an end to appeasement. Watch & see.
7. liars
yosef ,   tel aviv   (10.24.07)
This video was changed from the original one - The originial shows shimon peres looking into rabin's car before he walked by. Amir was also a go0d 3 feet away from him.
8. technology at it's greatest...
josh ,   haifa   (10.24.07)
Amir's gun didn't even have real bullets in it. What a crime how they framed him.
9. Anyone claiming that video is not authentic
Talula ,   Israel   (10.24.07)
is a sick brainless should-be-sharing-a-cell-with-Amir evil bastard.
10. Dave - no he doesn't, watch carefully - he looks as he falls
(10.24.07)
11. yosef - wrong - Peres does look in as he walks by
(10.24.07)
Watch again - from the angle it's taken from...
12. YNET ! THE VIDEO NOT WORKING HERE
(10.24.07)
Atilla Karagözoğlu
13. blank shot !!!
avi   (10.24.07)
I can say 2 things re that video: 1.the cameraman knew what is happening ... how ??? 2.Rabin did not know and after the shots, he is alive and well. G.od bless !!
14. Remind me never to hire this security
Josh   (10.24.07)
...company. For minutes, the security never looked anywhere but forward. Yeheeyeh beseder at its best. By the book! We dont need no stinkin book!
15. Could be anybody in the picture...
Josh   (10.24.07)
...the quality is too bad to tell who the inidvidual is and there is no camera covering the book depository or the grassy knoll.
16. #13 Typical gun shot victim behavior
Josh   (10.24.07)
...It is not uncommon for an individual being shot to not feel pain at the moment they are shot. Only the loud bang startles him and he searches for the source before he realizes he has a problem. I was an inner-city fire fighter and have seen people chatting away as if nothing is wrong while part of their body is severely injured.
17. #0: No exxageration at all..
abdullah ,   ashkenaz   (10.24.07)
It marked the beginning of the end of secular zionism, and the ascendancy of 'religious' zionism.
18. Terry/Eilat
EM ,   Ra'anana   (10.24.07)
The only delusion is your concept of left wing ideology. No one assumed "paradise" after Oslo. Just looking for a peace process as a pragmatic necessity for our society. What is your alternative?
19. rabins role in hate industry
baruch ,   ramat gan   (10.24.07)
this film raises more questions then answers about yigals role in the murder. But what bothers me more is the leftist industry in craeting and keeping alive hate against their way of life.
20. Ynet has a lot to learn about CSI...
Al   (10.24.07)
This video is a joke..No where do I see Rabin falling on the ground after being shot in the back as per the two flashes of fire.I counted two not three. Point being Rabin is dead as are all those 1500 others who were suckered into believing fairytales. Tell the people in Sederot about the wonderful benefits of a Judenrein Gaza. Keep on this death march and in due time you will be history. What part of that do you not understand? I guess all of it.
21. 7. Here's the original u saw before - Yosef, it's the same!
Justice   (10.24.07)
http://www.liveleak.com/player.swf?token=c53ae25e6a
22. Any ceremonies for Altalena mass murder by Rabin ??????
Lo nislach   (10.24.07)
23. Attila ...
avi   (10.24.07)
look at it here: http://www.yigalamir.com/kempler_video.htm
24. Experts
EM ,   Ra'anana   (10.24.07)
I am amazed by the "experts" using this video clip to prove Amir's innocence. Dave - when did you get your medical degree? Don't any of you on the lunatic fringe even realize the contradiction? On the one hand you applaud the assasination for bringing about the demise of the peace process, and admire the murderer for his heinous act.. yet on the other hand you try to exonerate him. For what? Is he your hero or not? Did he do it or not?. Why did he admit killing Rabin..?
25. Atilla - it is you who is 'not working'. You joker!
The Anti-Atilla ,   Coolsville   (10.24.07)
Ever think that it's a local problem with your connection speed/machine? Idiot.
26. Shooting
Simon ,   C.Town, South Africa   (10.24.07)
The video quality is shocking ! One cannot make out who the shooter is. One must be able to view the original recorded tape. The cameraman seems to be panning around too much as if he knew what was going to transpire.
27. I hope the killer never gets out of jail and that his
Rivkah   (10.24.07)
wife dies in child birth and the child is cursed, too. The sins of the fathers are visited on the children to the third and fourth generation of those who hate God, the Bible says. Why did he conceive a child who could only be cursed and hated?
28. #18 - EM in Ra'anana - Pragmatic?
Terry ,   Eilat, Israel   (10.24.07)
What an odd choice of words. Can you tell me what was "pragmatic" about Oslo? It was based on false assumptions & the fact that it totally failed is proof that the assumptions were false. Who in their right mind could have believed that bringing a terrorist from Tunis & all of his corrupt & incompetent cronies in crime would be a "pragmatic" move towards peace? Arafat & his Fatah movement were on their deathbed, totally irrelevent & we resurrected them. How pragmatic is the idea of a Palestinian state - do you seriously believe it won't be a failed terrorist state endangering our security? And the strangest assumption is that the Palestinians, Arabs, & Muslims generally, are willing to accept the idea of a Jewish state anywhere on what they consider "Muslim" land. Even the Israeli Arabs who have lived in a Jewish state for 60 years don't support it's continued existence. What is the alternative? Sometimes reality does not offer any good options. That's life. All our options are bad. But the peace process has ended up being our worst option. This conflict does not have a political solution - there is only a military solution as much as we might wish otherwise.
29. No-one is condoning murder
Shalom   (10.24.07)
The point here is not "right-wing" or "left wing". The fact is that the wrong guy is accused. He really wanted to murder Rabin - and that is a horrendous thing for any Jew to do. The difficulty here though is that he was just set up to think he murdered Rabin. My guess is that he was supposed to do it, but "someone high up" got scared that he would miss his mark, so that put blanks in his gun, and did it themselves.
30. Rivka
EM ,   Ra'anana   (10.24.07)
As much as I deplored the murder of Rabin...I deplore your curse. How absolutely evil of you to wish death upon Larissa and to curse the child. Shame on you!
Next talkbacks
Back to article