News
Special: Video of Rabin's murder as never seen before
Ynet, Yedioth Ahronoth
Published: 24.10.07, 09:27
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
56 Talkbacks for this article
31. Enough Conspiracy
EM ,   Ra'anana   (10.24.07)
The cameraman 'panned around'...because he was not a good one. He even lost his steady hand after the shots were fired. Insinuating that he 'knew too much' instead of his just happening to catch the infamous assasination on tape is like accusing the French film crew who happened to catch the first plane slamming into the World Trade Center on 9/11.
32. One day the Truth will come out
Simcha ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (10.24.07)
Why did they tell Leah Rabin not to worry that it was only blanks????? Why did it take them so long to arrive at the hospital???? What was 'the vulture' Peres waiting around for????
33. Not Odd
EM ,   Ra'anana   (10.24.07)
Oslo was a practical attempt to find a solution.
34. Even Arutz7 is mocking the conspiracy nuts:
eli ,   haifa   (10.24.07)
http://www.israelnationalnews.com/Blogs/Blog.aspx/1#2358
35. Unity
Sam ,   Canada   (10.24.07)
In times past, Rabin, Peres or Barak would not have been able to reach agreement with the Palestinians on borders, Jerusalem or refugees. Amir and those like him became hysterical at the idea of biblical territorial concessions. The same mentality exists today so a referendum of the people should be announced in the event of an agreement. If it is clear that Palestinian demands are too great or that they cannot stop violence then Jews should go ahead and freely settle all of the West Bank. In this way neither the right nor the left should feel cheated.
36. SKILLED PHOTOGRAPHY!!!
al mann ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (10.24.07)
Is it not interesting that the one who made this video was there when all of this happened. What was he doing on the roof? Why did the picture drop to the roof floor when certain things happened? Was it all coincidental? Was the photographer on the roof totally by accident? H,m-m-m-m-m-m-m.
37. #28: There isn't even a military solution...
abdullah ,   ashkenaz   (10.24.07)
If there is no political solution to the conflict. Then that will be the end of secular (pragmatic) zionism. 'Religious' zioinists are going to be in charge of the state of isreal very soon. And thus the 'solution' to the conflict will mostly be influenced by them. Since they're observant jews, the chances are their ulitmate solution will be torah-based.
38. 36 - mann, are you off your face?
Hardy Har Har ,   Jamaica   (10.24.07)
Um maybe he was there recording a BIG EVENT? I mean what kind of fiend films topical public occasions like Peace Rallies? And yes, why did the camera film the ground after recording THE PRIME-MINISTER BEING SHOT!? Isn’t the sinister cameraman capable of super-human, machine-like instincts? Really al, when did you fire up your last doobie?
39. 30 EM: There are some people's seed that should be cut off.
Rivkah   (10.24.07)
I have seen the seed of families cut off for far less offenses than murder. In a generation or two, there were no more children of entire families who upset the Lord. The murder of Rabin should have been punished with the death of the shooter, not conjugal visits with an obviously crazy woman to produce more monsters.
40. The other side of the story
Meir ,   Arad   (10.24.07)
The evidence shows that the shot that killed Rabin was at close range and from the front. Amir was convicted for a crime he did not commit and should be released from jail. The real murderer is still free. http://www.tisanim.com/Web/Sites/hadar/PAGE17.asp
41. Prime time, 5th column jewish terrorism
Rami ,   Nazareth, Israel   (10.24.07)
42. Video
Naomi ,   Catalonia   (10.24.07)
Is true, yosef.
43. WHAT THE HELL IS NEW ?
AVROHOM BILGREI ,   ZION   (10.24.07)
I'VE SEEN THIS BEFORE ATLEAST MANY MONTHS AGO-THERE'S NOTHING NEW , IMPROVED OR EVIDENT THAT I CAN SEE-HOW STUPID DO THEY THINK WE ARE ? DID I MISS SOMTHING ?
44. how precisely did this change history?
david ,   new york   (10.24.07)
it didn't stop the oslo nightmare. all it did was make rabin a "martyr". the damage he did to israel was already done by the time he was killed.
45. Thought so (see TB1)
Justice   (10.24.07)
46. to # 21 Justice. The orgnal u r showing was also doctored
Norman   (10.24.07)
47. AVROHOM BILGREI
You missed something ,   alright   (10.24.07)
Yeah dummy, it's slowed down to almost frame by frame -where did you see the clip running so slow for carful scrutiny - piror to this?? NOWHERE!
48. to 46: Well Norman,
Justice   (10.24.07)
Yosef seems to think that this latest version was the doctored version of the one he (we all) first saw (because the narration in the original describes Peres checking inside Rabin's car - and this clip has no narration - big deal). But you guys just seem to claim ANYTHING that shows evidence of the beloved killer Yigal Amir . . . is doctored. That is sick and disgusting to no end!
49. My hatred
A ,   TX/Israel   (10.24.07)
My hatred for the ultra right wing shows no limits. You are destroying my country with your extremism. Rabin was the man to bring us to a new world. One where we could raise our children without looking over our shoulders. But the ultra right wingers in Israel seem to love war more than they love their children. Just like the Palestinians.
50. so, what does this prove? not much.
dante ,   uk   (10.24.07)
51. There are still serious unanswered questions:
Rafael   (10.25.07)
1) Why did the Coroner's official report claim that Rabin was fatally shot from the front, not in his back? 2) Why hasn't the entire video by Roni Kempler ever been released, instead of just edited segments lasting only seconds? 3) Why hasn't there ever been a real investigation by an independent commission of the security failures of Rabin's body-guards, instead of merely the investigation then-Premier Shimon Peres ordered the Shin Bet to conduct of itself? 4) Why did one of Rabin's body-guards immediately yell out the shots fired by Amir were just "blanks"? 5) Why is the video produced here on YNET "enhanced" to simulate muzzle-flashes that did not exist on the original segment of video?
52. Rabin's murder ? Who behind?
S ,   Italy   (10.25.07)
Why the man who had to cover behind Rabin let so many space in which Amir entered and fired? What did the man on the let (white jacket) of Rabin tell to the men before ? Why ,after this argue, these man behind Rabin walk slowing and so Amir could enter in this space? .......only incapacity ....?
53. Fake job
Joe ,   LA, California, USA   (10.25.07)
The video is fake. Very poor scripting by a nonprofessional. Why to post such a bad job in place of the original video? I am an expert and made more than 50 movies.
54. Hey Joe - are you really a movie maker?
ROID   (10.25.07)
So how come you cannot work out that IT IS THE ORIGINAL - SLOWED DOWN!!! (It is even mentioned in the article...) What a turkey you are!
55. See the SHIN man (white jacket) on the let of Rabin !!
S. ,   Italy   (10.26.07)
What did he tell to another SHIN man behind Rabin ? Before the attack, this latter wolk slowing so there is enough space in which Amir can enter.... Only a coincidence ??? and why the guard of Perez are so clore their man ?? only more professional ??
56. proves conspiracy
Barry Chamish ,   Florida, USA   (10.28.07)
Read Shamgar. Amir shoots Rabin in the back from 50 cm. A hiatus. Bodyguard Yoram Rubin falls on Rabin. As they are prone on the asphalt, Amir shoots again and hits Rubin in the shoulder. Rubin testified to Shamgar and at the Amir trial that he felt electricity racing down his arm. Then Amir shoots Rabin from ABOVE in his waist from 40 cm. So where is Rubin in this film? Why did he lie to Shamgar? If Rabin's spine has been shattered why does he turn his head and keep walking? This film blows the truth out if you know what lies the government sold us. In short, we saw three blank bulllets and no Rubin.
Previous talkbacks
Back to article