News
Israeli killed in West Bank terror attack
Efrat Weiss
Published: 20.11.07, 07:08
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
55 Talkbacks for this article
1. Give these Peace-Lovers a state with Jerusalem its capital.
Dov   (11.19.07)
2. Israeli, not settler
jewish mother ,   jerusalem   (11.20.07)
Why the change of definition? You normally call Israeli's from the West Bank "settlers". To most of us, he is simply another Jewish victim of our blood thirsty neighbors. Will they still release more prisoners who have carried out similar attacks. Baruch dayan HaEmes.
3. Targeting Civilians
Mark ,   South Africa   (11.20.07)
So its ok for Palestinians to murder Jewish civilians, but run to U.N. the moment one of theirs is killed by the IDF, even if by mistake. Its time Israel took its gloves off & to hell with world opinion.All Palestinians should be considered potential murderers-- Period.
4. You see....You cant trust muslims!
God ,   USA,Israel   (11.20.07)
Need more prooves? It is now...wait if you will give them more land of Israel! Dont u understand that you can;t trust muslims?
5. Close off Westbank for Anapls just like for High Holidays
Alan ,   SA   (11.20.07)
6. Readying ourselves for the post -Annapolis reaction
YMBMY ,   Modiin, Israel   (11.20.07)
I thought this was only supposed to happen if Annapolis fails !?! Another death that Yariv Oppenheimer and his ilk will not lose sleep for.
7. Olmert/Rabin/Sharon/Peres ~ : "Sacrifices for Peace"
David ,   Har Nof   (11.20.07)
GET OF YOU ARSE AND BRING DOWN THIS GOVERNMENT. WHAT ARE YOU WAITING FOR - SOMEONE CLOSE TO YOU TO BE HURT OR WORSE KILLED WE ARE ALL BROTHERS AND SISTERS - Family - Start Acting Like It and Help Us Destroy This Evil Government - A government that gives money/arms and prisoners to our enemies - for what - DEATH
8. Give them an Israeli driving license, as well
AK   (11.20.07)
They are just like all peace loving mothers and fathers around the world who are misunderstood by 'wicked racists, like me. Dafer, if you're lurking around, take credit for this 'peaceful act,' buddy. I have no doubt that you'll find a way to blame it on the Israelis.
9. Open them All, and Open them NOW
Mr. Knowitall ,   Frostbite Fall, MN   (11.20.07)
Israel's occupation and attempted annexation of East Jerusalem has never been recognized by any country or the UN, so Israel is not giving back or conceding anything, it is just abiding by UNSCR 242 which states clearly that the acquisition of land by war, such as Israel's occupations of the Golan, WB, Gaza and East Jerusalem are illegal and not allowed and that Israel must withdraw from those areas. The transfer of parts of Israel's civilian population onto land it held under belligerent occupation is also illegal under the IV Geneva Convention, so returning their occupation settlers to Israel proper is also not a concession, and no different than recalling any other portion of Israel's occupation army. So Israel is not making concessions to the Palestinians any more than when the cops drag the thief out of your home, the thief is making concessions by leaving your house and giving back your belongings to you. Yeah, I've heard all the hogwash about how 4 bazillion years ago an all powerful deity gave Jews the land, but that is simply a religious belief and certainly does not constitute a legal claim unless said deity can appear in court. But then if that were true, why has the deity not aided Israel one bit, but instead seems to be helping the indigenous Palestinians gain their freedom from Israeli oppression.
10. #5, CLOSE OFF ANNOPOLIS..NOT THE WESTBANK !!!
OLMERT GET OUT ,   ..............DACON9   (11.20.07)
11. Throw them all out..
Arthur ,   SF, CA   (11.20.07)
Level the village 'Funduk'.. The sooner - the better. Kahane was right!
12. They're thugs...
Micha   (11.20.07)
the community in the WB and gaza are mainly thugs...this is the mentality..they need to be eliminated.. There is no justification for the murder of innocent Jews.
13. and this is why
(11.20.07)
checkpoints dismantling, walls coming down, freedom to terrorists in israeli jails will not work! there will be thousands like this poor man, god forbid.
14. good result
dd ,   ny, ny   (11.20.07)
I think that the poor Jew Hy'd fell the victim to the "good" desire to strengthen Abbas 1. the hundreds of former terrorists who were included into amnesty to strengthen him 2. hundreds who were released from jail. 3. the checkpoints that were removed to say yes sir to US 4.promising them everything and more if they behave, like Jerusalem 5. cancelling the "good neighbour" policy used in arrests 6. providing support and training to Abass' forces (who invariably turn around and kill us later) At this point the man's blood is boiling at what was done to him. another "victim of peace". We are all victims. Shalom u'vracha
15. isn't the group the one Rice invited to US
alan ,   Kiku Island   (11.20.07)
These are the same bed fellows of the fatah that is going to be negotiating in America with the fool Olmert
16. 34 Palestinians murderred in November
Salameh ,   Gaza, Palestine   (11.20.07)
So spare me the BS
17. Settlers = squatters...most true Israeli's...
Elokim ,   Israel   (11.20.07)
As most settlers are not considered true Israelis and most law abiding Israelis don't support what the settlers do to inflict harm upon themselves and Israelis in general. This looks like there is a deeper story here. This "Israeli" (as they would like to state now) may have done something to cause his own demise. First off...he was in the West Bank!!! Well that alone caused his own death... and thus if he'd thought about it, it would have saved his life...if he wasn't on the land of Israelis enemy!!!! duuuuhh In this case we have a murder not a terrorist attack!!! NO ONE IN THIS REGION CAN BE TRUSTED!!! NO ONE #4!!!!
18. THE MODERATE FATAH TAKES RESPONSIBILITY?!
mike ,   TA   (11.20.07)
This can't be right...I thought Fatah were the good guys led by Abbas? I guess I can't believe what CNN tells me anymore...or Pres Bush and Secty Rice either for that matter...
19. #3.... he is considered as an illegal resident!
Jerusalem ,   Jerusalemite   (11.20.07)
20. Round them up and blow them with dynamite
Johnny ,   Stockholm Sweden   (11.20.07)
People doing things like this deserve nothing else.
21. Thank you hell achshav
mira   (11.20.07)
Now run to your friends the poor palestinians, but STAY THERE with them where your (non-existent jewish) heart is.
22. I am confused !
Yisrael ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (11.20.07)
OK, so Fatah, the military wing of our Peace Partner kills one of our citizens as a gesture to Olmert, and we reciprocate by releasing some of his colleagues. But soon we will be doing even more for our good buddies ! I wonder what they will do for us ? I'm sure this makes sense, but I just can't see it. Please explain !
23. please remember
dafer ,   international jerusa   (11.20.07)
that not all palestinians are terrorists , and if israel ( the all mighty israel ) cannot catch those terorists , how can we catch them ? i asssure you though , the majorety of the palestinians will turn them in and will wish for there execution m if we will be able to identify them . the only solution availeble is to give a strong backing to PA and not turn your back on them , and not to allow your kahana's to control you , may god bless the murdered israeli's soul , and the perpetraters stand to face justice
24. #3 mark , please stay in south africa where you belong
dafer ,   jerusalem   (11.20.07)
with your apparthied ideas.....
25. 9 Mr. Knowitall. What are you views on the Palestinian
freedom ,   canada   (11.20.07)
annexation of the city of Bethlehem.?
26. 16 Does that number include those that
freedom ,   canada   (11.20.07)
were killed in Fatah to Hamas violence. What a joke. Youd be better off being an Egyptian in what Gaza should really be, Egyptian territory.
27. Give them water, electricity, food, medical
(11.20.07)
assistance, technology, know-how. Free their criminals and extend your hand in peace and we will all get in return more killings, more destruction, more Quassams, more hatred, more suicide bombers, more determination for destruction. Is it worth the pain and trouble ?
28. As if these filthy cowardly terrorists
Sara   (11.20.07)
need a ShmAnapolis as an excuse. Why do we always flatter them? Their guiding lights, hell achshav, does that well enough all by themselves.
29. #24 dafer. please leave israel.where YOU dont belong..
ari ,   israel   (11.20.07)
30. Sad but he had no business being there
Sam   (11.20.07)
The West Bank is not an Israeli territory. The setters are trespassers that have no business being on that land.
Next talkbacks
Back to article