News
Israeli killed in West Bank terror attack
Efrat Weiss
Published: 20.11.07, 07:08
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
55 Talkbacks for this article
31. #3 targeted killing of armed settler;
(11.20.07)
selective, reciprocal & proportionate. in line with the rules put by Israel itself.
32. result of giving in to terrorists demands
eliezer ,   jerusalem   (11.20.07)
the more we give in to terrorists demands the bolder they become. Like a shark that smells blood, the terrorists take hark from the release of their friends to be re awakened from their depression. My the good G-d avenge the innocent blood that was spilt.
33. NO. 9 Fool
Mark ,   South Africa   (11.20.07)
Mr. Kowitall, given your address, i presume you most likely another American hypocritical idiot. Let me suggest that before you comment on who owns Jewish lands in Israel, you leave occupied American soil that you stole from the Red Indians, slaughtering millions in the process of stealing their lands & " Give America back to the people it legitimately belongs to". You hypocritical idiot.
34. FATAH took "credit" for this atrocity
Mamalama ,   Israel   (11.20.07)
Olmert, Livni, Barak - Do you really think that FATAH is any different from HAMAS? They're all thugs and genocidal killers soaked through with the blood of the Jews they murdered and plan to murder. Stop the Annapolis charade now!
35. Organize public protests before Annapolis
Outraged Citizen ,   Israel   (11.20.07)
We MUST get out there to protest before the next war against Israel begins. The Palithugs, Syrians, Hizbonazis and Iranians have been preparing for years.
36. murder needs to turn himself in - in time to be released
by ehud olmert   (11.20.07)
37. when Hamas takes over the west bank, the game will be up
aaron ,   ra'anana   (11.20.07)
38. He is a settler.
AAQ ,   MENA   (11.20.07)
39. A Man of God, A Man of Love
ys ,   Israel   (11.20.07)
A pillar of the community, a father, a son, a grandson , a mench, a Chassid - lost to all of Israel today.
40. Such a lovely family. There is so much sorrow for Jews.
Rivkah   (11.20.07)
Whenever Jews are in Arab areas of Israel, they should shake the dust from their shoes for all the evil the Jews have suffered. Rabbi Yeshua says it will be better for Sodom and Gomorrah than for that place in the day of judgment when his people shake the dust from their shoes in a place. There are bottles in heaven, the Psalms say, where the tears of God's beloved people are collected for later vengeance. Vengeance is mine, the Lord says, He will repay.
41. Correct choice of Government
Iuseff Abu-Kalba   (11.20.07)
Good all my village people voted Olmert during the elections. We are free to do as we wish .........
42. the title is correct
(11.20.07)
armed settler's transgression is terror act, whether he is Israeli or not, Jew or not.
43. round and round
Invicta ,   europa   (11.20.07)
How many Palestinians have been killed by Israelis recently? Anyone want to hazard a guess? Then we can start a talk back about innocent Palestinians being murdered by Israeli bullets
44. Fewer Roadblocks = Jews Murdered
Dr. David ,   Netanya, Israel   (11.20.07)
Is it coincidental that an Israeli citizen was killed in a drive-by shooting just after over 20 roadblocks were removed? Olmert should sit shiva with his family instead of going to Annapolis to give away our country.
45. A murdered motorist
umm Danny ,   Israel   (11.20.07)
All the hypocritical comments about murder victim Ido Zoldan, ignore the fact that he could just have easily been an Arab traveller. Labelling him a "settler" does not make this vile act heroic or justified.
46. TO #17 GEHONIM
DAVID ,   JUDEA   (11.20.07)
Reading your TB which is sick making, you are right about one thing. You show by your lack of compassion that there are israelis and that are there jews. Now if you are going to mention law abiding israelis, I have not met many of them including your true israeli leaders who are compromised of thiefs,sexual predators and so on. We can all see how well your law and justice system works. Second of all they are israeli laws, not jewish laws. In many ways you do not even deserve a reaction ,but I understand by your mentioning that that you are a true israeli why so many people hate us and want to destroy us. I have to say us because in the end that is how we are perceived by the outside world. If you represent the new age humanistic democratic israeli, then I am afraid we are on borrowed time here.
47. Death of Father
Rod ,   Fargo N.Dakota   (11.20.07)
You in the Israeli media dehumanize these residents of Ye'Sha you call them settlers i'm sure some these Israeli's living in Yehuda and Shomron died fighting for in IDF as a matter of fact when i read the names of those killed in the Lebanon war i saw many from Ye'Sha .What were they then members of 'settler army or the IDF.You would never talk of arabs this way
48. # 24
Birdi ,   Israel   (11.20.07)
Breaking news to you;South Africa is now governed by BLACK South Africans,therefore there is no apartheid in that country.Logical isnt it? Sicere condolences to the family of the murdered settler.
49. RAP OVER THE KNUCLES
ROLAND SEENER ,   LONDON ENGLAND   (11.20.07)
DISMANTLING ROAD BLOCKS,FREEING OF PRISONERS,ALLOWING ESSENTIAL PROVISIONS TO A DEDICATED ENEMY DID NOT SAVE THIS MAN'S LIFE WITH A GOOD-WILL GESTURE FROM A GOVERNMENT THAT IS SUPPOSED TO HAVE THE TOP BRAIN POWER AT ITS FINGER TIPS.WELL,IT HAS CAUSED THE LOSS OF A MAN'S LIFE .THIS CANNOT BE COMPENSATED WITH A CURSORARY HAND OUT OF MONEY FOR COMPENSATION,TOGETHER WITH A SORRY NOTE.PLEASE HASHEM ,I HOPE THERE IS NOT A NEXT TIME AS THE GOVERNMENT WILL GET ITS ACT TOGETHER AND RE-INSTIUTE THE MAXIMUM SECURITY METHODS THAT WILL EFFECTIVELY BLOCK SUCH INCIDENTS FROM OCCURING AGAIN.
50. #31 your either on drugs or a dream world.
Elchonon ,   Chevron   (11.20.07)
Where does the article say he was armed ?!?! you just made that up right? because the media shows images of armed settlers right? Of course you have ever been to judea & samaria.. you never met a settler either. They do not issue m16's or uzi's any more unless you are a select case i.e. work in security or medic. Thats just to bust your ilusioned bubble.. Armed settlers only use their weapons for self defense.. spare me the lines of goldstein, amir and popper.. Please do show me the last reported factual case of a settler targeting arab cars eh?
51. The querry: was the man shot with the Israeli or U.S. gun?
AK   (11.20.07)
and did our CIA provided training to the shooters? Thus another victim of the 'Peace Process' and of the 'good-will-gestures' is being put to rest and the PM is yet again letting go another bunch of terrorist killers free, while heading to Annapolis to submit Israel's unconditional surrender. When will the Israeli finally take to the streets and make their corrupt politicians, including their newly minted President, account for their misdeeds?
52. dafer, 'mighty Israel' you can sell to that MN idiot
AK   (11.20.07)
The rest of us can see on a map the size of Israel in comparison with your Arab lands. Make a country of Jordan bloom, the way the Jews have made Israel -- Jordan is Palestine and it is 4 or five times the size of entire Israel, including Judea and Samaria, historic, ancestral Jewish lands. You can dig and destroy all the evidence of the Jewish presence on the Temple Mount but the thousands of years of written history will negate your lie, darfer. As to peaceful Palestinians, I haven't seen but a handful -- if you don't do the killing yourself, you give money to others to commit the murder. There are indeed very, very few who repudiate and loudly condemn the violence and murders being daily committed by palestinians. The only solution is for you to reform, totally unconditionally, but instead, like a good Muslim, you call on the Jews to submit. Your PA is a terrorist organization, just like Hamas is, just like Hezbollah is. There isn't in fact one single palestinian organization that isn't undeniably terrorist in nature. So don't ask us to back PA, an unrepentant terrorist organization. Prove you peaceful intentions by loudly denouncing PA and all it stands for, than I will consider you a peaceful and innocent man.
53. #38; ALL ARABS ARE SETTLERS IN ISRAEL.
ARABSRSETTLERS   (11.21.07)
THE LAND BELONGS TO THE JEWS! EXPEL ALL THE ARAB OCCUPIERS NOW!
54. 30#
Leah   (11.21.07)
If Mr.Zoldan had no living in the West Bank,commonly known as Judea and Samaria to many Jews. Maybe the 1 million Arab Israelis or Palestinians Israelis living inside the Israeli greenline, have no right to be there either. Especially since there own representatives don't even recognize Israel. What's so ironic is If an Arab Israeli was murderedby a Jew for nationalist reasons,people like you would be outraged and cry racism if someone said that's just too bad,but since he's a Palestinian he had no right being there within Israel proper.
55. so fatah
davidmj ,   new england   (12.03.07)
So fatah was protesting fatah's participation in a "peace" conference by killing a Jewish civilian?
Previous talkbacks
Back to article