Opinion
Arab racism must go
Jackie Levy
Published: 03.12.07, 17:34
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
121 Talkbacks for this article
1. Racism is evil.
John ,   London,UK   (12.03.07)
Jackie Levy is right. Arabs dont even consider Jews as humans. According to average Arab on the street, Jews are worse than dogs and pigs. This means shedding Jewish blood is fine for them. Their holy book teaches them that all Jews will go to Hell in the next life. Allah is going to burn Jews for killing his prophets. This is what small kids are taught in schools. It is no wonder that there cannot be any peace. But I have to also say that Israel is seens by many in Europe to be acting in a racist way towards the Palestinians. Building racist aparthied wall and humilaiting Palestinains every day. British people are not blind to Israeli racism as well. Jews faced racism in Europe which led to Holocaust. I think they should be the foremost people on earth to fight racism whereever it takes its ugly head out.
2. great piece
RobertK ,   Jerusalem   (12.03.07)
and this is its greatest passage-- "Years after Annapolis, some Israeli minister or advisor could write in his memoirs how he made a quick comment to the Syrian official about the crappy American coffee, and yes, he thinks he saw a hint of a smile on the Syrian’s face – for a moment there, the Israeli will say, we were able to overcome the raging conflict and just be two men, Khaled and I, yearning for some good coffee." Captures the pathetic, ingratiating Israeli attitude with fine nuance.
3. jews are one of their own worst enemies
zionist forever   (12.03.07)
The anti jewish feeling has been there for centuries and has nothing to do with palestians or Israel itself its about the islamic world where jews have been treated as dhimi and can continue to live in islamic lands provided they pay their taxes, dont ask for to much then they can continue to live there but not as citizens. No kind of peace process with palestians or arab states or saying on paper the conflict is over this is something that both the arab and islamic world WANT to end because its how they feel not because of politics. Jews also need to stop this desire to be liked at all costs which has been a problem the jewish world has allways had in the diaspora they would in some cases abandon their jewish culture so they could fit in with their non jewish naighbors and be accepted. Israels greatest problem is its wanted everybody to accept its there and want to be friends so we have been willing to compromise on just about any issue if the enemy says PEACE. The arabs dont care if everybody loves them or hates them they are only interested in sucseeding in their own goals if nobody likes them because they have those goals they they hold up 2 fingers and say we are not looking to be loved we are out to do what suits our interests most. Herzals original plan to end anti sematism was for all jews to convert to christianity then we would all be equals and no longer discriminated against. Jews themselves are part of the problem as long as we are afriad to be different and not folow the popular crowd at the expense of our own culture.
4. Arab Racism
Simon ,   London   (12.03.07)
When the Moslem world stops selling Mien Kampf and the "Protocols" in Arabic including Moslem book shops in the UK and europe, then we will have a chance of peace. The Moslem world has to stop using Nazi iconography in the schools and the mosques.
5. Racisim goes both ways..
Rami ,   Nazareth, Israel   (12.03.07)
Arabs are wrong in dehumanizing jews, the same applies to jews, Israeli-jews that is. They also dehumanize arabs and consider "a good arab is a dead arab". Niether arabs nor jews are right, both need to act more human like..
6. When was the last time?
Marlene Newesri ,   New York City/USA   (12.03.07)
That Israel treated its Arab citizens as complete equals? When was the last time that Israel stopped using racist laws and policies against the non-Jewish population? When was the last time that Israel decided NOT to bulldoze Palestinian homes? When was the last time Israel stopped humiliating and harrassing Palestinians? When was the last time Israel stopped torturing Palestinians? When was the last time Israel stopped speaking about the demographic threats or transfer of the Arab population? When was the last time a Palestinian refugee could return to his land even though he was not Jewish? You have the audacity to speak about Arab racism! Everything that is carried out in Israel is carried out in the position of a supremacy.
7. Arab racism won't go
Frank ,   Canada   (12.03.07)
Racism is part of the Arab culture. They hate all people who are not Muslims. Arab racism will stop when Israel will be strong and if they truly understand that they will be smashed if they even think to agress Israel. Olmert and the Left are making Israel weak and are encouraging war and Arab racism.
8. Here's the standard Muslim response to this article...
Joe ,   Los Angeles, CA   (12.03.07)
Forgive me for being a bit simplistic in my talkback here, but the standard Muslim response to this article would most likely sound like the following: "We Muslims don't hate Jews. We have never hated Jews. Islam teaches us that Jews and Muslims are able to live in peace, and, for over a thousand years, we did live in peace. After all, just look at Golden Age Spain! There is only a certain type of Jew that we hate: the Zionist, the hateful, oppressive, apartheidist, occupationist, racist Zionist." Let me deconstruct this straw man argument that I have built. "We Muslims don't hate Jews." Ever heard of "The Promise of the Rock and of the Tree"? Yes, Muhammad "prophecied" that the end times would be sounded by a war in which the Muslims would annihilate the Jews. So, Muslims don't hate Jews, they just have to kill them to attain their goal of world supremacy... "Islam teaches us that Jews and Muslims are able to live in peace, and, for over a thousand years, we did live in peace. " Islam teaches that Jews are "Ahl al-Kitaab" (people of the book), and are to be fought against until they become "Ahl al-Dhimmi" (the protected people). Jews become "Ahl al-Dhimmi" when they give up their rights to self-determination, subject themselves to humiliation and second-class citizenship, and pay a tax for the "right" to practice their religion. Living as a second-class citizen is hardly "living in peace"... "After all, just look at Golden Age Spain!" Golden Age Spain was ruled my Muslim rulers whose religious tolerance flirted with apostasy. At times when Sharia was applied to its fullest extent, Jews and Christians lived in abject poverty and misery... "There is only a certain type of Jew that we hate: the Zionist, the hateful, oppressive, apartheidist, occupationist, racist Zionist." After stating that Muslims don't hate Jews, they then make the statement that they only hate one type of Jew. Well, if you hate a type of Jew, you hate Jews. It's like saying you love vegetables, but then, post-facto, state that you only hate celery. How can you love vegetables if you hate a vegetable? As for Zionists being oppressive, apartheidist, occupationist and racist, Muslims enjoy far greater rights in Israel than Jews do in Muslim countries. Remember, Jews are "Ahl al-Dhimmi" and, as such, are second class citizens subject to humiliation, usurious tax-levying, denial of civil rights, and government-sanctioned vigilante justice. Islam is terror... don't be fooled into believing it isn't.
9. John I liked your post until I got to your 'but'
AK   (12.03.07)
and then I realized what you're all about. British people having never been Israel - friendly can not even be considered friendly towards Jews in general, so why should attitudes or beliefs of Britons be relevant? There is no apartheid fence, but defensive fence and no Israeli racism of any relevance but the Arab and the ‘Palestinian’ expressions of violent and homicidal racism that goes well beyond an ethic joke or dislike, as I said, it's himicidal. So, shove your British moral relativism. At Annapolis, the British officials, together with the rest of European delegations together with their American hosts fully agreed to Arab racist demands. Reminds one of the acquiescence to Nazi Germany's demands regarding Jews in the 30s, i.e. the exclusion of Jew from the Olympic teams in 1936. And you John are one of those many Europeans acquiescing to anti-Semitism; only you are searching for a fig leaf to hide behind.
10. #5 Amen to that Rami!
Saul ,   Barcelona   (12.03.07)
I would gladly shake your hand anytime!
11. #6 When was the last time you stopped beating your children?
Saul ,   Barcelona   (12.03.07)
There is nothing anyone can answer to those kinds of questions. I think you have already answered all your questions for yourself. Why would you bother with the truth?
12. #6 - Marlene, when was the last time...
Joe ,   Los Angeles, CA   (12.03.07)
That Muslim countries treated its Jewish citizens as complete equals? When was the last time that Muslim countries stopped using racist laws and policies against the non-Muslim population? When was the last time that Muslim countries decided NOT to torch synagogues and Israeli flags? When was the last time Muslims stopped humiliating and harrassing Jews? When was the last time Muslims stopped torturing Jews? When was the last time Muslim countries stopped speaking about the demographic threats or annihilation of the Jewish population? When was the last time a Jew could own land in a country he owned land in prior to the rise of Islam even though he was not Muslim? You have the audacity to speak about Jewish racism! Everything that is carried out by Muslim countries is carried out in the position of a supremacy. By the way, I'm still waiting for you to respond to your talkback that I refuted on the basis of its crux being a logical fallacy. When was the last time a supporter of "the Palestinian cause" showed intellectual honesty?
13. Hmm...
Zeal ,   Zionist America   (12.03.07)
"We must cleanse the country of Arabs and resettle them in the countries where they came from," head of the Yesha Rabbis Council, Rabbi Dov Lior, declared Monday. Damn hypocrites.
14. #6 Marlene, you proved Levy's point. Shame on you.
David ,   Boston, USA   (12.03.07)
This is why there will never be peace. The Arabs just take take take. Look in the mirror and reflect a little as to what Arabs/Muslims have been doing for centuries. Its not pretty.
15. Arabs are not racist only good muslim ....
Ponte Acrer ,   Muslimia East   (12.03.07)
as is proved here: "Rights of Non-Muslims in an Islamic State" http://www.answering-islam.org/NonMuslims/rights.htm
16. #13, Zeal what is your point?
David ,   Boston, USA   (12.03.07)
The point is the Arab world has racist policies in place. No one is denying racism occurs everywhere, even amoung Jews I am sad to say, but its the PA and Hamas (rulers) who say Jews must go even though we were there first. I dont here this from Israeli rulling government (note rulling, party members dont always toe government policy ANYWHERE). I also only see it in Arab/Muslim text books teaching racism. DOnt make Israel into utopia. It is a real country with real problems, but it doesnt better than most.
17. Bravo, YNET!
Cameron ,   USA   (12.03.07)
Much credit to the folks at YNET for throwing a blunt & dead-honest posting out into the sunlight. As troubled as the times are, they have a true virtue in that they are forcing the Arab/Muslim community to consider their own self-generated bad bullshit. The comments by #8 rang only too true. Any student of history can't avoid coming to the same conclusion.
18. 6 Marlene do you need a compass, you seem lost?
freedom ,   canada   (12.03.07)
When is the PA leaving the occupied city of Bethlehem. When is the PA going to treat all religions equally in the west bank. Did you ever hear about the burning of the christian churches in the west bank. Do me a favor come back with some facts, do some research.
19. Thank you Saul. I hope more moderate readers would post to..
Rami ,   Nazareth, Israel   (12.03.07)
add more balance ot the mostly inciting right wing radicalisim..
20. Based on
Zeal ,   Zionist America   (12.03.07)
my last (and very recent) quote by a prominent rabbi, this article is a pathetic piece of trash. What do you, Mr. Levy, think of the following slogans/quotes? 1. The dead arab is a good arab 2. kill all the arabs, let God sort out the rest 3. 1,000,000 arabs are not worth the Jewish fingernail (One million Arabs are not worth a Jewish fingernail." -- Rabbi Yaacov Perrin, Feb. 27, 1994 ) 4. "We have to make sure that no Palestinian individual remains under our occupation. If they (Palestinians) escape then it is good; but if anyone of them remains, then he should be exterminated" (Rabbi Yousef Falay) 5. Arabs to the Gas Chambers! (located in Hebron)
21. to # 8 Joe. Can you please tell us about the life style
Simon Mohammed ,   Falls Church, VA USA   (12.03.07)
of the jews people before Islam even was revealed? please be objective as you try to be in your article. The way you talk and generalize a religions itself from the start shows really who you are in term of hate feeling to a lot of people and more to a religion in general. I might be critical in a civilized respectuese way to some one from other faith, but i never make the rule general to the religion/beleive all togother. if we want to abosrd the dhimmi area in time we might find some good in it comparinf it to what was going on that time, and we might discover that some of muslim leader and preacher didn't allow the religion to be adjusted in time, we might find no thing. I think it is irresponsible from you to make that generalization as we all need to learn a lot. with regard thanks
22. Brillant nr. 9# Well said!
Esteban ,   Pully Suisse   (12.03.07)
23. #6, easy answers
Danny   (12.03.07)
Arab citizens have had the vote, equality before law since 1949. What "racist" laws? Israel ceased bulldozing houses in 2005. My guess is that the Palestinians stopped being "harrassed" and "humiliated" around the same time they stopped trying to kill us - ie never. For comparision, I had to wait in a queue to get my bag checked and be searched for a weapon six times today - now where is my suicide belt? Also several tens of thousand Palestinian "refugees" were let into Israel in the 50s and after Oslo. How many Arab Jews got compensation for their loss post 1948? As for demographic threats, you may want to read the article about Arab Israeli views[or at least their leaderships] on integration with Israel. How often do we hear about actual transfer of Jews out of the territories as opposed to redrawing the borders so that the triangle is in the future "democratic", "non-racist" lovefest that will be Palestine.
24. Two sides of the coin
Jewish CANADIAN ,   Toronto   (12.03.07)
The author ignores the widespread and vile racism that many Jews hold toward Arabs-esp. Palestinians,Among the religious and the right it is endemic.How often do I see tbs saying they dont "exist",That they have NO rights in the land God "gave" to the Jews?That they are all vile sub human terrorists?That their children "deserved" to die whatever the true facts of a confrontation were?Hell just like Muslim fanatics the extreme right and ultra Orthodox seem to think all non Jews are inferior ,even sub human,Until BOTH sides recognize the humanity of the other they shall have no peace,Nor will they deserve any.
25. Jews are human beings. Right wing Israelis are monsters.
(12.04.07)
26. Prejudice is taught
Robby ,   San Jose, USA   (12.04.07)
It is wrong for any group of people to dehumanize any other entire group. For example: not too long ago an Israeli radio station released balloons with Hebrew and English writing, some errantly drifted into Lebanon. The Arab press went overboard; the Iranian Farsnews called it a “massacre” (http://english.farsnews.com/newstext.php?nn=8511120182). Several people were rushed to the hospital with various symptoms, one paper reported one victim was paralyzed. When the balloons were proved to be harmless some Arab papers printed follow-up stories, but not all of them. I don’t know that we can blame an individual so overwhelmed with such fears that they become sick without putting some of the blame on who is teaching it to them. Especially if they are never exposed to both sides of the story.
27. #5 Rami
Robby ,   San Jose, CA   (12.04.07)
Chances are anyone who uses terms like "a good arab is a dead arab" doesn't know any. I agree - it huts both sides.
28. #6 devotes her life for hating Jews.
Keren ,   Israel-SP   (12.04.07)
Interested ,go to google and see the name of the devil there:Marlene Newesri. It is impressive up to where can a sick mind go. I even wonder if my post anouncing this dreck is useful .Maybe what this sick one wants is justly propaganda. My G'od ,what a devil!
29. Cameron, how did you do that?
Ihab ,   Lebanon   (12.04.07)
Cameron any hostory student can come up to the same conclusion? Really, really, how did you do that? It mus take one of two possibilities: - Acute chronic Hypocrisy Or - Ignorance Only you Cameron can combine both of them.
30. To Rami in Nazareth (5)
Marlene ,   New York City   (12.04.07)
Of course racism goes both ways. In this world, racism goes many different ways and unfortunately always will, but are you denying that you are not a completely equal citizen in Israel based on Israel's own racist laws and policies, or do you accept that way of life for yourself and your family? We are not speaking of racism here on the part of individuals and groups, but state-sanctioned racism. There's a big difference.
Next talkbacks
Back to article