News
Former US Intelligence official: Israel will attack Iran
Yitzhak Benhorin
Published: 21.12.07, 12:01
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
129 Talkbacks for this article
31. Yisraeli you are wrong about this one
Shir ,   Finland   (12.21.07)
Israel has been secretly preparing for the attack against Iran. This has been going on for years and will continue. Nuclear warheads will likely be used. You as an Israeli should be aware of this...
32. #11 Dont talk too much pal...Venezuela is in US sights.
(12.21.07)
Your dictator might have a few problems at some stage too ...lots of oil there too as a consolation :-)
33. As Golda Meir used to say.....
Andy ,   ramat hasharon   (12.21.07)
we have the benefit of no alternative. The world will be a better place when we remove nukes from the mullahs' grip. I believe we need to do this for our own survival. If we need to use our nukes, then so be it. This is an existential threat we cannot afford to let come to fruition. Once a chunk of that wonderful country, Iran, is flattened, the rest of it will re-emerge as the liberal, western-minded country it once was. Yes there will be loss of life, theirs and ours, but we cannot afford the monsters in power there to have nukes.
34. The world has not seen Israel's full military strength...
Andy ,   ramat hasharon   (12.21.07)
in decades. We have the equipment, manpower and knowhow to do this. And we are increasingly left with no alternative. Our enemies beat their puffed out chests, and threaten with nothing to back it up. So keep underestimating Israel. Watch, we will have a peace treaty with the Palestinians in the West Bank and at the same time kick Iran in the balls. Bye bye, Hamas. Bye bye, Hisbuallah. Bye bye Assad. Bye bye English Guy. (whoops, got a little carried away there - we can't stike as small as the mouth of a moron).
35. 14 Mark: Actually, the Iraq war was to stop Iraq from
Rivkah   (12.21.07)
trading oil for currencies other than the dollar. There is no gold or silver to back up the dollar. Oil backs the US dollar by agreement between President Nixon and OPEC. Iraq started trading in other currencies and that had to be stopped for the dollar not to collapse. Now Iran in trading oil for euros, yen, yuan, etc. To keep the American economy from collapsing, that has to be stopped. Ariel Sharon said he was not going to do America's dirty work by attacking possible nuclear arms producing facilities in Iran. It appears this Israeli government is willing to do America's dirty work. The consequence of that will be an attack on American forces in Iraq, starting at Basra from Daniel in the Bible's vision of the Battle of Hedikel River (Tigris where it meets Euphrates River). Ezekiel chapter 32 in the Authorized King James Bible says the multitude (military) of a young lion nation and its pharoah (leader) will be destroyed by a sword of the King of Babylon. That could be the US forces in Iraq. They will probably be attacked with dirty nukes since the Bible says Babylon (land of Chaldees, so it must be Iraq) becomes uninhabitable forever. Depleted uranium in dirty nukes has a half-life of 10,000 years. Then Russia (Magog), Persia (Iran), and a multitude of Moslem nations and a land called Gomer will attack Israel and also go up (north) to the land of unwalled villages (North America) to take a spoil. That is the Ezekiel chapter 38 war. That is not Armageddon. Syria will be attacked and Damascus will be a rubble heap (Isaiah 17:1). Egypt will become uninhabitable for forty years which sounds like regular nuclear weapons. The Russian alliance will be destroyed in Northern Israel by an earthquake and a plague that melts the eyes. TWO BILLION people are about to die. Read Irvin Baxter's current magazine "Two Billion May Die in 12 Months" cover to cover. Then there will be three and a half years of peace until a world leader says he is God in the Third Temple that is rebuilt. After that false peace, many billions of more will die of famines, plagues, wars, persecutions in what is described by Daniel as the worst time in world history. Finally Armageddon comes and so does the Jewish Messiah (deliverer). At that point only a third of the Jews will be left alive, but fewer than a twentieth of the world's population will be alive. No one would survive if the Messiah did not come. That is how bad it will get.
36. nuclear war
sakis ,   London, UK   (12.21.07)
funny how israelis like to assign rights to themselves and only themselves. I suppose you're all too stupid to realise this, so i'll point it out: since all of your beligerent posts, and the grumbling noises coming out of your governmental 'representatives" (ha!) about war with Iran, and wiping them out, don't you think Iran has the right to a pre-emptive attack against Israel?... its self-defence naturally!
37. 2000 years ago...
Shir   (12.21.07)
Israeli Jewish men were not able to utilize their intelligence in order to save themselves, their women and children. They had to watch their country being destroyed, their women and chidren die and the last Zealots in Masada Temple killed themselves, because they preferred that option to slavery. This time its different. Jews have made a desert into an oasis and turned Israel into the strongest military power in Middle-East. Now they have a chance to make up what happened 2000 years ago and get back at their arch enemy that is ultimately responsible for all suicide bombings and rocket launches. And I am SO PROUD to be part of this generation.
38. Bruce Riedel
ben ,   singapore   (12.21.07)
...is one of the culprit who is responsible for the indefinate detention of Jonathan Pollard. This Bruce Riedel is now saying Israel shoul attack Iran ! This Idiot thinks he is so smart to out wit the Israel- fight a war for America. Well the American's dont want a war,Israelis also dont want a war. Anway if Israel want to enter a war. first end the Qassam Attacks. Bruce Reidel is an idiot and his UNITED NATION is ass of a brains.
39. I hope Russia sent its elite Chernobl Expert team to Iran
Squalid Ibn Harman ,   Qtir   (12.21.07)
40. Beware of your Friends, Israel
Marcel ,   Florida   (12.21.07)
Every real intelligence knows that in 2005 Iran bought 18 Russian SS-N-6 ballistic missiles from North Korea. These North Korean modified Soviet missiles are specifically designed to carry one megaton NUCLEAR warheads. What is wrong with so-called INTELLIGENCE that does not know why Iran would buy such a system from North Korea in 2005, if it had abandoned its nuclear warhead program in 2003? Any genuine Intelligence would know that Iran's nuclear program is NOT located only in Iran. Parts of Iran's nuclear capability, as recently proven by the Israeli air strike on Syria's nuclear stuff, are located in Syria, North Korea, Pakistan, China, and most certainly Russia as well. The Israeli strike in Syria demonstrated that Israel has some genuine Intelligence. Israel's intelligence services insist that Iran's nuclear program is the greatest threat to global security. The US so-called intelligence report sets a dangerous trap for Israel. The OPEN existential threats of Iran to annihilate Israel makes it very unlikely for Israel to avoid the trap set by the US Intelligence. Yes, part of the so-called Road Map, better known biblically as the antichrist plan to, by peace, destroy many, calls for Israel not only to be destroyed, but also to be blamed for the great NUCLEAR worldwide destruction of the Great Tribulation World War Three, so long planned by the antichrist global Satanists. The US has not limited its entrapment of Israel to the political realm. Massive US pressure has stopped Israel from launching a very important strategic Israeli satellite from a missile contracted to be launched from India. The originally scheduled September launch has not yet been rescheduled. This was the apparent US response to Israel's action on Syria's nuclear program, to prevent Israel from further improving its intelligence capabilities. Israeli Defense Minister Ehud Barak is a Peres horn puppet. Barak, like his Peres boss, could not win a popular election for dog catcher in Israel. By Barak's accepted the most ridiculous aspect of the NIE report, that there is a distinction between Iran's "civilian" and "military" nuclear programs. Barak, by this acceptance, prevents Israel from attacking the NIE report for its deceptiveness, and obvious outright absurdity, and the trap for Israel's destruction that it represents. The hatred of the Bush administration for Israel is both obvious and cast in concrete by Annapolis and the LIE of NIE. Of course, Iran's controlling Ayatollahs are celebrating the NIE's publication because it is a clear green light for Iran to acquire and use the means to carry out the second genocide of the Jewish people in 70 years... JimS
41. # 17 johnny, Stockholm ABSOLUTELY!!Right on the mark!!!!!
Petra ,   usa   (12.21.07)
42. # 18 Michel You bought it, idiot
Petra ,   usa   (12.21.07)
your so far from the point, it's pointles... Not about monoply it's about survival.
43. THE FINNISH IDIOT CALLED SHIR......#6
MAHMOOD ,   LONDON-UK   (12.21.07)
By calling me a baffoon,you are not achieving anything.All your talk-back are full of hatred,spite and aimless provocation leading you to nowhere.If you are under the slightest misapprehension that the retaliation on the part of Iranians is going to be modest,for God sake forget it.I can predict a very disastrous situation indeed and rightly so,you idiot.Sitting in Finland and becoming a spokesman on someone else's behalf is very easy for you.It looks like you have hardly anything else to do,dumb!!. Whether the Iranians are fearing or not is not my concern at all.If they are,be it so.So far as their boasting is concerned,you may be on the wrong side of the fence to believe so,Shir.Miscalculation and difficulties in getting supplies due to single source of armaments impeded Iranian response to the mad Saddam.But do remember the Iranians took the lesson indeed seriously and know exactly what to do should any country become adventurist. concentrate more on your own talk-back and refrain from personalising topics under discussion.
44. #37 and place of abode
English guy ,   London   (12.21.07)
So proud are you to be part of the generation that "turned the desert into an oasis" [sic] - which is a very debatable fact, since it involved a policy of scorched earth, ethnic cleansing and wholesale theft. As for your being "SO PROUD" to be part of this generation (by which I suppose you mean the money-making capitalist generation since the socialist kibbutzniks have now been discredited as leftie pinko commies) - indeed so PROUD are you that you live in Finland as a yored. By many peoples' standards, at least among the TB facistos, that means you have no further right to an opinion. As for the modern zealots "having a chance to make up what happened 2000 years ago and get back at their arch enemy", you really do write a load of retrograde filth. Not even the bible suggests visiting the sins of the father upon their nth generation granchildren 2,000 years later. Your posting really do reveal that very slightly below the surface you are an Islamophobe whose only joy in life will be seeing dead non-Jews. Disgusting sentiments. I am ashamed to be related to you. Filth.
45. Some points you're missing, people
Steve ,   UK   (12.21.07)
1. How responsible is it for this guy - an advisor to Bush on M.I. policy (and we see how accurate THAT IS) to announce to the world that Israel WILL attack. Not 'may', 'could', or even 'want to' - WILL. He either leaked one hell of a secret, sending a 'warning', or setting Israel up. 2. In order for Iran to have reliable nukes, they'd need to test them. Tell me there aren't spy satellites above Iran watching for that very event. 3. Even Ahmadinejad, who is an engineer, realizes what "fallout" is. He may be crazy but he's not insane. 4. Wind and weather patterns would severely screw up every country in the M.I. and southern Europe with any above ground detonation's fallout. Raise your hand, who wants to trigger another Chernobyl. 5. All this is designed to do one thing: get Israel to attack, to give the U.S. an excuse to go to war with Iran. All Bushco needs is one "national emergency", and he and Darth Cheney can rule together, suspending the Constitution. Bet you forgot about that "Executive Order", didn't you.
46. Peace, Shalom, Salem
phil b ,   Portland OR USA   (12.21.07)
I wish peace to you all, but I know there will be no peace until the threat is faced. How I wish there could be community works, swimming pools, parks, and wealth for everyone, instead of weapons. But I stand with Israel in this. Funny Europe is now threatend, but still have their head in the sand, perhaps their wealth has blinded them?
47. just tell the Iranians that he belives Israel will attack
zionist forever   (12.21.07)
Saying he believes Israel will attack and will sabotage equipoment is saying to the monkey in Theran we know your allready on the lookout and prepared for any Israeli air strikes but make sure you prepare yourselves against the possibility of equipment sabotage as well. The man might not be doing Israel any favours here but at the end of the day Israel cant do this alone at best it can slow down the Iranian program by a year or two but this isnt Saddam in 1981 Iran has its facilities spread around in some of it in undeground bunkers and as soon as Israeli jets attacked the first target all the others would be defending themselves and sabotage will probably delay things for even less time than hitting a target with air strikes. Only the Americans can do this properly they have the hardware to do it and they have 3 carrier fleets in the Gulf as well as air bases in arab states within range of Iran. The Americans can also deal with some of the balistic missles at the same time limiting the capability of any Iranian retaliation, Israel could carry out an airstrike to create an Iranian response and the Americans could then come and use that as an excuse to finish of Iran using the justifiction they are coming to Israel in its hour of need.
48. Israel have not the balls to attack Iran
Mateo ,   Spain   (12.21.07)
I agree with Mahmood it is a not realistic option for israel.Israel would suicide if attack Iran.In fact,i believe that USA won´t attack Iran.
49. ISRAEL WILL ATTACK IRAN
MISTY ,   USA   (12.21.07)
WHY DO YOU THINK BUSH IS GOING TO ISRAEL ? TO WISH THEM A HAPPY NEW YEAR? TO GIVE HIS OK FOR THE ATTACK.! IMPEACH CHENEY AND BUSH NOW !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! PEACE ON EARTH!!!!!!! IS ISRAEL THE HOLY ONES?
50. #2 Mahmood - The repurcussions (an analysis)
Aharon   (12.21.07)
"Does Israel realise the repurcussions of such an act?" I've decided to chime in and give my opinion, and hopefully break down some of the dellusions of a grand middle-east war that you have in mind. Israel is more than capable of taking out Iran's nuclear facilities, as you conceed. So, what could Iran's responses be? 1) Make use of its proxies in Gaza and South Lebanon to attack Israel 2) Counter-attack with a large scale tactical missile attack. 3) Attempt to cause Syria to escalate the tension over the Golan Heights and spark some sort of conflict. 4) Make use of the "oil weapon" 5) Any combination of the above However, let's consider the likelihood of these options taking place. (1) seems possible, since it is impossible to trace that back directly to Iran.(2) Also possible, but with limited effectiveness due to Israel's ABM systems, yetr also unlikely since Israel could respond with its own missile strikes.(3) Highly unlikely, because the Syrian military is completely outclassed by the IDF in any conventional war. (4) Practically impossible since they need the money, and it would strengthen the Sunni Arab exporters like Saudi Arabia, not to mention it might trigger an American attack. So, we come to the conclusion that at best, Iran could attempt to rain missiles down on Tel-Aviv and escalate the situation in Northern Israel and Gaza - nothing Israel can't handle if it utilizes sufficient military force. So, there you have it Mahmood. No great battle in the Middle East, no epic scenes of Iranian soldiers capturing Jerusalem, but a few home made rockets being lobbed over Israel's border. That is the only repurcussion.
51. #16 I have a genuine question for you?
Aharon   (12.21.07)
According to your understanding, how exactly do these 200,000 Iranian soldiers attack Israel? (by the way, Iran has MUCH more than 200,000 soldiers) Do they magically appear on the non-existant border that Iran shares with Israel? Or will Syria allow its territory to be violated by a million Persian soldiers?
52. Steve thanks for presenting five reasons
Shir ,   Finland   (12.21.07)
why Israelis should not trust you as their "friend". You are constantly making excuses for Iranians and even their Government and leaders. Just to let you pro-Iranian traitor know, Israelis have waken up a long time ago, and prepare attack for Iran. Too late to try to stop them now.
53. Not only is Stevie-boy
Shir   (12.21.07)
pro-Iranian and anti-Israeli, he is also anti-American and tries to put Americans in bad light to make Iranians look good. He is so transparent that even the dumbest people see through him.
54. #42 irony is not dead
English guy ,   London, UK   (12.21.07)
You calling Michel "idiot"??? As I said, irony is not dead.
55. VENEZUELA
MISTY ,   USA   (12.21.07)
#32 GIVING FREE OIL TO USA POOR IS MORE THEN BUSH IS GIVING. BREAD $ 1.90 MILK $ 5.00 A GAL EGGS $ 2.99 A DOZ GAS $3.09 A GAL TOTAL $ 12.98 NOW FEED A FAMILY OF FIVE ON $ 20. OOO A YEAR MUST BE THE NEW WAY TO FIGHT WEIGHT GAIN.
56. Rosenberg spies have come full circle
Dave ,   Ft. Lauderdale   (12.21.07)
How ironic that the technology that was transferred to the Soviets by the traitorous Rosenbers may be utilised by the Russians against Israel.
57. AHARON.......SUPERB CONCLUSION.....#
MAHMOOD ,   LONDON-UK   (12.21.07)
Aharon,you seem to be knowing much more than the Armed Forces Heads.No doubt, I have no dispute with your conclusions if that is what YOU think could be the retaliation.You may very well live with this notion but I feel doubtful and concerned.
58. #44 and #54, ohh pot and kettle
Danny   (12.21.07)
So someone who thinks Iran having nukes is a bad idea is an "Islamophobe"? Aren't you the first to ridicule the idea that anyone who makes up lies about israel is "anti-semitic"? What part of making the desert bloom is debatable? That it was mostly swamp and desert pre-1880? Or that now it isn't? You are right that in Israel's history there was ethnic cleansing - the ethnic cleansing of Jews from East Jerusalem, Hebron, Gush Etzion, the Golan, virtually every arab country - and wholesale theft - this would be land purchased legitimately and legally from Arabs in virtually every single arab country. But somehow I don't think you mean that.... That's because you are a super-smart, wholely unbiased person who doesn't pump out hateful filth against a particular group on an almost daily basis. No, perish the thought.
59. #43, big words from the man in London
Danny   (12.21.07)
The Iranians had difficulties in the Iran-Iraq war because their leaders were incompetent. They had plenty of weapons but drove away and/or killed the people who were trained to use them. As such they were forced to resort to sending waves of boys against Iraqi troops. Iraq, despite having half the population of Iran, fought Iran to a standstill. Iran made zero progress in 6 years from 1982. There is simply zero evidence the Iranians are an effective fighting force. Good terrorists maybe but fighting a conventional battle or putting up a fight against Israeli or US bombers? Not a chance.
60. #51, it is not just Syrian soil
Danny   (12.21.07)
They'd also have to violate either Iraqi or Turkish soil to get to Syria. There is zero chance of a direct confrontation between the Israeli army and Iranian army. Maybe the odd IRGC might turn up in Lebanon.
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article