News
Peres: No ‘hudna’ until Qassams cease
Aviram Zino
Published: 21.12.07, 15:15
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
27 Talkbacks for this article
1. Why negotiate with Hamas at all
Joe ,   Ohio, USA   (12.21.07)
A hudna is useless! Bomb them until they are seriously willing to make peace! No gas, No water, no electricity and nothing but military pressure in all the right areas targeting Palestinian terror at it highest levels until they admit defeat. Your leaders are Israel's own worst enemies!
2. Rockets Shmockets.Now Hudna Shmoedna
Alan ,   SA   (12.21.07)
3. release of Gilaad Shalit could have led Israel...
ygalg   (12.21.07)
to consdier to agree to temporal cease fire. what a missed opportunity :(
4. realing shalit!! Thats what needs to be done.....
God   (12.21.07)
before anything else!
5. perfect time
(12.21.07)
this is the time israel has wanted to arrive at. the enemy hamas is scared. they have been deleted somewhat with power bases and power leader assassinated. they are scared and now vulnerable. this is the time to continue. israel must continue the clean up operation and must do so irregardless of the hudna cry of hammas. do not stop otherwise you, israel, will pay a dearer price when hamas rests, reorganizes, shuffles leaderships, etc... for them a hudna or ceasefire is a time to regroup and rethink a response strategy. do not let them have this time. do not let them get stronger. do not let them continue. pound and pound because this is the only language they understand. eliminating a cancer by a single shot or radiation is bound to fail. constant radiation and constant assult will cure the kassam issue for good. then, you enter gaza....when they are too weak to respond. like softening the ground before digging and planting.
6. Gilad Shalit is still in Gaza. But it is well said to stop
(12.21.07)
peace negotiations until the attacks from Gaza stop.
7. So says the architect of Oslo ...
Terry ,   Eilat, Israel   (12.21.07)
What a lying, self-centered, delusional, under-handed, sneaky, hypocrite. In other words, the perfect Israeli politician. You can't believe a word he says - tomorrow morning he'd announce a deal with Hamas & then justify it with more empty words. Having this recycled loser as president is truely symbolic of how low our political system has sunk.
8. Why does Gaza provide Qassams. We provide gas,water,Electric
Squalid Ibn Harman ,   Qtir   (12.21.07)
Why does Gaza provide Qassams. We provide gas,water,Electricity? Why do we risk our soldier's lives? Why do we spend a fortune in advanced missiles, etc? SIMPLE PROBLEM. NO RISK. SAVE LIVES. STOP THE QASSAMS IMMEDIATELY. EITHER STOP ALL GAS, ELECTRICITY, AND WATER OR SHOOT INEXPENSIVE INACCURATE QASSAMS BACK AT THEM. EITHER WAY WE WIN AND IT WILL TAKE LESS MONEY, LESS RISK, AND IT WILL QUICKLY TO OVER AND DONE WITH.
9. # 4 your name and spelling offends me.)
Petra ,   usa   (12.21.07)
10. Peres
ben ,   singapore   (12.21.07)
What is the point you are the President of Israel? 1. You plug you ears on all matters concering Shalit and the other IDFsoldiers 2. You played out Jonathan Pollard and also plug your ears when we raise this imoral american syatem of administration of Justice. 3. You never spoke to the Great George Bush ever. yet. Olmert did an he forgot The name Jonathan Pollard 4, You have been talking and talking about the Qassam it it is still talking and talking. 5. if it is not for the IDF and the IAF I wonder where Israel will be today ? 6. sederot you sold 7. gush Katib you sold Peres it is very frustrating man !!!! DO SOMETHING REAL IDIOT !!! Dont just talk and Talk!
11. No Hudna
khader herzallah ,   DH-SA   (12.21.07)
Mr Perez is a soft spoken politician but a failer one.Why ? because he is cunny and never respected the Noble Peace prize ho got.He is questioning why Qassam is falling on Israel while there are no Israeli soldiers or Civilians in Gaze?He knows exactly why , the physical presence is replaced by an IDFair strikes and tanks destroying people , property.Mr Perez can fool the world for sometime but not all the time.I am reversing the question why the daily air strikes and daily killing and invasion?the moment your daily assaults cease ,ther will be no Qassam.
12. hudna
Albert Greenbaum ,   Spring Valley, USA   (12.21.07)
and the israeli politicians quietly dropped "the return of the kidnapped" as their precondition for talks. Very convenient.
13. #7 exactly what I was thinking
(12.21.07)
the pathetic master sellout Arafal tocheskisher gives advise what to do with Hamas
14. khader herzallah , DH-SA
(12.21.07)
wrong, the Israelis left Gaza and shortly after the missile and mortar firing started
15. Who is Rabinovich when I am Perske
Ben Temalion ,   Shiloh, MO USA   (12.22.07)
This assassin of Jews including those who love the land, not just the one that shelled the ship by Jabo's nome de plume still propogates the hope that Ismael is just real good guy. Lauren Bacall may have bought the sack of crap by her cousin but Perske is just another self hating, suicidal Jew that thinks the land can be extorted. Pleadse G-d have mercy such that the lovers of their land are no lnger harmed by their suicidal brtheren.
16. It is so,so important
vered ,   israel   (12.22.07)
that our politicians scream out loud that Israel has left Gaza, and not only are qassams still falling, but that Hamas has declared war on its own people. But most important again, we must state all the time out loud that we left Gaza.
17. Mr. Peres (you did not got it)
Jalal Y. Marzouq ,   Gaza Palestine   (12.22.07)
everybody knows that you don’t need negotiations, you need to stop rocket attacks. but how there is one way whether you like it or not ,, you have to talk to hamas and as you know Mr. Abbas is so far from gaza and he will like so much to stop the rockets but no way just hamas can do hope u got it now
18. Just keep it up
paul malykont ,   United States   (12.22.07)
Bomb them when they attack, leave them in peace when they don't and know that it will take time for it to work. You are on the right path.
19. Khader, you are mistaken..
real Shir ,   Finland   (12.22.07)
We, innocent Finns, suffered from Russian neighbors for years - but once we gave up Karelia - they don't fight us anymore! We have peace NOW!!!! We can even go to St. Petersburgh and drink alcohol there! You should do the same - leave the land of Israel - and you will see how beautiful life is! My Koran teacher says that you have to submit yourself to the will of the Israelis. Are you South Africa now? How is life there?
20. Truce?
Frank ,   Canada   (12.22.07)
There is no possible negociations with any of these mobsters, even the so-called moderates.
21. #17 Jalal, Ana Mota-Asef. Sorry But it is Hamas' fault
Squalid Ibn Harman ,   Qtir   (12.22.07)
How do you talk to someone whose Charter and all actions call uncompromisingly for our destruction. Look at all the rhetoric on their 20th Anniversary. "Only by force....." HAMAS only knows terror. It only speaks HUDNA when they are seriously hurting from Israeli counter-terror measures and need to regroup and re-arm. Never do they mean anything approaching peace or peaceful co-existance. Nihna Lazim Naqba Ethanyee
22. #14 Khader - The twisted Arab Mind
Squalid Ibn Harman ,   Qtir   (12.22.07)
Khader, As usual Arabs some to twist the truth to somehow save face. The truth is that we left Gaza in Disengagement by Sep 15, 2005 and Gaza intensified its Qassam attacks by March of 2006. So instead of lying or making up stories, try checking out the facts. Disengagement Aug 12-Sept 15 2005 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Israel's_unilateral_disengagement_plan Graph showing Qassam rocket attacks. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Image:Qasam_graph2002-2007.svg
23. the ONLY way is People integration...
Ibrahim ,   Egypt   (12.22.07)
you have to be smarter...No hudna..without much more people integration into one society...e.g 22000 Egyptian men have married israeli women...now they have more than 5500 childrens.... fighting the Israel without one bullet...by allowing the black refugees..ethiopia and sudan..somalia....iretria.. cross the Egyptian border to israel...Why does my government arrest them!!!!...because the israeli society is more susceptible for that...let them go there and spark the racism among the israeli society....by some intelligence agents...The ONLY way is people integration into one society...the same thing you can do with the palestinans at different levels...
24. #23 Ibrahim - Shukran bas Lah Shukran
Squalid Ibn Harman ,   Qtir   (12.22.07)
Ibrahim El Masri, Zayak El Naharda? Ana Mota-asef bas ... Sorry but we have suffered every kind of persecution imaginable for 2000 or more years. I don't have to tell you about the Crusades. There was the Spanish Inquisition, Pogroms, etc. etc. Assimilation is just a sugar coated way to see us destroyed, lose our religion, nationality, and identity. While it may sound "nice" at face value, it is no less a threat to our very existance than all the other forms of persecution and attacks that we have suffered. Ma'ah Salame' Squalid Ibn Harman Qtir
25. To #24
Ibrahim ,   Egypt   (12.23.07)
some members in the Egyptian parliament council....wanted to introduce a project about the 22000 Egyptian men and their 5500 childrens....those members wanted to give up their Egyptian nationality and prevent some of them to enter Egypt...due to security issue and they are dangerous people...all those Egyptians and childrens are listed their names to follow them...by Egyptian intelligence agency....but I see this project will be refused...and enough to follow them only....
26. HUDNAH ...NO "SULHAH"...MAYBE.
ROLAND SEENER ,   LONDON ENGLAND   (12.23.07)
HUDNA IS UNEACCEPTABLE,AS IT IS ALLOWED TO BE BROKEN WHEN AN OPORTUNE MOMENT IS DEEMED TO BE RIGHT TO RESUME WARFARE.FOR A TRUCE TO BE EXTENDED TO NON BELLIGERANCY PERHAPS THE SOLUTION IS IN A "SULHAH ".THIS WAS EFFECTIVE IN BRINGING THE TROUBLES INVOLVING FRENCH RULE, TO A PEACEFUL END ,AND INDEPENDANCE FOR ALGERIA.THIS TERM IS APPLIED TO A MORE PERMANENT PEACE THAN THAT OF A "SULHAH".
27.  publish what I want not you want....
Ibrahim ,   Egypt   (12.23.07)
Yeah there are innocent finns...I have met finns and some of them are called Saila.., Aki,..they always like to enjoy with a real innocent smile on their cheeks and they also like to read some books ...NO political issues that drive them crazy...especially if it is related to the Middle East...heh I call them Nerd....I confess the finns are good readers really....they even have no tendency to insult the thinking power of anyone....NO wars, kill,Violent,hate words in their daily life....so what do you call those people (Yeah Innocent).....and what do you call yourself and me!!! I think you are immigrant...... Haman Ibrahim
Back to article