Culture  The Buzz
Will Smith: Hitler thought he was doing good
Ynetnews
Published: 24.12.07, 08:40
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
144 Talkbacks for this article
61. Will , I'm no longer your fan, and I WAS one.
gabriela ben ari ,   jerusalem   (12.24.07)
62. i was a fan, now i hate his guts
robert renders ,   belgium   (12.24.07)
63. In what context were these comments made?
Susan ,   Israel   (12.24.07)
64. News reporting
mr ,   israel   (12.24.07)
I find it difficult to understand how and why Will Smith got into this subject in Scotland !! Anyway, I read: "Hitler thought himself to be a good man" and not that Will thinks Hitler was a good man !!!!! Not long ago he was here with his wife and child on a visit and appeared to be very personable. I for one wouldn't condemn him - only the news reporter.
65. #40
eh-oop ,   United KIngdom   (12.24.07)
Agree with you, Ed. Will Smith is anything but a fool, and his image is such that he will retract / clarify once he knows the impact of his words / how he has been misquoted. Let's not get our knickers in a twist.
66. Concerning Will
Mary Jones ,   Australia   (12.24.07)
Is this man morally bankrupt or is he just a person with a very low IQ? Perhaps he is simple minded? On the other hand maybe he is extremely uneducated!
67. And yet Shas attacks Gay people on a daily basis
Simon ,   TA Israel   (12.24.07)
And yet gay people (yes the jewish variety) are verbally attacked practically everyday in the press from the likes of Shas which incites violence and crimes of hatred towards their fellow jews and Israelis but that somehow is acceptable.
68. Wlll Smith
mo ,   staten island ,usa   (12.24.07)
Yes, and slavery was good for Blacks - give me a break.
69. To #30
M. Hartley ,   Atlanta, US   (12.24.07)
Anne Frank was a child who had never seen a KZ. Will Smith should be made to watch every l945 newsreel and US military film of those camps, with pictures and descriptions as to exactly what went on there. Add to that all the footage of the Nazis proudly documenting Babi Yar and every place like it, and Will should be made to look at all of it until there's not another tear left in him. If he has trouble with German, I'll translate for him. I'm sure that Will is not a bad person; just missing chunks of education. I wonder why he thinks our soldiers died over there. It couldn't have been for oil. Maybe we were after Schnaps, Kuckucksuhren and Apfelstrudel ( booze, cuckoo clocks and apple strudel.)
70. This is meant to insult Will Smith only:
M. Hartley ,   Atlanta, US   (12.24.07)
Zebra dies and arrives at the Pearly Gates. As he enters, he asks St.Peter, "I have a question that's haunted me all of my days on earth. Am I white with black stripes, or am I black with white stripes?" St.Peter said, "That's a question only God can answer." So the zebra went off in search of God. When he found Him, the zebra asked, "God, please - I must know. Am I white with black stripes, or am I black with white stripes?" God simply replied "You are what you are." The zebra returned to see St. Peter once more, who asked him, "Well, did God answer your question?" The zebra, looking confused, said. "No sir, God simply said, “You are what you are.” St. Peter smiled and said to the zebra, "Well then, there’s your answer. You are white with black stripes." The zebra, now looking even more addled, then asked, "How do you know that for sure?" "Because," said St. Peter, "If you were black with white stripes, God would have said, "You is what you is." How does this feel, Mr. Smith???
71. Settle down, Will is not Hitler
Oy ,   usa   (12.24.07)
I would like to see the whole interview. Because it seems to me that he may be going off the philosophy, one that we can all remember Anne Frank expressed, that ALL people are inherently good. So with this in mind he needs to come up with a theory as to why good people do evil. In relation to Hitler this would include telling some story that what he did he thought was 'good' via some twisted logic that just needs reprogramming. Obviously it's not a very good argument. But if you believe this way, it's really one of the only arguments you can make. It's just liberal crap: if you live near Hollywood, you're used to hearing this garbage every day. But it doesn't follow that Will is the new Hitler. So settle down people!
72. just read the full article
Oy ,   usa   (12.24.07)
and it does say what i suspected: the context of this remark comes from Will expressing that he "believes everyone is basically good." So this is really the only story he can tell if he believes this way.
73. Smith
John ,   Rechovot Israel   (12.24.07)
Someone should point out to that " Idiot" that had his" friend Hitler" gotten hold of him, he would have been among the first to go into the extermination ovens. Still think he did good things Moron!!!!!!!!!!!!
74. Moral Judgement
Debra ,   United kingdom   (12.24.07)
" The road to hell is paved with good intentions" describes what Hitler thought. Unless there is a clear distinction between good and evil, for which the only source is the universal Mosaic Law, morality is inverse. This is the danger we face today from the international community's good intentions directing our leaders.
75. Hitler, The Madman
Javier ,   Valencia, Spain   (12.24.07)
The other night there was in History channel one of the tons of documentaries on Hitler. There was a shot of him close up in colour, the camera handheld turning a rround his face. There is no question or doubt this guy was absolutely MAD. How can people just consider some sligth good inside this demented? And all hs parnafernalia is like a bad pretentious opereta staged by Speer and the other madman Goebbels. Anything in the Nazi regime is insane.
76. Do only Idiots write the comments here?
Rouven ,   Tel-Aviv   (12.24.07)
I'm jewish. I lost family members in the holocaust. I say Will Smith is 100% right. All those dumbarses who call him an antisemite are nothing but eternal victims who need antisemites for survival. Nobody is 100% evil. Nobody does evil things just for the fun of doing EVIL. Hitler had an agenda, an ideology, a plan he was following. In his own eyes he was doing the pure good. He said that so many times. I read not only "Mein Kampf" in it's original version but also 3 books on Hitler from 3 different countries. I can say I know Hitler a little bit. People, wake TF up! It's 21. century, the shoa was 3 generations ago. Not the whole world hates jews. In fact the most people don't give a damn about us. Yes, that's right, the most humans don't care because they live in countries completely unrelated to jewish / christian history. It's only the western hemisphere whining. We should learn to accept that not everybody who mentions "jews", "israel", "nazi" and "hitler" does automatically take a firm stand on who's side he's on. There's a also neutral and a non-emotional point of view. It's non-emotinal in Will Smith's case. He for sure is no antisemite. Get your own emotions right!!!
77. Only Thing Dumber is the Ridiculous YNET Headline
Seth ,   Washington, DC   (12.24.07)
78. Will Smith's comments
Linda Ginsburg ,   Florida, USA   (12.24.07)
Unbelievable naivety. Will, read a little history before you open your mouth.
79. Overreaction!
Raz ,   Rishlach   (12.24.07)
Who cares what he said? The guy's an actor, not a philosopher. He's not anti-Semitic. He's not a Nazi. He's just an actor who didn't study his history a little too close. Who cares! Btw - he missed out on college because of career - this might be a cause of his actions. Cut him a break. Jeez, ppl - from your comments, you sound like the ppl on JPost.
80. WILL SMITH & THE MORON MENTALITY
DENNIS ,   CHICAGO   (12.24.07)
"AMEN " TO #13. HERE IN THE USA WE'RE BURSTING WITH MORONS...... SOME EVEN MANAGE TO ACQUIRE POLITICAL OFFICE.
81. Dont Worry Will
Ab nibe   (12.24.07)
There will always be some jewish mogul producer in Holywood to pay you for making movies. Money is more important than Shoah to them! Keep rolling!
82. I agree with will
John   (12.24.07)
Will's right. No slip of the tongue. The guy thought what he was doing was right just like suicide bombers, they both just have screwed up minds.
83. Will Smith
Manny ,   Israel   (12.24.07)
I always thought that Will Smith was intelligent - until now. Hitler believed that non-Aryans were sub-human, and therefore as a black, Will Smith would have been one of the first exterminated. I think that Will should study the Holocaust and then express his opinions. And by the way, aside from 6 million Jews, another 50 million people died because of World War II. Whether Hitler had "good intentions" or not, he was a mass murderer and therefore no excuses can be made for him.
84. This Is It!
Ginette ,   Toronto, Canada   (12.24.07)
Willy boy in now in the same category as Mel Gibson in my book. No more seeing his films because I CAN'T STAND STUPIDITY AND ANTI-JEWISH REMARKS as they come from the heart, how these People really feel about us! Any more actors/actresses out there who want to join the club? Be my guest and come out already! Discusting and brainless stuff, that's what his remarks were. They don't get that Hollywood is mostly Jewish and that my friends is their downfall.
85. Hollywood
Johnson ,   USA   (12.24.07)
Smith is just another Hollywood liberal who deludes himself in a sea of mindless stupidity. Poor little Adolf, he was just misunderstood. Right?
86. evil
daniel ,   guatemala   (12.24.07)
and you think Hitler had good intentions when he ordered to starve the 3 milllion people in leningrad in order to avoid invading the city? what an idiot...
87. Will SSmith
(12.24.07)
You are pathetic, ignorant. READ HISTORY BOOKS HITLER WAS ANTISEMITIC AND HAVE LAID OUT ITS FINAL SOLUTION BACK IN 1920´S. BLOODY IGNORANT
88. Leave him alone
David ,   Tel Aviv   (12.24.07)
All he was trying to say is that there is no such thing as inherent evil. Whether you agree or not is a different subject, but it is a perfectly acceptable position to have. Some journalist made it into something it isn't. I think it borders on libel to tell you the truth.
89. whats the big deal
james ,   harlem USA   (12.24.07)
in 1947 israel thought and planned on invading and stealing palestine from the palestinians , and they thought it would be over in a couple of months , but they thought wrong ,instead , they will be fighting wars for the rest of there lives , and in the end they will be kicked out of palestine . so did hitler , he thought i would kill all the jews and get rid of them for the sake of the world , and he was mistaken , he should have finished the war with a total win and finish what he started . he also was wrong. he did not think that by what he did , he gave the jews more power which translates to more disaster for humanity . will smith my man you are absouloutly correct my brother .
90. Will Smith
Norman Cone ,   Orlando,Florida   (12.24.07)
Will Smith is a dumb actor whose thoughts about Hitler or anything else don't deserve the attention the media are spending on him. Really : even to ignore him is overdoing.
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article