Opinion
No more withdrawals
Haim Misgav
Published: 09.01.08, 18:07
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
30 Talkbacks for this article
1. too bad
joseph ,   israel   (01.09.08)
too bad Olmert, Peres and Yariv Oppenheimer are less intelligent than Haim Misgav
2. excellent points
augustine e johnson ,   birmingham-usa   (01.09.08)
excellent points
3. At lest :a valid opinion in YNET '!!!!!
trumpeldor ,   eurabia   (01.09.08)
Awesome this kind of events should be repeated....
4. Ha ha ha
Peace Now ,   Israel   (01.09.08)
You wish . Youre day is done my friend . It was done the night you shot Rabin in the back . No brother to us are you now or forever.
5. no more withdrawl
Just a Girl ,   Israel   (01.09.08)
You said it. good for you. But no one else cares about us here in Yesha. Hashem is going to got pretty mad now... now ynet is going to call me extreme.
6. Excellent article. I wonder if it appeared in Hebrew.
AK   (01.09.08)
If Israelis read this and still don't take to the streets, the is indeed no hope for the Jewish survival. And if the West sells out the Jews again, the is no hope for the West's survival as well.
7. Dont ever count on the West - they dont need to care
andrew ,   miami,fl   (01.09.08)
israel is a burden and not a blessing to the west - forget them - israel is a middle eastern nation ...a semitic nation so join the other semites - the arabs
8. I for one...
Scott ,   NY, NY   (01.09.08)
I for one, completely agree! There is no logical reason for withdrawal. For example, the US never gave back mexico, (even though there was almost an attempt made by Germany, and Mexico) There are many more example of this, but why is the tiny nation of Israel forced to give land back after she won land fairly. It's not Israel's fault that some of the Arab countries refused to take in palestinian refugees.
9. #4 - Peace Now, you speak the truth...
Palestinian ,   Palestine   (01.09.08)
Indeed, the Zionist enemy is finished. Little do you know, though, it wasn't when Rabin was shot in the back, it was when Rabin signed the Oslo Accords and shook Arafat's hand (Pee be upon him)!
10. #4 You dumb wad...Do you have the means
Al   (01.09.08)
to leave Israel and settle in the Trump Towers on the west side of Manhatten? If you did you'd be there already. Most probably, your some dumb poor smuck who makes a living writing for Peace Now Dead Tomorrow. If you had the means you'd be out of there. The point is you dont so you sit in Israel and tell yourself if only the bad old settlers will leave than you will live in peace and sip your coffee and continue partying in that cesspool of a town called TA. Sit there in cesspool TA and keep on telling yourself stories. You will be quickly forgotten once the bullets fly.
11. Excellent and Must Read Article
Brod ,   USA   (01.09.08)
This is an excellent and Must Read article by Haim Misgav. Americans, Europeans and Israelis must read this. Israel will do well by not cowing, bowing, and bending under the pressure of usurpation by Islamist-Jihadists engineered and manipulated by Israel's pernicious enemies-Antisemitism and Wahhabhism-Jihadism.
12. The Arabs should move to their State Jordan
e.m.Jordan is Palest ,   s.f   (01.09.08)
President Bush and 70 millions American evangelicals strongly believe in that the Jordan is Palestinians State and Israel is Jewish State and belong to Jews but because only year left to Bush Presidency he is plying game to get more vote for next election beside the situation in the W.B indicate of the next intifada by the majority of Palestinians whom opposed the President Abbas .Stop believe those nonsense peace with the Islamism’s fanatic’s impossible because they will not change their ideas regarding the destruction of Jewish State
13. #4 & #10 - Don't fight each other!!
Chaya ,   Bat Yam, Israel   (01.09.08)
Unfortunately, the day might come #4 when you will wake up and realize that you had been sold a bill of goods and that you - #10 - are truly his brother. Do not let our enemies divide us!! #10 - don't speak in the same manner as #4. It will only antagonize and alienate him more.
14. God Bless You!!!
Joe ,   U.S.A   (01.09.08)
You are absolutly right with your column. There will be no such thing as "peace" for your country when every country in the middle east wants to destroy the Jewish people. It makes me very upset when my President goes to Israel to try and talk "peacful negotiations" with Israel and the palestinians and every other country that wants to destroy the Jewish State! I say enough of that, for one thing the West Bank, Gaza Strip and Golan Heights has always been Israeli land right from the very begining. Israel has every right to take back whats theres. So just do it! Enough with this "peace talk" it will never happen. God Bless the Jews and may the country thrive with His will.
15. Haim is correct! Only TA and Peace Now doesnt get it
bjl ,   usa   (01.09.08)
They think because they are Israeli and not "Jews" they will not be a target. You are wrong! The enemy thinks you are just as Jewish as someone in Judea or Samaria, Gush Katif or Gush Etzion. TA and all of Israel is THE target. You can continue to give the arabs the high ground only to see that it is then too late. All of Israel is JEWISH to them and therefore a target.
16. #4 is obviously a right-wing hack....
Eyal ,   Jerusalem   (01.09.08)
And not Palestinian. I have to say guys, when you have to resort to such pathetic tactics to try to make your point, you've already lost the argument. This is what the Euro- lefty, anti-Israel losers do on haaretz.com.
17. BRAVO !!!!!!!!!
Dan ,   USA   (01.10.08)
18. #16 - Eyal, SARCASM!
Joe ,   Los Angeles, CA   (01.10.08)
Come on, Eyal, you expected a real Palestinian to write, "Arafat (Pee be upon him)"? If we can't laugh at the absurdity and empty boasts of both those who claim victory while consistently snatching defeat from the jaws of victory, as well as those who are willing to give away our country for nothing more than a 'hudna', we have clear cut evidence that terrorism and fear-mongering, both from the Israeli left as well as from Islam, indeed works in shaping public opinion. Peace Now's approach to ending bloodshed by disengagement was twice proven wrong by the withdrawals from Gaza and Southern Lebanon. Isn't the definition of insanity doing the same thing over and over again and expecting different results?
19. #4 Go Back to the UK You Traitor
Joe Kelly ,   Canada   (01.10.08)
Peace Now are Traitors who pays them? All that UK Government Money paid to them to spy.
20. Czechoslovakia
Marvin ,   USA   (01.10.08)
Yes, there are parallels with Czechoslovakia, but at least their leader, Benes, wasn't collaborating with the Germans to dismember his country.
21. Peace now how many representative has in the Keenest?
e.m.Jordan is Palest ,   s.f   (01.10.08)
They did not get enough votes even for one
22. To Just a Girl #5
Avi ,   Tel-Aviv   (01.10.08)
G-d getting mad? Nothing in the world (especially in Eretz Israel) happens without G-d's acceptance. And if the Gush Katif evacuation took place you should start to accept the fact that He permitted it.
23. Chaim should be wary - Soon Bagatz & media will frame him
Dudu ,   Kfar Sava   (01.10.08)
They punish those who disbelieve the Peace Religion
24. Reply # 21
Peace Now ,   Israel   (01.10.08)
Ever heard of Meretz ? Meretz voters are all Peace Now . Anyhow Bush says the settlements have to go ...... so I just want to say Bye bye o)
25. # 14 Amy G-d bless you too, Joe I fully agree!
Petra ,   usa   (01.10.08)
No nation gives its land to anyone without a battle that costs are in human blood. Israels land is not for sale or trade.
26. be careful georgie poo, pat robertson
george bush ,   usa   (01.10.08)
will curse you if you give away any jewish lands
27. #22 behind the times
Israel Israeli ,   tel aviv   (01.10.08)
You are a few thousand years behind or in the wrong religion. Since the Garden of Eden man has free will. Ariel Sharon and his supporters chose to destroy the lives off 10000 Jews with their racist transfer and they chose to subject the children of Sderot to Arab rocket fire. They cannot escape responsibility by saying that it was allowed so it is G-d's plan.
28. when I see number 4# and its respond on number 9...
me ,   jerusalem israel   (01.10.08)
I understand why extreme lefters are bad... If all the world was thinking like them, everything was fine. But as you see in number 9...
29. Prophets say Exile is Over
Christy ,   Boston, US   (01.13.08)
The Biblical prophets say The Exile is over, no more exile on the horizon. The time we're now in, according to the prophets, is The Regathering. There WILL be future wars, the last of which G-d fights&wins. But, nobody will drive Jews from their land again. Read Ezekiel, start at chapter 30 and go on from there. You should find it very encouraging!
30. #24, so thats five seats Peace now has?
Danny   (01.14.08)
or roughly 4% of the vote.
Back to article