Jewish Scene
Former chief Rabbi to Bush: Don't act against God’s will
Kobi Nahshoni
Published: 10.01.08, 08:54
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
206 Talkbacks for this article
91. Rabbi's letter to Bush
Suzanne Beck ,   Birmingham,AlabamaUS   (01.11.08)
I wholeheartedly agree w\ the Rabbi's letter to Pres. Bush! Israel belongs to the Jewish people. It was given to them by God eternally by covenant. I, as a Christian, stand w\ the people of Israel on this matter. I'm so sorry our president is doing this! There are others who feel as I do. Shalom!
92. Amen, Rabbi
Kathleen ,   California, USA   (01.11.08)
This is SO true! Look back on recent catastrophic events in this country - and you will see how it coincides with any decision by this government to try and give away Israel's land to the Palestinians. Even now, with Bush trying to pacify the Palestinians.... horrendous storms across this country. Leave Israel alone - this is the land of God's people - the Jews!
93. So moot
CJ ,   United States   (01.11.08)
All this debating, all this arguing, all this chais is all for naught. What God deems and wills is coming to pass no matter what we yell at each other. We must love, we must wait and we must let Israel have Her land that is promised. Watch, wait and love.
94. On the nail Rabbi!
Sadhasiv ,   Washington DC, USA   (01.11.08)
95. # 92 sorry, pure coincidence !
Abel Shoni ,   France   (01.11.08)
Has to do with global warming. Of course, you may say this is under God's control, like the Holocaust ?
96. Well Put # 8
Ginette ,   Toronto, Canada   (01.12.08)
The main problem in the Middle East is that other countries do not understand ISRAEL BELONGS TO THE JEWS! Shabatt Shalom
97. # 6 wrong thinking.
venita ,   cornell wi   (01.12.08)
God does not care if secular or christian or other live in Israel. It is his and you do not separate any of it from God. This may be MODERN times but The words of God are still true. Do not divide of give away the land of Israel for it is Gods. Your therory of separation of religion and state does not work any where or in Israel. This is the land of God and it is about religion. you cannot separate the two, Yes the other countries have done so and they have moved on with out God which was not a good thing for any country. Look at the rebelion that is taking place anoung the people there. Crime , divorce, lawlessness is terrible now in these countries. Children murdered in the schools for God is no longer allowed there to protect them.. We are not better off now with out God. We are worse. Israel must stand against this and go with God in all they do. venita
98. Rabbi is right
venita ,   cornell wi   (01.12.08)
RAbbi is so right to confront our presiden. If he would only listen to the Rabbi. He is like Noah. no one listened to him either till it was to late. I here you Rabbi for I know you speak the truth. Most of america heres you Rabbi and we know that God is useing you to tell the truth. Blessings venita
99. pity pity
venita ,   cornell wi   (01.12.08)
Wow !!! are you in for a rude awakening one day... You sir have been duped by satan of who you will serve one day. Hope you come to your senses before it is eternally to late for your soul. Read the bible and educate yourself or be silenced with you ignorance. venita
100. To # 75
venita ,   cornell wi   (01.12.08)
# 75 The bible or Torah perhaps. My bible tells me that the jews will never leave Israel again ..once it became a nation again it will be eternal for God is there.
101. #82
venita ,   cornell wil   (01.12.08)
All of you athiest are in for a shocking end of life. There was a plan put in place before you came along with your athiest belief. God created all things and he has the plan. a plan for Isreal and the world as a whole is yet to be totally fulfilled. They are in the land of Isreal as he fortold in scripture thousands of years ago. Prophetic word was full filled when they returned to the land of Isreal and made it florish as he said in his word that he would allow them to do... As time moves own we see his word come to pass and soon the grand finalle will take place but you must read the bible to find out what that will be. Athiest have a short part in the end time but it is not going to be a good part. Sorry but you have to believe in the almighty God and have faith in his word as it comes to pass. . When you are a believer and know the word of God you can sit back and watch his mighty hand work in all things that effect our lives on a small scale or giant scale effecting our nations. I have joy that I would not trade for you non belief because I have faith in God and I see him at work as we speak,,, venita
102. to 34 hartly
nana ,   jerusalem   (01.12.08)
when we say god will .it is not about this day or that nation or that merchant .. it is about all the life from the start of creation till the end of the life and after the life ,,it is about evrything that god create it .... this is the glance that i look for god will
103. Bless those who bless Israel.
dee ,   Just passing through   (01.12.08)
I see no threats here.... My King James bible states that God will bless those who bless Israel, and curse those who curse Israel.
104. #95 Abel
Ephraim ,   Diaspora   (01.12.08)
If these storms were a first time occurance Abel, I would agree with you. Check out history. Over the past several years every time Bush, Rice, or the US in general has interfered in Israeli affairs, trying to divide Eretz Israel and the Holy city of Yerushalayim There have been similar occurances. They can't all be coincidences. People had better wake up! It may be too late for national t'shuvah, but not for personal. Zechariah 14 makes it clear that Yerushalayim will be divided and that those nations causing the division will be judged, so if you live in America folks you better take cover.
105. Warning?
Steve ,   USA   (01.12.08)
What is this all about a warning? Who the hell do these people think they are, warning us. What's next, give Israel billions more, Tanks, missiles, bombs to be used against civilians, or God will punish us? All I can say is, I hope Ron Paul wins, no more aid, time for you people to start being nice to other nations, and start working for the money you need. Warning my rear end!!!
106. Peace initative
Ernie Lofthouse ,   Sun City, USA   (01.12.08)
since the Rabbi is talking to a President who feels that Islam is a religion of peace. And that you can deal with and make peace treaties with those those that are sworn to anniliate the nation of Israel. And will if not today then tomorrow will try again. And you are dealing on the one hand with an American president who ignores history and a Jewish state that is almost completely secular. Is almost surely ignorant of Gods word that warns Israel and anyone else about giving away or selling the land given to the Jews, after the rebirth of the nation Israel. But i also know that the God i worship also say's that the Jewish people will never again be driven out of the land that he restored to them. I am ashamed of my President who claims to be a Christian (like myself) continues to demand Israel give up yet more land, that puts the Jews in greater jeopardy. And a so-called Jewish leader (Olmert) who is facilitating this lie called peace. I continue to pray for the peace of Jerusalem, and that the Jewish people will rise up with one voice and drive Ehud Olmert and men like him out of office....
107. Forgive US, Isreal...
Reido ,   OK USA   (01.12.08)
for we know not what we do. I voted for Bush 2x to fight terror - NOT Isreal, and yet, we get Bush (Christian) and Rice (Christian) who obviously haven't read their Old Testament. Millions of American Christians DO NOT agree with them! Please pray for US in this election year. Thanks, Rabbi.
108. Bush G-d Israel
Paul ,   Aberdeenshire, Sco   (01.12.08)
Im honestly not as well educated on these matters as you guys, but if every christian accepts that Israel is for the Jewish people only thenthe christians (maybe even bush) can still aknowledge that but then the danger lies in the action to be taken, any action has to be peaceful,
109. # 13 And a German would have all Jews gone!
Petra ,   usa   (01.12.08)
Just imagine how many more Jews would live in Israel if Hitler hadn't murdered 6 million? Every live Jew must annoy you, asshole.
110. # 23 Doesn't matter whether or not you believe
Petra ,   usa   (01.12.08)
in the bible. The words re: Israel are coming true. Israel is the apple of G-ds eye. HIS words are as true today as they were when written eons ago. No other nation has been reborn as Israel. It galls all who neither believe or care to learn. Doesn't matter, it is truth come to life. Israel, a tiny piece of land has been coveted by everyone even though the eternal home of the Israelites, that's Jews to you! What other nation is as vital to the world democracy in only 60 years? What brings us together is whether or not we stand by Israel, the Promised Land promise is coming true. I have no doubt that every word concerning Israel is truth as written by the sages thousands of years ago. Amazing that G-d even chose Jews alone to write the books.!!! No other books have prophecy written for all to read and know the truth.
111. # 22 Eddie pity Bush is so paid off by the Saudis!
Petra ,   usa   (01.12.08)
some christian! He makes an appearance after 7 years and thinks the world will listen ? What a putz! His loyalties are with the Arabs NOT Israel. He'll be remebered as a liar, a war monger and no friend to Israel. Gaza is his gift to Israel. The rockets are his legacy. He has no G-d. He will be rememberes as the worst US Prez ever!
112. # 53 You got through! And he read them!
Petra ,   usa   (01.12.08)
So, the censors let you get one in? I notice sometimes my words are not always published either. I don't mind. However, one post was completely rewritten and even though I said nothing, I wondered, why? Keep trying, your bound to wear them out or, get through by accident. These words are worth what we pay for them, nada. I do enjoy your thoughts though even if we don't always agree.
113. # 59 M. Hartley Tough crowd!
Petra ,   usa   (01.12.08)
Are you still Jewish male watching? Beware of tight designer pants that tells you the religion before the man says a word. lol, I liked your joke, I'll try and think of one for you. Laughter, the best medicine. Hmm, know any cute Jewish Drs?
114. # 63 Keren lighten up Hartleys funny and a friend of Israel.
Petra ,   usa   (01.12.08)
You Keren,sound very angry and it's not becoming. M. Hartleys okay even though we may not always agree. You, on the other hand lack elan and any smooth babe. Lighten up. Hartleys more fun to read than you. Jews may make the best comics but, she's right up there giving us some giggles, and you? You give me a headache. OY VEYS MER!
115. # 64 M. Hartley LOL
Petra ,   usa   (01.12.08)
" as for Hiram, I don't have any idea what his personal habits are with regard to my or anyone else's read end'. I do, and it aint pretty. Bet he used to live in Iran before the mini monket was in charge. Bet the only reason he wasn't hung is that he isn't hung. My bad? Laugh and the world laughs with you. If not, they take life too seriously.
116. The Rabbi's letter to President Bush
Bette McGuire ,   Longview, Texas   (01.12.08)
I am in agreement with everything the Rabbi said in his letter. I would like to add one thing he didn't mention: God said in the Bible that those who are for His people (Israel) He will be for and those who are against His people (Israel) He will be against. The USA needs to be acutely aware of this at all times. The US doesn't want to have God against it even though there are those in this country who are doing everything they can to pull the US out from under His Hand. I would add to the Rabbi's letter these words: "Mr. President, as a Christian, you must realize that this nation needs God's blessings and protection. Support Israel. Not those who have pledged to kill us!"
117. Keren , your # 43 , vulgair
charles ,   petach tikva   (01.12.08)
A french saying : on chasse la nature , elle revient a plein galop . You can't hide your favellas background , your heading # 43 , is a proof of what i say . And this for a "religious" woman , shame on you .
118. paqid , insulting is easy , but you can't answer
charles ,   petach tikva   (01.12.08)
my questions in # 87 and 88 . Again , do TRUE Orthodox Jews [ Rav Metzger or the Mayor of Jerusalem , for example ] agree with your saying that ribi yeshua was the maschiah , or are they still awaiting Him to come ? Say only yes , they say , or no they don't say it . Not more needed from you
119. Letter to President Bush
Prof. P. Hatgil ,   Austin, TX   (01.12.08)
The statement by the Rabbi is racist in content. No other country in the world decides that all residents be of one belief or race.
120. BUSH PUTS GOD ON HIS SIDE
Norway   (01.12.08)
"Before September 11, President George W Bush kept his evangelical Christian beliefs largely to himself. But all that changed on the day of the attacks on the Pentagon and World Trade Center. Those close to Mr Bush say that day he discovered his life's mission. He became convinced that God was calling him to engage the forces of evil in battle, and this one time baseball-team owner from Texas did not shrink from the task. "We are in a conflict between good and evil. And America will call evil by its name," Mr Bush told West Point graduates in a speech last year. In this battle, he placed his country firmly on the side of the angels. BATTLE WITH ANTI-CHRIST In fact, nearly all the mainline churches in America oppose this war, including Mr Bush's own church, the United Methodists. One in three American Christians call themselves evangelicals and many evangelicals believe the second coming of Christ will occur in the Middle East after a titanic battle with the anti-Christ. Does the president believe he is playing a part in the final events of Armageddon? If true, it is an alarming thought. But he would not be alone, as 59% of all Americans believe that what is written in the Bible's Book of Revelation will come to pass." http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/americas/2921345.stm
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article