Jewish Scene
Neturei Karta: IDF conducting ethnic cleansing in Gaza
Neta Sela
Published: 17.01.08, 14:59
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
104 Talkbacks for this article
1. Why?
Keith ,   USA   (01.17.08)
The Neturei Karta are nothing but little yapping dogs. Ynet, why do you report on them? Better you should report the latest on Britney Spears.
2. Neturei Karta: The mouse that sqeaked
Matt ,   Israel   (01.17.08)
How many of them are there, 10 maybe? ROFLMAO
3. I love these guys
ayman ,   jersey   (01.17.08)
These guys are my real cousins. May god bless them and their children.
4. Please stop giving these people a platform.
LEE ,   NY, USA   (01.17.08)
They thrive on press coverage. Its time you put them in Cherem. The majority of the Jewish world has practically excommunicated this anti-Jewish cult. They have been barred from hotels, synagogues, public gatherings.. etc.
5. Here they are again !
charles ,   petach tikva   (01.17.08)
Well let them go and live in Gaza or in their beloved Iran . They are a minority amongst the Charidim , and i think , and hope i'm correct , that most of the Charidim are opposed to this minority . If not in Gaza , let them go and live for some time in Sderot , so they will feel how their "brethren" behave .
6. A wise Jewsih voice, but..
Adam keller ,   Jerusalem, Palestine   (01.17.08)
how many Jews are not Zionists?
7. where are our pro-religious right winger??
Mordechai   (01.17.08)
eat this you bunch of parasites!
8. Why give them a platform ???
Harry   (01.17.08)
Ignore them, You could not count more than ten orthodox Jews that support them.
9. Government must consider resettling Naturei Karta...
Jack ,   San Diego, USA   (01.17.08) Sderot and points north as buffer against Kassams and Katyushas.
10. Different place but same tune...
Hiram ,   Paris   (01.17.08)
Last time we heard of these "enlighted representative of the true faith" was when they went to meet with Ahmadinedjad inTeheran in 2007 ! With friends like these , who needs ennemies ! I am sure this will please some of the "Orthodox community"....As we all know , the state of Israel does not exist, Israel is only a product of zionist imagination .... and in fact all of Tzahal soldiers who gave their lives for the protection of the country did not even die ! It s all a fallacy ! What do they call it already ? Ahhh ! Yes, the "ZIONIST ENTITY " What they do not realize is that is Israel did not exist , they would not be where they are ...but of course understanding this is far too much of an effort ! a Mollah is a Mollah, regardless on which side of the fence he is sitting ! Poor us !
11. at least these traitorous gangsters are not in the governmen
chaim ,   brooklyn n.y   (01.17.08)
at least these traitorous gangsters,dont sit in the cabinet let me ask you a simple question,who does more damage to israel,these ignorant savages,or this criminally insane,traitorous,pathetic delusional fool,who pretends to be prime minister?
12. NK also believe that Hitler was sent by G-d
Jake   (01.17.08)
to punish the Jews for the "sins" of secularism, Haskalah, and Zionism. These are the true disciples of those Pharisees who in ancient times betrayed the independent Hashmonean Jewish kingdom by giving the Seleucid Syrians carte blanche to reconquer Jerusalem. The same bunch who later brought Pompey into Jerusalem to descrate the Temple. And if it isn't NK, it is the "moderate non-Zionist" Shas and UTJ, who are preparing to enter the Olmert government, to exchange Jerusalem for "Yavne and its sages". The Jewish people will not forgive or forget this betrayal of their sovereignty over their land.
13. #6 puts the judas into judas
JC   (01.17.08)
14. I want them to live in "Shderot" they are Israel cancer
Israel   (01.17.08)
15. Don't give them a platform
Shalom   (01.17.08)
YNet knows fine well that they do not represent any Chareidi/Orthodox Jewish position other than their own pathetic selves. They have been ostracised by every major religious community. Let them hang!
16. I can't decide who is worse, Evangelists or these Jews
The Neturei Karta are Jews who hate Israel, while the Evangelists are goyyim who love Israel. Enemies all they are.
Eyal ,   Jerusalem   (01.17.08)
Ynet, these guys are a tiny minority and they represent NO ONE. Why publish articles about them and give them the publicity they seek? As you know, our enemies always point to them and claim that many Jews are against Israel, when in fact this is a tiny tiny fringe minority. The don't warrant any news coverage, and if they stopped getting coverage maybe they would finally shut up.
18. Such idiots!
Baruch ,   Boston, USA   (01.17.08)
19. Neturei Karta is NOT orthodox Jewish
josef cohen ,   herzliya il   (01.17.08)
Frankly I don't think they are even Jewish. Neturei Karta represents no one but themselves. Neturei Karta left US, the Jewish people, a long time ago. They don't care about US, the Jewish people. Even the Haredim want nothing to do with them. They may not like the state and isolate themselves from most of US, but even they know better than making common cause with people who only wish Jewish people harm. Yediot could demonstrate a little more journalistic integrity and stop slandering the entire Orthodox community by 'reporting' Neturei Karta are a part of the Orthodox or any other Jewish community.
20. neturei karta
Laura ,   Jersalem Israel   (01.17.08)
My suggestion to those members of NK who wish bad things on the Jewish nation of Israel..why dont they go live in Gaza , Ramallah or maybe Jenin. I am sure they would be welcome there !
21. to adam keller #6
Laura ,   Jersalem Israel   (01.17.08)
how many times is Jerusalem mentioned in the Koran? the answer is 0 ,ZERO , NADA There is NO Jerusalem in palestine nor is there a palestine
22. To #5
M. Hartley ,   Atlanta, US   (01.17.08)
Good grief, have mercy on the poor people of Sderot. They have enough problems already. It all comes down to what I saw in a cartoon not too long ago: "If Jews only had one or two outside enemies, they'd all get along." The fact that these strange people are allowed to spew their anti-Jewish/Zionist rants and not disappear a la Jimmy Hoffa is a compliment to all of Israel.
23. How many of them?
Alberto ,   nyc, usa   (01.17.08)
Does anyone know how many Jews belong to the Neturei Karta group?
24. Killing rocket launching terrorists = "Ethnic cleansing"?
Zvi   (01.17.08)
Hamas has said that its "soldiers" were killed because their lookout wasn't paying attention and they used RPGs instead of mortars. How exactly is a battle "brutality"? And - thanks, guys, for propagandizing on behalf of people (Hamas) who want to commit another genocide. Thanks so very much. Blind idiots.
25. haerdi
Marcel   (01.17.08)
Put these guys in the army or throw these religions freaks out of the country.
26. Idiots! They will be The First to die ..and must die! Morons
GOD   (01.17.08)
27. Lamalshinim Al T'hi Tikva V'chol Haresh Karega Toved
Squalid Ibn Harman ,   Qtir   (01.17.08)
As Jews are bombarded daily the Netura Kartei supports the enemy who attack us. We added the 19th prayer to the Amidah just for enemy of Jews from within. Their member in Austria was excommunicated and children thrown out of the school. Their synagogue in Monsey was firebombed. They must be totally excommunicated and cut off from Judaism until they join the ranks of the Essenes and all others that fought against us and are now extinct.
david ,   usa   (01.17.08)
your choice of words indicate your own disgust with your heritage
29. these anti israel rabbis should live in Gaza
Petra ,   usa   (01.17.08)
they certainly don't beling in Israel.
30. # 5 Chales You're 100% right!!!!
Petra ,   usa   (01.17.08)
these Rabbis might as well be Islamic radicals.
Next talkbacks
Back to article