Jewish Scene
Neturei Karta: IDF conducting ethnic cleansing in Gaza
Neta Sela
Published: 17.01.08, 14:59
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
104 Talkbacks for this article
31. DOSE YNET MAKE A HEADLINE OF LINE THAT COMES OUT OF A MENTEL
(01.17.08)
HOME?
32. TODAY AND YESTERDAY
ROLAND SEENER ,   LONDON ENGLAND   (01.17.08)
WHAT WAS GOOD FOR JERICHO WHEN JOSHUA WAS COMMANDER IN CHIEF AFTER MOSES,IS THE SAME CASE AS TODAY IN GAZA.WHY DONT THESE CHAREIDIM CRITICISE OUR HEROES OF LONG PAST,ACCEPTABLE IN "BIBLICAL TIMES" AS HAVING BEEN ALSO UNACCEPTABLE ?THEY ARE THROWING STONES IN GLASS HOUSES!
33. Rabinical lies
Josh   (01.17.08)
"Jews are forbidden from having their own state until the coming of the Messiah" This is a gross perversion of Torah. How can any of these men claim they are men of Torah or even for Beni Israel! The first settling of Israel was done without the presence of Moses and everyone since has not had a Messiah. Did any of prophets in the subsequent times when Israel settled in the land state "leave your to early for the messiah"? No they stated, you are settled in the land but unless you abandon magical devices and lawlessness, you will be kicked out. Doing Torah is our only way of seeking and receiving G-d's permission to be and stay in the land. It is the path to life and love. The idea that Israel must have a prophet to tell them how to do Torah is a joke although there are many lazy people who are happy to say this so that they can fall away from doing the law. Torah does not need someone to go and get it for you, it is written and between the individual and G-d. It is the nations heart to do it. One only need pick up the book and read it for what it is. Not cosmic dust, proverbs, geamatra, or philosophy but laws. Israel is again and again laid low because they will not read it for themselves and let idiots interpret absurd out-of-context ideas into its simple communications. Just do what it says. Everyone and all. Since there is no legal adding Torah and a prophet does not add or subtract a word (rabbis do however), we have everything we need to do Torah. The idea that the messiah is already living in Israel has never even crossed the minds of these fools who think Israel is better off in diaspora. If G-d did not want us here, we would not be here! These men are like those who denied the miracles of the Exodus and stated G-d planned to deliver the Hebrews into the hands of the giants. Did not the miracles of the states formation teach these fools anything. Did not the Shoa and the forces that drove so many Jews back to the land make any impression on these men? Just teach people to do Torah so that G-d will lets us dwell long in the land and at peace. Of course this means these men will have to learn real Torah too. The statement that Jews are forbidden from having their own state is not true. We are required to have a Torah state with laws and judges. Torah is not about doing what you feel like, not majority rules. If it was there would have been no issue with the golden calf. They would have just taken a vote. So clearly the state we have is not based on Torah principles but rather copying other nations which explains the gay parades. lesbian adoptions, and smut on television. Saying what these men say is just another cult device for brainwashing.
34. neturei karta
fish ,   tel-aviv   (01.17.08)
I have to warn these neturei punks - if anyone ever appears near me, i'll punch him on the nose, nice and hard. I also have to say that I don't know any other nation which have people who don't sympatize with their own people and support them ( Neturei don't give a damn about children of sderot), but who rather feel for the enemies.
35. Even in the Orthodox world
Chaya ,   Bat Yam, Israel   (01.17.08)
these people are considered beyond the pale!! They don't speak for the Jewish people! But they are dangerous in that they present themselves as Jews against Zionism, thus giving 'legitimacy' to those would say: "See? Even some religious Jews think that Israel has no right to exist!"
36. there's nothing ethnic about killing everybody.
(01.17.08)
i think "ethnic cleansing" became the go-to word for anti Israeli groups. of course when Palestinians fire into Israel and only apologizing when they hurt Arab people there, thats A okay. "sorry we hurt, arabs, we were aiming for the jews"
37. NKs are Arabs dressed in chassidic cloths.
Joseph P. ,   JewRusalem   (01.17.08)
38. It seems that admin for Ynet section Jewish world
Jonas ,   SAD   (01.17.08)
...Is from there, judging by his stupidity and bias.
39. World media latches on to this lunatic fringe every time
(01.17.08)
as if they were a 'mainstream' element in Israeli society - far from it.
40. And What Do They Say About Rocket Attacks
emanon ,   USA   (01.17.08)
on the civilians in Sedrot? Of the homicide bombings the Arabs have committed in the past? Of the attacks the Arabs are planning now? Fine . . . Send THESE people to the other side and see how THEY will be treated.
41. nutre k
boaz ,   uas   (01.17.08)
They are neither left wing or right wing nor centered but wing-a-dings who should not be given prominence
42. Big deal! So they said something. Who cares?
sorele bas chulent ,   shtampferd here   (01.17.08)
Bored bunch of nobodies.
43. YNET is stupid to report every bowel movement by NK idiots
Gabe   (01.17.08)
Shame on YNET for obsessively reporting every disgusting thing said by anti-Israelis.
44. NK are as Jewish...
Micha   (01.17.08)
as messianic Jews. ie. they're not!!!
45. ynets got it all wrong again
menachem arnen ,   jerusalem israel   (01.17.08)
This is disgusting how people continue to portray naturei karta as orthodox jews. This plays into their game. They have been ostracized by the entire orthodox world. They arent religious jews, and maybe not jews at all.
46. Let me say this clearly:
Mike   (01.17.08)
Neturei Karta are the Mossad's most valued assets
47. Zayman
Jane   (01.17.08)
Screw you, Zayman. You WOULD like them. And, since you do, you can have them. They are certainly not wanted nor needed by us.
48. Petra , they are NOT Rabbi's !!
charles ,   petach tikva   (01.17.08)
49. Explanations please
Non-Jew?   (01.17.08)
I am confused: Under other circumstances you would call those dudes Tzadikim, because they follow the exact word of the bible. In fact: There is no mentioning of Zionists in the bible. I see a couple of voices who normally don't get tired of telling everybody off, who doubts this prophecy (other people might call it madness) that is called Bible. Is it possible that you are measuring with double standards, are you simply hippocrits based on what serves you best or am I missing something?
50. # 48 Charles, I agree!
Petra ,   usa   (01.17.08)
51. # 22 M. Hartley You reminded me of another funny,
Petra ,   usa   (01.17.08)
remember Tevia in "Fiddler on the roof" where ( Zero Mostel) playing Tevia says, "G-d I know we're your chosen people but, next time could you choose someone else?" I still love the thought of David and Goliath, sure would make a great movie.
52. To # 22 , M Hartley
Charles ,   petach tikva   (01.17.08)
You are right , those people in Sderot don't deserve this garbage . They are the same as those Messianic guys or those allegedly converted Rabbanim hating or ribi yeshua adoring goyim , garbage
53. Joseph P
charles ,   petach tikva   (01.17.08)
I do not agree with you , why do you insult arabs ? Those NK are worse .
54. I think that one of these goons
Miss shmarbles ,   shtamferd here 2   (01.17.08)
has a relative working for ynet, and ynet don't (want to?) realize it.
55. What Josh, the messiah is already living in Israel
Yehoshua   (01.17.08)
What fruit loops are you eating? What, are you the messiah? Think you need a rubber room. You like to spout Torah, but you are not even Jewish according to any rabbi's except the ones who you paid for your false conversion.
56. Why do these bozos merit an article?
Etoile ,   Montreal, CAN   (01.17.08)
Honestly, they are all going to dissapear soon anyway. Let these monkeys die in peace, and enough with the obituaries!
57. Neturei Karta = Mossad?
Chuck   (01.17.08)
Agree with #46. Mossad could be playing devil's advocate...
58. Good to see some sane Israelis speak for a change!
IRAN#1   (01.17.08)
Their voice is being drown out in the sea of the noise made by racists and blood thristy thugs.
59. Stop picking on Neturei Karta
Choni Daviowitz   (01.17.08)
They are crazy idiots, and are marginilised, but Sharon with his disengagement from Gush Katif, and what Olmert wishes to do in Judea and Samaria, has done far more harm to Eretz Yisrael than these crazies.
60. Admire NK, but they are against gay marriges
Yaakov Sullivan ,   NYC   (01.17.08)
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article