Jewish Scene
Anti-Semitic carnival
Shlomi Laufer
Published: 23.01.08, 09:58
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
62 Talkbacks for this article
31. who cares- its her religion
(01.23.08)
SHES not killing people. so leave here alone. you complaining fools.
32. #23 Joe in L.A. That's how it started.
Terry ,   Eilat, Israel   (01.23.08)
Of course, we're still here. Doesn't say much for the truth of any replacement theology. How embarrassing, wouldn't you say?
33. # 10
a hated jew fm ,   faransa   (01.23.08)
thanks for the compliment, kaf'r fm yerushalaim.
34. Apology a true victory for Jewish community
observer   (01.23.08)
May G-d bless the Jews with more and more apologies. May G-d make their lives full of more apologies. May G-d make apologies flourish more and more.
35. this is not antisemitism!
bernard ,   paris   (01.23.08)
sounds more like conscious, or unconscious J E W H A T R E D. at least one retard here ( dafer from jerusalem) spoke his poor mind out tonight.
36. ## 26
comic relief ,   stratford upon avon   (01.23.08)
still didn't catch his sense of humour?
37. #32 - Terry, I find it most amusing when...
Joe ,   Los Angeles, CA   (01.24.08)
I find it most amusing when people who follow these forms of replacement theology try to proselytize us to their form of worship. When I explain Jewish objections to their beliefs and how their Jewish straw-men are exactly that, straw-men, it's like seeing an idol crash in their temple. Nevertheless, it's interesting to witness the mental gymnastics people put themselves through in justifying the unjustifiable. It's not unlike reading the talkbacks of some of our "Zionism is racism"-spouting 'friends' here on Ynet...
38. lol
donnie ,   nyc/usa   (01.24.08)
boo hoo everyones anti semite when it comes to exposing crimes of israelis, as if palestinians expelled themselves. whoever criticizes you guys is either nazi anti semite or hitler and now even "ahmedinejad" word is in fashion, while u at same time make illegal gaza incursions to kill militants and claim at same time "peace process is still valid and unbroken" then they fire rockets and u make it look as if rockets were start of the problem, you evil hypocrites you are lying to the face of the world, while you know it
39. 13...well said
(01.24.08)
40. I'm Sorry.....for for snivilling cry babies!
James ,   Toledo Ohio USA   (01.24.08)
41. Jesus was falsely accused...
Josh   (01.23.08)
...and it was the fault of the fallen Jews who followed Jesus. Namely the first Christians who got Jesus in trouble with the ruthless rulers in that day. People just like this woman who claim Jesus is something he was not.. Jesus stated he was not the Messiah, he told his disciples he was not the Messiah and he even warned his followers not to think nor listen to anyone who says he is the messiah. But we know these fallen secular Jews who became Christians didn't listen and their still not listening, Thus Jesus was falsely accused of claiming he was the Messiah, Prince of Peace and King of the Jews when he didn't. Because of the big mouths that said he was, he was taken away to prison and accused of a political crime. To the accusations he responded to Pontious Pilate "you say I am". Note he did not say "I say I am" as he never did. So whos fault is it? His followers of course who were the sinners and the fallen. A reversal to the reversal. All these years they have been blaming the Jews who said Jesus is not the Messiah when in fact the fault was the Jews who said he was the Messiah. Mathew 10:23 & 24:5 Oh the irony of the chose death part of Torah is so sad and comical at the same time. Fear the number 13 from the failed test Devarim (Deut) 13. Signs and wonders. Moses did not lie when a great humiliation would be waiting at the end for fallen secular jews who chose death.
42. to #10 DAFER - JERUSALEM
NARAH CORREA ,   BRASIL   (01.24.08)
You're a idiot, Dafer, you don't know us, brasilians.You don't have a slightly idea of who we are or how we think or feel. We're not haters like you. We're a happy people, we love to love others peoples, specially the beautiful and bright ones like the jewish people is.
43. # 28 Mel Gibson is shocked? LOL
Petra ,   usa   (01.24.08)
I think you should psot under another name or suffer the consequences.
44. # 39 Thank you
Petra ,   usa   (01.24.08)
45. Like withdrawing a comment in court after jury hears it
Jack ,   San Diego, USA   (01.24.08)
46. #1: and your call them "friends"?
Jack ,   San Diego, USA   (01.24.08)
47. She represents her 'religion'
Petra ,   usa   (01.24.08)
like the muslims, any excuse to denograte the Jews and in false theology where they first got the notion, like mothers milk. Bigotry is supreme to these 'newer religions who forget who brought them 'the good news'. Many will come in my name'.
48. Brazilian singer
Israelite ,   Israel   (01.24.08)
Wouldn't it be something if she had Jewish blood in her and doesn't know it? Millions of Brazilians are descendants of Jews; some know it but many don't.
49. Anti-Semitic Remark
David ,   Detroit, Michigan   (01.24.08)
It's really not anti-semitism, her error is accepting an old ignorant and anti-semitic doctrine of the church. Someone needs to teach her the truth. 1) 80% of the Jews were not living in Israel at the time and could never have even heard of him. 2) Of the Jews actually in Israel, most had never heard of him. They had no phones or newspapers. 3) The New Testament itself states that most of the Jews in Israel were not to blame. 4) Even according to the New Testament, a few corrupt Jews and the many corrupt Italians / Romans were to blame. Do Christians blame the Romans / Italians?? 5) One Jew can not verbally place blame on all other Jews by simply stating so. 6) No one can kill G-d.
50. Anti-Semitic Remark
David W ,   Detroit, Michigan   (01.24.08)
Condemnation and Apology is a very hollow if not worthless "victory". Education and correction of incorrect beliefs is the only approach that has value.
51. I LOVE Brasilian music
Gideon Reader ,   USA   (01.24.08)
Yes, Ms.Caymmi made a "slip of the tounge". Nothing to get excited about. OK. She has the usual fear and hate of Jews. I can live with her dislike. After all she is a rather large but obscure figure outside of Brasil. It may be indicative of the total mood and general feeling towards Jews of Brasilian citizenship/residency, and something to watch if it develops. But one thing of greater consideration in the career and life of Ms.Caymmi is the fact that she **LOOKS FAT** in every dress she owns. Chubby deluxe with fins and extra mayo. A porker, if you get my drift. Two axe handles across the WIDE LOAD of her butt which seems to go from here to Sao Paulo. We as Jews may celebrate Rosh HaShannah, but she will never be a size 2.
52. #48 "Jewish blood" ?
Yair   (01.24.08)
53. Why Do They Whine When Their Talmud
World Citizen ,   the world   (01.24.08)
admits that the Pharisees did indeed try in court and then request the crucifixion of Jesus? Were the Pharisees not Jews? In a court of law the man who facilitates the murder of another is just as guilty and the man who actually commits the act of murder. I know you won't post this but the gatekeeper at this site will and s/he needs to go read Jewish holy texts. I speak the truth. If only ynetnews and world Jewry could do the same.
54. HOW PATHETIC THAT .O1 % IS A PROBLEM FOR THIS PERSON
HAL TRIPP ,   LA PAZ ,BOLIVIA   (01.24.08)
DAMN HER WITH HER APOLOGY,JUST AS IN SPAIN, POTUGAL AND BRAZIL, THE JEW IS VILIFIED IN PRESCHOOL CLASSES AND IN THEIR HOMES,99.9 % OF BRAZILIANS HAVE NEVER MET A JEW BUT I GUESS CHRIST'S BLOOD IS STILL ON OUR CLOTHING.ALL THE KILLING THE SPANIARDS AND THE PORTUGESE DID TO THE LOCAL INDIAN POPULATION IS FORGOTTEN IN HSTORY. AM YISROEL CHAI
55. World citizen, Jesus is mentioned nowhere in the Talmud
Jake   (01.24.08)
There is not a single verifiable contemporary mention of Jesus in ANY Jewish texts. What the heck are you talking about?
56. #53 If Ynet wouldn't have published your idiotic talkback
Keren ,   Israel-SP   (01.24.08)
You could be spared of such an embarassment.You don't know what is Talmud,creature! You are confused.Keep quiet;it is better for you. The only advantage of your post is to expose once again the antisemitism of the Church through its doctrinal creation.
57. Jesus Was Jewish...........
GP ,   Connecticut USA   (01.24.08)
...something that seems to get conveniently forgotten.
58. #57 And why exactly such a disgrace should be remembered?
Keren ,   Israel-SP   (01.24.08)
59. "Father forgive them.They know not...
Zooog   (01.25.08)
what they do" was what Jesus said on the cross. I never could understand why Christians have historically attacked Jews for supposedly having killed Christ when Jesus himself was forgiving.
60. Yes 53, you really miss the point!
David W ,   Detroit, MI   (01.25.08)
1. Nowhere in the Talmud, Mishna, or Old Testament is Jesus ever mentioned. He is a non-entity. 2. Jews never accepted the New Testament as part of the Bible, so what it states is the authors opinion of history he personally never saw. 3. Pharisees is a New Testament term that does not exist in the Hebrew lexicon, Jews do not even know what it means. 4. Rabbinic courts that could handle capital punishment cases were disbanded long before Jesus. Rabbinic courts are never held on holidays such as Passover. 5. Lastly, even if one were to believe the tale of the Pharisee court, a handful of mistaken or corrupt people do NOT bring eternal condemnation on their entire race or religion. There were many, many who did horrific evils in the name of Jesus Christ, Tourqemada and his court for example. Do they bring eternal damnation on all Christians? Are all Roman citizens (people of Rome) condemned to eternal damnation? Even the Pope?as he does live in Rome.
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article